This article is a revised version of an analysis of reported incidents related to anaesthesia, originally published in the journal Anaesthesia (Catchpole et al 2008a) and undertaken on behalf of the National Patient Safety Agency. The purpose was to examine the range, types, frequencies and causes of reported patient safety incidents associated with anaesthesia. First we examined anaesthetic incidents as a sub-set of the total number of reported incidents; then we examined pre-surgery assessment, epidural anaesthesia, and anaesthetic awareness incidents, as they were identified as being frequent and of potential concern. To our knowledge it was the first paper to analyse and present results of the NPSA's database in a clinical academic journal. Here, we take the opportunity to re-present and review the findings in light of subsequent progress in understanding and improving patient safety and quality of care.
CandidoK.D., StevensR.A.2003Post-dural puncture headache: pathophysiology, prevention and treatmentBest Practice and Research Clinical Anaesthesiology17(3) 451–469
CatchpoleK., BellM.D., JohnsonS., BoultM.2006Reviewing the evidence of patient safety incidents in anaestheticsReport to the National Patient Safety AgencyLondon, NPSA
4.
CatchpoleK.R., GiddingsA.E., WilkinsonM., HirstG., DaleT., de LevalM.R.2007Improving patient safety by identifying latent failures in successful operationsSurgery142(1) 102–110
5.
CatchpoleK., BellM.D., JohnsonS.2008a Safety in anaesthesia: a study of 12,606 reported incidents from the UK National Reporting and Learning SystemAnaesthesia63(4) 340–346
6.
CatchpoleK.R., GiddingsA.E., HirstG., DaleT., PeekG.J., de LevalM.R.2008b A method for measuring threats and errors in surgeryCognition, Technology and Work10(4) 295–304
7.
CatchpoleK., MishraA., HandaA., McCullochP.2008c Teamwork and error in the operating room: analysis of skills and rolesAnnals of Surgery247(4) 699–706
8.
CookR.I., WoodsD.D.1996Adapting to new technology in the operating roomHuman Factors38(4) 593–613
9.
FastingS., GisvoldS.E.2002Equipment problems during anaesthesia–are they a quality problem?British Journal of Anaesthesia89(6) 825–831
10.
de FilhoG.R., GomesH.P., da FonsecaM.H., HoffmanJ.C., PederneirasS.G., GarciaJ.H.2002Predictors of successful neuraxial block: a prospective studyEuropean Journal of Anaesthesiology19(6) 447–451
11.
FletcherG.C.L., FlinR.H., McGeorgeP.2000Review of Human Factors Research in AnaesthesiaThe identification and measurement of anaesthetists' non-technical skills SCPMDE Project: RDNES/991/C Industrial Psychology Group, University of Aberdeen.
12.
FletcherG.C.L., McGeorgeP., FlinR.H., GlavinR.J., MaranN.J.2002The role of non-technical skills in anaesthesia: a review of current literatureBritish Journal of Anaesthesia88(3) 418–429
13.
FletcherG.C.L., FlinR.H., GlavinR.J., MaranN.J., PateyR.2003Anaesthetists' Non-Technical Skills (ANTS): Evaluation of a behavioural marker systemBritish Journal of Anaesthesia90(5) 580–588
14.
GoldhillD., WaldmannC.2006Excellent anaesthesia needs patient preparation and postoperative support to influence outcomeCurrent Opinions in Anaesthesiology19(2) 192–197
15.
HallerG., GarnerinP., MoralesM.A.2008Effect of crew resource management training in a multidisciplinary obstetrical settingInternational Journal for Quality in Health Care20(4) 254–263
16.
HaynesA.B., WeiserT.G., BerryW.R.2009A surgical safety checklist to reduce morbidity and mortality in a global populationNew England Journal of Medicine360(5) 491–499
17.
HealeyA., CatchpoleK., YuleS.2008Enhancing surgical systemsCognition, Technology and Work10(4) 251–254
18.
Healthcare Commission2009Investigation into Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation TrustLondon, Commission for Healthcare Audit and Inspection
19.
HelmreichR.L.2000On error management: lessons from aviationBritish Medical Journal320(7237) 781–785
20.
HelmreichR.L., MussonD.M.2000The University of Texas threat and error management model: components and examplesBritish Medical Journal Web Site Available from: http://www.bmj.com/misc/bmj.320.7237.781
21.
HoferT.P., HaywardR.A.2002Are bad outcomes from questionable clinical decisions preventable medical errors? A case of cascade iatrogenesisAnnals of Internal Medicine137(5) 327–333
22.
HornJ., BellM.D., MossE.2004Handover of responsibility for the anaesthetised patient - opinion and practiceAnaesthesia59(7) 658–663
23.
KlugerM.T., BullockM.F.2002Recovery room incidents: a review of 419 reports from the Anaesthetic Incident Monitoring Study (AIMS)Anaesthesia57(11) 1060–1066
24.
KrecklerS., CatchpoleK., McCullochP., HandaA.2009Factors influencing incident reporting in surgical careQuality and Safety in Health Care18(2) 116–120
25.
LennmarkenC., BildforsK., EnlundG., SamuelssonP., SandinR.2002Victims of awarenessActa Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica46(3) 229–231
26.
MayberryL.J., ClemmensD., DeA.2002Epidural analgesia side effects, co-interventions, and care of women during childbirth: a systematic reviewAmerican Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology186(5) S81–S93
27.
McCullochP., MishraA., HandaA., DaleT., HirstG., CatchpoleK.2009The effects of aviation-style nontechnical skills training on technical performance and outcome in the operating theatreQuality and Safety in Health Care18(2) 109–115
28.
MoorthyK., MunzY., ForrestD.2006Surgical crisis management skills training and assessment: a simulation[corrected]-based approach to enhancing operating room performanceAnnals of Surgery244(1) 139–147
29.
OrmrodG., CaseyD.2004The educational preparation of nursing staff undertaking pre-assessment of surgical patients–a discussion of the issuesNurse Education Today24(4) 256–262
30.
PhillipsJ.M., StedefordJ.C., HartsilverE., RobertsC.2002Epidural abscess complicating insertion of epidural cathetersBritish Journal of Anaesthesia89(5) 778–782
31.
RaiM.R., PanditJ.J.2003Day of surgery cancellations after nurse-led pre-assessment in an elective surgical centre: the first 2 years.Anaesthesia58(7) 692–699
32.
ReasonJ.T.1990Human ErrorCambridge, University Press
33.
ReasonJ.1997Managing the Risks of Organisational AccidentsAldershot, Ashgate
34.
ResarR., PronovostP., HaradenC., SimmondsT., RaineyT., NolanT.2005Using a bundle approach to improve ventilator care processes and reduce ventilator-associated pneumoniaJoint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety31(5) 243–248
35.
SchaeferH.G., HelmreichR.L., ScheideggerD.1995Safety in the operating theatre – part 1: interpersonal relationships and team performanceCurrent Anaesthesia and Critical Care648–53
36.
SigalovskyN.2003Awareness under general anesthesia.American Association of Nurse Anaesthetists Journal71(5) 373–379
37.
SteffekM., OwczukR., Szlyk-AugustynM., Lasinska-KowaraM., WujtewiczM.2004Total spinal anaesthesia as a complication of local anaesthetic test-dose administration through an epidural catheterActa Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica48(9) 1211–1213
38.
TamuzM., ThomasE.J., FranchoisK.E.2002Defining and classifying medical error: lessons for patient safety reporting systemsQuality and Safety in Health Care1313–20
39.
TrimJ., FordyceF., DuaS.2003Using clinical governance to standardise an epidural serviceNursing Standard18(9) 43–45
40.
WeingerM.B., EnglundC.E.1990Ergonomic and human factors affecting anesthetic vigilance and monitoring performance in the operating room environmentAnesthesiology73(5) 995–1021
41.
WoodsD., CookR.I.1999Hindsight biases and local rationality pp 141–171 In: DursoF.T. eds Handbook of Applied CognitionChichester, John Wiley and Sons Ltd
42.
YoungT.P., McCleanS.I.2008A critical look at lean thinking in healthcareQuality and Safety in Health Care17(5) 382–386
