Dr B.R. Ambedkar led the mass conversion of the Mahar population from Hinduism to Navayana Buddhism in the year 1956, aiming at the emancipation of the Mahar community, who were treated as untouchables. Dr Ambedkar believed that since untouchability was a part of Hindu tradition, Mahars could not be freed from it until they remained within the Hindu tradition. Contrarily, M.K. Gandhi maintained religious conversion as the purification and change of heart and attaining a higher level of spirituality. Every great religion has the capability for reform within it. He believed that a change of heart being within own religious tradition might eradicate social evils like untouchability, and for that, one should not change his religion. The article thus discusses the various perspectives of religious conversions and analyses the views of these two great thinkers of modern India, situating the Mahar conversion as the primary focus. Based on secondary literature sources, the author tries to situate the views of Gandhi and Ambedkar in the broader discourse on religious conversion and show that the Mahar conversion had a socio-political necessity and Gandhi’s views and appeal for eradication of untouchability did not have a practical value given the socio-religious context in India.
AmbedkarB. R. (1936a). What path to salvation? [speech delivered in conference]. The Bombay Presidency Mahar Conference, 31st May 1936, Bombay, https://www.columbia.edu/itc/mealac/pritchett/00ambedkar/txt_ambedkar_salvation.html
2.
AmbedkarB. R. (1936b). Annihilation of caste with a reply to Mahatma Gandhi. https://ccnmtl.columbia.edu/projects/mmt/ambedkar/web/readings/aoc_print_orig.pdf
3.
AmbedkarB. R. (2003). Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar: Writings, and speeches (Vol. 17, Issue 3). Education Department, Government of Maharashtra.
4.
AmbedkarB. R. (1945). What Congress & Gandhi have done to the untouchables. Gautam Book Centre.
5.
AmbedkarB. R. (2014). Dr Baba Saheb Ambedkar’s writings and speeches (Vol. 5). Ambedkar Foundation.
6.
AxtellJ. (1986). The invasion within: The contest of cultures in Colonial North America. Oxford University Press.
7.
BardiaM. (2009). Dr. B. R. Ambedkar: His ideas about religion and conversion to Buddhism. The Indian Journal of Political Science, 70(3), 737–749.
8.
BaruaA. (2015). Debating ‘conversion’ in Hinduism and Christianity. Routledge.
9.
BaylyS. (1989). Saints, goddesses and kings. Cambridge University Press.
10.
BeinartH. (1981). Conversos on trial: The inquisition in Ciudad Real (Hispania Judaica 3). Hebrew University.
11.
BilgramiA. (2011). Gandhi’s religion and its relation to his politics. In BrownJ. M., & ParelA. (Eds.), The Cambridge companion to Gandhi. Cambridge University.
12.
BurkeP. (2009). Cultural hybridity. Cambridge.
13.
ChatterjeeM. (1983). Gandhi’s religious thought. Macmillan and Notre Dame University Press.
14.
ChoudhuryS. (2021). ‘Beyond Protective Discoloration: Ambedkar on Conversion’. A DOT online Lecture Series—Caste in India, by Professor Soumyabrata Choudhury on 29th July 2021. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NPENaJhaTp0
15.
ClaerhoutS. (2014). Gandhi, conversion, and the equality of religions: More experiments with truth. Numen, 61(1), 53–82.
16.
DukeJ. T., & BarryL. J. (1989). The stages of religious transformation: A study of 200 nations. Review of Religious Research, 30(3), 209–224.
17.
DurkheimE. (1965). The elementary forms of religious life, (trans. SwainJoseph Ward). Free Press.
18.
ElmS. K. (2003). Inscriptions and conversions: Gregory of Nazianzus on Baptism. In MillsK., & GraftonA. (Eds.), Conversion in late antiquity and the early Middle Ages (pp. 1–35). University of Rochester Press.
19.
GandhiM. K. (1933). Statement in reply to Dr. Ambedkar’s view in caste. Harijan, 1(1), 3.
20.
GandhiM. K. (1935, May11). Interview to a missionary nurse. Harijan. English Weekly (Reproduced from Gandhi literature: Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi. Gandhi Sevagram Ashram, Vol. 67, p. 48–49).
21.
GretchenD. S.-L. (2003). In the shadow of the virgin: Inquisitors, friars, and conversos in Guadalupe, Spain. Princeton University Press.
22.
HindmarshD. B. (2008). The evangelical conversion narrative: Spiritual autobiography in early modern England. Oxford University Press.
23.
JaffrelotC. (2010). Religion, caste and politics in India. Primus Books.
24.
JordensJ. T. F. (1977) Reconversion to Hinduism, the Suddhi of the Arya Samaj. In OddieG. A. (Ed.), Religion in South Asia (pp. 145–146). Curzon Press.
25.
KatjuM. (2015). The politics of ‘Ghar Wapsi’. Economic & Political Weekly, 50(1), 21–24.
26.
LeopoldA. M., & JensenJ. S. (2004). Syncretism in religion: A reader. Routledge.
27.
MathewA. (1988). Christian missions, education and nationalism (pp. 121–122). Anamika Prashan.
28.
MattamJ. (1997) Mission as social concern: In official church documents and recent missiological literature. In MattamJ. & KimS. (Eds). Mission trends today (pp. 55–75). St Pauls.
29.
MintzS. W., & PriceR. (1992). The birth of African-American culture: An anthropological perspective. Beacon Press.
30.
MosseD. (1994). Idioms of subordination and styles of protest among the Christians and Hindu harijan castes in Tamil Nadu. Contribution to Indian Sociology, 28, 67–106.
31.
NagarajD. R. (2011). The flaming feet and other essays: The Dalit movement in India. Seagull Books.
32.
NetanyahuB. (1995). The origins of the inquisition: In fifteenth century Spain. Random House.
33.
PanthamT. (2009). Against untouchability: The discourses of Gandhi and Ambedkar. In GuruG. (Ed.). Humiliation: Claims and context (pp. 179–208). Oxford University Press.
34.
PickettJ. W. (1933). Christian mass movement in India. Abingdon.
35.
Radcliffe-BrownA.R. (1965). Structure and function in primitive society: Essays and addresses. Free Press.
36.
RudolfC. H. (2015). Ghar wapsi: Political agenda, religious garb. Economic & Political Weekly, 50(3), 17–20.
37.
SikandY.KatjuM. (1994). Mass conversions to Hinduism among Indian Muslims. Economic and Political Weekly, 29(34), 2214–2219.
38.
SinghA. (2014). Gandhi and Ambedkar: Irreconcilable differences?International Journal of Hindu Studies, 18(3), 413–449.
39.
StarkR., & BainbridgeS. W. (1985). The future of religion: Secularization, revival and cult formation. University of California Press.
40.
TeltumbdeA. (2018). Strategy of conversion to Buddhism: Intent and aftermath. In SurajY. & TeltumbdeA. (Eds.), The radical in Ambedkar: Critical reflections. Penguin Books India.
41.
VeerP. Van der. (1994). Religious nationalism. The University of California Press.
42.
ZelliotE. (2013). Ambedkar’s world: The making of Babasaheb and the Dalit movement. Navayana Publishing.
