Farmer seed systems survive by engaging changing conditions and by sharing seeds and indigenous knowledge. Although the systemic change attracting the most attention as a challenge to farmer seed systems is climate change, another systemic threat needs equally urgent analysis. The Alliance for a Green Revolution in Africa (AGRA) of the Gates Foundation is trying to transform farmer seed systems through ‘business rule’ and ‘business practices’ of philanthrocapitalism. Outlining the trajectories of philanthrocapitalism, this analysis explores fundamental differences in how large foundations are interjecting their private goals into public spaces, while extracting public funds for private use. Although much has been written about philanthrocapitalism in the fields of education and health, this article focusses on its role in farmers’ seed systems. Grounded in Southern Africa, it explains how smallholder farmers are not just resisting the insertion of philanthrocapitalism into their seed systems, but are offering alternatives.
Africa Union/Economic Commission for Africa (AU/ECA) (2014). Conference of ministers of finance. Track it! stop it! get it! Illicit financial flows. Report of the high level panel on illicit financial flows from Africa. Retrieved from https://www.uneca.org/sites/default/files/PublicationFiles/iff_main_report_26feb_en.pdf
2.
Alliance for a Green Revolution in Africa (AGRA) (2016). Africa agriculture status report. Retrieved from https://agra.org/aasr2016/public/assr.pdf
3.
AndersenR., ShresthaP., OtienoG., NishikawaY., & KasasaP. (2018). Community seed banks: Sharing experiences from North and South. Diversifood. Retrieved from https://www.bioversityinternational.org/fileadmin/user_upload/Community_Andersen_2018.pdf
4.
AsiabakaC. C. (2009). Promoting sustainable approaches: Farmer field schools (FFS) and its role in sustainable agricultural development in Africa. Owerri, Nigeria: Federal University of Technology.
5.
BishopM., & GreenM. (2009). Philanthrocapitalism: How giving can save the world. New York, NY: Bloomsbury Press.
6.
BrownB., NubergI., & LlewellynR. (2018). Further participatory adaptation is required for community leaders to champion conservation agriculture. International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability, 16(3), 286–296.
7.
ChambatiW. (2017). Changing forms of wage labor in Zimbabwe’s new agrarian structure. Agrarian South, 6(1), 79–112.
8.
ChangH. (2009). Rethinking public policy in agriculture: Lessons from history, distant and recent. The Journal of Peasant Studies, 36(3), 477–515.
9.
ChinsingaB., & ChasukwaM. (2018). Agricultural policy, employment opportunities and social mobility in rural Malawi. Agrarian South, 7(1), 28–50.
10.
CollinsC., & HoxieJ. (2017). Billionaire bonanza—The Forbes 400 and the rest of us. Washington, DC: Institute for Policy Studies. Retrieved from https://ips-dc.org/report-billionaire-bonanza-2017/
11.
Community Biodiversity Development and Conservation Program (2009). Conservation agriculture: A sustainable farming manual: How to grow your crops with minimal inputs and maximal output. Harare: Community Technology Development Trust.
12.
Community Technology Development Organization (CTDO) (2016). Facilitators’ field guide for farmer field schools on participatory plant breeding in maize, pearl millet, sorghum and groundnut. Oxford, UK: Oxfam.
13.
Community Technology Development Organization (CTDO) (2017). Annual reports. Retrieved from http://www.ctdt.co.zw/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/Annual-Report-2017-FINAL.pdf
14.
Consortium of International Agricultural Research (CGIAR) (2016). CGIAR system framework. Retrieved from http://www.cgiar.org/about-us/our-governance/system-council/sc-composition/
15.
Consortium of International Agricultural Research (CGIAR) (2017). 2017 Performance report. Executive Summary. Retrieved from https://www.cgiar.org/executive-summary/
16.
Crop Trust (2017). Genebank platform 2017–2022. Retrieved from https://cgspace.cgiar.org/bitstream/handle/10947/4658/GENEBANK%20Leaflet.pdf?sequence=4
17.
DalyH., & FarleyJ. (2011). Ecological economics. Washington, DC: Island Press.
18.
Douwe van der PloegJ. (2013). Peasants and the art of farming: A Chayanovian manifesto. Halifax, Nova Scotia: Fernwood Publishing.
19.
Douwe van der PloegJ. (2018). Differentiation: Old controversies, new insights. The Journal of Peasant Studies, 45(3), 489–524.
20.
The Economist. (Editorial). (2006, February23). The birth of philanthrocapitalism, the leading new philanthropists see themselves as social investors. Retrieved from https://www.economist.com/node/5517656
21.
EdwardsM. (2010). Small change—Why business won’t change the world. San Francisco, CA: Berrett-Koehler Publishers.
22.
ErikssonR., & AnderssonJ. O. (2010). Elements of ecological economics. London, UK: Routledge.
23.
ETC Group (2012, January/February). The greed revolution: Mega foundations, agribusiness muscle in on public goods. (Communiqué Issue No. 108). Retrieved from www.etcgroup.org
24.
FendlerL. (2018). The Gates Foundation MET research project as a case of philanthrocapitalism. In SmeyersP. & DepaepeM. (Eds.), Educational research: Ethics, social justice, and funding dynamics (pp. 239–259). London, UK: Springer.
25.
FusireM. (Ed.). (2009). The principle of community seed banking: A guide to germ plasm conservation, restoration and utilization in marginalized communities of Southern Africa. Harare: Community Biodiversity Development and Conservation.
26.
GhoshA. R., & QureshiS. (2016). What’s in a name? That which we call capital controls (IMF Working Paper No. 16/25). Retrieved from https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2016/wp1625.pdf
27.
GRAIN (2017). Colonialism’s new clothes: The EU’s economic partnership agreements with Africa. Retrieved from www.grain.org
28.
HalewoodH., DeupmannP., SthapitB. R., VernooyR., & CeccarelliS. (2007). Participatory plant breeding to promote farmers’ rights. Biodiversity International. Retrieved from https://www.bioversityinternational.org/fileadmin/_migrated/uploads/tx_news/Participatory_plant_breeding_to_promote_Farmers__Rights_1254.pdf
29.
HammondE. (2017). IRRI seeks patents on yield-boosting gene taken from Indonesian farmers’ rice. TWN Info service on sustainable agriculture, biodiversity/TK and intellectual property. Third World Network. Retrieved from www.twn.my
30.
HayI., & MullerS. (2014). Questioning generosity in the golden age of philanthropy: Towards critical geographies of super-philanthropy. Progress in Human Geography, 38(5), 635–653.
31.
HughesO., & VenemaJ. H. (2005). Integrated soil, water and nutrient management in semi-arid Zimbabwe. Farmer field schools facilitators manual (Vol. 1). Harare, Zimbabwe: AREX, FAO, ICRISAT.
32.
JürgenH., MurwiraK., & ConnolyM. (2000). Learning together through participatory extension. Harare: AGRITEX.
33.
LeblondN., & TrottierJ. (2016). Performing an invisibility spell: Global models, food regimes and smallholders. International Journal of Sociology of Agriculture and Food, 23(1), 21–40.
34.
LowderS., CarismaB., & SkoetJ. (2012). Who invests in agriculture and how much? An empirical review of the relative size of various investments in agriculture in low and middle-income countries. (FAO-ESA Working Paper No. 12-09). Rome: FAO.
35.
MabayaE., OmangaP., & DeVriesJ. (2013). Africa agriculture status report: Focus on staple crops. Nairobi: Alliance for a Green Revolution in Africa.
36.
MboziH. (2015). Community-based seed production manual. Harare: Community Technology Development Organization.
37.
McGoeyL. (2015). No such thing as a free gift: The Gates Foundation and the price of philanthropy. London, UK: Verso.
38.
MushitaA., & ThompsonC. (2013). More ominous than climate change? Policy hazards to African food production. African Studies Quarterly, 13(4), 1–25.
39.
MustafaY., GrandoS., & CeccarelliS. (2006). Assessing the benefits and costs of participatory and conventional barley breeding programs in Syria. Aleppo, Syria: ICARDA.
40.
NdikumanaL., & BoyceJ. (2011). Africa’s odious debts: How foreign loans and capital flights bled a continent. London, UK: ZED Books.
41.
Oxfam (2018, January). Reward work not wealth. Retrieved from https://www.oxfam.org/en/pressroom/pressreleases/2018-01-22/richest-1-percent-bagged-82-percent-wealth-created-last-year
42.
Oxfam (2019, January). Public good or private wealth? Retrieved from https://oxfamilibrary.openrepository.com/bitstream/handle/10546/620599/bp-public-good-or-private-wealth-210119-summ-en.pdf
43.
ÖzgedizS. (2012). The CGIAR at 40: Institutional evolution of the world’s premier agricultural research network. Retrieved from https://cgspace.cgiar.org/bitstream/handle/10947/2761/cgiar40yrs_book_final_sept2012.pdf?sequence=1
44.
PatnaikP. (2018). Globalization and the peasantry in the South. Agrarian South, 7(2), 234–248.
45.
PlankK. (2017). Philanthrocapitalism and the hidden power of big U.S. foundations. Zeitschrift für Sozialen Fortschritt [Momentum Quarterly], 6(3), 203–209.
46.
ReckhowS. (2013). Follow the money: How foundation dollars change public school politics. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
47.
RhodesC., & BloomP. (2018, May24). The trouble with charitable billionaires. The Guardian. Retrieved from https://www.theguardian.com/news/2018/may/24/the-trouble-with-charitable-billionaires-philanthrocapitalism
48.
ScherrerC. (2018). The disrupted passage from an agrarian rural to an industrial urban workforce in most countries in the Global South. Agrarian South, 7(3), 301–319.
49.
Stakeholders’ Consultation on Farmers’ Rights (2016). African Position Paper. Harare, Zimbabwe.
50.
ThompsonC. (2014). Valuing smallholder food production: A call for new theories. Journal of Critical Thought and Praxis, 3(1). Retrieved from https://lib.dr.iastate.edu/jctp/vol3/iss1/
51.
TilzeyM. (2017, July). Reintegrating economy, society, and environment or cooperative futures: Polanyi, Marx, and food sovereignty. Journal of Rural Studies, 53, 317–334.
52.
VenemaJ., & MasendekeD. (2006). Review of land and water management: Farmer field school experiences in Zimbabwe. In Proceedings of the Farmer Field Schools International Workshop. Jinja, Uganda.
53.
West African Committee for Farmer Seeds (COASP) & Coalition for the Protection of African Genetic Heritage (COPAGEN) (2018, July9). Farmer seeds, plants of the future for healthy and sustainable nutrition. Joint Press Release, Dakar. Retrieved from https://www.grain.org/bulletin_board/entries/6001-farmer-seeds-plants-of-the-future-for-healthy-and-sustainable-nutrition
