Drawing upon empirical data collected during HMP Birmingham’s privatisation in 2011, this article explores the prospects of competition increasing performance in the delivery of ‘probation services’ in England and Wales. The constraints and challenges that stem from the public procurement rules and their manner of implementation are highlighted, alongside the adverse impacts that competition can have upon organisational culture. Together with current evidence about the (mixed) performance of privately managed prisons, the article argues that the Government’s faith in competition as a panacea solution to improve public services is misplaced and that too few lessons are being learned from commissioning mistakes.
ArrowsmithS (2012) The purpose of the EU procurement directives: ends, means and the implications for national regulatory space for commercial and horizontal procurement policies. In: BarnardCGehringM with Solanke I (eds) Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies (2011–2012). Oxford: Hart, pp. 1–47.
2.
ArrowsmithSTreumerS (2012) Competitive Dialogue in EU Procurement. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
BrownTPotoskiMvan SlykeD (2006) Managing public service contracts: Aligning values, institutions and markets. Public Administration Review: 323–331.
5.
CartwrightSCooperC (1992) Mergers and Acquisitions: The Human Factor. Oxford: Butterworth Heinemann.
6.
CBI (2008) Actions speak louder than words: Unlocking the full potential of competitive dialogue. CBIBRIEF.
7.
CoyleA (2007) Policy and operational implications of prison privatization. Scottish Consortium on Crime and Criminal Justice. Colloquium on the implications of prison privatisation for penal policy in Scotland.
8.
CreweBLieblingAHulleyS (2011) Staff culture, use of authority and prisoner quality of life in public and private sector prisons. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology44(1): 94–115.
9.
CrouchC (2013) Making Capitalism Fit For Society. Cambridge: Polity Press.
10.
CutlerTWaineB (1994) Managing the Welfare State. Oxford: Berg.
11.
Davis-BlakeABroschakJ (2009) Outsourcing and the changing nature of work. Annual Review of Sociology35: 321–340.
HallidayJ (2001) Making Punishments Work: Report of a Review of the Sentencing Framework for England and Wales. London: Home Office.
14.
HaywardR (2013) What is the working character of the public to private sector prison officer? Thesis in fulfilment of requirements for M.St. in Penology, Institute of Criminology, University of Cambridge.
KünzlikP (2013) Neoliberalism and the European Union public procurement regime. In: BarnardCAlbors-LlorensAGehringMW with Schütze R (eds) Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies (2012–2013). Oxford: Hart, pp. 283–356.
LieblingASchmidtBCreweB. (2013) Birmingham prison: A benchmark study, one year on. Unpublished.
19.
LudlowA (2014) Privatising Public Prisons: Labour Law and the Public Procurement Process. Oxford: Hart (forthcoming).
20.
LudlowA (2012) Competition & contestability in action: Restructuring the prison sector to achieve workforce and industrial change. Public Law (3): 508–526.
21.
McLeanCLieblingA (2008) Prison staff in the public and private sector. In: BennettJCreweBWahidinA (eds) Understanding Prison Staff. Cullompton: Willan Publishing.
22.
MairGBurkeL (2011) Redemption, Rehabilitation and Risk Management: A History of Probation. Cullompton: Willan Publishing.
PatelR (2009) The Value of Nothing: How to Reshape Market Society and Redefine Democracy. London: Portobello Books.
29.
SachdevS (2008) Private punishment? An examination of the expansion, development and employment relations of private prisons. In: HoughMAllenRSolomonE (eds) Tackling Prison Overcrowding. Bristol: The Policy Press.
30.
SainsburyD (2013) Progressive Capitalism: How to Achieve Economic Growth, Liberty and Social Justice. London: Biteback Publishing.
31.
Sánchez GraellsA (2011) Public Procurement and the EU Competition Rules. Oxford: Hart.
32.
SennettR (2006) The Culture of the New Capitalism. New Haven & London: Yale University Press.
33.
SmithersA (2013) The Road to Recovery: How and Why Economic Policy Must Change. Oxford: Wiley.
34.
StelmanA (2007) From probation to the National Offender Management Service: Issues of contestability, culture and community involvement. Probation Journal54(1): 91–94.
35.
WalshKDeakinNSmithP. (1997) Contracting for Change: Contracts in Health, Social Care and other Local Government Services. Oxford: OUP.
