‘A pilgrimage of camels’: Dairy capitalism,nomadic pastoralism,and subnational Hindutva statism in Rajasthan

Abstract

Hindu nationalists and NGOs proffer camel dairying as an employment strategy for Rajasthan's nomadic pastoralists, akin to the commodification of bovine milk for poverty alleviation in India. Commercial dairying however is inconsistent with pastoralist ethics though it is consistent with the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party's broader agenda to consolidate Hindutva at the national and subnational levels in India, and with developmentalism that regards animals as capital. In an original contribution bringing together pastoralist studies and critical animal geographies, this paper introduces species to the ‘conjugated oppressions’ in agrarian economies, currently composing caste, tribes, and class, through the suturing of (dairy) capitalism and right-wing ultranationalism. Focussing the camels and the Raika herders in the subregions of Jaisalmer, and Sirohi, home to India's only camel sanctuary, the paper delineates how the camel is entrapped in the coalescing and conflicts of dairy-based development and Hindutva nationalism. Interconnected oppressions upon the camels and herders are conceptualised and enacted through the control and appropriation of rangelands, understood as yatra or pilgrimage by the pastoralists. However, the camel is also enmeshed in the older violent histories of domestication, raising difficult questions about how nomadic and camel sovereignties may be imagined, together. Arguing that dairy capitalism will discipline the nomads and camels while strengthening Hindutva in Rajasthan, the paper draws on pastoralist worldviews as a starting point to re-imagine human–animal relations, based on an ethic of de-commodification.

Keywords

pastoralism Raika tribe camel dairying subnational Rajasthan statism Hindu nationalism

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Asnani

(2020) Rajasthan: Bans fail to loosen sand mining mafia’s vice-like grip. The New Indian Express. https://www.newindianexpress.com/nation/2020/feb/21/rajasthan-bans-fail-to-loosen-mining-mafias-vice-like-grip-2106356.html (accessed 15 November 2021)

Bornstein

Younan

(2013) Significant veterinary research on the dromedary camels of Kenya: Past and present. Journal of Camelid Science 6: 1–48.

Brandlova

Bartos

Haberova

(2013) Camel calves as opportunistic milk thefts? The first description of allosuckling in domestic bactrian camel (Camelus bactrianus). PLoS One 8(1): 1–9.

Bazzoli

De Marchi

Cecchinato

, et al. (2014) Factors associated with age at slaughter and carcass weight, price, and value of dairy cull cows. Journal of Dairy Science 97(2): 1082–1091.

Bourgois

(1988) Conjugated oppression: Class and ethnicity among Guaymi and Kuna banana workers. American Ethnologist 15(2): 328–348.

Brara

(1992) Are grazing lands wastelands? Some evidence from Rajasthan. Economic and Political Weekly 2(8): 411–418.

Chacko

(2019) Marketizing hindutva: The state, society, and markets in Hindu nationalism. Modern Asian Studies 53(2): 377–410.

Chandran

(2020) South Asian herders fight for right to roam as pressure to settle grows. Reuters . https://www.reuters.com/article/instant-article/idUKL5N26N43K (accessed 8 February 2021)

Collard

R-C

Dempsey

(2017) Capitalist natures in five orientations. Capitalism Nature Socialism 28(1): 78–97.

10.

Connell

St Denny

Martin

(2021) How can subnational governments develop and deliver distinctive policy agendas? International Review of Administrative Sciences 1−17. doi:10.1177/0020852321996429

11.

Crowley

(2014) Camels Out of place and time: The dromedary (Camelus dromedarius) in Australia. Anthrozoös 27(2): 191–203.

12.

CSE (2021). CSE’s report on mining – rich lands poor people – released in Rajasthan. https://www.cseindia.org/cses-report-on-mining-rich-lands-poor-people-released-in-rajasthan-435 (accessed 31 March 2021)

13.

Das

(2015) Critical observations on neo-liberalism and India’s new economic policy. Journal of Contemporary Asia 45(4): 715–726.

14.

Deckha

(2020) Unsettling anthropocentric legal systems: Reconciliation. Indigenous Laws, and Animal Personhood. Journal of Intercultural Studies 41(1): 77–97.

15.

Dhar

(2014) Camel made Rajasthan state animal. The Hindu . https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/camel-made-rajasthan-state-animal/article6167575.ece (accessed 7 December 2020)

16.

Farm Policy Exports (2019) Subsidy spotlight: India. https://www.farmpolicyfacts.org/2018/10/subsidy-spotlight-india-2/ (accessed 15 January 2021)

17.

FAO (2021). Policy support and governance gateway. FAO . http://www.fao.org/policy-support/policy-themes/pastoralism/en/ (accessed 19 April 2021)

18.

Francione

(2020) Some brief comments on animal rights. Animal Frontiers 10(1): 29–33.

19.

Garibaldi

Turner

(2004) Cultural keystone species: Implications for ecological conservation and restoration. Ecology and Society 9(3): 1–18.

20.

Ghai

(2021) Understanding ‘culture’ of pastoralism and ‘modern development’ in Thar: Muslim pastoralists of north-west Rajasthan, India. Pastoralism 11: 3.

21.

Gellner

(2014) Introduction. In Gellner

(Ed.). Borderland Lives in Northern South Asia. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 1–23.

22.

Gilbert

(2014) Nomadic Peoples and Human Rights. New York. NY: Routledge.

23.

Gillespie

(2018). The Cow with Ear Tag #1389. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

24.

Gillespie

Narayanan

(2022) Global atmospheres of violence: Shifting terrains of othering in feminist multispecies witnessing. In Adams

Gruen

(Eds.). Ecofeminism: Feminist Intersections with Other Animals and the Earth. London: Bloomsbury. 335–353.

25.

Giraud

. (2019). What Comes After Entanglement? Activism, Anthropocentrism, and an Ethics of Exclusion. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

26.

Gupta

Gokarıksel

Smith

(2020) The politics of saving muslim women in India: Gendered geolegality, security, and territorialization. Political Geography 83: 1–10.

27.

Haraway

(2008) When Species Meet. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

28.

Ibrahim

(2011) Re-making a region: Ritual inversions and border transgressions in Kutch. South Asia: Journal of South Asian Studies 34(3): 439–459.

29.

ICAR. (2017). Camel milk gets the food tag from FSSAI. Indian Council of Agricultural Research . https://icar.gov.in/node/4644 (accessed 3 December 2020).

30.

Jenkins

(1998) Rajput Hindutva, caste politics, regional identity and Hindu nationalism in contemporary Rajasthan. In Jaffrelot

C and

Hansen

(Eds.). The BJP and the Compulsions of Politics in India. New Delhi: Oxford University Press. 101–120.

31.

Jodha

(1985). Population and the decline of common property resources in Rajasthan, India. Population and Development Review 11(2): 247–264.

32.

Kabachnik (2007). The Place of the Nomad: Situating Gypsy and Traveler Mobility in Contemporary England. PhD thesis, University of California.

33.

Kohler-Röllefson

(2016). Camel dairying: The solution to rescuing Rajasthan’s state animal. Down to Earth . https://www.downtoearth.org.in/blog/economy/camel-dairying-the-solution-to-rescuing-rajasthan-s-state-animal-53537 (accessed 3 December 2020)

34.

Kohler-Röllefson

(1995) Camels in the land of kings. Natural History 104(3): 54–61.

35.

Köhler-Röllefson

(2015). Why Rajasthan’s camel protection law is not enough to save its camels. Down to Earth . https://www.downtoearth.org.in/blog/why-rajasthan-s-camel-protection-law-is-not-enough-to-save-its-camels-49292 (accessed 19 April 2021)

36.

Köhler-Röllefson

(2017). Shifting camel cultures. https://www.india-seminar.com/2017/695/695_ilse_kohler-rollefson.htm (accessed 20 October 2020)

37.

Köhler-Röllefson

(2018). Purdah, purse and patriarchy: The position of women in the Raika shepherd community in Rajasthan (India). Journal of Arid Environments 149: 30–39.

38.

Kohler-Röllefson

Rathore

(1998) NGO strategies for livestock development in Western Rajasthan (INDIA): An overview and analysis. Oberamstadt.

39.

Kohler-Röllefson

Rathore

ISH

Mathias

(2009) Local breeds, livelihoods and livestock keepers’ rights in south Asia. Tropical Animal Health and Production 41(7): 1061–1070.

40.

Kurien

(2005) I too Have a Dream…[as Told to Gouri Salvi]. New Delhi: Lotus Collection. Roli Books.

41.

Lerche

Shah

(2018) Conjugated oppression within contemporary capitalism: Class, caste, tribe and agrarian change in India. The Journal of Peasant Studies 45(5–6): 927–949.

42.

Lestel

Brunois

Gaunet

(2006) Etho-ethnology and ethno-ethology. Social Science Information 45(2): 155–177.

43.

Lodha

(2016) Subregions, identity and nature of political competition in Rajasthan. In Kumar

(Ed.). Rethinking State Politics in India: Regions Within Regions. London: Taylor & Francis Group. 399–429.

44.

Marx

Engels

(1970) The German Ideology. Arthur CJ (Ed.). New York: International Publishers.

45.

Marwah

(2019). Provincializing progress: Developmentalism and anti-imperialism in colonial India. Polity 51(3): 498–531.

46.

Meena

(2020) Borders and bordering practices: A case study of Jaisalmer district on India–Pakistan border. Journal of Borderlands Studies 35(2): 183–194.

47.

Mosse

(2020) The modernity of caste and the market economy. Modern Asian Studies 54(4): 1225–1271.

48.

Moudgil

(2020). Camel milk inspires hope for herders. Mongabay. https://india.mongabay.com/2020/10/camel-milk-inspires-hope-for-herders/ (accessed 3 December 2020)

49.

Narain

I and Mathur P C

(1990) The thousand year Raj: Regional isolation and Rajput Hinduism in Rajasthan before and after 1947. In Frankel FR and Rao MSA (Eds.). Dominance and State Power in Modern India. Delhi: Oxford University Press. 1–58.

50.

Narayanan

(2018) ‘Cow protection’ as ‘casteised speciesism’: Sacralisation, commercialisation and politicisation. South Asia: Journal of South Asian Studies 41(2): 331–351.

51.

Narayanan

(2019a) ‘Cow is a mother, mothers can do anything for their children!’ Gaushalas as landscapes of anthropatriarchy and hindu patriarchy. Hypatia: A Journal of Feminist Philosophy 34(2): 195–221.

52.

Narayanan

(2019b) Jugaad and informality as drivers of India’s cow slaughter economy. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 51(7): 1516–1535.

53.

Nibert

(2013). Animal Domestication & Human Violence: Domescration, Capitalism and Global Conflict. New York: Columbia University Press.

54.

Padalino

Aube

Fatnassi

, et al. (2014). Could dromedary camels develop stereotypy? The first description of stereotypical behaviour in housed male dromedary camels and How It Is affected by different management systems. PLoS One 9(2): 1–7.

55.

Potts

(2019) Defining capitalism: The case for (relational) abstraction. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 51(5): 1197–1200.

56.

Probyn-Rapsey

(2014) Review article: Multispecies mourning: Thom van Dooren’s flight ways: Life and loss at the edge of extinction by Thom van Dooren. Animal Studies Journal 3(3): 4–16.

57.

Quicke

Green

(2018). “Mobile (nomadic) cultures” and the politics of mobility: Insights from indigenous Australia. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 43: 646–660.

58.

Randall

(2019). To save India’s camel culture, a New dairy Is selling milk and cream cheese. Atlas Obscura . https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/camel-milk-in-india (accessed 19 April 2021)

59.

Robbins

(2004) Pastoralists inside-out: The contradictory conceptual geography of Rajasthan’s Raika. Nomadic Peoples 8(2): 136–149.

60.

Sahoo

(2013) Doing development or creating dependency? NGOs and Civil Society in India. South Asia: Journal of South Asian Studies 36(2): 258–272.

61.

Salzman

(1986). Shrinking pasture for Rajasthani pastoralists. Nomadic Peoples 20: 49–61.

62.

Sanbonmatsu

(2017) Capitalism and speciesism. In Nibert

(Ed.). Animal Oppression and Capitalism. Santa Barbara: Praeger. 1–30.

63.

Srinivasan

Kasturirangan

(2016) Political ecology, development, and human exceptionalism. Geoforum; Journal of Physical, Human, and Regional Geosciences 75: 125–128.

64.

Sud

(2020) The actual Gujarat model: Authoritarianism, capitalism, Hindu nationalism and populism in the time of Modi. Journal of Contemporary Asia: 1–25. doi:10.1080/00472336.2020.1846205

65.

Taylor

(2007). Pilgrimage and the moral geography of the US/Mexico border. Mobilities 2(3): 383–393.

66.

Tanyas

(2016) Experiences of otherness and practices of othering: Young Turkish migrants in the UK. Young 24(2): 157–173.

67.

Thomas

(2020). Pastoralists push for recognition at the UN. The Third Pole . https://www.thethirdpole.net/2020/09/30/pastoralists-push-for-recognition-at-the-un/ (accessed 8 December 2020)

68.

Wadiwel

. (2015). The War Against Animals. New York: Brill Rodopi.

69.

Wadiwel, D. (2018). Chicken harvesting machine: Animal labor, resistance, and the time of production. The South Atlantic Quarterly 117(3): 527–549.

70.

Weber

Horst

(2011) Desertification and livestock grazing: The roles of sedentarization, mobility and rest Pastoralism: Research, Policy and Practice 1(19): 1–19.

71.

Wilson

. (1840). trans. The Vishnu Purana. London: The Oriental Translation Fund of Great Britain and Ireland.

72.

Yiftachel

(2020) From displacement to displaceability: A Southern perspective on the new metropolis. City. 24(1–2): 151–165. doi:10.1080/13604813.2020.1739933