The urban dialectic: Between distant time and thick time

Abstract

In this commentary, I discuss the dialectic between Datta's concept of ‘distant time’ and Kentridge's visualization of ‘thick time’ to explore spatial and temporal relationships between colonial, postcolonial, and smart city urbanism in India. I am interested in extending the lines of Datta's contoured time in Shimla onto the plains of Chandigarh to see what are the different ways in which temporal distancing is maintained and challenged. The commentary elaborates on the concept metaphor of distant time by moving spatially from the lines of Shimla's contours to the Chandigarh grid. I also, introduce another temporal frame (postcolonial city) between the colonial city and the smart city to show how thick time prevails in urban crevices, simultaneously governed and ignored by distant time.

Keywords

Chandigarh grid India postcolonial urbanism Shimla space-time temporality urban planning

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Correa

(1987) Chandigarh: The view from Benares. Architecture Plus Design 3(6): 73–75.

Datta

(2019) Postcolonial urban futures: Imagining and governing India’s smart urban age. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 37(3): 393–410.

Datta

(2022) ‘Thick time’: Experiments with feminist urban futures in community podcasts. Geoforum 134: 108–117.

Datta

(2026) Distant time: The future of urbanisation from ‘there’ and ‘then’. Dialogues in Human Geography 16(1): 5–25.

Dickinson

(2022) Time after time: William Kentridge’s heterochronies. Angelaki 27(5): 97–112.

Grant

(2001) The dark side of the grid: Power and urban design. Planning Perspectives 16(3): 219–241.

Kalia

(1999) Chandigarh: In Search of an Identity. Delhi: Oxford University Press.

Kitchin

(2019) The timescape of smart cities. Annals of the American Association of Geographers 109(3): 775–790.

Massey

(2005) For Space. London: Sage.

10.

Mcfarlane

(2012) Rethinking informality: Politics, crisis, and the city. Planning Theory and Practice 13(1): 89–108.

11.

Rose-Redwood

Bigon

(eds) (2018) Gridded Worlds: An Urban Anthology. Cham: Springer International Publishing.

12.

Roy

(2011) The blockade of the world class city: Dialectical images of Indian urbanism. In: Roy

Ong

(eds) Worlding Cities: Asian Experiments and the Art of Being Global. Oxford: Wiley Blackwell, 259–278.

13.

Sabhlok

(2023) The city and its discontents: Chandigarh’s alternative story. Question of Cities. https://questionofcities.org/the-city-and-its-discontents-chandigarhs-alternative-story/

14.

Sharma

Gandhi

Sabhlok

(2023) Queering utopia: Pride walks in modernist Chandigarh. Urban Studies 60(14): 2799–2815.

15.

Shaw

(2009) Town planning in postcolonial India, 1947–1965: Chandigarh re-examined. Urban Geography 30(8): 857–878.

16.

Yiftachel

(2009) Theoretical notes on ‘gray spaces’: The coming of urban apartheid? Planning Theory 8(1): 88–100.