Resisting workers’ disalienation: The making and survival of capitalist conservation in Niombato,Senegal

Abstract

The making and survival of capitalist conservation depends upon the creation and maintenance of contradictory class relations based on alienated labour. The literature has, however, often ignored this aspect. Looking at capital as a contradictory class relation and through the study of a tourism-oriented protected area and three reforestation payment for ecosystem service projects in Senegal, this article shows how capital’s instrumentalisation of conservation requires a constant adaption to workers’ struggles against alienation. In the case here analysed, this adaptation manifests in the avoidance, silencing and appropriation of workers’ mobilisations against forest privatisation and labour exploitation. This resistance to workers’ disalienation reinforces not only capitalist class relations but also state, neo-colonial and white people’s power.

Keywords

Capitalist conservation alienated labour disalienation class relations ecotourism payments for ecosystem services protected areas Senegal

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Barca

(2012) On working-class environmentalism: A historical and transnational view. Interface 4(2): 61–80.

Barca

Leonardi

(2018) Working-class ecology and union politics: A conceptual topology. Globalizations 15(2): 1–17.

Benjaminsen

Bryceson

(2012) The conservation, green/blue grabbing and accumulation by dispossession in Tanzania. Journal of Peasant Studies 39(2): 335–355.

Beymer-Farris

Bassett

(2012) The REDD menace: Resurgent protectionism in Tanzania’s mangrove forests. Global Environmental Change 22: 332–341.

Bianchi

(2011) Tourism, capitalism and Marxist political economy. In: Mosedale

(ed.) Political Economy of Tourism: A Critical Perspective. London/New York: Routledge, pp.17–37.

Bird

(2016) Are ‘Blue Carbon’ projects a win for the climate and the people? Available at: https://e360.yale.edu/features/african_mangroves_blue_carbon_win_for_climate_and_for_people (accessed 14 January 2017).

Blechman M, Chari A and Hasan R (2005) Democracy, dissensus and the aesthetics of class struggle: an exchange with Jacques Rancière. Historical Materialism 13(4): 285–301.

Böhm S, Misoczky MC and Moog S (2012) Greening capitalism: a Marxist critique of carbon markets. Organisation Studies 33(11): 1617–1638.

Brockington

Scholfield

(2010) The conservationist mode of production and conservation NGOs in sub-Saharan Africa. Antipode 42(3): 551–575.

10.

Brockington

Duffy

Igoe

(2008) Nature Unbound: Conservation, Capitalism and the Future of Protected Areas. London: Earthscan.

11.

Büscher

Igoe

(2013) Prosuming conservation? Web 2.0, nature and the intensification of value-producing labour in late capitalism. Journal of Consumer Culture 13(3): 283–305.

12.

Büscher

Sullivan

Neves

, et al. (2012) Towards a synthesised critique of neoliberal biodiversity conservation. Capitalism Nature Socialism 23(2): 4–30.

13.

Carrier

(2010) Protecting the environment the natural way: Ethical consumption and commodity fetishism. Antipode 42(3): 672–689.

14.

Cavanagh

Benjaminsen

(2014) Virtual nature, violent accumulation: The ‘spectacular failure’ of carbon offsetting at a Ugandan National Park. Geoforum 56: 55–65.

15.

Chen

Gallagher

(2018) Mobilization without movement: How the Chinese state “fixed” labor insurgency. ILR Review 71(5): 1029–1052.

16.

Communauté Rurale de Toubacouta (2002) Procès Verbal de Déliberation No 6 du Conseil Rural de Toubacouta en date 10 Octobre 2002 (Minutes report of deliberation no. 6 by Toubacouta Rural Council, date 10 October 2002), 10 October 2002. Toubacouta: Republic of Senegal.

17.

Devine

Ojeda

(2017) Violence and dispossession in tourism development: A critical geographical approach. Journal of Sustainable Tourism 25(5): 605–617.

18.

Dinerstein

(2014) Disagreement and hope: The hidden transcripts in the grammar of political recovery in post-crisis Argentina. In: Levey

Ozarow

Wylde

(eds) Argentina since 2001: Recovering the Past, Reclaiming the Future. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, pp.115–133.

19.

Duffy

(2015) Nature-based tourism and neoliberalism. Concealing contradictions. Tourism Geographies 17(4): 529–543.

20.

Dunlap

Sullivan

(2020) A faultline in neoliberal environmental governance scholarship? Or, why accumulation-by-alienation matters. Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space 3(2): 552–579.

21.

Felli

(2014) On climate rent. Historical Materialism 22(3–4): 251–280.

22.

Fletcher

(2019) Ecotourism after nature: Anthropocene tourism as a new capitalist “fix”. Journal of Sustainable Tourism 27(4): 522–535.

23.

Gilbert

Afrizal (2019) The land exclusion dilemma and Sumatra’s agrarian reactionaries. The Journal of Peasant Studies 46(4): 681–701.

24.

Goepp J, Diame I, Diame A, et al. (2006) Plan de gestion de l'aire marine communautaire du Bamboung. Dakar: Oceanium. Unpublished paper.

25.

Harvie

(2002) Alienation, class and enclosure in UK universities. Capital and Class 71: 103–132.

26.

Hiraldo R (2017) Value is still labour: exploitation and the production of environmental rent and commodities for nature tourists in rural Senegal. Human Geography 10(2): 54–71.

27.

Hiraldo

(2018) Experiencing primitive accumulation as alienation: Enclosures, mangrove forest privatisation and the everyday adaptation of bodies to capital in rural Senegal. Journal of Agrarian Change 18(3): 517–535.

28.

Holmes

(2012) Biodiversity for billionaires: Capitalism, conservation and the role of philanthropy in saving/selling nature. Development and Change 43(1):185–203.

29.

Holmes

(2014) What is a land grab? Exploring green grabs, conservation and private protected areas in Southern Chile. The Journal of Peasant Studies 41(4): 547–567.

30.

Howson P (2018) Slippery violence in the REDD+ forests of Central Kalimantan, Indonesia. Conservation and Society 16(2): 136–146.

31.

Igoe

Neves

, and Brockington

(2010) A spectacular eco-tour around the historic bloc: Theorising the convergence of biodiversity conservation and capitalist exploitation. Antipode 42(3): 486–512.

32.

Jones

(2009) Saving the planet or selling off the atmosphere? Emissions trading, capital accumulation and the carbon rent. Marxist Interventions 1: 9–22.

33.

Kante

(2012) Rapport de mission. Appui juridique sur le statut légal de la structure de gestion de l’Aire marine Protégé communautaire du Bintang, unpublished paper.

34.

Kelly

(2011) Conservation practice as primitive accumulation. Journal of Peasant Studies 38(4): 683–701.

35.

La Via Campesina (2012) Mozambique. Carbon trading and REDD+: Farmers ‘grow’ carbon for the benefit of polluters. Available at: https://viacampesina.org/en/mozambique-carbon-trading-and-redd-farmers-grow-carbon-for-the-benefit-of-polluters/ (accessed 2 September 2019).

36.

Lefebvre H (2002) Critique of everyday life, Vol. 2. London: Verso.

37.

Livelihoods Fund (2013) The livelihoods project of restoration of mangroves in Senegal validated by the United Nations. Available at: http://www.livelihoods.eu/archive/2012/07/10/the-livelihoods-project-of-restoration-of-mangroves-in-seneg.html (accessed 13 May 2014).

38.

McAfee

(2016) Green economy and carbon markets for conservation and development: A critical view. International Environmental Agreements 16: 333–353.

39.

Marx

(1956) The Holy Family. Moscow: Foreign Languages Publishing House.

40.

Marx

(1959) [1844] Economic and Philosophical Manuscripts. Moscow: Progress Publishers.

41.

Marx

(1967) Capital. Vol. I. London: Penguin Books.

42.

Marx

(1973) Grundrisse. London: Macmillan.

43.

Marx

(1981) Capital, Vol. 3. London: Penguin Books.

44.

Ojeda

(2012) Green pretexts: Ecotourism, neoliberal conservation and land grabbing in Tayrona National Natural Park, Colombia. Journal of Peasant Studies 39(2): 357–375.

45.

Pramono

Sukiman

(2008) Small farmers victims of forest carbon trading. Available at: https://viacampesina.org/en/small-farmers-victims-of-forest-carbon-trading/ (accessed 12 April 2019).

46.

Quijano

(2000) Coloniality of power, Eurocentrism and Latin America. Nepantla: Views from the South 1(3): 533–580.

47.

République du Sénégal (2003) Réglément Intérieur de l’Aire Marine Protégée du Bamboung (Internal Regulation of the Bamboung Protected Wetland), 2 April 2003. Dakar: Republic of Senegal.

48.

Rocheleau

(2015) Networked, rooted and territorial: Green grabbing and resistance in Chiapas. The Journal of Peasant Studies 42(3–4): 695–723.

49.

Siu K and Chan A (2015) Strike wave in Vietnam (2006–2011). Journal of Contemporary Asia 45(1): 71–91.

50.

Sullivan

(2013) Banking nature? The spectacular financialisation of environmental conservation. Antipode 45(1): 198–217.

51.

Sullivan

(2014) The natural capital myth; or will accounting save the world? Preliminary thoughts on nature, finance and values. LCSV Working Paper Series 3. Manchester: Leverhulme Centre for the Study of Value.

52.

United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (2007) Biosphere reserve information: Senegal, Delta du Saloum. Available at: http://www.unesco.org/mabdb/br/brdir/directory/biores.asp?code=SEN+02&mode=all (accessed 14 March 2018).

53.

United Nations Environmental Programme (2012) Carbon Finance for Agriculture, Silviculture, Conservation and Action Against Deforestation (CASCADE). Available at: http://www.unep.org/energy/Activities/CASCADe/tabid/79470/Default.aspx. (accessed 14 July 2015).

54.

World Rainforest Movement (2016) We denounce and resist the green economy’s impacts on women and forests. Available at: https://www.ienearth.org/we-denounce-and-resist-the-green-economys-impacts-on-women-and-forests/ (accessed 14 November 2019).

55.

Yamin

Depledge

(2004) The International Climate Change Regime: A Guide to Rules, Institutions and Procedures. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.