From HIV prevention to HIV protection: addressing the vulnerability of girls and young women in urban areas

Abstract

This paper argues that there is a need to revisit prevention methodologies with regard to HIV/AIDS, especially in relation to urban areas. Unlike in other epidemics, where it was recognized that the physical and social environments had a key role, HIV/AIDS has become the terrain of moralists, who insist that individual behaviour drives the epidemic and who pour millions of dollars into individual behaviour change programmes. This is done regardless of the obvious truth that HIV/AIDS flourishes in a situation of poverty, compounded by inequity and lack of social cohesion, and that those most affected by an epidemic are precisely those who are affected by that environment. In the case of HIV/AIDS in Africa, these are adolescent girls and young women, especially in urban areas. The paper also looks at how the physical environment (including the effects on the immune system of malnutrition, helminths and bilharzia) and social environment affect the vulnerability of adolescent girls and young women, who have often migrated to town, live and work in squatter areas, are isolated, and are victims of sexual exploitation and abuse. The very high number of orphans that existed before HIV/AIDS, and that has increased further as a result of the epidemic, compounds the situation. The highest number of child-headed households is in informal settlements in urban areas, which have the most sexual abuse and the highest HIV prevalence. This paper builds on the above to highlight the inadequacy of current behaviour change interventions, quite apart from the fact that the most vulnerable are not even reached by these interventions. It argues for deliberate and systematic attention to be paid to these girls and young women, to ensure that they are identified, included and allowed to participate in developing the protective environment and safe spaces in the community, in schools and in livelihoods which will enable them to protect themselves from HIV infection. This requires addressing the underlying and basic causes, including the impact of globalization, for the continued spread of the epidemic.

Keywords

gender girls HIV/AIDS protection poverty urban areas vulnerability

References

Adefrsew, A (2003), “Study on child sexual abuse and exploitation in Shashemenae and Dilla towns”, Forum for Street Children, Addis Ababa .

Adeyi, O , R Hecht , E Njobvu and A Soucat (2001), AIDS, Poverty Reduction and Debt Relief: A Toolkit for Mainstreaming HIV/AIDS Programmes into Development Instruments, UNAIDS/World Bank, Geneva .

Barnett, T and A Whiteside (2002), AIDS in the Twenty-First Century: Disease and Globalization, Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke .

Batebie, Z S, C Meyers, G Mireille and L Salif (2005), “Exercice de couverture des activités des paires éducateurs au Burkina Faso: rapport final”, Population Council and UNFPA.

Bruce, J and A Joyce (editors) with contributions from N Haberland , E Chong and M Grant (2006, forthcoming), The Girls Left Behind: The Failed Reach of Current Schooling, Child Health, Youth Serving and Livelihoods Programmes for Girls Living in the Path of HIV.

Centre for AIDS Development, Research and Evaluation - CADRE (2004), Child Sexual Abuse, HIV and AIDS in South Africa: A Review, CADRE, Johannesburg .

Chawla, L (2002), “Insight, creativity and thoughts on the environment: integrating children and youth into human settlement development” , Environment & Urbanization Vol 14, No 2, October, pages 11-22 .

D’Cruz, Celine and David Satterthwaite (2005), “Building Homes, changing official approaches: the work of urban poor federations and their contributions to meeting the Millennium Development Goals in urban areas”, Working Paper 16 in Poverty Reduction in Urban Areas Series, IIED, London .

Denny, L (2001), “How best can South Africa address the impact of HIV/AIDS on women and girls?” Presentation to the Joint Monitoring Committee on Improvement of Quality of Life and Status of Women , available at http://www.pmg.org.za/appendix/010925GSH.htm.

10.

Environment & Urbanization (2002), Vol 14, No 2, October.

11.

Erulkar, A , T Mekbib , N Simie and T Gulema (2004), Adolescent Life in Low-income and Slum Areas of Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, Population Council/Ministry of Youth Sports and Culture, Addis Ababa .

12.

Gender-AIDS@lists.healthdev.net.

13.

Guerra, Eliana (2002), “Citizenship knows no age: children’s participation in the governance and municipal budget of Barra Mansa, Brazil” , Environment & Urbanization Vol 14, No 2, October, pages 71-84 .

14.

Hallman, K (2004), “Socioeconomic disadvantage and unsafe sexual behaviours of young women and men in South Africa”, Policy Research Division Working Paper No 190, New York Population Council .

15.

Hallman, K (2005) “Gendered socioeconomic conditions and HIV risk behaviours among young people in South Africa” , African Journal of AIDS Research Vol 4, No 1, pages 37-50 .

16.

Hallman, K and J Diere (2005), “Social isolation and economic vulnerability: adolescent HIV and pregnancy risk factors in South Africa” , poster presentation at the Annual Meeting of the Population Association of America, Boston, MA.

17.

Human Rights Watch (2002), “Suffering in silence: the links between human rights abuses and HIV transmission to girls in Zambia”, Human Rights Watch, New York .

18.

Kelly, M (2005), “AIDS, education and the MDGs” , Paper presented to the International Students’ Conference against AIDS, Lusaka, July 2005.

19.

Khan, Arjmand Banu and Ann Leonard (2002), Skills Training and Beyond: Expanding Livelihood Opportunities for Adolescent Girls and Young Women in Kenya, Population Council, Nairobi .

20.

Landgren, K (2005), “The protective environment: development support for children”, in Human Rights Quarterly 27, Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore .

21.

Landsdown, G (2005), Innocenti Insight: The Evolving Capacity of the Child, Save the Children, UNICEF .

22.

Lowicki, J (2000), Untapped Potential: Adolescents Affected by Armed Conflict, Women’s Commission for Refugee Women and Children, New York .

23.

Marais, H (2005), Buckling. The Impact of AIDS in South Africa, University of Pretoria, Pretoria .

24.

Mekbib, T , A Erulkar and F Belete (2005), “Who are the targets of youth programmes: results of the capacity-building exercise in Ethiopia” , Ethiopian Journal of Health Development Vol 19, No 1, pages 60-62 .

25.

Mensch, B S , J Bruce and M E Greene (1998), The Uncharted Passage: Girls’ Adolescence in the Developing World, Population Council, New York .

26.

Molo Songololo (2000), “The trafficking of children for purposes of sexual exploitation”, Cape Town .

27.

Mullen, P E and J Fleming (1998), “Long-term effects of child sexual abuse”, Issues in Child Abuse Prevention 9, Australian Institute of Family Studies, Melbourne .

28.

National Research Council and Institute of Medicine (2005), Growing up Global: The Changing Transition to Adulthood in Developing Countries, Panel on Transitions to Adulthood in Developing Countries, edited by Cynthia Lloyd , Committee on Population and Board on Children, Youth and Families, Division of Behavioural and Social Sciences and Education, Washington DC, The National Academies Press, Washington DC .

29.

Panos (2003), Missing the Message, The Panos Institute, London .

30.

Rajaraman, D (2001), “The future of the nation: HIV/AIDS and orphans in Botswana”, unpublished paper.

31.

Satterthwaite, D (2002), Coping with Rapid Urban Growth, RICS, London .

32.

Satterthwaite, D and T Bigg (editors) (2005), How to Make Poverty History. The Central Role of Local Organizations in Meeting the MDGs, IIED, London .

33.

Shisana, O (principle investigator) and L Simbaya (2002), “Nelson Mandela/HSRC study of HIV/AIDS: South African national HIV prevalence, behaviour risks and mass media household survey 2002”, HSRC, MRC, CADRE, ANRS, Pretoria .

34.

Shisana O , T Rehle , L C Simbayi , W Parker , K Zuma , A Bhana , C Connolly , S Jooste , V Pollay et al. (2005), South African National HIV Prevalence, HIV Incidence, Behaviour and Communication Survey, HSRC Press, Cape Town .

35.

Stillwaggon, E (2006), Aids and the Ecology of Poverty, Oxford University Press, Oxford .

36.

Swan, N J and K Hallman (2002), “Adolescent livelihoods programme situation, Durban, South Africa: a situation analysis”, mimeo .

37.

TvT Associates/The Synergy Project (2002), Children on the Brink, UNAIDS, UNICEF and USAID .

38.

UN ESCOR (1998), “Report of the Special Rapporteur on the sale of children, child prostitution and child pornography”, UN ESCOR Commission on Human Rights 54th Session .

39.

UNAIDS (1999), “Fact sheet on differences in HIV spread in African cities”, UNAIDS, Geneva .

40.

UNAIDS (2002), “Thailand country profile: HIV/AIDS situation in Thailand and national response to epidemic”, UNAIDS, Bangkok .

41.

UNAIDS (2004), “Facing the future together”, Report of the Secretary General’s Task Force on Women, Girls and HIV/AIDS in Southern Africa, UNAIDS .

42.

UNAIDS (2004), “Epidemic update”, UNAIDS, Geneva .

43.

USAID , UNAIDS , WHO , UNICEF , CDC , US Census Bureau (2004), Tanzania HIV/AIDS Indicator Survey 2003-04.

44.

WHO (2002), World Report on Violence and Health, WHO, Geneva .

45.

World Bank (2005), The World Bank’s Global HIV/AIDS Programme of Action 2005, IBRD/World Bank, Washington .