Using a macro-meso-micro framework this paper examines the shifts in the hegemonic
development model and the implementation of new participatory mechanisms. It argues
that despite macro-level policy shifts, in the Chilean context, the implementation
of these mechanisms at the meso- and micro-levels has limited opportunities for
citizen input into policy-making processes. The analysis focuses on citizen
engagement with the machinery of participation and argues that the co-option of NGOs
and civil society groups by the state has meant that there has been little real
challenge to the implementation from civil society and policy-making remains a
top-down process.
Aycrigg, M.
1998:
Participation and the World Bank: successes, constraints and responses
. Discussion draft prepared for the International Conference on
Upscaling and Mainstreaming Participation of Primary Stakeholders: Lessons
Learned and Ways Forward. World Bank Social Development Papers, No. 29.
Washington DC: Environmentally and Socially Sustainable Development Network.
2.
Bosworth, B. P.
,
Dornbusch, R.
and
Labán, R.1994: The Chilean economy: policy lessons and challenges.
Washington DC: The Brookings Institute
.
3.
Cammack, P.1994: Democracy and citizenship in Latin America. In
Moran, M.
and
Parry, G.
, editors, Democracy and democratisation.
London: Macmillan
, 174-195.
4.
Cammack, P.2001:
Making the poor work for globalisation
. New Political Economy397-408
.
5.
Cammack, P.2002:
Attacking the poor
. New Left Review2,
125-135
.
6.
Chuchryk, P.1994: From dictatorship to democracy: the women’s
movement in Chile. In
Jaquette, J.
, editor, The women’s movement in Latin America: participation
and democracy.
Boulder CO and Oxford: Westview Press
, 65-107.
7.
Colclough, C.
and
Manor, J.1991: States or markets? Neo-liberalism and the development policy
debate.
Oxford: Clarendon Press
.
8.
College of Nurses, Chile. Retrieved February 2004 from http://www.colegiodeenfermeras.cl/gremial.html.
9.
Cornia, A.
,
Jolly, R.
and
Stewart, F.1987: Adjustment with a human face, Volume 1.
Oxford: Clarendon Press
.
10.
Cornwall, A.
,
Lucas, H.
and
Pasteur, K.2000:
Accountability through partnership: developing workable models in the
health sector
. IDS Bulletin31,
1-13
.
11.
Elson, D.1995: Male bias in the development process.
Manchester: Manchester University Press
.
12.
Elson, D.
and
Evers, B.1998: Sector programme support: the health sector - a gender aware
analysis.
Mimeo. Manchester: GENECON Unit, University of Manchester
.
13.
Fine, B.1999:
The developmental state is dead - long live social capital?Development and Change30,
1-19
.
14.
Foweraker, J.2001: Grassroots movements, political activism and social
development in Latin America: a critical comparison of Chile and Brazil.
Geneva: UNRISD Programme on Civil Society and
Social Movements
, Paper No. 4.
15.
Francis, P.2001. Participatory development at the World Bank: the primacy of
process. In
Cooke, B.
and
Kothari, U.
, editors, Participation: the new tyranny?
London and New York: Zed Books
, 72-87.
Goetz, A. M.1997: Getting institutions right for women in development.
London and New York: Zed Books
.
18.
Goetz, A. M.
and
Gaventa, J.2001: Bringing citizen voice and client focus into service
delivery. IDS Working Paper No. 138,
Brighton: IDS, University of Sussex
.
19.
Gore, C.2000:
The rise and fall of the Washington Consensus as a paradigm for developing countries
. World Development28,
789-804
.
20.
Harriss, J.2002: Depoliticizing development. The World Bank and social
capital.
London: Anthem Press
.
21.
Howard-Grabman, L.2000:
Bridging the gap between communities and service providers. Developing
accountability through community mobilisation approaches
. IDS Bulletin31,
88-96
.
22.
Howell, J.
and
Pearce, J.2002: Civil society and development. A critical exploration.
Boulder CO and London: Lynne Reinner Books
.
23.
Lethbridge, J.2002: Social dialogue in health services - case studies in Brazil,
Canada, Chile and the United Kingdom.
Geneva: ILO Sectoral Activities Programme
, Working Paper No. 189.
24.
Loewenson, R.1999: Public participation in health: making people matter.
IDS Working Paper No. 84.
Brighton: University of Sussex
.
25.
Loveman, B.1995: Chilean NGOs: forging a role in the transition to
democracy. In
Reilly, C.
, editor, New paths to democratic development in Latin America. The rise
of NGO-municipal collaboration.
Boulder CO and London: Lynne Reinner Publishers
, 119-144.
26.
Lowerson, R.
,
Hoard-Grabman, L.
,
Musemb, F.
and
Kilalo, C.2000:
Accountability through participation. Developing working models in the
health sector
. IOS Bulletin31-31
.
27.
McGee, R.2002: Participating in development. In
Kothari, U.
and
Minogue, M.
, editors, Development theory and practice: critical perspectives.
Hampshire: Palgrave
, 92-116.
28.
MINSAL 2000: Metas Ministeriales de Mediano Plazo (2000-2002), Retrieved
October 2002 http://www.minsal.cl.
29.
MINSAL 2002: Jornadas de Participación Ciudadana en Salud.
Retrieved October 2002 from http://www.minsal.cl
30.
Molyneux, M.2002:
Gender and the silences of social capital: lessons from Latin American perspective
. Development and Change33,
167-188
.
31.
Molyneux, M.
and
Razavi, S.2002: Liberalism and its discontents: the politics of gender, rights
and development in a global age.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
32.
Montecinos, V.1994: Neo-liberal economic reforms and women in Chile.
In
Aslanbeigui, N.
,
Pressman, S.
and
Summerfield, G.
, editors, Women in the age of economic transformation.
London: Routledge
, 160-177.
33.
Morgan, L.2001:
Community participation in health: perpetual allure, persistent challenge
. Health Policy and Planning16,
221-230
.
34.
Mosquera, M.
,
Zapata, Y.
,
Lee, K.
,
Arango, C.
and
Varela, A.2001:
Strengthening participation through health sector reform in Colombia: a
study of institutional change and social representation
. Health Policy and Planning16 (supplement),
52-60
.
35.
Mosse, D.2001. ‘People’s knowledge’,
participation and patronage: operations and representations in rural
development. In
Cooke, B.
and
Kothari, U.
, editors, Participation: the new tyranny?
London and New York: Zed Books
, 16-35.
36.
Raczynski, D.1994: Social policies in Chile: origin, transformations and
perspectives. Note Dame In Kellogg Institute, Democracy and Social
Policy Series, Working Paper No. 4.
37.
Reichard, S.1996:
Ideology drives health care reforms in Chile
. Journal of Public Health Policy17,
80-98
.
38.
Remmer, K.1989: Military rule in Latin America.
Boston MA: Unwin Hyman
.
39.
Revista Punto Final 2002a: No. 519. Santiago: Chile. Retrieved February 2004
from http://www.puntofinal.cl
40.
Revista Punto Final 2002b: No. 523. Plan AUGE: El negocio está
primero. Santiago: Chile. Retrieved February 2004 from http://www.puntofinal.cl
41.
Salinas, J.
and
Solimano, G.1995: Chilean health NGOs. In
Reilly, C.
, editor, New paths to democratic development in Latin America. The rise
of NGO-municipal collaboration.
Boulder CO and London: Lynne Reinner Publishers
, 145-164.
42.
Scarpaci, J.1991: Dismantling public health services in authoritarian
Chile. In
Scarpaci, J.
, editor, Health services privatisation in industrialised
societies.
London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers
, 219-244.
43.
Schild, V.2002: Engendering the new social citizenship in Chile: NGOs and
social provisioning under neoliberalism. In
Molyneux, M.
and
Razavi, S.
, editors, Liberalism and its discontents: the politics of gender, rights
and development in a global age.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
, 170-203.
44.
Solimano, G. and Salinas, J. 1994: Salud con la Gente: El Rol de las ONG
en las Políticas Públicas en América
Latina. Santiago: Corporaácion de Salnd Polticas Sociales.
45.
Stiglitiz, J.
1997:
An agenda for development for the twenty-first century
. Presented at the World Bank Ninth Annual Conference on
Development Economics, Washington DC. Retrieved
February 2004 from http://www.worldbank.org/mdf/mdf1/agenda.htm
46.
Taylor, L.1998: Citizenship, participation and democracy. Changing dynamics in
Chile and Argentina.
Hampshire and New York: Macmillan Press
.
47.
Tendler, J.1997: Good government in the Tropics.
Baltimore MD and London: John Hopkins
University Press
.
48.
World Bank1997: The state in a changing world, world development report.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
49.
Zackus, J. D.
and
Lysack, C.1998:
Revisiting community participation
. Health Policy and Planning13,
1-12
.
