Epidemiological and sociological research on recovery from mental disorder is based on three rarely tested medical model assumptions: (1) recovery without treatment is the result of less severe illness, (2) treatment predicts recovery, and (3) recovery and well–being do not depend on individuals’ treatment histories. I challenge these assumptions using National Comorbidity Survey-Replication data for individuals with any disorder occurring prior to the current year (N = 2,305). Results indicated that (1) untreated remissions were fully explained by less serious prior illness, (2) treated individuals were less likely to recover due to more serious illness, and (3) people who had past–only treatment were more likely to recover than the never–treated, while those in recurring and recently initiated care were less likely to recover. Treatment histories predicted greater well–being only if recovery had been attained. Histories of care help to explain recovery rates and suggest new directions for treatment–seeking theory and research.
AlegríaMargaritaChatterjiPinkaWellsKennethCaoZhunChenChih-nanTakeuchiDavidJacksonJamesMengXiao-Li. 2008. “Disparity in Depression Treatment among Racial and Ethnic Minority Populations in the United States.”Psychiatric Services59:1264–72.
2.
American Psychiatric Association. 1994. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. 4th ed.Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association.
3.
AndersenRonald. 1968. A Behavioral Model of Families’ Use of Health Services. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
4.
AndersenRonald. 2008. “National Health Surveys and the Behavioral Model of Health Services Use.”Medical Care46:647–53.
5.
AndradeL. H.AlonsoJ.MneimnehZ.WellsJ.Al-HamzawiA.BorgesG.BrometE.BruffaertsR.de GirolamoG.de GraafR.FlorescuS.GurejeO.HinkovH. R.HuC.HuangY.HwangI.JinR.KaramE. G.Kovess-MasfetyV.LevinsonD.MatschingerH.O’NeillS.Posada-VillaJ.SagarR.SampsonN. A.SasuC.SteinD. J.TakeshimaT.VianaM. C.XavierM.KesslerR. C.2014. “Barriers to Mental Health Treatment: Results from the WHO World Mental Health Surveys.”Psychological Medicine44:1303–17.
6.
AneshenselCarol S.van DraanenJennaRiessHeleneVillatoroAlice P.2019. “Newcomers and Old Timers: An Erroneous Assumption in Mental Health Services Research.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior60:453–73.
7.
BrownPhil. 1995. “Naming and Framing: The Social Construction of Diagnosis and Illness.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior35:34–52.
8.
ChenLian-YuCrumRosa M.MartinsSilvia S.KaufmannChristopher N.StrainEric C.MojtabaiRamin. 2013. “Service Use and Barriers to Mental Health Care in Major Depression and Comorbid Substance Use Disorders.”Psychiatric Services64:863–70.
9.
ConradPeter. 1992. “Medicalization and Social Control.”Annual Review of Sociology18:209–32.
10.
EdlundMark J.2009. “Perceived Need for Treatment for Alcohol Use Disorders: Results from Two National Surveys.”Psychiatric Services60:1618–28.
11.
GranfieldRobertCloudWilliam. 2001. “Social Context and `Natural Recovery’: The Role of Social Capital in the Resolution of Drug-Associated Problems.”Substance Use & Misuse36(11):1543—70.
12.
GreenJennifer GreifMcLaughlinKatie A.FillbrunnMirkoFukudaMarieJacksonJames S.KesslerRonald C.SadikovaEkaterinaSampsonNancy A.VilsaintCorrieWilliamsDavid R.Cruz-GonzalezMarioAlegríaMargarita. 2020. “Barriers to Mental Health Service Use and Predictors of Treatment Drop Out: Racial/Ethnic Variation in a Population-Based Study.”Administration and Policy in Mental Health and Mental Health Services Research47:606–16.
13.
GrellaChristine E.SteinJudith A.2013. “Remission from Substance Dependence: Differences between Individuals in a General Population Longitudinal Survey Who Do and Do not Seek Help.”Drug and Alcohol Dependence133:146–53.
HenriksenChristine AnneSteinMurray B.AfifiTracie O.EnnsMurray W.LixLisa M.SareenJitender. 2015. “Identifying Factors That Predict Longitudinal Outcomes of Untreated Common Mental Disorders.”Psychiatric Services66:163–70.
16.
JonesChristopher M.NoonanRita K.ComptonWilson M.2020. “Prevalence and Correlates of Ever Having a Substance Use Problem and Substance Use Recovery Status among Adults in the United States.”Drug and Alcohol Dependence214:108169. doi:10.1016/j.drugalcdep.2020.108169.
17.
KesslerRonald C.BerglundPatricia A.BruceMartha L.KochJ. RandyLaskaEugene M.LeafPhilip J.ManderscheidRonald W.RosenheckR. A.WaltersE. E.WangP. S.2001. “The Prevalence and Correlates of Untreated Serious Mental Illness.”Health Services Research36:987–1007.
18.
KesslerRonald C.BerglundPatricia A.DemlerOlgaJinRobertMerikangasKathleen R.WaltersEllen E.2005. “Lifetime Prevalence and Age-of-onset Distributions of DSM-IV Disorders in the National Comorbidity Survey Replication.”Archives of General Psychiatry62:593–602.
19.
KesslerRonald C.BerglundPatriciaChiuWai TatDemlerOlgaHeeringaStevenHiripiEvaJinRobert, et al. 2004. “The US National Comorbidity Survey Replication (NCS-R): Design and Field Procedures.”International Journal of Methods in Psychiatric Research13:69—92.
20.
KesslerRonald C.ChiuWai TatDemlerOlgaWaltersEllen E.2005. “Prevalence, Severity, and Comorbidity of 12–month DSM-IV Disorders in the National Comorbidity Survey Replication.”Archives of General Psychiatry62:617–27.
21.
KesslerRonald C.UstunT. Bedirhan. 2004. “The World Mental Health (WMH) Survey Initiative Version of the World Health Organization (WHO) Composite International Diagnostic Interview (CIDI).”International Journal of Methods in Psychiatric Research13:93–121.
22.
LibermanRobert PaulKopelowiczAlex. 2005. “Recovery from Schizophrenia: A Concept in Search of Research.”Psychiatric Services56:735–42.
23.
MarkowitzFred E.2001. “Modeling Processes of Recovery from Mental Illness: Relationships between Symptoms, Life Satisfaction, and Self-concept.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior42:64–79.
24.
MarkowitzFred E.2005. “Sociological Approaches to Recovery.” Pp. 85–100 in Recovery and Mental Illness: Consumer Visions and Research Paradigms, edited by RalphR. O.CorriganP. W.Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
25.
MarkowitzFred E.2015. “Involvement in Mental Health Self-help Groups and Recovery.”Health Sociology Review24:199–212.
26.
MarkowitzFred E.AngellBethGreenbergJan S.2011. “Stigma, Reflected Appraisals, and Recovery Outcomes in Mental Illness.”Social Psychology Quarterly74:144–65.
27.
McBainRyan K.CollinsRebecca L.WongEunice C.BreslauJoshuaCefaluMathew S.RothElizabethBurnamM. Audrey. 2020. “Mental Health Services and Personal Recovery in California: A Population-based Analysis.”Psychiatric Services71:580–87.
28.
MechanicDavid. 2003. “Is the Prevalence of Mental Disorders a Good Measure of the Need for Services?”Health Affairs22:8–20.
29.
MojtabaiRaminEvans-LackoSaraSchomerusGeorgThornicroftGraham. 2016. “Attitudes toward Mental Health Help Seeking as Predictors of Future Help-seeking Behavior and Use of Mental Health Treatments.”Psychiatric Services67:650–57.
30.
MojtabaiRaminOlfsonMarkMechanicDavid. 2002. “Perceived Need and Help-seeking with Mood, Anxiety, or Substance Use Disorders.”Archives of General Psychiatry59:77–84.
31.
MojtabaiRaminOlfsonM.SampsonN. A.JinR.DrussB.WangP. S.WellsK. B.PincusH. A.KesslerR. C.2011. “Barriers to Mental Health Treatment: Results from the National Comorbidity Survey Replication.”Psychological Medicine41:1751–61.
32.
NovakPriscillaFederKenneth A.AliMir M.ChenJie. 2019. “Behavioral Health Treatment Utilization among Individuals with Co-occurring Opioid Use Disorder and Mental Illness: Evidence from a National Survey.”Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment98:47–52.
33.
PrévilleMichelBoyerRichardVasiliadisHelen-MariaGrenierSébastienStreinerDavidCairneyJohnBrassardJoëlle. 2010. “Persistence and Remission of Psychiatric Disorders in the Quebec Older Adult Population.”Canadian Journal of Psychiatry55:514–22.
34.
RalphRuth O.CorriganPatrick W.2005. Recovery and Mental Illness: Consumer Visions and Research Paradigms. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
35.
RobertsTessaEspondaGeorgina MiguelKrupchankaDzmitryShidhayeRahulPatelVikramRathodSujit. 2018. “Factors Associated with Health Service Utilisation for Common Mental Disorders: A Systematic Review.”BMC Psychiatry18:262–82.
36.
SalzerMark S.BrusilovskiyEugeneTownleyGreg. 2018. “National Estimates of Recovery-remission from Serious Mental Illness.”Psychiatric Services69:523–28.
37.
SareenJ.HenriksenC. A.SteinM. B.AfifiT. O.LixL. M.EnnsM. W.2013. “Common Mental Disorder Diagnosis and Need for Treatment Are Not the Same: Findings from a Population-based Longitudinal Survey.”Psychological Medicine43:1941–51.
38.
SladeMikeLongdenEleanor. 2015. “Empirical Evidence about Recovery and Mental Health.”BMC Psychiatry15:285–99.
39.
ten HaveM.NuyenJ.BeekmanA.de GraafR.2013. “Common Mental Disorder Severity and Its Association with Treatment Contact and Treatment Intensity for Mental Health Problems.”Psychological Medicine43:2203–205.
40.
ThoitsPeggy A.2010. “Stress and Health: Major Findings and Policy Implications.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior51:S41–53.
41.
TurnerJ. BlakeTurnerR. Jay. 2013. “Social Relations, Social Integration, and Social Support.” Pp. 341–56 in Handbook of the Sociology of Mental Health, 2nd ed., edited by AneshenselC. S.PhelanJ. C.BiermanA.Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer.
42.
WalkerElizabeth ReisingerCummingsJanet R.HockenberryJason M.DrussBenjamin G.2015. “Insurance Status, Use of Mental Health Services, and Unmet Need for Mental Health Care in the United States.”Psychiatric Services66:578–84.
43.
WangYunqiaoHenriksenChristine A.HaveMargreet tende GraafRonSteinMurray B.EnnsMurray W.SareenJitender. 2017. “Common Mental Disorder Diagnosis and Need for Treatment Are Not the Same: Findings from the NEMESIS Study.”Administration and Policy in Mental Health and Mental Health Services Research44:572–81.
44.
WatsonDennis P.2012. “The Evolving Understanding of Recovery: What Does the Sociology of Mental Health Have to Offer?”Humanity & Society36:290–308.
45.
WHO World Mental Health Survey Consortium. 2004. “Prevalence, Severity, and Unmet Need for Treatment of Mental Disorders in the World Health Organization World Mental Health Surveys.”Journal of the American Medical291:2581–90.
