This article explores the root causes of a missing swab incident. It reinforces the scrub practitioner's responsibility for the surgical count as reflected on by a student operating department practitioner. With environmental pressures and methods upheld by the operating room culture it is recognised that mistakes do sometimes arise from human error when the stress from workload becomes apparent. Through reflection, mistakes can become learning opportunities, as sought through this critical appraisal.
Association of Perioperative Practice2007Standards and guidance: Staffing policy template [online] Available from: www.afpp.org.uk/careers/Standards-Guidance [Accessed February 2012]
AtkinsS2008Developing underlying skills in the move towards reflective practice In: BulmanC, SchutzS (ed) Reflective practice in nursingOxford, Blackwell Publishing Ltd
Boylan-KempJ2009The legal system Part 1: it's not just for lawyersBritish Journal of Nursing18(2) 106–8
6.
BromileyM, MitchellL2009Would you speak up if the consultant got it wrong?…and would you listen if someone said you'd got it wrong? Journal of Perioperative Practice19(10) 326–9
7.
BulmanC, SchutzS2008Reflective practice in nursing4th edOxford, Blackwell Publishing Ltd
8.
CuschieriA2006Nature of human error, implications for surgical practiceAmerican Surgical Association Forum244(5) 642–8
9.
de VriesEN, RamrattanMA, SmorenburgSM, GoumaDJ, BoermeesterMA2008The incidence and nature of in-hospital adverse events: a systematic reviewQuality and Safety in Healthcare (19) 216–23
10.
DekkerS2005Ten questions about human error: A new view of human factors and system safetyLondon, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Inc
DeweyJ1938Experience and educationNew York, Macmillan
13.
DimondB2011The legal aspects of nursing6th edHarlow, Pearson Education ltd
14.
EdwardsP2005The national patient safety agency and theatre practitionersBritish Journal of Perioperative Nursing15(10) 428–33
15.
FullbrookS2005Risk management In: WoodheadK, WickerP (ed) A textbook of perioperative careEdinburgh, Elsevier Churchill Livingstone
16.
GawandeAA, StuddertDM, OravEJ, BrennanTA, ZinnerMJ2003Risk factors for retained instruments and sponges after surgeryThe New England Journal of Medicine Available from: www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMsa021721#t=abstract [Accessed February 2012]
GhayeT, LillymanS2010Reflection: principles and practices for healthcare professionalsLondon, Quay Books Division
19.
GibbsG1988Learning by doing: a guide to teaching and learning methodsOxford, Oxford Brookes University
20.
HaynesAB, WeiserTG, BerryWR2009A surgical safety checklist to reduce morbidity and mortality in a global populationNew England Journal of Medicine Available from: http://content.nejm.org/cgi/reprint/NEJMsa0810119.pdf [Accessed February 2012]
McSherryR, PearceP2011Clinical Governance. A guide to implementation for healthcare practitionersWest Sussex, Wiley-Blackwell
23.
MitchellL, MitchellJ2011‘Pass the buzzy thing, please.’ Recognising and understanding information: an essential non-technical skill element for the efficient scrub practitionerJournal of Perioperative Practice21(6) 203–5
24.
National Health Service Litigation Authority2011NHSLAClaims Available from: http://www.nhsla.com/Claims/ [Accessed February 2012]
NHS Trust local policy2010a Incident reporting and investigation policy and procedure [Accessed October 2011]
28.
NHS Trust local policy2010b Completion of the WHO checklist and perioperative care record [Accessed October 2011]
29.
NHS Trust local policy2010c Urinary catheterisation: female [Accessed November 2011]
30.
NHS Trust local policy2011Count (swab, instruments and sharps) policy [Accessed September 2011]
31.
PanditJJ, CareyA2006Estimating the duration of common elective operations: implications for operating list managementAnaesthesia Journal of the Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland Available from: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1365-2044.2006.04719.x/full [Accessed February 2012]
32.
PanditJJ, WestburyS, PanditM2007The concept of surgical operating list ‘efficiency’: a formula to describe the termAnaesthesia Journal of the Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland Available from: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1365-2044.2007.05174.x/full [Accessed February 2012]
QuickJ2010Legal, professional and ethical considerations of advanced perioperative practiceJournal of Perioperative Practice20(5) 177–80
36.
ReidJ, ClarkeJ2009Progressing safer surgeryJournal of Perioperative Practice19(10) 336–41
37.
RolfeG, JasperM, FreshwaterD2010Critical reflection in practice2nd edHampshire, Palgrave Macmillan
38.
RymarukS2011A retrospective observational study of patient cancellations on the day of surgery in the general surgical directorateJournal of Perioperative Practice21(10) 337–41
39.
SchönD A1991The reflective practitioner: how professionals think in action2nd edAldershot, Ashgate
40.
ScottE, SummerbellL2004Managing risk in the perioperative environmentNursing Standard18(30) 47–52
41.
TaylorB J2006Reflective practice: a guide for nurses and midwives2nd edMaidenhead, Open University Press
42.
VatsA, NagpalK, MoorthyK2009Surgery: a risky businessJournal of Perioperative Practice19(10) 330–33
43.
WilsonI, WalkerI2009The WHO surgical safety checklist: the evidenceJournal of Perioperative Practice19(10) 362–64
44.
WoodheadK2009Safe surgery: reducing the risk of retained itemsJournal of Perioperative Practice19(10) 358–61
45.
World Health Organization2009Safe surgery saves lives. The second global patient safety challenge Available from: www.who.int/patientsafety/safesurgery/en/ [Accessed February 2012]
