Challenging oversimplified models, the leader identity literature calls for new perspectives of leadership identity construction (LIC). Using a collective leadership lens and narrative methods, this collaborative study explores how Indigenous women’s leadership identities develop within a contest for power and voice. Observations, interviews, and micro-ethnographies helped identify how history, community dynamics and cultural contradictions influence LIC. We find the LIC process to unfold as a dialectical spiral, informed by contradictions experienced when enacting social identities in various spheres of influence. This highlights the intersectionality of salient identities when theorizing LIC, and suggests that minoritized leaders can resignify and ultimately, capitalize on their multiple identities to strengthen their leadership.
AlvessonMLee AshcraftKThomasR (2008) Identity matters: reflections on the construction of identity scholarship in organization studies. Organization15(1): 5–28.
2.
AlvessonMWillmottH (2002) Identity regulation as organizational control: producing the appropriate individual. Journal of Management Studies39(5): 619–644.
3.
AngelDLopez-CarmenVAStamatopoulouE, et al. (2019) Global Indigenous Youth: Through Their Eyes. Institute for the Study of Human Rights, Columbia University.
4.
AshforthBESchinoffBS (2016) Identity under construction: how individuals come to define themselves in organizations. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior3: 111–137.
5.
BarkdullC (2009) Exploring intersections of identity with native American women leaders. Affilia24(2): 120–136.
6.
BelloBM (2004) Etnicidad y ciudadanía en América Latina: la acción colectiva de los pueblos indígenas. United Nations Publications, 79.
7.
BownCMcClellanJ (2017) Culturally situated leadership in the Ecuadorian Andes. Journal of Leadership Studies11(3): 6–20.
8.
BravataDMWattsSAKeeferAL, et al. (2020) Prevalence, predictors, and treatment of impostor syndrome: a systematic review. Journal of General Internal Medicine35: 1252–1275.
9.
BreslinRAPandeySRiccucciNM (2017) Intersectionality in public leadership research: a review and future research agenda. Review of Public Personnel Administration37(2): 160–182.
10.
BrueKLBrueSA (2018) Leadership role identity construction in women’s leadership development programs. Journal of Leadership Education17(1): 7–27.
11.
BrownMHHoskingDM (1986) Distributed leadership and skilled performance as successful organization in social movements. Human Relations39(1): 65–79.
12.
BrownAD (2019) Identities in organization studies. Organization Studies40(1): 7–22.
13.
Byrd SrC (2009) Voices of Identity and Responsibility: A Description of the Development of Identity, Using Cross’ Theory of Nigrescence, and the Manifestation of Responsibility Among African-American Urban School Principals. Cardinal Stritch University.
14.
CampbellCShollenSLEganC, et al. (2019) The capacious model and leader identity: an integrative framework. Journal of Leadership Studies13(1): 6–19.
15.
CarrollBLevyL (2010) Leadership development as identity construction. Management Communication Quarterly24(2): 211–231.
16.
ChamberlainCFergieDSinclairA, et al. (2016) Traditional midwifery or ‘wise women’ models of leadership: learning from indigenous cultures. Leadership12(3): 346–363.
17.
CliftonJ (2018) The in situ construction of leader identity in a leader’s life story during an alumni talk to MBA students. Leadership14(6): 622–643.
18.
CollinsPH (2015) Intersectionality’s definitional dilemmas. Annual Review of Sociology41: 1–20.
CollinsonD (2005) Dialectics of leadership. Human Relations58(11): 1419–1442.
21.
CollinsonD (2014) Dichotomies, dialectics and dilemmas: new directions for critical leadership studies?Leadership10(1): 36–55.
22.
CollinsonD (2017) Critical leadership studies: a response to Learmonth and Morrell. Leadership13(3): 272–284.
23.
CrenshawK (1991) Mapping the margins: Intersectionality, identity politics, and violence against women of color. Stanford Law Review43: 1241–1299.
24.
CrevaniLLindgrenMPackendorffJ (2010) Leadership, not leaders: on the study of leadership as practices and interactions. Scandinavian Journal of Management26(1): 77–86.
25.
CrevaniLEndrissatN (2016) Mapping the leadership-as-practice terrain: Comparative elements. In: RaelinJ (ed), Leadership-as-Practice. Theory and Application. New York, NY: Routledge, pp. 21–49.
26.
CunliffeALEriksenM (2011) Relational leadership. Human Relations64(11): 1425–1449.
27.
DayDVFleenorJWAtwaterLE, et al. (2014) Advances in leader and leadership development: a review of 25 years of research and theory. The Leadership Quarterly25(1): 63–82.
28.
DeRueDSAshfordSJ (2010) Who will lead and who will follow? A social process of leadership identity construction in organizations. Academy of Management Review35(4): 627–647.
29.
DrathWH (2001) The Deep Blue Sea: Rethinking the Source of Leadership. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
30.
DrathWHMcCauleyCDPalusCJ, et al. (2008) Direction, alignment, commitment: toward a more integrative ontology of leadership. The Leadership Quarterly19(6): 635–653.
31.
DriskoJMaschiT (2015) Interpretive content analysis. In: DriskoJMaschiT (eds), Content Analysis. New York: Oxford University Press.
32.
DuttonJERobertsLMBednarJ (2010) Pathways for positive identity construction at work: four types of positive identity and the building of social resources. Academy of Management Review35(2): 265–293.
EganCShollenSLCampbellC, et al. (2017) Capacious model of leadership identities construction. In: StorbergWalkerJHaberCurranP (eds), Theorizing women and leadership: New insights and contributions from multiple perspectives. IAP, pp. 121–140.
35.
ElyRJIbarraHKolbDM (2011) Taking gender into account: Theory and design for women’s leadership development programs. Academy of Management Learning & Education10(3): 474–493.
36.
EndresSWeiblerJ (2017) Towards a three-component model of relational social constructionist leadership: a systematic review and critical interpretive synthesis. International Journal of Management Reviews19(2): 214–236.
37.
EpitropakiOKarkRMainemelisC, et al. (2017) Leadership and followership identity processes: a multilevel review. The Leadership Quarterly28(1): 104–129.
38.
Espinosa ArangoML (2007) Memoria cultural y el continuo del genocidio: lo indígena en Colombia. Antípoda. Revista de Antropología y Arqueología5: 53–73.
39.
EvansMMSinclairA (2016) Navigating the territories of Indigenous leadership: exploring the experiences and practices of Australian Indigenous arts leaders. Leadership12(4): 470–490.
40.
EyongJE (2017) Indigenous African leadership: key differences from anglo-centric thinking and writings. Leadership13(2): 133–153.
41.
FoleyD (2007) Leadership: the quandary of aboriginal societies in crises, 1788 to 1830, and 1966. In: HannaMMacfarlaneI (eds), Transgressions: Critical Australian Indigenous Histories. Canberra: Australian National University, pp. 177–192.
42.
ForsterMEPalmerFBarnettS (2016) Karanga mai ra: stories of māori women as leaders. Leadership12(3): 324–345.
43.
FrimannSHerstedL (2016) Constructing leadership identities through stories. Tamara14(4): 149–162.
44.
GagnonSCollinsonD (2014) Rethinking global leadership development programmes: the interrelated significance of power, context and identity. Organization Studies35(5): 645–670.
45.
GagnonSCollinsonD (2017) Resistance through difference: the co-constitution of dissent and inclusion. Organization Studies38(9): 1253–1276.
46.
GambrellKM (2016) Lakota women leaders: getting things done quietly. Leadership12(3): 293–307.
47.
GanzM (2010) Leading change: leadership, organization, and social movements. In: NohriaNKhurana (eds), Handbook of Leadership Theory and Practice. Harvard Business Press, 19, pp. 1–10.
48.
GladstoneJSPepionDD (2017) Exploring traditional indigenous leadership concepts: a spiritual foundation for Blackfeet leadership. Leadership13(5): 571–589.
49.
Gram-HanssenI (2021) Individual and collective leadership for deliberate transformations: insights from indigenous leadership. Leadership17(5): 519–541.
50.
GrayA (2008) Indigenous peoples and their territories. In: de Oliveira A Decolonising Indigenous Rights. New York: Routledge, pp. 27–54.
51.
GrundmannMJA (2020) Sobre las mujeres desde las historias de las mujeres, Gente de centro y muchas otras en diálogo con María José. Calle 14 revista de investigación en el campo del arte15(27): 152–166.
52.
HaarJRocheMBroughamD (2019) Indigenous insights into ethical leadership: a study of māori leaders. Journal of Business Ethics160(3): 621–640.
53.
HeifetzRA (1994) Leadership Without Easy Answers. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
54.
HellerDWatsonDKomarJ, et al. (2007) Contextualized personality: traditional and new assessment procedures. Journal of Personality75(6): 1229–1253.
HoggMAvan KnippenbergDRastDEIII (2012) The social identity theory of leadership: theoretical origins, research findings, and conceptual developments. European Review of Social Psychology23(1): 258–304.
57.
HorsfordSD (2012) This bridge called my leadership: an essay on black women as bridge leaders in education. International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education25(1): 11–22.
58.
HugginsJ (2004) Indigenous women and leadership. Indigenous Law Bulletin6(1): 5–7.
59.
IbarraH (1999) Provisional selves: experimenting with image and identity in professional adaptation. Administrative Science Quarterly44(4): 764–791.
60.
IbarraHWittmanSPetriglieriG, et al. (2014) Leadership and identity: an examination of three theories and new research directions. In: DayDV (ed), The Oxford Handbook of Leadership and Organizations. Oxford University Press, pp. 285–301.
61.
JulienMWrightBZinniDM (2005) Songs from the Circle: Leadership Lessons from Aboriginal Leaders. ON: Brock University.
62.
JulienMZinniDWrightB (2008) Keeper of the Drums: Female Aboriginal Leadership and the Salience of Gender. Advancing Women in Leadership, 28.
63.
KamaraM (2017) Remote and invisible: the voices of female indigenous educational leaders in northern territory remote community schools in Australia. Journal of Educational Administration and History49(2): 128–143.
64.
KellerT (1999) Images of the familiar: individual differences and implicit leadership theories. The Leadership Quarterly10(4): 589–607.
65.
KellyDJacksonBHenareM (2014) ‘He apiti hono, he tātai hono’: ancestral leadership, cyclical learning and the eternal continuity of leadership. In: WestwoodRJack KhanFFrenkelM (eds), Core-periphery relations and Organisation Studies. London: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 164–184.
66.
KennyCFraserTN (eds), (2012) Living Indigenous Leadership: Native Narratives on Building Strong Communities. Vancouver: UBC Press.
67.
KlenkeK (2007) Authentic leadership: a self, leader, and spiritual identity perspective. International Journal of Leadership Studies3(1): 68–97.
68.
KrippendorffK (2018) Content Analysis: An Introduction to its Methodology. CA: Sage publications.
69.
Kuiro CastroF (2018) La fuerza de la manicuera: Acciones de resistencia de las mujeres uitoto de la Chorrera (Amazonía) durante la explotación del caucho (Casa Arana 1990–1932). PhD Thesis. Colombia: Universidad del Rosario.
70.
KwaymullinaAKwaymullinaB (2010) Learning to read the signs: law in an Indigenous reality. Journal of Australian Studies34(2): 195–208.
71.
LankaETopakasAPattersonM (2020) Becoming a leader: catalysts and barriers to leader identity construction. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology29(3): 377–390.
72.
LeadbeaterCWongA (2011) Learning from the Extremes. San Jose: Cisco.
73.
LearmonthMMorrellK (2019) Critical Perspectives on Leadership. The Language of Corporate Power. London: Routledge.
74.
LeitchA (2017) Indigenous public service leadership and issues of cultural fluency. Australian Journal of Public Administration76(4): 403–405.
75.
LugonesM (2007) Heterosexualism and the colonial/modern gender system. Hypatia22(1): 186–219.
76.
MarchiondoLAMyersCGKopelmanS (2015) The relational nature of leadership identity construction: how and when it influences perceived leadership and decision-making. The Leadership Quarterly26(5): 892–908.
77.
McGregorD (2018) Mino-mnaamodzawin: achieving indigenous environmental justice in Canada. Environment and Society9(1): 7–24.
78.
MeisterASinclairAJehnKA (2017) Identities under scrutiny: how women leaders navigate feeling misidentified at work. The Leadership Quarterly28(5): 672–690.
79.
MilesBMHubermanAMSaldanaJ (2014) Qualitative Data Analysis: A Methods Sourcebook. (3rd.Ed). Los Angeles: Sage.
80.
MiscenkoDGuenterHDayDV (2017) Am i a leader? Examining leader identity development over time. The Leadership Quarterly28(5): 605–620.
81.
MureGRG (1950) A Study of Hegel’s Logic. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
82.
MurilloDV (2009) The creation of indigenous leadership in a Spanish town: Zacatecas, Mexico 1609-1752. Ethnohistory56(4): 669–698.
83.
OspinaSFoldyE (2009) A critical review of race and ethnicity in the leadership literature: surfacing context, power and the collective dimensions of leadership. The Leadership Quarterly20(6): 876–896.
84.
OspinaSSuC (2009) Weaving color lines: race, ethnicity, and the work of leadership in social change organizations. Leadership5(2): 131–170.
85.
OspinaSM (2019) Toward inclusive leadership scholarship: inviting the excluded to theorize collective leadership. In: CarrollBFirthJWilsonS (eds), After Leadership. Routledge, pp. 147–156.
86.
OspinaSMFoldyEGFairhurstGT, et al. (2020) Collective dimensions of leadership: connecting theory and method. Human Relations73(4): 441–463.
87.
PalmerFRMastersTM (2010) Māori feminism and sport leadership: Exploring Māori women’s experiences. Sport Management Review13(4): 331–344.
88.
PeteetBJMontgomeryLWeekesJC (2015) Predictors of imposter phenomenon among talented ethnic minority undergraduate students. The Journal of Negro Education84(2): 175–186.
PrattMG (2017) Leadership as Identity and Self-Process? Keynote Presentation at 2nd Interdisciplinary Perspectives on Leadership. Greece: Mykonos.
91.
ProutS (2009) Vacuums and veils: engaging with statistically ‘invisible’ indigenous population dynamics in yamatji country, western Australia. Geographical Research47(4): 408–421.
92.
RichardsonALoubierC (2008) Intersectionality and leadership. International Journal of Leadership Studies3(2): 142–161.
SantamariaA (2020) Seven women in The Bath of Remembrance: one narrator and three surrealistic indigenous women in the Amazon. International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education33(3): 311–326.
95.
ShamirBDayan-HoreshHAdlerD (2005) Leading by biography: towards a life-story approach to the study of leadership. Leadership1(1): 13–29.
96.
ShollenSL (2018) Women’s leader identity development: building a team for the journey. In: TanSJDeFrank-ColeL (eds), Women’s Leadership Journeys: Stories, Research, and Novel Perspectives. Routledge, pp. 162–177.
97.
SinclairA (2010) Placing self: how might we place ourselves in leadership studies differently?Leadership6(4): 447–460.
98.
SinclairA (2011) Being Leaders: Identities and Identity Work in Leadership. The Sage handbook of leadership, pp. 508–517.
99.
SpillerCMaunganui WolfgrammRHenryE, et al. (2019) Paradigm warriors: advancing a radical ecosystems view of collective leadership from an indigenous Māori perspective. Human Relations73(4): 516–543.
100.
SveibyKESkuthorpeT (2006) Treading Lightly: The Hidden Wisdom of the World's Oldest People. Sydney: Allen and Unwin.
101.
SveningssonSAlvessonM (2003) Managing managerial identities: organizational fragmentation, discourse and identity struggle. Human Relations56(10): 1163–1193.
102.
TajfelHTurnerJC (1986) The social identity theory of inter group behavior. In: WorchelSAustinWG (eds), Psychology of Intergroup Relations. Chicago: Nelson, 3.
103.
TubinD (2017) Leadership identity construction practices: the case of successful Israeli school principals. Educational Management Administration and Leadership45(5): 790–805.
104.
Uhl-BienMOspinaSM (eds), (2012) Advancing Relational Leadership Research: A Dialogue Among Perspectives. Charlotte: Information Age Publishing.
105.
Uhl-BienM (2011) Relational Leadership Theory: Exploring the Social Processes of Leadership and Organizing, pp. 75–108. Leadership, Gender, and Organization.
106.
VareseS (2018) Los Fundamentos éticos de las Cosmologías Indígenas Amérique Latine Histoire et Mémoire. Les Cahiers ALHIM, 36.
107.
WilliamsC (2019) They crow as speakers, as leaders”: a case study of experiential leadership in the miss world eskimo-indian olympics pageant. American Indian Quarterly43(2): 204–235.
WorthenH (2015) Indigenous women’s political participation: gendered labor and collective rights paradigms in Mexico. Gender and Society29(6): 914–936.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
