Under a ‘landscape approach’ to biodiversity conservation,
USAID/Madagascar integrates by design concerns for forest resources and humans in
five target ecoregions. This paper examines relationships between its strategic
framework and how the mission reports results from development interventions between
1998 and 2002 in protected areas, multipurpose forests and agricultural lands.
Development activities focused on expanding parks and reducing negative impacts by
local communities. In contrast, a proposal for ecological monitoring provides
opportunities for information sharing and consultation among stakeholders about
biodiversity conditions under different land uses. The study recommends
strengthening incentives for community participation by measuring positive change
across human-modified landscapes.
Abramovitz, J. N.1989: A survey of U.S.-based efforts to research and conserve
biological diversity in developing countries.
Washington DC: World Resources Institute
.
2.
Adams, W.
and
Hulme, D.2001: Conservation and community. Changing narratives, policies
and practices in African conservation. In
Hulme, D.
and
Murphree, M.
, editors, African wildlife and livelihoods. The promise and performance
of community conservation.
Oxford: James Currey Ltd
, 9-23.
3.
Agrawal, A.
and
Gibson, C. C.2001: The role of community in natural resource
conservation. In
Agrawal, A.
and
Gibson, C. C.
, editors, Communities and the environment. ethnicity, gender, and the
state in community-based conservation.
New Brunswick NJ: Rutgers University Press
, 1-31.
4.
Aguir, J.1998:
Evanescent diversity - the palms of Madagascar
. BioScience48(7),
499-503
.
5.
Alpert, P.1994:
USAID’s expanded program to conserve biodiversity in Sub-Saharan Africa
. Ambio23(2),
167-167
.
6.
Alpert, P.1996:
Integrated conservation and development projects. Examples from Africa
. BioScience46(11),
845-855
.
7.
Baydack, R. K.
and
Campa, H. III1999: Setting the context. In
Baydack, R. K.
,
Campa, H. C., III
, and
Haufler, J. B.
, editors, Practical approaches to the conservation of biological
diversity.
Washington DC: Island Press
, 3-16.
8.
Bell, R. H. V.1987: Conservation with a human face: conflict and reconciliation
in African land use planning. In
Anderson, D.
and
Grove, R.
, editors, Conservation in Africa. People, policies, and practice.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
, 79-101.
9.
Bernard, T.
and
Young, J.1997: The ecology of hope.
Communities collaborate for sustainability. Gabriola Island
BC: New Society Publishers
.
10.
Bethune, T.1996: Country experimental laboratories: one year later.
Reengineering Best Practices No. 1 (PN-ABY-270).
Washington DC: Center for Development
Information and Evaluation, U.S. Agency for International Development
.
11.
Biodiversity Support Program (BSP)1993: African biodiversity: foundation for the future. A framework
for integrating biodiversity conservation and sustainable development.
Beltsville MD: Professional Printing, Inc.
12.
Brandon, K.
,
Redford, K. H.
and
Sanderson, S. E.
, editors 1998: Parks in peril. People, politics, and
protected areas.
Washington DC: The Nature Conservancy and
Island Press
.
13.
Brechin, S. R.
,
Wilshusen, P. R.
,
Fortwangler, C. L.
and
West, P. C.2002:
Beyond the square wheel: toward a more comprehensive understanding of
biodiversity conservation as social and political process
. Society and Natural Resources15,
41-64
.
14.
Breitmeier, H.
and
Rittberger, V.2000: Environmental NGOs in an emerging global civil
society. In
Chasek, P. S.
, editor, The global environment in the twenty-first century: prospects
for international cooperation.
New York: United Nations University Press
, 130-163.
15.
Brinkerhoff, D. W.1996:
Coordination issues in policy implementation networks: an illustration from
Madagascar’s environmental action plan
. World Development24,
1497-1510
.
16.
Brown, K.2002:
Innovations for conservation and development
. The Geographical Journal168,
6-17
.
17.
Brown, K.2003:
Integrating conservation and development: a case of institutional misfit
. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment1,
479-487
.
18.
Brown, M.
and
Wyckoff-Baird, B.1992: Designing integrated conservation and development projects.
Biodiversity Support Program.
Land-over MD: Corporate Press, Inc.
19.
Bruce, J. W.
and
Fortmann, L.1988: Why land tenure and tree tenure matter: some fuel for
thought. In
Fortmann, L.
and
Bruce, J. W.
, editors, Whose trees: proprietary dimensions of forestry.
Boulder CO: Westview Press
, 1-9.
20.
Bruner, A. G.
,
Gullison, R. E
,
Rice, R. E.
and
da Fonseca, G. A. B.2001:
Effectiveness of parks in protecting tropical biodiversity
. Science291,
125-128
.
21.
Buck, L. E.
,
Geisler, C. C.
,
Schelhas, J.
and
Wollenberg, E.
, editors, 2001: Biological diversity. balancing
interests through adaptive collaborative management.
Boca Raton FL: CRC Press
.
22.
Burney, D. A.1997: Theories and facts regarding holocene environmental change
before and after human colonization. In
Goodman, S. M.
and
Patterson, B. D.
, editors, Natural change and human impact in madagascar.
Washington DC: Smithsonian Institutions Press
, 75-89.
23.
Cooke, B.
and
Kothari, U.2001: The case for participation as tyranny. In
Cooke, B.
and
Kothari, U.
, editors, Participation: the new tyranny?London: Zed Books
, 1-15.
24.
Cornell International Institute for Food, Agriculture and Development
(CIIFAD) 2000: 1999- 2000 Annual Report. At
http://ciifad.cornell.edu/annualreports/1999-2000/documents/africa.pdf
(last accessed 4 February 2004).
25.
Cowles, P. D.
,
Rakotoarisoa, S.
,
Rasolonirinamanana, H.
and
Rasoaromanana, V.2001: Facilitation, participation, and learning in an
ecoregion-based planning process: the case of AGERAS in Toliara,
Madagascar. In
Buck, L. E.
,
Geisler, C. C.
,
Schelhas, J.
and
Wollenberg, E.
, editors, Biological diversity. Balancing interests through adaptive
collaborative management.
Boca Raton FL: CRC Press
, 407-422.
26.
Crumley, C. L.1994: Historical ecology: a multidimensional ecological
orientation. In
Crumley, C. L.
, editor, Historical ecology.
Santa Fe NM: School of American Research Press
, 1-16.
27.
Denevan, W. M.1992:
The pristine myth: the landscape of the Americas in 1492
. Annals of the Association of American Geographers82,
369-385
.
28.
Dorm-Adzobu, C.1998: Institutionalizing environmental management in
Africa. In
Veit, P.
, editor, Africa’s valuable assets. A reader in natural
resource management.
Washington DC: World Resources Institute
, 27-70.
29.
Fairhead, J.
and
Leach, M.1998: Reframing deforestation.
New York: Routledge
.
30.
Faramalala, M.H. 1995: Formations végétales et domaine
forestier national de Madagascar. 1:1,000,000 color map. Washington DC: Conservation International.
31.
Ford, R.
and
McConnell, W. J.2001: Linking geomatics and participation to manage natural
resources in Madagascar. In
Buck, L. E.
,
Geisler, C. C.
,
Schelhas, J.
and
Wollenberg, E.
, editors, Biological diversity. Balancing interests through adaptive
collaborative management.
Boca Raton FL: CRC Press
, 385-405.
32.
Forrester, D. J.
and
Machlis, G. E.1996:
Modeling human factors that affect the loss of biodiversity
. Conservation Biology10(4),
1253-1263
.
33.
Foster-Turley, P.1996: Making biodiversity conservation happen: the role of
environmental education and communication. A GreenCom Discussion Paper.
Washington DC: U.S. Agency for International
Development, GreenCOM Environmental Education and Communication Project
.
34.
Franklin, J. F.1993:
Preserving biodiversity: species, ecosystems, or landscapes?Ecological Applications3(2),
201-205
.
35.
Freedman, J.2000: Introduction: aid at the forks. In
Freedman, J.
, editor, Transforming development: foreign aid for a changing
world.
Toronto: University of Toronto Press
, 3-14.
36.
Furze, B.
,
DeLacy, T.
and
Birckhead, J.1996: Culture, conservation, and biodiversity.
New York: John Wiley and Sons
.
37.
Ganzhorn, J. U.
,
Rakotosamimanana, B.
,
Hannah, L.
,
Hough, J.
,
Iyer, L.
,
Olivieri, S.
,
Rajaobelina, S.
,
Rodstron, C.
and
Tilkin, G.1997:
Priorities for biodiversity conservation in Madagascar
. Primate Report48(1),
1-81
.
38.
Gezon, L.1997:
Institutional structure and the effectiveness of Integrated Conservation
and Development Projects: case study from Madagascar
. Human Organization56(4),
462-470
.
39.
Gezon, L.2000:
The changing face of NGOs: structure and communitas in conservation and
development in Madagascar
. Urban Anthropology29,
181-215
.
40.
Ghimire, K. B.
and
Pimbert, M. P.1997: Social change and conservation: an overview of issues and
concepts. In
Ghimire, K. B.
and
Pimbert, M. P.
, editors, Social change and conservation. Environmental politics and
impacts of national parks and protected areas.
London: Earthscan Publications Limited
, 1-45.
41.
Goodman, S. M.
and
Patterson, B. D.
, editors 1997: Natural change and human impact in
Madagascar.
Washington DC: Smithsonian Institution Press
.
42.
Hannah, L.
,
Rakotosamimanana, B.
,
Ganzhorn, J.
,
Mittermeier, R.
,
Olivieri, S.
,
Iyer, L.
,
Rajaobelina, S.
,
Hough, J.
,
Andriamialisoa, F.
,
Bowles, I.
and
Tilken, G.1998:
Participatory planning, scientific priorities, and landscape conservation
in Madagascar
. Environmental Conservation, 25,
30-36
.
43.
Haufler, J. B.1999: Strategies for conserving terrestrial biological
diversity. In
Baydack, R. K.
,
Campa, H. C., III
and
Haufler, J. B.
, editors, Practical approaches to the conservation of biological
diversity.
Washington DC: Island Press
, 17-53.
44.
Hoben, A.
,
Peters, P.
and
Rocheleau, D.1998: Participation, civil society, and foreign assistance to
Africa. In
Veit, P.
, editor, Africa’s valuable assets. A reader in natural
resource management.
Washington DC: World Resources Institute
, 109-153.
45.
Hough, J. L.1994:
Institutional constraints to the integration of conservation and
development: a case study from Madagascar
. Society and Natural Resources7,
119-124
.
46.
Hulme, D.
and
Murphree, M.
, editors 2001: African wildlife and livelihoods. The promise
and performance of community conservation.
Oxford: James Currey Ltd.
47.
Jarosz, L.1993:
Defining and explaining tropical deforestation: shifting cultivation and
population growth in colonial Madagascar (1896-1940)
. Economic Geography69(4),
366-379
.
48.
Johnson, N. C.1995: Biodiversity in the balance: approaches to setting geographic
conservation priorities. Biodiversity Support Program.
Land-over MA: Corporate Press, Inc.
49.
Jolly, A.2001:
Monkeys in the back garden
. Science291,
1705-1706
.
50.
Knight, G. C.1992: Geography’s worlds. In
Abler, R. F.
,
Marcus, J. G.
and
Olson, J. M.
, editors, Geography’s inner worlds.
New Brunswick NJ: Rutgers University Press
, 9-26.
51.
Kothari, U.2001: Power, knowledge, and social control in participatory
development. In
Cooke, B.
and
Kothari, U.
, editors, Participation: the new tyranny?London: Zed Books
, 139-152.
52.
Kramer, R.
,
van Schaik, C.
and
Johnson, J.
, editors, 1997: Last stand: protected areas and the defense
of tropical biodiversity.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
53.
Kremen, C.
,
Merenlender, A. M.
and
Murphy, D. D.1994:
Ecological monitoring: a vital need for integrated conservation and
development programs in the tropics
. Conservation Biology8(2),
388-397
.
54.
Kremen, C.
,
Raymond, I.
and
Lance, K.1998:
An interdisciplinary tool for monitoring conservation impacts in Madagascar
. Conservation Biology112(3),
549-563
.
55.
Kull, C.1996:
Evolution of conservation efforts in Madagascar
. International Environmental Affairs8(1),
50-86
.
56.
Kull, C.2000:
Deforestation, erosion, and fire: degradation myths in the environmental
history of Madagascar
. Environment and History6(4),
423-450
.
57.
Lappé, F.
and
Lappé, A.2002: Hope’s edge.
New York: Jeremy P. Tarcher/Putnam
.
58.
Larson, B. A.1994:
Changing the economics of environmental degradation in Madagascar: lessons
from the National Environmental Action Plan process
. World Development22,
671-689
.
59.
Little, P. D.1994: The link between local participation and improved
conservation: a review of issues and experiences. In
Western, D.
,
Wright, R. M.
and
Strum, S.
, editors, Natural connections: perspectives in community-based
conservation.
Washington DC: Island Press
, 347-372.
60.
Liu, J.
,
Linderman, M.
,
Ouyang, Z.
,
An, L.
,
Yang, J.
and
Zhang, H.2001:
Ecological degradation in protected areas: the case of Wolong Nature
Reserve for giant pandas
. Science292,
98-101
.
61.
Marcus, R. R.2001:
Seeing the forest for the trees: Integrated Conservation and Development
Projects and local perceptions of conservation in Madagascar
. Human Ecology29(4),
381-397
.
62.
Mbora, D.2000:
Assault on the lower Tana
. Swara23(1),
19-21
.
63.
Medley, K. E.1999:
Women’s work: a positive force for the environment in Madagascar
. Women in Natural Resources20(2),
32-37
.
64.
Medley, K. E.2000:
Accentuate the positive
. Swara23(2),
14-14
.
65.
Medley, K. E.2002:
Ecology of hope for the Masoala Peninsula, Madagascar
. Focus47(2),
21-25
.
66.
Miller, R. I.
and
Allen, J. H.
, editors 1994: Mapping the diversity of nature.
London: Chapman and Hall
.
67.
Mittermeier, R. A.
,
Myers, N.
, and
Thomsen, J. B.1998:
Biodiversity hotspots and major tropical wilderness areas: approaches to
setting conservation priorities
. Conservation Biology12(3),
516-520
.
68.
Mittermeier, R. A.
,
Myers, N.
and
Mittermeier, C. G.1999: Hotspots. Earth’s biologically richest and most
endangered terrestrial ecoregions.
Mexico City: CEMEX, Conservation International.
Agropación Siera Madre, SC
.
69.
Morell, V.1999:
Restoring Madagascar
. National Geographic195(2),
60-71
.
70.
Mosse, D.2001: ‘People’s knowledge’,
participation and patronage: operations and representations in rural
development. In
Cooke, B.
and
Kothari, U.
, editors, Participation: the new tyranny?London: Zed Books
, 16-35.
71.
Myers, N.
,
Mittermeier, R. A.
,
Mittermeier, C. G.
,
da Fonseca, G. A. B.
and
Kent, J.2000:
Biodiversity hotspots for conservation priorities
. Nature403,
853-858
.
72.
Newmark, W. D.
and
Hough, J. L.2000:
Conserving wildlife in Africa: Integrated Conservation and Development
Projects and beyond
. BioScience50(7),
585-592
.
73.
New Partnership Initiative (NPI)1997: New Partnership Initiative: a strategic approach to
development partnering.
Washington DC: United States Agency for
International Development (USAID)
. http://www.usaid.gov/pubs/npi/npiresrc.htm (last accessed 4
February 2004).
74.
Noss, R. F.1990:
Indicators for monitoring biodiversity: a hierarchical approach
. Conservation Biology4,
355-364
.
75.
Nudds, T. D.1999: Adaptive management and the conservation of
biodiversity. In
Baydack, R. K.
,
Campa, H. C., III
and
Haufler, J. B.
, editors, Practical approaches to the conservation of biological
diversity.
Washington DC: Island Press
, 179-193.
76.
Olson, D. M.
and
Dinerstein, E.1998:
The global 200: a representation approach to conserving the
Earth’s most biologically valuable ecoregions
. Conservation Biology12(3),
502-515
.
77.
Perrings, C.
, editor 2000: The economics of biodiversity conservation in
sub-Saharan africa. Mending the ark.
Northampton MA: Edward Elgar
.
78.
Perrings, C.
and
Lovett, J.2000: Policies for bio-diversity conservation in sub-Saharan
Africa. In
Perrings, C.
, editor, The economics of biodiversity conservation in sub-Saharan
africa. Mending the ark.
Northhampton MA: Edward Elgar
, 309-342.
79.
Pimbert, M. P.
and
Pretty, J. N.1997: Parks, people and professionals: putting
‘participation’ into protected area management. In
Ghimire, K. B.
and
Pimbert, M. P.
, editors, Social change and conservation. Environmental politics and
impacts of national parks and protected areas.
London: Earthscan Publications Limited
, 297-330.
80.
Pretty, J.2002: People, livelihoods and collective action in biodiversity
management. In
O’Riordan, T.
and
Stoll-Kleemann, S.
, editors, Biodiversity, sustainability and human communities.
Cambridge UK: Cambridge University Press
, 61-86.
81.
Rietbergen-MacCracken, J.
and
Narayan, D.1997: Participatory rural appraisal. Module III. Participatory tools
and techniques: a resource kit for participation and social assessment. Social
Policy and Resettlement Division, Environment.
Washington DC: The World Bank
.
82.
Salafsky, N.
and
Margoluis, R.1999:
Threat reduction assessment: a practical and cost-effective approach to
evaluating conservation and development projects
. Conservation Biology13(4),
830-841
.
83.
Salafsky, N.
and
Wollenberg, E.2000:
Linking livelihoods and conservation: a conceptual framework and scale for
assessing the integration of human needs and biodiversity
. World Development28(8),
1421-1438
.
84.
Sayer, J.
,
Harcourt, C.
and
Collins, N.
, editors, 1992: The conservation atlas of tropical forests.
Africa. Forest Conservation Program, IUCN.
New York: Simon & Schuster
.
85.
Sayer, J.
,
Ishwaran, N.
,
Thorsell, J.
and
Sigaty, T.2000:
Tropical forest biodiversity and the World Heritage Convention
. Ambio29(6),
302-309
.
86.
Sheppard, D.
and
McNeely, J. A.1998: Education and protected areas: a perspective from
IUCN. In
Filho, W. L.
,
de Carvalho, C. A. R.
and
Hale, W. H. G.
, editors, Environmental education in protected areas: international
perspectives and experiences.
New York: The Parthenon Publishing Group
, 139-147.
87.
Smillie, I.1999: United States. In
Smillie, I.
and
Helmich, H.
, editors, Stakeholders. Govern-ment-NGO partnerships for international
development.
London: Earthscan Publications Ltd
, 247-262.
88.
Smillie, I.2000: NGOs: crisis and opportunity in the new world
order. In
Freedman, J.
, editor, Transforming development: foreign aid for a changing
world.
Toronto: University of Toronto Press
, 114-133.
89.
Smith, R. C.1996: Biodiversity won’t feed our children.
Biodiversity conservation and economic development in indigenous
Amazonia. In
Redford, K. H.
and
Mansour, J. A.
, editors, Traditional peoples and biodiversity conservation in large
tropical landscapes.
Arlington VA: American Verde Publications and
The Nature Conservancy
, 197-217.
90.
Soberó n, J.
,
Rodriguez, P.
and
Vázquez-Domínguez, E.2000:
Implications of the hierarchical structure of biodiversity for the
development of ecological indicators of sustainable use
. Ambio29(3),
136-142
.
91.
Sundberg, J.1998:
NGO landscapes in the maya biosphere reserve, Guatemala
. Geographical Review88,
388-412
.
92.
Swanson, R.1995: Development for conservation: monitoring and evaluation.
Unpublished report submitted to USAID/Madagascar, Antananarivo.
Gainesville, Florida: Tropical Resources and Development
.
93.
Swanson, R.1996: Hypothesis testing: do target activities reduce pressures on
parks/reserves through changed human behavior. Unpublished report prepared
for USAID/Madagascar, Antananarivo.
Gainesville, Florida: Tropical Resources and Development
.
94.
Tuxill, J.
and
Nabhan, G. P.2001: People, plants and protected areas.
London: Earthscan Ltd.
95.
Veit, P. G.
,
Mascarenhas, A.
and
Ampadu-Agyei, O.1995: Lessons from the ground up. African development that
works.
Washington DC: World Resources Institute
.
96.
Veit, P. G.
,
Nagpal, T.
and
Fox, T.1998: Africa’s wealth, woes, worth. In
Veit, P.
, editor, Africa’s valuable assets. A reader in natural
resource management.
Washington DC: World Resources Institute
, 1-25.
97.
Wapner, P.2000: The transnational politics of environmental NGOs:
governmental, economic, and social activism. In
Chasek, P. S.
, editor, The global environment in the twenty-first century: prospects
for international cooperation.
New York: United Nations University Press
, 87-108.
98.
Wells, M.
,
Brandon, K.
and
Hannah, L.1992: People and parks. Linking protected area management with local
communities.
Washington DC: The World Bank, The World
Wildlife Fund, and U.S. Agency for International Development
.
99.
Western, D.
and
Gichohi, H.1994:
Segregation effects and the impoverishment of savanna parks: the case for
ecosystem viability analysis
. African Journal of Ecology31,
269-281
.
100.
Sobero Western, D.
,
Wright, R. M.
and
Strum, S. C.
, editors, 1994: Natural connections: perspectives in
community-based conservation.
Washington DC: Island Press
.
101.
Wilshusen, P. R.
,
Brechin, S. R.
,
Fortwangler, C. L.
and
West, P. C.2002:
Reinventing a square wheel: critique of a resurgent ‘protection
paradigm’ in international biodiversity conservation
. Society and Natural Resources15,
17-40
.
102.
Wollenberg, E.
,
Edmunds, D.
and
Buck, L.2000:
Using scenarios to make decisions about the future: anticipatory learning
for the adaptive co-management of community forests
. Landscape and Urban Planning47,
65-77
.
103.
World Bank1996: Madagascar second environment program (EP2). Staff
Appraisal Report.
Washington DC: World Bank
.
104.
World Resources Institute (WRI)
,
The World Conservation Union (IUCN)
and the
United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP)1992: Global biodiversity strategy.
Washington DC: World Resources Institute
.
105.
Wright, P.1997: The future of biodiversity in Madagascar: a view from
Ranomafana National Park. In
Goodman, S. M.
and
Patterson, B. D.
, editors, Natural change and human impact in Madagascar.
Washington DC: Smithsonian Institution Press
, 381-405.
106.
Young, E.1999:
Local people and conservation in Mexico’s El Vizaíno
Biosphere Reserve
. Geographical Review89(3),
364-390
.
107.
Zimmerer, K. S.
and
Bassett, T. J.
, editors, 2003: Political ecology. An integrative approach to
geography and environment-development studies.
New York: The Guilford Press
.
108.
Zimmerer K.S. and Young, K.R. 1998: Introduction: the geographical nature of land-
