This study examines the interrelations between journalists and communication practitioners from environmental nongovernmental organizations (NGOs). Taking the annual United Nations climate change conferences as a case in point, we show that the exceptional circumstances of these events foster a temporary blurring of the professional boundaries between both actor groups that partly results in a joint production of interpretations. Based on seventy-eight semi-standardized interviews with journalists and NGO representatives, we identify four distinct coproduction networks that pair particular types of journalists and NGO communicators. Our analysis shows that (1) the journalistic beat, (2) the type of media journalists work for, (3) journalists’ and NGOs’ perceived target audiences, and also (4) the NGOs’ strategic orientation toward either lobbying or popular mobilization are decisive for the formation of these networks. Our study helps to systematically explain message production in a transnational context and provides a deeper understanding of the relationship between journalism and public relations.
AdolphsenManuel. 2014. Communication Strategies of Governments and NGOs: Engineering Global Discourse at High-Level International Summits. Wiesbaden: Springer VS.
2.
AdolphsenManuelLückJulia. 2012. “Non-Routine Interactions Behind the Scenes of a Global Media Event: How Journalists and Political PR Professionals Co-produced the 2010 UN Climate Conference in Cancun.” In Medien & Kommunikationswissenschaft, Sonderband Grenzüberschreitende Medienkommunikation, ed. WesslerHartmutAverbeck-LietzStefanie, 141–58.
3.
BenteleGüntherNothhaftHoward. 2008. “The Intereffication Model: Theoretical Discussions and Empirical Research.” In Public Relations Research: European and International Perspectives and Innovations, ed. ZerfassAnsgarRulerBetteke vanSrirameshKrishnamurthy, 33–47. Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.
4.
BerglezPeter. 2011. “Inside, outside, and beyond Media Logic: Journalistic Creativity in Climate Reporting.”Media, Culture & Society33 (3): 449–65.
5.
BrüggemannMichaelEngesserSven. 2014. “Between Consensus and Denial: Climate Journalists as Interpretive Community.”Science Communication36 (4): 399–427.
6.
CameronGlen T.SallotLynne M.CurtinPatricia A.1997. “Public Relations and the Production of News: A Critical Review and Theoretical Framework.” In Communication Yearbook 20, ed. BurlesonBrant R., 111–56. Thousand Oaks: Sage.
7.
CottleSimonNolanDavid. 2007. “Global Humanitarianism and the Changing Aid-Media Field.”Journalism Studies8 (6): 862–78.
8.
DavisAeron. 2002. Public Relations Democracy: Public Relations, Politics, and the Mass Media in Britain. Manchester, NY: Manchester University Press.
9.
DoyleJulie. 2009. “Climate Action and Environmental Activism: The Role of Environmental NGOs and Grassroots Movements in the Global Politics of Climate Change.” In Climate Change and the Media, ed. BoyceTammy, 103–16. New York: Peter Lang.
10.
ElfenbeinDick. 1986. “Business Journalists Say if It’s Not Local, It’s Trashed.”Public Relations Quarterly31 (2): 17–20.
11.
EngesserSvenBrüggemannMichael. 2015. “Mapping the Minds of the Mediators: The Cognitive Frames of Climate Journalists from Five Countries.”Public Understanding of Science. Published electronically May12, 2015. doi:10.1177/0963662515583621.
12.
FahyDeclanNisbetMatthew C.2011. “The Science Journalist Online: Shifting Roles and Emerging Practices.”Journalism12 (7): 778–93.
13.
FentonNatalie. 2010. “NGOs, New Media and the Mainstream News.” In New Media, Old News: Journalism & Democracy in the Digital Age, ed. FentonNatalie, 153–68. Los Angeles: Sage.
14.
GeorgeAlexander L.BennettAndrew. 2005. Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences. Cambridge: MIT Press.
15.
GiannoulisChristosBotetzagiasIosifSkanavisConstantina. 2011. “Newspaper Reporters’ Priorities and Beliefs about Environmental Journalism: An Application of Q-Methodology.”Science Communication32 (4): 425–66.
16.
GordonJoyeDeinesTinaHaviceJacqueline. 2010. “Global Warming Coverage in the Media: Trends in a Mexico City Newspaper.”Science Communication32 (2): 143–70.
17.
GoughClairShackleySimon. 2001. “The Respectable Politics of Climate Change: The Epistemic Communities and NGOs.”International Affairs77 (2): 329–46.
18.
GreenbergJoshKnightGrahamWestersundElizabeth. 2011. “Spinning Climate Change: Corporate and NGO Public Relations Strategies in Canada and the United States.”International Communication Gazette73 (1–2): 65–82.
19.
JeffersDennis W.1977. “Performance Expectations as a Measure of Relative Status of News and PR People.”Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly54 (2): 299–306.
20.
KrøvelRoy. 2012. “Setting the Agenda on Environmental News in Norway.”Journalism Studies13 (2): 259–76.
21.
KuneliusRistoEideElisabeth. 2012. “Moment of Hope, Mode of Realism: On the Dynamics of a Transnational Journalistic Field during UN Climate Change Summits.”International Journal of Communication6:266–85.
22.
LarssonLarsåke. 2009. “PR and the Media. A Collaborative Relationship?”Nordicom Review30 (1): 131–47.
23.
LewisJustinWilliamsAndrewFranklinBob. 2008. “A Compromised Fourth Estate? UK News Journalism, Public Relations and News Sources.”Journalism Studies9 (1): 1–20.
24.
LiebesTamarKatzElihu. 1997. “Staging Peace: Televised Ceremonies of Reconciliation.”The Communication Review2 (2): 235–57.
25.
MayringPhilipp. 2002. Einführung in die qualitative Sozialforschung. Eine Anleitung zu qualitativem Denken [Introduction to Qualitative Social Research: A Guidance to Qualitative Thinking]. 5th ed.Weinheim: Beltz-Verlag.
26.
McCluskeyMichael. 2008. “Reporter Beat and Content Differences in Environmental Stories.”Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly85 (1): 83–98.
27.
NeijensPeterSmitEdith. May2003. “The Problematic Relationship between Journalists and Public Relations Practitioners in Government and Business.”Paper presented at the Annual Conference of the International Communication Association, San Diego, USA.
28.
NielsenKristian HvidtfeltKjærgaardRikke Schmidt. 2011. “News Coverage of Climate Change in Nature News and Science NOW during 2007.”Environmental Communication5 (1): 25–44.
29.
NisbetMatthew. 2009. “Communicating Climate Change: Why Frames Matter for Public Engagement.”Environment: Science and Policy for Sustainable Development51 (2): 12–23.
30.
PowersMatthew. 2014. “The Structural Organization of NGO Publicity Work: Explaining Divergent Publicity Strategies at Humanitarian and Human Rights Organizations.”International Journal of Communication8:90–107.
31.
PowersMatthew. 2015. “Contemporary NGO-Journalist Relations: Reviewing and Evaluating an Emergent Area of Research.”Sociology Compass9 (6): 427–37.
32.
PrincenThomas. 1994. “NGOs: Creating a Niche in Environmental Diplomacy.” In Environmental NGOs in World Politics: Linking the Local and the Global, ed. PrincenThomasFingerMatthias, 29–47. London: Routledge.
33.
ReeseStephen. 2015. “Globalization of Mediated Spaces: The Case of Transnational Environmentalism in China.”International Journal of Communication9:2263–81.
34.
ReichZvi. 2010. “Measuring the Impact of PR on Published News in Increasingly Fragmented News Environments: A Multifaceted Approach.”Journalism Studies11 (6): 799–816.
35.
RyanMichaelMartinsonDavid L.1988. “Journalists and Public Relations Practitioners: Why the Antagonism?” Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly65 (1): 131–40.
36.
SachsmanDavid B.SimonJamesValentiJoAnn Myer. 2010. Environment Reporters in the 21st Century. New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers.
37.
SallotLynne M.JohnsonElisabeth A.2006. “To Contact . . . or Not? Investigating Journalists’ Assessments of Public Relations Subsidies and Contact Preferences.”Public Relations Review32 (1): 83–86.
38.
SallotLynne M.SteinfattThomas M.SalwenMichael B.1998. “Journalists’ and Public Relations Practitioners’ News Values: Perceptions and Cross-Perceptions.”Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly75 (2): 366–77.
39.
SchäferMike S.AnaIvanovaSchmidtAndreas. 2014. “What Drives Media Attention for Climate Change? Explaining Issue Attention in Australian, German and Indian Print Media from 1996 to 2010.”International Communication Gazette76 (2): 152–76.
40.
SchlichtingInga. 2013. “Strategic Framing of Climate Change by Industry Actors: A Meta-analysis.”Environmental Communication7 (4): 493–511.
41.
SchmidtAndreasIvanovaAnaSchäferMike S.2013. “Media Attention for Climate Change around the World: A Comparative Analysis of Newspaper Coverage in 27 Countries.”Global Environmental Change23 (5): 1233–48.
42.
SheaferTamirGabayItay. 2009. “Mediated Public Diplomacy: A Strategic Contest over International Agenda Building and Frame Building.”Political Communication26 (4): 447–67.
ShinJae-HwaCameronGlen T.2003. “The Interplay of Professional and Cultural Factors in the Online Source-Reporter Relationship.”Journalism Studies4 (2): 253–72.
45.
WaisbordSilvio. 2011. “Can NGOs Change the News?”International Journal of Communication5:142–65.
46.
WarkentinCraig. 2001. Reshaping World Politics: NGOs, the Internet, and Global Civil Society. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield.
47.
WhiteJonHobsbawmJulia. 2007. “Public Relations and Journalism: The Unquiet Relationship—A View from the United Kingdom.”Journalism Practice1 (2): 283–92.
