YouTube discourse of the Oting massacre in Nagaland: investigating affiliations,sentiments and Naga identity negotiation in YouTube comments

Abstract

Personae identification and understanding the social bonds shared in online interactions are found to be key to combating misinformation and conspiratorial discourse as well as aiding in developing solutions for specific communities. The 2021 Oting massacre in Nagaland that killed 14 civilians sparked public outrage and widespread protests calling for justice and the repeal of the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act in northeast India. The massacre received a lot of attention, including YouTube videos, and reignited discussion on militarization, Naga identity and a backlash over the botched operation. A close qualitative analysis of 500 randomly extracted comments from 10 selected YouTube videos identified 15 personae with unique linguistic patterns that reveal specific ideational targets and their affiliation strategies in the discourse. A sentiment analysis of 11,294 comments shows a higher negative score linked to condemnation, hate speech and conspiracy than a positive score linked to solidarity and empathy. ‘Nagaism’ as being a Naga is reimagined and reinforced via YouTube, countering misconceptions about Naga identity.

Keywords

affiliation Naga identity Oting massacre personae sentiments YouTube

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aier

(2009) Encyclopaedia of Nagaland. New Delhi: Anmol Publisher.

Ambrocia

(2021) Nagaland: Mon residents take out candle march, demand repeal of AFSPA. East Mojo, 8 December. Available at: https://www.eastmojo.com/news/2021/12/08/nagaland-mon-residents-take-out-candle-march-demand-repeal-of-afspa/ (accessed 25 February 2023).

Anthony

(2022) AntConc (Version 4.2.0) [Computer Software]. Tokyo, Japan: Waseda University. Available at: https://www.laurenceanthony.net/software (accessed 22 February 2023).

Army in Nagaland (1996) Economic and Political Weekly 31(34): 2284–2287.

Asian Centre for Human Rights (ACHR) (2022) Oting Massacre and the Case for Repeal of the APSFA. New Delhi: ACHR.

Chakravarthi

(2022) Hope speech detection in YouTube comments. Social Network Analysis and Mining 12(1): 1–19.

Chang

Y-C

Chang

Y-J

(2019) Identity negotiation in the third space: An analysis of YouTube channels hosted by expatriates in Taiwan. Language and Intercultural Communication 19(1): 77–92.

Chen

Flowerdew

(2019) Discriminatory discursive strategies in online comments on YouTube videos on the Hong Kong umbrella movement by mainland and Hong Kong Chinese. Discourse & Society 30(6): 549–572.

Datta-Ray

(2021) Inked in blood. The Telegraph Online, 11 December. Available at: https://www.telegraphindia.com/opinion/the-mon-massacre-joins-a-list-of-bloody-provocations/cid/1842755 (accessed 19 March 2023).

10.

Demsar

, et al. (2013) Orange: Data mining toolbox in Python. Journal of Machine Learning Research 14: 2349−2353.

11.

Deori

Verma

Kumar

(2021) Sentiment analysis of users’ comments on Indian Hindi News Channels using Mozdeh: An evaluation based on YouTube videos. Journal of Creative Communications. Epub ahead of print 17 November 2021. DOI: 10.1177/09732586211049232.

12.

Ezung

(2021) Indo-Naga Poltical Conflict: Rewriting the Post-Colonial Idea of Nation. Nagaland: Whetstone Publications.

13.

Graham

Gray

(2022) Where conspiracy theories flourish: A study of YouTube comments and Bill Gates conspiracy theories. Harvard Kennedy School Misinformation Review 3(5): 1–12.

14.

Human Rights Watch (2021) India: Army kills 14 civilians in Nagaland. Human Rights Watch, 8 December. Available at: https://www.hrw.org/news/2021/12/08/india-army-kills-14-civilians-nagaland (accessed 19 March 2023).

15.

Inwood

Zappavigna

(2023a) Conspiracy theories and white supremacy on YouTube: Exploring affiliation and legitimation strategies in YouTube comments. Social Media + Society 9(1): 1–16.

16.

Inwood

Zappavigna

(2023b) The marriages of celebrity politicians: A social semiotic approach to how commenters affiliate around YouTube gossip videos. In: McDonnell

Silver

(eds) A Gossip Politic: Rhetoric, Politics and Society. Cham, Switzerland: Palgrave Macmillan, 133–153.

17.

Jamir

(2021) Grassroot reality of the Oting massacre. The Naga Republic, 13 December. Available at: http://www.thenagarepublic.com/discourse/grassroot-reality-of-the-oting-massacre/ (accessed 19 March 2023).

18.

Kapoor

(2022) ‘Don’t act like a Sati-Savitri!’: Hinglish and other impoliteness strategies in Indian YouTube comments. Journal of Pragmatics 189: 4–16.

19.

Kemp

(2023) Digital 2023: India. Datareportal, 14 February. Available at: https://datareportal.com/reports/digital-2023-india (accessed 19 March 2023).

20.

Kense

(2022) When bloody Sunday came to Kohima: Memories of March 5, 1995. The Morung Express, 5 March. Available at: https://www.morungexpress.com/when-bloody-sunday-came-to-kohima-memories-of-march-5-1995 (accessed 19 March 2023).

21.

Khala

(2004) The Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA) and Its Impact on Violence Against Women in Nagaland. New Delhi: WISCOMP.

22.

Kikon

(2003) Destroying differences, schooling consent: A critical analysis of education policy in Indian-administered Nagaland 1. Inter-Asia Cultural Studies 4(2): 232–248.

23.

Kikon

(2005) Engaging Naga nationalism: Can democracy function in militarised societies? Economic and Political Weekly 40(26): 2833–2837.

24.

Kikon

(2009) The predicament of justice: Fifty years of Armed Forces Special Powers Act in India. Contemporary South Asia 17(3): 271–282.

25.

Kumar

(2005) Naga identity. New Delhi: Concept Publishing Co.

26.

Kumar

(2023) Sterotypes about the northeast are losing grip, but new challenges emerge. The Wire, 16 March. Available at: https://thewire.in/books/northeast-stereotypes-vikas-kumar-book-excerpt (accessed 19 March 2023).

27.

Kundra

(2023) A Resurgent Northeast: Narratives of Change. Delhi: HarperCollins Publishers India.

28.

Longchari

(2021) Reflections on Oting. The Arunachal Times, 23 December. Available at: https://arunachaltimes.in/index.php/2021/12/23/reflections-on-oting/ (accessed 19 March 2023).

29.

Martínez

Olsson

(2019) Making sense of YouTubers: how Swedish children construct and negotiate the YouTuber Misslisibell as a girl celebrity. Journal of Children and Media 13(1): 36–52.

30.

Marshall

Christopher

Kim

(2015) Persona as method: Exploring celebrity and the public self through persona studies. Celebrity Studies 6(3): 288–305.

31.

Martin

(2009) Realisation, instantiation and individuation: Some thoughts on identity in youth justice conferencing. DELTA: Documentação de Estudos em Lingüística Teórica e Aplicada 25: 549–583.

32.

Misra

(1978) The Naga national question. Economic and Political Weekly 13(14): 618–624.

33.

Mohan

Punathambekar

(2019) Localizing YouTube: Language, cultural regions, and digital platforms. International Journal of Cultural Studies 22(3): 317–333.

34.

Oxford Economics (2021) A platform for Indian opportunity: Assessing the economic, societal and cultural impact of YouTube in India. Available at: https://kstatic.googleusercontent.com/files/45fedbf71b2dd6e7a59b4990a731b6b8067a434accfdc9c6c15df18177e63b4a2f454fe1a165ca47b78412325386c1a101d950355e4811d5e09cb363cb9f3d77 (accessed 20 March 2023).

35.

Rieder

(2015) YouTube data tools (Version 1.31). Available at: https://tools.digitalmethods.net/netvizz/youtube/ (accessed 21 February 2023).

36.

Sinha

(2021) Nagaland civilian killings: How many stories do you read on my face. Outlook, 17 December. Available at: https://www.outlookindia.com/website/story/india-news-nagaland-massacre-protests-in-the-blue-mountains/405510 (accessed 19 March 2023).

37.

Talukdar

(2021) Between the law and the lawless: Civilian killings in Nagaland provoke outrage, calls to revoke AFSPA intensify. Frontline, 21 December. Available at: https://frontline.thehindu.com/cover-story/between-the-law-and-the-lawless/article37936339.ece (accessed 25 February 2023).

38.

Tohring

(2010) Violence and Identity in North-east India Naga-Kuki Conflict. New Delhi: Mittal Publications.

39.

Udwan

Leurs

Alencar

(2020) Digital resilience tactics of Syrian refugees in the Netherlands: Social media for social support, health, and identity. Social Media + Society 6(2): 1–11.

40.

Wouters

JJP

(2018) In the Shadows of Naga Insurgency: Tribes, State, and Violence in Northeast India. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.

41.

Wouters

JJP

(2022) Nagapolis: A Community Portrait. New Delhi: Barkweaver Publications.

42.

Yanlem

(2023) Can the Oting killings ever be forgotten? Outlook, 11 February. Available at: https://www.outlookindia.com/national/can-the-oting-killings-ever-be-forgotten–magazine-261038 (accessed 25 February 2023).

43.

Yau

Marder

O’Donohoe

(2020) The role of social media in negotiating identity during the process of acculturation. Information Technology & People 33(2): 554–575.

44.

Yonuo

(1984) The Rising Nagas: A Historical and Political Study. Delhi: Manas Publications.

45.

Zappavigna

Martin

(2018) #Communing affiliation: Social tagging as a resource for aligning around values in social media. Discourse, Context and Media 22: 4–12.