Abstract
Manipulating nanowires with external magnetic fields has emerged as a powerful tool in various engineering applications, which prompts an urgent need to better understand the dynamics of nanowire rotation under different control conditions. In this article, the motion of ferromagnetic nickel (Ni) nanowires under a rotating magnetic field was investigated both theoretically and experimentally. The synchronous and asynchronous rotations were characterized in detail. Analytical models were developed for the major modes of motion by solving the governing equations of rotation. Particularly, a selection of theoretical formula for fluid viscous torque on nanowires of large aspect ratios was made based on the computational fluid dynamics simulation results. The comparisons of the theoretical prediction and the experimental data showed very good agreement. The effects of various system variables, such as the strength and rotating frequency of the magnetic field and the nanowire aspect ratio, were examined. Hence, the insights gained from this work can be applied to future exploration of magnetic manipulation of nanowires.
Keywords
Introduction
Manipulating rod-like nanoparticles, such as nanowires, with external magnetic fields has attracted extensive interests in a myriad of engineering applications in micro/nanofluidics and biomedical engineering.1–15 For instance, in a study of nanowire alignment in solidifying films where the fluid viscosity increased with time, it was found that a large portion of the nanowires cannot properly align due to the viscous force. Hence, by analyzing the relaxation time of a single nanowire under different viscosities, the total time required for the whole field to align can be extracted. 1 To measure the protein generation rate, proteins were adhered to the surface of nanowires. The nanowire’s geometry was modified by the protein coating and their rotation trajectories were changed. Thus, the average generation rate of protein can be determined from the measurement of the angle variety of single nanowire in different position. 3 In an application involving laser beam transmission, the beam transmission was accurately controlled with manipulating the movement of nanorods. 9 Other applications requiring specific nanowire motion include nanomotor, 12 drug delivery, 14 and nanosensors. 15 Therefore, a good understanding of the dynamics of nanowire motion is imperative to ensure the success and future advancement of these new technologies.
The study of magnetic rotation of small particles was initially conducted with a pair of bounded spherical particles or single ellipsoidal particle. Depending on the angular frequency of the magnetic field, either synchronous rotation, in which the lag angle between the magnetic field and the long axis of the ellipsoidal nanoparticle (or the centerline connecting the pair of spherical nanoparticles) remains constant, or asynchronous rotation, in which the lag angle exhibits periodic oscillation, can be observed.16,17 Analytical models have been successfully developed to account for the mechanisms of both modes of particle motion.18,19 However, new challenges arise when these models are extended to describe the magnetic rotation of nanowires, which are typically characterized by extremely large aspect ratios (defined as the ratio of nanowire length to its diameter). The anisotropic shape of the nanowires can no longer be approximated by ellipsoidal geometries, thereby rendering the existing theoretical models of the viscous torque inaccurate. 18 Some efforts have been taken to rectify this issue. For example, Edwards and Doi 20 treated the slim nanowire as a string of spheres in “shish-kebab” model and calculated the viscous torque as a summation of those experienced by the individual constituent spheres. Tirado and De La Torre 21 and Tirado et al. 22 followed a similar approach in considering the nanowire as a cluster of spheres, which refined the accuracy of solution. Keshoju et al. 6 modeled the nanowire as several segments of short cylinders and estimated the overall viscous torque as the accumulation of each of them. Despite the improvement by the new models, the applicability of these models is limited to a specific range of nanowire aspect ratios. Additionally, the available studies in the open literature focus on either theoretical analysis or experimental characterization of the nanowire motion in a magnetic field. Much essential information of the underlying rotation dynamics, especially that which is related to the experimental corroboration of theoretical models, is scattered or even missing. Therefore, it is the goals of this work to perform an in-depth analysis of the dynamics of magnetic field–driven nanowire rotation, to conduct comprehensive experimental measurements of the key parameters, and, eventually, to compare the theoretical predictions with the measured data.
In this article, the motion of ferromagnetic nickel (Ni) nanowires under a rotating magnetic field was investigated both theoretically and experimentally. The synchronous and asynchronous rotations were characterized in detail. Analytical models were developed for the major modes of motion by solving the governing equations of rotation. Particularly, a selection of fluid viscous torque was made according to computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations for nanowires of large aspect ratios. The comparisons of the theoretical prediction and the experimental data show very good agreement. The effects of various system variables, such as the strength and rotating frequency of the magnetic field and the nanowire aspect ratio, were examined. Hence, the insights gained from this work can be applied to future exploration of magnetic manipulation of nanowires.
Experimental apparatus and method
Ni nanowires were synthesized using electrochemical deposition in porous anodic aluminum oxide (AAO) templates.
23
The average nanowire radius
A pair of Helmholtz coils was mounted on a rotating disk driven by a brushed direct current (DC) motor to create the magnetic field with controlled angular frequency (as shown in Figure 1). The field strength can be varied from 0 to 20 Gs, and the rotating frequency of the field was between 1 and 3 Hz. Dynamics of nanowire rotation was visualized using a biological microscope (Eclipse Ti-U; Nikon). A 50× objective lens (M Plan APO; Mitutoyo) was used to achieve sufficient magnification and long working distance. A high-speed charge-coupled device (CCD) camera (X-MOTION; AOS Technology) was employed to record the real-time nanowire rotation with a frame rate of up to 1000 frames per second (fps) and a maximum resolution of 1280 × 600 pixels. Static images were extracted from the recorded videos and analyzed with an in-house MATLAB code to yield information of the location and phase angle of the nanowire at desired time instants.

Schematic of the experimental setup.
During each experiment, a stationary magnetic field was first established by actuating the Helmholtz coils. The initially randomly oriented nanowires quickly aligned along the direction of the field. Then, the DC motor was turned on to rotate the magnetic field at a specified frequency, and the high-speed camera started simultaneously to record the nanowire rotation. It was found that a frame rate of 63 fps and a resolution of 800 × 600 pixels were sufficient to yield an optimal image quality for subsequent analysis. In a series of experiments, the rotating frequency was varied and both synchronous and asynchronous motions of the single nanowire with respect to the magnetic field were observed.
Theoretical analysis
Magnetically driven rotation of a single nanowire is shown schematically in Figure 2. The external magnetic field with frequency

Schematic of a magnetically driven nanowire.
The nanowire rotation is governed by the magnetic torque, the fluid viscous torque, and the Brownian motion. The magnetic torque provides the driving force for the nanowire motion, whereas the viscous torque acts as the resisting mechanism. Due to the extreme small size of nanowire, the Brownian motion may have some effect on the rotation dynamics. All these factors will be discussed in this section.
Magnetic torque
The magnetic torque
where
Fluid viscous torque
Due to its nanoscale size, the
where

Comparison of fluid viscous torque models.
and, therefore, it was selected in this work to estimate the fluid viscous torque in equation (2).
Brownian motion
Nanowires suspended in a liquid are subject to the effects of Brownian motion. In particular, the rotational Brownian motion may compete with the magnetic and viscous torques to disorient the nanowire. For a given time interval Δ
where
Governing equation
The equation of nanowire motion is obtained from Newton’s second law for rotation
where the moment of inertia is
A scaling analysis of equation (6) reveals that for nickel nanowires suspended in EG,
and
Note that essentially, equation (7) is equivalent to
Solutions
The solution to equation (7) can be obtained for different system conditions.
When a stationary magnetic field (
Depending on the initial lag angle
If
If
Otherwise
where
When the angular frequency of the magnetic field satisfies
In this case, the lag angle remains constant, that is, the motion is phase locked, and the nanowire rotates synchronously with the magnetic field. In particular, if
3. When the frequency of the magnetic field surpasses the threshold value,
where
Results and discussion
Criterion for nanowire rotation trajectory
As shown in the previous section, the parameter
where the left-hand side (LHS) of the equation is associated with the magnetic driving torque, and the right-hand side (RHS) represents the viscous resistance torque. As the lag angle
Physically, when

Theoretical prediction of synchronous versus asynchronous rotation of nanowire.
Nanowire alignment when a stationary field is rotated abruptly
When a stationary magnetic field is rotated abruptly by a certain angle, the nanowire will re-orient and align itself with the field. The relaxation of the lag angle can be described by equation (10) as a function of time, which represents by line in the plot. In Figure 5, the theoretical predictions are compared to the experimental data measured under various test conditions, where a good agreement is observed.

Lag angle versus
Synchronous rotation
Figure 6(a) shows the instantaneous orientations of a nanowire in a magnetic field (

Synchronous rotation of nanowire: (a) images of synchronous rotation of nanowire; (b) angle of nanowire, magnetic, and lag angle; and (c) angular velocity of nanowire, magnetic, and lag angle.
The startup and steady-state processes can be better discerned from Figure 6(c) where the respective angular frequencies are plotted as a function of time. It is easy to note that the measured steady-state lag angle (

Asynchronous rotation
When
Figure 8 shows the asynchronous rotation of a nanowire (

Nanowire asynchronous rotation in one period: (a) images of asynchronous rotation of nanowire; (b) angle of nanowire, magnetic, and lag angle; and (c) angular velocity of nanowire, magnetic, and lag angle.
The polar representation of the rotation dynamics of a nanowire (

Nanowire asynchronous rotation under different
From the foregoing discussion, the forward motion of the nanowire starts at
where

Time and angle of nanowire of forward and backward rotation in one period: (a) time of forward and backward regimes and (b) angle of forward and backward regimes.
With the angle relation
where
Conclusion
The dynamics of ferromagnetic nickel (Ni) nanowires rotating in a driving magnetic field was investigated. The major findings are summarized as follows.
The dynamics of nanowire rotation is governed primarily by the magnetic torque and the fluid viscous torque, whereas the Brownian motion and inertia have negligible impact.
There exists a critical rotation speed for the magnetic field,
Analytical models were developed to describe the major modes of nanowire motion. The comparisons of the theoretical prediction and the experimental data show very good agreement.
Footnotes
Acknowledgements
We thank Dr Li Sun at the University of Houston for supplying the nanowire samples.
Academic Editor: Hyung Hee Cho
Declaration of conflicting interests
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest.
Funding
This work was supported by National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 51376022).
