Higher educational aspirations, the ongoing academic drift and the widely discussed shift towards a knowledge society are putting increasing pressure on vocational education and training. The often higher level of academic qualifications within national qualifications frameworks also suggests that these are to be regarded as more valuable than vocational qualifications. However, few studies to date directly compare vocational and academic qualifications. Using the example of the occupation ‘Dispensing Optician’, this study compares an academic with a vocational qualification approach. Employing a document analysis of the respective intended curricula in Germany and the UK, the areas of competence, competence levels and the scope of content in both countries are analysed and compared. Finally, the results are discussed in terms of their possible implications concerning the trend towards higher qualifications, the categorisation of qualifications in qualification frameworks and the constitutive characteristics of vocational and academic education.
AjithkumarUPilzM (2019) Attractiveness of Industrial Training Institutes (ITI) in India: a study on ITI students and their parents. Education and Training61(2): 153–168.
3.
AllaisS (2011) Using learning outcomes to make educational judgements: some practical and conceptual issues. In: BohlingerSMünchhausenG (eds) Validierung von Lernergebnissen – Recognition and Validation of Prior Learning. Bielefeld: WBV, pp. 145–166.
4.
AllaisS (2014) Selling out education. In: National Qualifications Frameworks and the Neglect of Knowledge. Rotterdam: Sense Publishers.
5.
AndersonLW (2014) A Taxonomy for Learning, Teaching and Assessing: A Revision of Bloom’s: Pearson. New International Edition. Harlow, Essex: Pearson.
6.
AnderssonP (2021) Recognition of prior learning for highly skilled refugees’ labour market integration. International Migration59(4): 13–25.
AntunesF (2012) ‘Tuning’ education for the market in ‘Europe’? Qualifications, competences and learning outcomes: reform and action on the shop floor. European Educational Research Journal11(3): 446–470.
9.
ArthurL (2006) Higher education and the knowledge society: issues, challenges and responses in Norway and Germany. Research in Comparative and International Education1(3): 241–252.
10.
BaetgheM (2006) PISA-VET. A Feasibility-Study. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner Verlag.
11.
BaethgeMWolterA (2015) The German skill formation model in transition: from dual system of VET to higher education?Journal for Labour Market Research48: 97–112.
12.
BillettS (2014) The standing of vocational education: sources of its societal esteem and implications for its enactment. Journal of Vocational Education and Training66(1): 1–24.
13.
BjornavoldJLe MouillourI (2009) Learning outcomes in validation and credit systems. European Journal of Vocational Training48(3): 27–47.
14.
BlackmurD (2004) A critique of the concept of a national qualifications framework. Quality in Higher Education10(3): 267–284.
15.
BMBF (Bundesministerium für Bildung und Forschung) (2024) Berufsbildungsbericht 2024. Bonn: BMBF.
16.
BMBF (Bundesministerium für Bildung und Forschung) and KMK (Kultusministerkonferenz) (2013) German EQF Referencing Report. Germany: Report, BMBF and KMK.
17.
BohlingerS (2008) Competences as the core element of the European qualifications framework. European Journal of Vocational Training42/43(3/1): 96–112.
18.
BohlingerS (2012) Qualifications frameworks and learning outcomes: challenges for Europe’s lifelong learning area. Journal of Education and Work25(3): 279–297.
19.
BohlingerS (2017) Comparing recognition of prior learning (RPL) across countries. In: MulderM (ed) Competence-based Vocational and Professional Education: Bridging the Worlds of Work and Education. Cham: Springer, 589–606.
20.
BohlingerS (2019) Ten years after: the ‘success story’ of the European qualifications framework. Journal of Education and Work32(4): 393–406.
21.
BoschG (2017) Different national skill systems. In: BuchananJ (ed) The Oxford Handbook of Skills and Training. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 424–443.
22.
BowenGA (2009) Document analysis as a qualitative research method. Qualitative Research Journal9(2): 27–40.
23.
BrockmannMClarkeLWinchC (2008) Knowledge, skills, competence: European divergences in vocational education and training (VET) – the English, German and Dutch cases. Oxford Review of Education34(5): 547–567.
24.
BrockmannMClarkeLWinchC (2009) Competence and competency in the EQF and in European VET systems. Journal of European Industrial Training33(8/9): 787–799.
25.
BrockmannMClarkeLWinchC (2010) A transnational synthesis of European bricklaying qualifications. In: BrockmannMClarkeLWinchC (eds) Bricklaying Is More than Flemish Bond. Bricklaying Qualifications in Europe, 8–25. Brussels: CLR.
26.
BrownA (2011a) Lessons from policy failure: the demise of a national qualifications framework based solely on learning outcomes in England. Journal of Contemporary Educational Studies5: 36–55.
27.
BrownA (2011b) Problems with national qualifications frameworks in practice. The English case. Magazin erwachsenenbildung14: 1–12.
28.
Bundesamt für JustizB (2011) Verordnung über die Berufsausbildung zum Augenoptiker und zur Augenoptikerin (Augenoptiker-Ausbildungsverordnung – AugenoptAusbV) vom 26.04.2011. Available at:https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/augenoptausbv/AugenoptAusbV.pdf(accessed 30 March 2024).
29.
BusemeyerMRTrampuschC (2012) Introduction: the comparative political economy of collective skill formation. In: BusemeyerMRTrampuschC (eds) The Political Economy of Skill Formation. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 3–40.
30.
Cedefop (2017) Defining, Writing and Applying Learning Outcomes – A European Handbook. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.
31.
Cedefop (2020) Vocational education and training in Germany. In: Short Description. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.
32.
Cedefop (2022) Vocational education and training in France. In: Short Description. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.
33.
Cedefop (2023) European Guidelines for Validating Non-formal and Informal Learning. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.
34.
Cedefop, ETF (European Training Foundation) and European Commission (2018) European Inventory on Validation of Non-formal and Informal Learning 2018. Final Synthesis Report. Report. Luxembourg: Cedefop, ETF and European Commission.
35.
ChenP (2021) International curriculum comparison in vocational education and training: a collaborative development of an analysis instrument. International Journal for Research in Vocational Education and Training8(4): 16–43.
36.
Chen (2024) Competence-based approaches in curricula: a comparative analysis of Russian and Chinese commercial vocational education and training programmes. Research in Comparative and International Education19(1): 63–90.
37.
ClarkeLWinchS (2015) Have Anglo-Saxon concepts really influenced the development of European qualifications policy?Research in Comparative and International Education10(4): 593–606.
38.
ClarkeLWinchCBrockmannM (2013) Trade-based skills versus occupational capacity: the example of bricklaying in Europe. Work, Employment & Society27(6): 932–951.
39.
ClarkeLWesterhuisAWinchC (2021) Comparative VET European research since the 1980s: accommodating changes in VET systems and labour markets. Journal of Vocational Education and Training73(2): 295–315.
40.
CollinsSHewerI (2014) The impact of the Bologna process on nursing higher education in Europe: a review. International Journal of Nursing Studies51(1): 150–156.
41.
CortP (2010) Stating the Obvious: the European Qualifications Framework is not a neutral evidence-based policy tool. European Educational Research Journal9(3): 304–316.
42.
Council of the European Union (2017) Council Recommendation of 22May2017 on the European Qualifications Framework for lifelong learning and repealing the recommendation of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 April 2008 on the establishment of the European Qualifications Framework for lifelong learning (2017/C 189/03). Brussels: Official Journal ofthe European Union. Available at:https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:32017H0615(01)&from=EN(accessed 30 March 2024).
43.
CreswellJWMillerDL (2000) Determining validity in qualitative inquiry. Theory Into Practice39(3): 124–130.
DeissingerT (2008) Cultural patterns underlying apprenticeship: Germany and the UK. In: AarkrogVHelms JorgensenCH (eds) Divergence and Convergence in Education and Work. Bern: Peter Lang, 33–55.
46.
EbnerC (2015) Labour market developments and their significance for VET in Germany: an overview. Research in Comparative and International Education10(4): 576–592.
47.
ECOO (European Council of Optometry and Optics) (2020) Blue book 2020. In: Trends in Optics and Optometry – Comparative European Data. Brussels: ECOO.
48.
ErtlHKremerHH (2006) Curricular reform and college-based innovation in vocational education and training in England and Germany. Research in Comparative and International Education1(4): 351–365.
49.
European Commission (2019) ESCO Handbook. European Skills, Competences, Qualifications and Occupations. Brussels: European Commission.
FaßbenderUPilzM (2020) Merkmale dualer Berufsausbildung in den internationalen Angeboten deutscher Bildungsanbieter. Journal of Technical Education8(2): 26–45.
53.
FermL (2021) Vocational students’ ways of handling the academic/vocational divide. International Journal for Research in Vocational Education and Training8(1): 1–20.
54.
FischerM (2020) Beyond typologies: alternative ways of comparing VET systems. In: PilzMLiJ (eds) Comparative Vocational Education Research. Enduring Challenges and New Ways Forward. Wiesbaden: Springer, 23–41.
55.
FisherRSimmonsR (2012) Liberal conservatism, vocationalism and further education in England. Globalisation, Societies and Education10(1): 31–51.
56.
FrommbergerDKrichewskyL (2012) Comparative analysis of VET curricula in Europe. In: PilzM (ed) The Future of Vocational Education and Training in a Changing World. Wiesbaden: Springer, 235–258.
57.
Fulst-BleiS (2003) Im Spannungsfeld von Modularisierung und Europäisierung: Die deutsche duale Berufsausbildung im Test. Ein deutsch-englischer Leistungsvergleich. München: Hampp.
58.
FürstenauBPilzMGononP (2014) The dual system of vocational education and training in Germany – what can Be learnt about education for (other) professions. In: BillettSHarteisCGruberH (eds) International Handbook of Research in Professional and Practice-Based Learning. Dordrecht: Springer, 427–460.
59.
GambleJ (2001) Modelling the Invisible: the pedagogy of craft apprenticeship. Studies in Continuing Education23(2): 185–200.
60.
GambleJ (2022) Occupation’, labour markets and qualification futures. Journal of Vocational Education and Training74(2): 311–332.
GOC (General Optical Council) (2023b) Requirements for approved qualifications in Optometry or dispensing optics. In: Outcomes for Registration, Standards for Approved Qualifications, Quality Assurance and Enhancement Method. London: GOC. Available at: https://optical.org/media/vatfn2gi/optom_do-requirements-revised-may-2023.pdf (accessed 8 March 2025).
66.
GOC (General Optical Council) (2023c) Annual Report, Annual fitness to practise report and financial statements for the year ended 31 March 2023. UK: GOC.
67.
GrafL (2013) The Hybridization of Vocational Training and Higher Education in Austria, Germany, and Switzerland. Opladen: Budrich UniPress.
68.
HylandT (2002) On the upgrading of vocational studies: analysing prejudice and subordination in English education. Educational Review54(3): 287–296.
69.
HylandT (2017) Craft working and the ‘hard problem’ of vocational education and training. Open Journal of Social Sciences5(9): 304–325.
70.
HylandT (2018) Beyond the vocational/academic divide: inclusion through craftwork and embodied learning. In: SimmonsRSmythJ (eds) Education and Working-Class Youth. Reshaping the Politics of Inclusion. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan, 209–231.
71.
KMK (Kultusministerkonferenz) (2011) Rahmenlehrplan für den Ausbildungsberuf Augenoptiker/Augenoptikerin. Beschluss der Kultusministerkonferenz vom 25.03.2011. Berlin: Sekretariat der Ständigen Konferenz der Kultusminister der Länder in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland. Available at: https://www.kmk.org/fileadmin/pdf/Bildung/BeruflicheBildung/rlp/Augenoptiker11-03-25-E_01.pdf (accessed 8 March 2025).
72.
KornelakisAPetrakakiD (2020) Embedding employability skills in UK higher education: between digitalization and marketization. Industry and Higher Education34(5): 290–297.
73.
KuckartzU (2014) Qualitative Text Analysis: A Guide to Methods, Practice & Using Software. London: Sage.
74.
KuckartzU (2019) Qualitative text analysis: a systematic approach. In: KaiserGPresmegN (eds) Compendium for Early Career Researchers in Mathematics Education. Cham: Springer, 181–198.
75.
KuhleeD (2015) Federalism and corporatism: on the approaches of policy-making and governance in the dual apprenticeship system in Germany and their functioning today. Research in Comparative and International Education10(4): 476–492.
76.
LahiffA (2020) Industrial standardisation as a driver for cross-national convergence in training processes: aviation apprenticeships in England and Germany. European Journal of Training and Development43(7/8): 752–766.
77.
LaihoA (2010) Academisation of nursing education in the nordic countries. Higher Education60: 641–656.
78.
LesterS (2015) The European Qualifications Framework: a technical critique. Research in Post-Compulsory Education20(2): 159–172.
79.
LesterS (2017) Sequential schooling or lifelong learning? International frameworks through the lens of English higher professional and vocational education. Education + Training60(2): 213–224.
80.
LiJPilzM (2023) International transfer of vocational education and training: a literature review. Journal of Vocational Education and Training75(2): 185–218.
81.
LiJ (2020) Comparative methods in practice: using an iterative approach to explore aviation apprenticeships in England and Germany. In: PilzMLiJ (eds) Comparative Vocational Education Research. Enduring Challenges and New Ways Forward. Wiesbaden: Springer, 243–257.
LiuYGruskyDB (2013) The payoff to skill in the third industrial revolution. American Journal of Sociology118(5): 1161–1474.
84.
MarkowitschJLuomi-MessererK (2007) Development and interpretation of descriptors of the European qualifications framework. European Journal of Vocational Training42/43(3/1): 34–58.
85.
MéhautPWinchC (2012) The European qualification framework: skills, competences or knowledge?European Educational Research Journal11(3): 369–381.
86.
MikulecB (2017) Impact of the Europeanisation of education: qualifications frameworks in Europe. European Educational Research Journal16(4): 455–473.
87.
MulderM (ed) (2017) Competence-based Vocational and Professional Education. Bridging the Worlds of Work and Education. Cham: Springer.
88.
MulderMWintertonJ (2017) Introduction. In: MulderM (ed) Competence-based Vocational and Professional Education: Bridging the Worlds of Work and Education. Cham: Springer, 1–43.
89.
MüskensW (ed) (2013) Module level indicator. MLI – user guide. In: Assessment of the Level of Competence Orientation. Bremen. Universität Bremen.
90.
NewtonPMDa SilvaAPetersLG (2020) A pragmatic master list of action verbs for Bloom’s taxonomy. Frontiers in Education5(107): 1–5.
91.
NuscheD (2008) Assessment of learning outcomes in higher education: a comparative review of selected practices. In: OECD Education Working Paper No. 15. Paris: OECD Publishing.
92.
NylundMRosvallPALedmanK (2017) The vocational–academic divide in neoliberal upper secondary curricula: the Swedish case. Journal of Education Policy32(6): 788–808.
OrnellCP (1974) Bloom’s taxonomy and the objectives of education. Educational Research17(1): 3–18.
95.
ParryG (2015) English higher education and its vocational zones. Research in Comparative and International Education10(4): 493–509.
96.
PhilippsD (2006) Comparative education: method. Research in Comparative and International Education1(4): 304–319.
97.
PilzM (2009) Initial vocational training from a company perspective: a comparison of British and German in-house training cultures. Vocations and Learning2: 57–74.
98.
PilzM (2012) International comparative research into vocational training: methods and approaches. In: PilzM (ed) The Future of Vocational Education and Training in a Changing World. Wiesbaden: Springer, 561–588.
99.
PilzM (2016) Typologies in comparative vocational education: existing models and a new approach. Vocations and Learning9(3): 295–314.
100.
PilzMFürstenauB (2019) Duality and learning fields in vocational education and training. Pedagogy, curriculum, and assessment. In: GuileDUnwinL (eds) The Wiley Handbook of Vocational Education and Training. Hoboken: Wiley-Blackwell, 311–328.
101.
PilzM (2022) Economic knowledge among pupils in Austria, India and China: empirical evidence and cross-country comparison. Research in Comparative and International Education17(2): 328–350.
102.
PowellJJWBernhardNGrafL (2012) The emergent European model in skill formation: comparing higher education and vocational training in the Bologna and Copenhagen processes. Sociology of Education85(3): 240–258.
103.
PsifidouI (2011) Methodological approaches to test the EQF descriptors on qualifications and curricula: experiences drawn from LDV pilot projects. European Journal of Qualifications2011/3: 33–42.
RaffeD (2013) What is the evidence for the impact of National Qualifications Frameworks?Comparative Education49(2): 143–162.
106.
SchreierM (2014) Qualitative content analysis. In: FlickU (ed) The Sage Handbook of Qualitative Data Analysis. London: Sage, pp. 170–183.
107.
SchusterADesiderioMVUrsoG (eds) (2013) Recognition of Qualifications and Competences of Migrants. Brussels: International Organization for Migration.
108.
SmebyJC (2015) Academic drift in vocational education? In: SmebyJCSutphenM (eds) From Vocational to Professional Education: Educating for Social Welfare. London: Routledge, 7–25.
109.
StalderBESarojniCLeAH (2022) The standing of vocational education: a global concern with diverse meanings and implications. In: BillettS (ed) The Standing of Vocational Education and the Occupations it Serves. Current Concerns and Strategies for Enhancing that Standing. Cham: Springer, 3–17.
110.
StanleyJ (2015) Learning outcomes – from policy discourse to practice. European Journal of Education50(4): 404–419.
111.
ThomasD (2011) Comparative analysis of delivery of primary eye care in three European countries. In: IBES Diskussionsbeitrag Nr. 189. Report, Universität Duisburg-Essen, Germany, October.
112.
ThompsonP (1995) It ain’t what you do, it’s the way that you do it: production organisation and skill utilisation in commercial vehicles. Work, Employment & Society9(4): 719–742.
113.
Unesco-IBE (Unesco International Bureau of Education) (2016) What Makes a Quality Curriculum?Geneva: Unesco IBE.
114.
Unseco-IBE (Unesco International Bureau of Education) (2013) Glossary of Curriculum Terminology. Geneva: Unesco IBE.
115.
VälimaaJHoffmanD (2008) Knowledge society discourse and higher education. Higher Education56: 265–285.
116.
Van den AkkerJFasoglioDMulderH (2010) A Curriculum Perspective on Plurilingual Education. Strasbourg: Council of Europe.
117.
WCO (World Council of Optometry) (2015) A Global Competency-Based Model of Scope of Practice in Optometry. St. Louis: WCO.
118.
WerquinP (2010) Recognising non-formal and informal learning. In: Outcomes, Policies and Practices. Paris: OECD Publishing.
119.
WinchC (2020) The learning outcome apporach to European VET policy tools: where are the arguments and the evidence? In: PilzMLiJ (eds) Comparative Vocational Education Research. Enduring Challenges and New Ways Forward. Wiesbaden: Springer, 81–95.
120.
WinchC (2023) Learning outcomes: the long goodbye: vocational qualifications in the 21st century. European Educational Research Journal22(1): 20–38.
121.
WolterAKerstC (2015) The ‘academization’ of the German qualification system: recent developments in the relationships between vocational training and higher education in Germany. Research in Comparative and International Education10(4): 510–524.
122.
YoungM (2007) Qualifications Frameworks: some conceptual issues. European Journal of Education42(4): 445–457.
123.
YoungM (2008) Towards a European qualifications framework: some cautionary observations. Journal of European Industrial Training32(2/3): 127–137.
124.
Zlatkin-TroitschanskaiaOPilzM (eds) (2022) Special issue on internationalization of vocational education and training – advances and developments. International Journal of Training and Development26: 581–746.
