One of the most striking features of the anglophone literature on NGOs is the
diversity of NGO sectors and their contributions to civil society and democracy;
yet, exploration of this complexity is often eschewed in favour of a normative
approach in which the apparently mutually enhancing relationship between NGOs, civil
society and the state is underpinned by liberal democratic assumption rather than an
engagement with wider debates about the politics of development. Following a
critique of this approach to NGOs, civil society and democracy, the paper argues
that the role of NGOs in the politics of development is far more complex than much
of the NGO literature would suggest, and calls for a more contextualized and less
value-laden approach to the understanding of the political role of NGOs.
Arellano-López, S.
and
Petras, J. F.1994:
Nongovernmental organizations and poverty alleviation in Bolivia
. Development and Change25,
555-568
.
2.
Baker, G.1997:
The taming of the idea of civil society
. Democratization6,
1-29
.
3.
Bebbington, A.1997:
New states, new NGOs? Crises and transitions among rural development NGOs
in the Andean region
. World Development25,
1755-1765
.
4.
Bebbington. A.
,
Carrasco, H.
,
Peralbo, L.
,
Ramon, G.
,
Trujillo, J.
and
Torres, V.1993:
Fragile lands, fragile organizations: Indian organizations and the politics
of sustainability in Ecuador
. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers18,
179-196
.
5.
Bratton, M.1989:
The politics of government-NGO relations in Africa
. World Development17,
69-587
.
6.
Campbell, J.2001: Autonomy and governance in Ethiopia: the state, civil
society and NGOs. In
Barrow O.
and
Jennings M.
, editors, The charitable impulse: NGOs and development in east and
northeastern Africa.
London: James Currey
, 282-310.
7.
Clark, Jeffrey2000: Civil society, NGOs and development in Ethiopia: a snapshot
view.
Washington DC: World Bank
.
Diamond, L.1997: In search of consolidation. In
Diamond, L.
,
Plattner, M. F.
,
Chu, Y-h.
and
Tien, H-m.
, editors, Consolidating the third wave democracies: regional
challenges.
London: Johns Hopkins University Press
, xiii-xlvii.
14.
Diamond, L.
,
Linz, J. J.
and
Lipset, S. M.1995: Introduction: what makes for democracy?. In
Diamond, L.
,
Linz, J. J.
and
Lipset, S. M.
, editors, Politics in developing countries: comparing experiences with
democracy. 2nd edition.
London: Lynne Rienner
, 1-66.
15.
Diamond, L.
,
Plattner, M. F.
,
Chu, Y-h.
and
Tien, H-m.
, editors 1997: Consolidating the third wave democracies:
regional challenges.
London: Johns Hopkins University Press
.
16.
Dicklitch, S.1998: The elusive promise of NGOs in Africa: lessons from
Uganda.
London: Macmillan
.
17.
Edwards, M.1999:
NGO performance - what breeds success? New evidence from South Asia
. World Development27,
361-374
.
18.
Edwards, M.
and
Hulme, D.
, editors 1992: Making a difference: NGOs and development in a
changing world.
London: Earthscan
.
19.
Edwards, M.
and
Hulme, D.
, editors 1995: Nongovernmental organizations - performance
and accountability: beyond the magic bullet.
London: Earthscan
.
20.
Farrington, J.
and
Bebbington, A.1993: Reluctant partners? Non-governmental organizations, the state
and sustainable agricultural development.
London: Routledge
.
21.
Farrington, J.
and
Lewis, D. J.
, editors 1993: Nongovernmental organizations and the state in
Asia: rethinking roles in sustainable agricultural development.
London: Routledge
.
22.
Feldman, S.1997:
NGOs and civil society: (un)stated contradictions
. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science554,
46-65
.
23.
Fisher, J.1998: Non governments: NGOs and the political development of the
Third World.
West Hartford: Kumarian Press
.
24.
Fowler, A.1991:
The role of NGOs in changing state-society relations: perspectives from
Eastern and Southern Africa
. Development Policy Review9,
53-84
.
25.
Fowler, A. 1993: Non-governmental organizations and the promotion of
democracy in Kenya. Unpublished D.Phil. Thesis, University of Sussex: Institute of
Development Studies.
26.
Fox, J.
and
Hernández, L.1992:
Mexico’s difficult democracy: grassroots movements, NGOs, and
local government
. Alternatives17,
165-208
.
27.
Fukuyama, F.2001:
Social captial, civil society and development
. Third World Quarterly22,
7-20
.
28.
Garrison. J.2000: From confrontation to collaboration: civil
society-government-World Bank relations in Brazil.
Washington DC: World Bank
.
29.
Gary, I.1996:
Confrontation, co-operation and cooptation: NGOs and the Ghanaian state
during structural adjustment
. Review of African Political Economy68,
149-168
.
30.
Gideon, J.1998:
The politics of social service provision through NGOs: a study of Latin America
. Bulletin of Latin American Research17,
303-321
.
31.
Gray, M. L.1999:
Creating civil society? The emergence of NGOs in Vietnam
. Development and Change30,
693-713
.
32.
Gyimah-Boadi, E.1999: The rebirth of African liberalism. In
Diamond, L.
and
Plattner, M.
, editors, Democratization in Africa.
London: Johns Hopkins University Press
, 34-47.
33.
Hadenius, A.
and
Uggla, F.1996:
Making civil society work, promoting democratic development: what can
states and donors do
. World Development24,
1621-1639
.
34.
Haynes, J.1996: Democracy and civil society in the Third World: politics and
new political movements.
Cambridge: Polity Press
.
35.
Hearn, J.1999: Foreign aid, democratisation and civil society in Africa: a
study of South Africa, Ghana and Uganda. IDS Discussion Paper No. 368,
Brighton: IDS
.
36.
Hodson, R.1997: Elephant loose in the jungle: the World Bank and NGOs in
Sri Lanka. In
Hulme, D.
and
Edwards, M.
, editors, NGOs, states and donors: too close for comfort?London: Macmillan
, 168-190.
37.
Hojman, D. E.1993:
Non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and the Chilean transition to democracy
. European Review of Latin American and Caribbean Studies54,
7-24
.
38.
Hulme, D.
and
Edwards, M.
, editors 1997: NGOs, states and donors: too close for comfort?London: Macmillan
.
39.
Korten, D. C.1990: Getting to the 21st century: voluntary action and the global
agenda.
West Hartford: Kumarian Press
.
40.
Lambrou, Y.1997:
The changing role of NGOs in rural Chile after democracy
. Bulletin of Latin American Research16,
107-116
.
41.
Landim, L.1993: Brazilian crossroads: people’s groups, walls and
bridges. In
Wignaraja, P.
, editor, New social movements in the South: empowering the people.
London: Zed
, 218-229.
42.
Luckham, R.
and
White, G.
, editors 1996: Democratization in the south: the jagged
wave.
Manchester: Manchester University Press
.
43.
Marcussen, H. M.1996:
NGOs, the state and civil society
. Review of African Political Economy69,
405-423
44.
McIlwaine, C.1998:
Contesting civil society: reflections from El Salvador
. Third World Quarterly19,
651-672
.
45.
Mercer, C.1999:
Reconceptualizing state-society relations in Tanzania: are NGOs
‘making a difference’?Area31,
247-258
.
46.
Miraftab, F.1997:
Flirting with the enemy: challenges faced by NGOs in development and empowerment
. Habitat International21,
361-375
.
47.
Ndegwa, S.1996: The two faces of civil society: NGOs and politics in
Africa.
West Hartford: Kumarian Press
.
48.
Pearce, J.1997: Between co-option and irrelevance? Latin American NGOs in
the 1990s. In
Hulme, D.
and
Edwards, M.
, editors, NGOs, states and donors: too close for comfort?London: Macmillan
, 257-274.
49.
Perera, J.1997: In unequal dialogue with donors: the experience of the
Sarvodaya Shramadana Movement. In
Hulme, D.
and
Edwards, M.
, editors, NGOs, states and donors: too close for comfort?London: Macmillan
, 156-167.
50.
Robinson, M.1994: Governance, democracy and conditionality: NGOs and the new
policy agenda. In
Clayton, A.
, editor, Governance, democracy and conditionality: what role for NGOs?Oxford: INTRAC
, 35-52.
51.
Robinson, M.1997: Privatising the voluntary sector: NGOs as public service
contractors? In
Hulme, D.
and
Edwards, M.
, editors, NGOs, states and donors: too close for comfort?London: Macmillan
, 59-78.
52.
Robinson, M.
,
Farrington, J.
and
Satish, S.1993: NGO-government interaction in India. In
Farrington, J.
and
Lewis, D. J.
, editors, Nongovernmental organizations and the state in Asia:
rethinking roles in sustainable agricultural development.
London: Routledge
, 91-101.
53.
Sandberg, E.1994: Introduction: the changing politics of non-governmental
organizations and African states. In
Sandberg, E.
, editor, The changing politics of non-governmental organizations and
African states.
London: Praeger
, 1-31.
54.
Sen, S.1999:
Some aspects of state-NGO relationships in India in the post-independence era
. Development and Change30,
327-355
.
55.
Shrestha, N. K.
and
Farrington, J.1993: NGO-government interaction in Nepal - overview. In
Farrington, J.
and
Lewis, D. J.
, editors, Nongovernmental organizations and the state in Asia:
rethinking roles in sustainable agricultural development.
London: Routledge
, 189-199.
56.
Silliman, G. S.
and
Noble, L. G.1998: Citizen movements and Philippine democracy. In
Silliman, G. S.
and
Noble, L. G.
, editors, Organizing for democracy: NGOs, civil society and the
Philippine state.
Honolulu: University of Hawai’i Press
, 280-310.
57.
Tvedt, T.1998: Angels of mercy or development diplomats? NGOs and foreign
aid.
Oxford: James Currey
.
58.
Webster, N.1995:
Democracy, decentralized development, and NGOs in Indian rural development
. Journal für EntwicklungspolitikXI,
187-212
.
59.
White, S.1999:
NGOs, civil society and the state in Bangladesh: the politics of
representing the poor
. Development and Change30,
307-326
.
60.
Williams, D.
and
Young, T.1994:
Governance, the World Bank and liberal theory
. Political StudiesXLII,
84-100
.
61.
Wood, G.1997: States without citizens: the problem of the franchise
state. In
Hulme, D.
and
Edwards, M.
, editors, NGOs, states and donors: too close for comfort?London: Macmillan
, 79-92.
62.
World Bank2000: World develoment report 1999/2000: entering the 21st
century.
Washington DC: World Bank
.
63.
Young, C.1994: In search of civil society. In
Harbeson, J. W.
,
Rothchild, D.
and
Chazan, N.
, editors, Civil society and the state in Africa.
London: Lynne Reinner
, 33-50.
64.
Zaidi, S. A.1999:
NGO failure and the need to bring back the state
. Journal of International Development11,
2-2
.
