Demonstrating Value for Human and Social Services Investment

Abstract

Neoliberal processes in Australia have seen the ‘roll out’ of the market-based approaches and ‘roll back’ of the welfare state sector, with significant impacts on the human and social services sector. Social services have been cast as a burden on the public purse and have been increasingly forced to show efficiencies, provide greater accountability and demonstrate their value and outcomes. This article explores the impacts of neoliberal reforms on the human and social services in Australia following consultations with the sector. The article unpacks the challenges for the sector in demonstrating value to justify further social investments. Four key areas emerge from consultations with service agencies as focus points: commodification of services, the fallacy of the choice discourse, challenges to service viability, and problems with measures and methods for accountability and demonstrating value. The article concludes with recommendations for future directions and change.

Keywords

Human and social services demonstrating value return on investment neoliberalism

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ACNC. (2014). Australian Charities Report 2014 . Melbourne: Australian Charities and Not-for-profits Commission.

Aiken

Bode

(2009). Killing the golden goose? Third sector organizations and back-to-work programmes in Germany and the UK. Social Policy & Administration , 43(3), 209–225.

Aldred

(2008). NHS LIFT and the new shape of neoliberal welfare. Capital and Class , 32(2), 31–57.

Alston

(2005). Forging a new paradigm for Australian rural social work practice. Rural Society , 15(3), 277–284.

Alston

Kent

(2004). Coping with a crisis: Human services in times of drought. Rural Society , 14(3), 214–227.

Arvidson

Lyon

(2014). Social impact measurement and non-profit organisations: Compliance, resistance, and promotion. Voluntas: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations , 25(4), 869–886.

Australian Human Rights Commission. (2012). Human rights approach to ageing and health: Respect and choice . Sydney: Author. Retrieved from https://www.humanrights.gov.au/sites/default/files/document/publication/human_rights_framework_for_ageing_and_health.pdf

Babacan

(2014). Human services sector development in Northern Australia. In Institute

Regional Australia

(Ed.), Green paper on developing northern Australia: A joint submission to the Northern Australia taskforce . Canberra: The Regional Australia Institute.

Bettman

Luce

Payne

(2006). Constructive consumer choice processes. In Lichtenstein

Slovic

(Eds.), The construction of preference (pp. 323–342). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

10.

Biesta

(2010). Good education in an age of measurement: Ethics, politics, democracy . Boulder, CO: Paradigm Publishers.

11.

Birch

Siemiatycki

(2016). Neoliberalism and the geographies of marketization: The entangling of state and markets. Progress in Human Geography , 40(2), 177–198.

12.

Brandsen

van de Donk

Putters

(2005). Griffins or chameleons? Hybridity as a permanent and inevitable characteristic of the third sector. International Journal of Public Administration , 28(9), 749–765.

13.

Bromley

(2010). The rationalization of educational development: Scientific activity among international nongovernmental organizations. Comparative Education Review , 54(4), 577–601.

14.

Cabinet Office. (2009). A guide to social return on investment . London: Office of the Third Sector. Retrieved from https://neweconomics.org/uploads/files/aff3779953c5b88d53_cpm6v3v71.pdf

15.

Cahill

Edwards

Stilwell

(Eds.) (2012). Neoliberalism: Beyond the free market. Capital and Class , 37(3), 496–499.

16.

Chenoweth

(2008). Redefining welfare: Australian social policy and practice. Asian Social Work and Policy Review , 2(1), 53–60.

17.

Chester

(2010). Actually existing markets: The case of neoliberal Australia. Journal of Economic Issues , 44(2), 313–324.

18.

Chiu

(2017). The impact of economic rationalism on the Australian public service: From 1991 to the present. In Yeatman

(Ed.), Economic rationalism in Canberra: Twenty-five years on (Working Papers in the Human Rights and Public Life Program No. 5; pp. 22–29). Sydney: Whitlam Institute, Western Sydney University. Retrieved from https://www.flipsnack.com/Whitlam/economic-rationalism-in-canberra-25-years-on.html?p=22

19.

Christensen

Lagreid

(Eds.). (2013). The Ashgate research companion to new public management . Farnham: Ashgate Publishers.

20.

Clarke

(2007). Citizen-consumers and public service reform. Policy Futures in Education , 5(2), 239–248.

21.

Connell

(2013). The neoliberal cascade and education: An essay on the market agenda and its consequences. Critical Studies in Education , 54(2), 99–112.

22.

Considine

(2003). Governance and competition: The role of non-profit organisations in the delivery of public services. Australian Journal of Political Science , 38(1), 63–77.

23.

Cunningham

Ricks

(2004). Why measure: Nonprofits use metrics to show that they are efficient: But what if donors don’t care? Stanford Social Innovation Review , 2, 44– 51.

24.

Davis

J. A.

Marino

L. D.

Aaron

J. R.

Tolbert

C. L.

(2011). An examination of entrepreneurial orientation, environmental scanning, and market strategies of non-profit and for-profit nursing home administrators. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly , 40(1), 197–211.

25.

Dekker

(2009). Civicness: From civil society to civic services? Voluntas , 20(3), 220–238.

26.

Dewson

Eccles

Tackey

N. D.

Jackson

(2000). Guide to measuring soft outcomes and distance travelled . Brighton: Institute for Employment Studies.

27.

Dixon

Robertson

Appleby

Burge

Devlin

Magee

(2010). Patient choice . London: Kings Fund.

28.

Ebrahim

Rangan

V. K.

(2010). Putting the brakes on impact: A contingency framework for measuring social performance. Academy of Management Proceedings , 2010(1), 1–6.

29.

Eikenberry

A. M.

Kluver

J. D.

(2004). The marketization of the non-profit sector: Civil society at risk. Public Administration Review , 64(2), 132–140.

30.

Esteves

A. M.

Franks

Vanclay

(2012). Social impact assessment: The state of the art. Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal , 30(1), 34–42.

31.

Evers

(2005). Mixed welfare systems and hybrid organizations: Changes in the governance and provision of social services. International Journal of Public Administration , 28(9), 737–748.

32.

Fitzgerald

Knipe

(2016). Policy reform: Testing times for teacher education in Australia. Journal of Educational Administration and History . 48(4), 1–12.

33.

Flockhart

(2005). Raising the profile of social enterprises: The use of social return on investment (SROI) and investment ready tools (IRT) to bridge the financial credibility gap. Social Enterprise Journal , 1(10), 29–42.

34.

Fotaki

(2013). Is patient choice the future of health care systems? International Journal of Health Policy Management , 1(2), 121–123.

35.

Frank

R. G.

Zeckhauser

R. J.

(2009). Health insurance exchanges—making the markets. New England Journal of Medicine , 361(12), 1135–1137.

36.

Gent

(2018). ‘Expensive’ people: Consumer citizenship and the limits of choice in neoliberal publics. Communication and the Public , 3(3), 190–204.

37.

Gibbon

Dey

(2011). Developments in social impact measurement in the third sector: Scaling up or dumbing down? Social and Environmental Accountability Journal , 31(1), 63–72.

38.

Gittins

(2013 December 18). Not everything that counts can be counted. Sydney Morning Herald . Retrieved from https://www.smh.com.au/opinion/not-everything-that-counts-can-be-counted20131217-2zj6e.html

39.

Goetz

A. M.

Jenkins

(2003). Voice, accountability and human development: The emergence of a new agenda . New York, NY: United Nations Development Programme.

40.

Gopalkrishnan

(2007). Neo-liberalism and lnfeartainment: What does a state do. In Babacan

Gopalkrishnan

(Eds.), Racisms in the new world order: Realities of culture, colour and identity (pp. 22–33). Newcastle: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.

41.

Greene

J. C.

(1994). Qualitative program evaluation: Practice and promise. In Denzin

N. K.

Lincoln

Y. S.

(Eds.), Handbook of qualitative research (pp. 530–544). California, CA: SAGE Publications.

42.

Gugerty

M. K.

Prakash

(2010). Voluntary regulation of NGOs and nonprofits: An accountability club framework . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

43.

Harvey

(2005). A brief history of neoliberalism . Oxford: Oxford University Press.

44.

Heale

Forbes

(2013). Understanding triangulation in research. Evidence Based Nursing , 16(4), 98.

45.

Hodge

Greve

(2010). Public–private partnerships: Governance scheme or language game? The Australian Journal of Public Administration , 69(1), 8–22.

46.

Howard-Wagner

(2018). Moving from transactional government to enablement in Indigenous service delivery: The era of new public management, service innovation and urban Aboriginal community development. Australian Journal of Social Issues , 53(3), 262–282.

47.

Hvenmark

(2013), Business as usual? On managerialization and the adoption of the balanced scorecard in a democratically governed civil society organization. Administrative Theory and Praxis , 35(2), 223–247.

48.

Hwang

Powell

W. W.

(2009). The rationalization of charity: The influences of professionalism in the nonprofit Sector. Administrative Science Quarterly , 54(2), 268–298.

49.

Jordan

(2007). A rights-based approach to accountability. In Ebrahim

Weisband

(Eds.), Global accountabilities: Participation, pluralism, and public ethics (pp. 151–167). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

50.

Keating

V. C.

Thrandardottir

(2017). NGOs, trust, and the accountability agenda. The British Journal of Politics and International Relations , 19(1), 134–151.

51.

Keevers

Treleaven

Sykes

Darcy

(2012). Made to measure: Taming practices with results-based accountability. Organization Studies , 33(1), 97–120.

52.

Kerlin

J. A.

(2013). Defining social enterprise across different contexts: A conceptual framework based on institutional factors. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly , 42(1), 84–108.

53.

Kitson

Martin

Tyler

(2011). The geographies of austerity. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society , 4(3), 289–302.

54.

Kroeger

Weber

(2014). Developing a conceptual framework for comparing social value creation. Academy of Management Review , 39(4), 513–540.

55.

Larner

(2000). Neo-liberalism: Policy, ideology, governmentality. Studies in Political Economy , 63(1), 5–25.

56.

Lee

Moon

(2017). Is consumer choice in health care good for society from an efficiency perspective. European Journal of Public Health , 27(3), 434.

57.

Limerick

Morris

Sutton

(2012). Local government service delivery to remote indigenous communities: Review of service delivery models and approaches in various jurisdictions . Broadway, NY: Australian Centre for Excellence for Local Government.

58.

Lingard

(2005). Socially just pedagogies in changing times. International Studies in Sociology of Education , 15(2), 165–186.

59.

Lyon

Arvidson

(2011). Social impact measurement as an entrepreneurial process (Third Sector Research Centre Briefing Paper 66}. Birmingham: University of Birmingham. Retrieved from https://www.birmingham.ac.uk/Documents/college-social-sciences/social-policy/tsrc/working-papers/briefing-paper-66.pdf

60.

Maier

Meyer

Steinbereithner

(2016). Nonprofit organizations becoming business-like: A systematic review. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly , 45(1), 64–86.

61.

Marston

McDonald

Bryson

(2013). The Australian welfare state: Who benefits now? Melbourne: Palgrave MacMillan.

62.

McNeil

Reeder

Rich

(2012). A framework for outcomes for young people . The Young Foundation. Retrieved from https://youngfoundation.org/publications/framework-of-outcomes-for-nonprofit/

63.

Moran

Anda

Elvin

Kennedy

Long

McFallan

Young

(2009). Desert services that work: Year one research report (Working Paper No. 30). Alice Springs: Desert Knowledge Cooperative Research Centre. Retrieved from https://www.nintione.com.au/resources/rao/desert-services-that-work-year-one-research-report/

64.

Murtaza

(2011). Putting the lasts first: The case for community-focused and peer-managed NGO accountability mechanisms. Voluntas International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations , 23(1), 109–125.

65.

Musson

(2008 April 15–19). Public–private partnerships the geography of the state. Boston MA: American Association of Geographers Annual Conference.

66.

Nicholls

(2010). The legitimacy of social entrepreneurship: Reflexive isomorphism in a pre-paradigmatic field. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice , 34(4), 611–633.

67.

Peck

(2010). Constructions of neoliberal reason . Oxford: Oxford University Press.

68.

Peck

Ticknell

(2002). Neoliberalizing space. Antipode , 34(3), 380–404.

69.

Peters

M.A.

(2012). Neoliberalism, education and the crisis of western capitalism. Policy Futures in Education , 10(2), 134.

70.

Pollack

(2008). Labelling clients ‘risky’: Social work and the neo-liberal welfare state. British Journal of Social Work , 40(4), 1263–1278.

71.

Polonsky

Grau

S. L.

(2011). Assessing the social impact of charitable organizations—Four alternative approaches. International Journal of Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Marketing , 16(2), 195–211.

72.

Power

(1997). The audit society: Rituals of verification . Oxford: Oxford University Press.

73.

Productivity Commission. (2010). Contribution of the not-for-profit sector (Research Report). Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia.

74.

Productivity Commission. (2011). Caring for older Australians (Report No. 53; Final Enquiry Report). Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia.

75.

Productivity Commission. (2016). Introducing competition and informed user choice into human services: Identifying sectors for reform (Study Report). Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia.

76.

Pusey

(2017). Economic rationalism in Canberra: Twenty-five years on. In Yeatman

77.

Reinders

(2008). The transformation of human services. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research , 52(7), 564–572.

78.

Richie

W. J.

Anthony

W. P.

Rubine

A. J.

(2004). Individual executive characteristics: Explaining the divergence between perceptual and financial measures of non-profit organizations. Journal of Business Ethics , 53(3), 267–281.

79.

Rutherford

(2003). Private finance initiative (PFI): The only show in town. Soundings , 21(3), 41–54.

80.

Spolander

Engelbrecht

Martin

Styrdom

Pervova

Marjanen

Adaikalam

(2014). The implication of neoliberalism for social work: Reflections from a six-country international research collaboration. International Social Work , 57(4), 301–312.

81.

Springer

(2012). Neoliberalism as discourse: Between Foucauldian political economy and Marxian poststructuralism. Critical Discourse Studies , 9(2), 133–147.

82.

Taylor-Gooby

(2004). New risks, New welfare . Oxford: Oxford University Press.

83.

Tonts

(2004). Spatially uneven development: Government policy and rural reform in the wheatbelt of Western Australia. Anthropological Forum , 14(3), 237–252.

84.

Tonts

McKenzie

(2005). Neoliberalism and changing regional policy in Australia. International Planning Studies , 10(3–4), 183–200.

85.

van Gramberg

Basset

(2005). Neoliberalism and the third sector in Australia (Working Paper Series). Melbourne: School of Management, Victoria University.

86.

Wallace

Pease

(2011). Neoliberalism and Australian social work: Accommodation or resistance? Journal of Social Work , 11(2), 132–142.

87.

Warren

Lloyd

(2009). Civil society self-regulation: The global picture . Oneworld Trust. Retrieved from http://www.oneworldtrust.org/csoproject/images/documents/CSO-self-regulation-the-global-picture-OWT-119-2009.pdf

88.

Welch

(2015). Evidence-based policy: Epistemologically specious, ideologically unsound. In Proctor

Brownlee

Freebody

(Eds.), Controversies in education: Orthodoxy and heresy in policy and practice (pp. 63–80). New York, NY: Springer.

89.

Weller

O’Neill

(2014). An argument with neoliberalism: Australia’s place in a global imaginary, dialogues. Human Geography , 4(2), 105–130.

90.

Western

Baxter

Janeen

Pakulski

Tranter

Western

van Gellecum

(2007). Neoliberalism, inequality and politics: The changing face of Australia. Australian Journal of Social Issues , 42(3), 401–418.

91.

Whitfield

(2010). The dynamics of public sector transformation. Soundings , 46, 99–111.

92.

Winslow

Baker

Goehring

(2018). The neoliberal conquest of the Supreme Court. Communication and the Public , 3(3), 205–217.

93.

Woolcock

(2013). Using case studies to explore the external validity of ‘complex’ development interventions. Evaluation , 19(3), 229–248.

94.

Wyn

(2007). Learning to ‘become somebody well’: Challenges for educational policy. The Australian Educational Researcher , 34(3), 35–52.