Structural behavior of hospitals during the Kahramanmaraş earthquake of February 6,2023

Abstract

On February 6, 2023, two earthquakes (M_w 7.8 and 7.5) occurred in Turkey. The earthquakes impacted 10 provinces in Turkey and others in Syria, resulting in significant casualties due to the total and partial collapse of many buildings. This article evaluates the impact of damage on the performance of healthcare services based on the investigation of seven hospitals. The observed damages in structural and non-structural elements identified during a post-earthquake inspection are presented and discussed in detail. When possible, interviews with hospital managers and staff members were conducted to understand the key decisions and possible rehabilitation activities after the earthquake. The study aims to improve knowledge of the seismic performance of hospitals and identifies aspects to improve the structural performance of healthcare infrastructure under severe seismic demands.

Keywords

Hospital damage isolator non-structural element collapse

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

AFAD (2023a) e-Government Gateway. Seismic information. Presidency of the Republic of Turkey. Transformation office. Retrieved on June 5, 2023. Available at: https://giris.turkiye.gov.tr/Giris/gir (in Turkish).

AFAD (2023b) Press Bulletin-36 about the Earthquake in Kahramanmaraş. Ministry of Interior, Disaster and Emergency Management Presidency, Department of Earthquake. Retrieved on May 25, 2023. Available at: https://en.afad.gov.tr/press-bulletin-36-about-the-earthquake-in-kahramanmaras

Achour

Miyajima

(2020) Post-earthquake hospital functionality evaluation: The case of Kumamoto Earthquake 2016. Earthquake Spectra 36(4): 1670–1694.

Achour

Miyajima

Kitaura

Price

(2011) Earthquake-induced structural and nonstructural damage in hospitals. Earthquake Spectra 27(3): 617–634.

Artigerçek (2023) Hatay’s earthquake report was announced. Artı gerçek Newspaper, Retrieved on May 24, 2023. Available at: https://artigercek.com/guncel/hatayin-deprem-raporu-aciklandi-89-bin-25-bina-gitti-245608h (in Turkish).

Baltzopoulus

Baraschino

Chioccarelli

Cito

Vitale

Iervolino

(2023) Near-source ground motion in the M7.8 Gaziantep (Turkey) earthquake. Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamics 52: 3903–3912.

Birpinar

[@Mbirpinar] (2023) We have completed our damage assessment work. The building stock of Hatay province is around 365 thousand. [Image attached]. Twitter, Retrieved on October 10, 2023. Available at: https://twitter.com/Mbirpinar/status/1638498226696339456 (in Turkish).

Bruneau

Chang

Eguchi

Lee

O’Rourke

Reinhorn

Shinozuka

Tierney

Wallace

Von Winterfeldt

(2003) A framework to quantitatively assess and enhance the seismic resilience of communities. Earthquake Spectra 19(4): 733–752.

Büyüksaraç

Işik

Bektaş

(2022) A comparative evaluation of earthquake code change on seismic parameter and structural analysis; a case of Turkey. Arabian Journal for Science and Engineering 47: 12301–12321.

10.

Caglar

Vural

Kirtel

Saribiyik

Sumer

(2023) Structural damages observed in buildings after the January 24, 2020 Elaziğ-Sivrice earthquake in Turkey. Case Studies in Construction Materials 18: e01886.

11.

Cimellaro

Reinhorn

Bruneau

(2008) Seismic resilience of a hospital system. Structure and Infrastructure Engineering 6(1–2): 127–144.

12.

Cubrinovski

Bradley

Elwood

Johnston

Orchiston

Sullivan

Wotherspoon

(2020) Wellington’s earthquake resilience: Lessons from the 2016 Kaikoura earthquake. Earthquake Spectra 36(3): 1448–1484.

13.

Dilsiz

Günay

Mosalam

(2023) Joint Preliminary virtual reconnaissance report, 2023 Türkiye Earthquake Sequence (StEER Structural Extreme Events Reconnaissance. Project ID: PRJ-3824). Earthquake Engineering Research Institute.

14.

Gülkan

Çeken

Çolakoğlu

Uğraş

Kuru

Apak

Anderson

Sucuoğlu

Çelebi

Akkar

Yazgan

Denizlioğlu

(2007) Enhancement of the national strong-motion network in Turkey. Seismological Research Letters 78(4): 429–438.

15.

Jacques

Mcintosh

Giovinazzi

Kirsch

Wilson

Mitrani-Reiser

(2014) Resilience of the Canterbury Hospital System to the 2011 Christchurch Earthquake. Earthquake Spectra 30(1): 533–554.

16.

Liu

Zhai

(2022) A probabilistic framework to evaluate seismic resilience of buildings using Bayesian Networks. Reliability Engineering and System Safety 226: 108644.

17.

Nagarajaiah

Xiaohong

(2000) Response of base-isolated USC hospital building in Northridge earthquake. Journal of Structural Engineering 126(10): 1177–1186.

18.

Price

De Sortis

Schotanus

(2012) Performance of the San Salvatore Regional Hospital in the 2009 L’Aquila Earthquake. Earthquake Spectra 28(1): 239–256.

19.

Sato

Furukawa

Kakehi

Nakashima

(2011) Full-scale shaking table test for examination of safety and functionality of base-isolated medical facilities. Earthquake Engineering Structural Dynamics 40(13): 1435–1453.

20.

Tapia-Hernández

García-Carrera

(2020) Damage assessment and Seismic behavior of Steel Buildings during the Mexico Earthquake of September 19, 2017. Earthquake Spectra 36(1): 250–270.

21.

TBEC-1998 (1998). Turkish Building Earthquake Code. Ankara, Turkey: T.C. Resmi Gazete (in Turkish).

22.

TBEC-2007 (2007). Turkish Building Earthquake Code. Ankara, Turkey: T.C. Resmi Gazete.

23.

TBEC-2018 (2018). Turkish Building Earthquake Code. Ankara, Turkey: T.C. Resmi Gazete (in Turkish).

24.

TIS (2023) General evaluation report of seismically isolated. Pazarcik and Elbistan Earthquake. Report no. 3.01.30. Ankara, Turkey: Teknolojik Izolatör Sistemleri.

25.

TMHH (2022) History of Dörtyol State Hospital. Republic of Turkey Ministry of Health, Retrieved on May 26, 2023. Available at: https://dortyoldh.saglik.gov.tr/TR-8770/tarihcemiz.html (in Turkish).

26.

TMHK (2022) Kahramanmaraş provincial directorate of health. Republic of Turkey Ministry of Health, Retrieved on June 6, 2023. Available at: https://elbistandh.saglik.gov.tr/TR-593150/tarihcemiz.html (in Turkish).