As the majority of breast cancers present as small non-palpable lesions, alternatives for surgical lumpectomy come into consideration. Breast tumor ablation without surgical excision may be a less morbid procedure without sacrificing cancer control. Cryosurgery is one of several ablative options for the treatment of small unifocal breast cancer. The potential advantages include avoidance of a surgical procedure, less overall discomfort, improved cosmesis, quicker recovery and the prospect of overall cost benefits. Clinical experience in 29 patients is reviewed demonstrating effectiveness in properly chosen patients. A comparison of ablation methods is discussed. Finally, future research of the role of cryosurgery in the management of breast cancer is described.
ArnottJ.Practical Illustrations of the Remedial Efficacy of a Very Low or Anesthetic Temperature. Lancet2, 257–259 (1850).
2.
RandR. W.RandR. P.EggerdingF.DenBestenL.KingW.Cryolumpectomy for Carcinoma of the Breast. Surg. Gynecol. Obstet.165, 392–396 (1987).
3.
GageA. A.BaustJ.Mechanisms of Tissue Injury in Cryosurgery. Cryobiology37, 171–186 (1990).
4.
JemalA.MurrayT.SamuelsA.GhafoorA.WardE.ThunM. J.Cancer Statistics, 2003. CA. Cancer. J. Clin.53, 5–26 (2003).
5.
U. S. Preventive Services Task Force. Screening for Breast Cancer: Recommendations and Rationale. Ann. Intern. Med.137, 344–346 (2002).
6.
DuffyS. W.TabarL.ChenH. H.HolmqvistM.YenM. F.AbdsalahS.EpsteinB.FrodisE.LjungbergE.Hedborg-MelanderC.SundbomA.TholinM.WiegeM.AkerlundA.WuH. M.TungT. S.ChiuY. H.ChiuC. P.HuangC. C.SmithR. A.RosenM.StenbeckM.HolmbergL.The Impact of Organized Mammography Service Screening on Breast Carcinoma Mortality in Seven Swedish Counties. Cancer95, 458–469 (2002).
7.
TabarL.DeanP. B.KaufmanC. S.DuffyS. W.ChenH. H.A New Era in the Diagnosis of Breast Cancer. Surg. Oncol. Clin. N. Am.9, 233–277 (2000).
8.
CadyB.New Era in Breast Cancer. Impact of Screening on Disease Presentation. Surg. Oncol. Clin. N. Am.6, 195–202 (1997).
9.
CadyB.Breast Cancer in the Third Millennium. Breast J.6, 280–287 (2000).
10.
StarenE. D.SabelM. S.GianakakisL. M.WienerG. A.HartV. M.GorskiM.DowlatshahiK.CorningB. F.HaklinM. F.KoukoulisG.Cryosurgery of Breast Cancer. Arch. Surg.132, 28–33 (1997).
11.
RewcastleJ. C.HahnL. J.SalikenJ. C.McKinnonJ. G.Use of a Moratorium to Achieve Consistent Liquid Nitrogen Cryoprobe Performance. J. Surg. Oncol.66, 110–113 (1997).
12.
RewcastleJ. C.SandisonG. A.SalikenJ. C.DonnellyB. J.McKinnonJ. G.Considerations During Clinical Operation of Two Commercially Available Cryomachines. J. Surg. Oncol.71, 106–111 (1999).
SmithD. J.FahssiW. M.SwanlundD. J.BischofJ. C.A Parametric Study of Freezing Injury in AT-1 Rat Prostate Tumor Cells. Cryobiology39, 13–28 (1999).
15.
BischofJ. C.SmithD.PazhayannurP. V.ManivelC.HulbertJ.RobertsK. P.Cryosurgery of Dunning AT-1 Rat Prostate Tumor: Thermal, Biophysical, and Viability Response at the Cellular and Tissue Level. Cryobiology34, 42–69 (1997).
16.
RewcastleJ. C.MuldrewK.SandisonG. A.In Vitro Injury Mapping for Single Cryoprobe Cryosurgery. Cryobiology43, 322 (2001).
17.
BaustJ. M.VanB.BaustJ. G.Cell Viability Improves Following Inhibition of Cryopreservation-induced Apoptosis. In Vitro Cell Dev. Biol. Anim.36, 262–270 (2000).
18.
RewcastleJ. C.SandisonG. A.HahnL. J.SalikenJ. C.McKinnonJ. G.DonnellyB. J.A Model for the Time-dependent Thermal Distribution Within an Iceball Surrounding a Cryoprobe. Phys. Med. Biol.43, 3519–3534 (1998).
19.
SabelM. D.KaufmanC. S.WhitworthP.ChangH.StocksL. H.SimmonsR.SchultzM.Cryoablation of Early-Stage Breast Cancer: Work-In-Progress Report of a Multi-Institutional Trial. Ann. Surg. Oncol. In Press (2004).
20.
GreenC. R.de RosayroA. M.TaitA. R.The Role of Cryoanalgesia for Chronic Thoracic Pain: Results of a Long-term Follow up. J. Natl. Med. Assoc.94, 716–720 (2002).
21.
RobinsonS. R.PurdieG. L.Reducing Post-tonsillectomy Pain with Cryoanalgesia: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Laryngoscope110, 1128–1131 (2000).
22.
KaufmanC. S.BachmanB.LittrupP. J.WhiteM.CarolinK. A.Freman-GibbL.FrancescattiD.StocksL. H.SmithJ. S.HenryC. A.BaileyL.HarnessJ. K.SimmonsR.Office-based Ultrasound-guided Cryoablation of Breast Fibroadenomas. Am. J. Surg.184, 394–400 (2002).
23.
FisherB.AndersonS.BryantJ.MargoleseR. G.DeutschM.FisherE. R.JeongJ. H.WolmarkN.Twenty-year Follow-up of a Randomized Trial Comparing Total Mastectomy, Lumpectomy, and Lumpectomy Plus Irradiation for the Treatment of Invasive Breast Cancer. N. Engl. J. Med.347, 1233–1241 (2002).
24.
VeronesiU.CascinelliN.MarianiL.GrecoM.SaccozziR.LuiniA.AguilarM.MarubiniE.Twenty-year Follow-up of a Randomized Study Comparing Breast-conserving Surgery with Radical Mastectomy for Early Breast Cancer. N. Engl. J. Med.347, 1227–1232 (2002).
25.
FinelliA.RewcastleJ. C.JewettM. A.Cryotherapy and Radiofrequency Ablation: Pathophysiologic Basis and Laboratory Studies. Curr. Opin. Urol.13, 187–191 (2003).
26.
MannsF.MilneP.ParelJ. M.Ultraviolet Corneal Photoablation. J. Refract. Surg.18, S610-S614 (2002).
27.
GardnerR. A.VargasH. I.BlockJ. B.Focused Microwave Phased Array (FMPA). Thermotherapy for Primary Breast Cancer. Ann. Surg. Oncol. 9, 326–332 (2002).
28.
HuberP. E.JenneJ. W.RastertR.SimiantonakisI.SinnH. P.StritmatterH. J.von FournierD.WannenmacherM. F.DebusJ.A New Noninvasive Approach in Breast Cancer Therapy using Magnetic Resonance Imaging-guided Focused Ultrasound Surgery. Cancer Research61, 8441–8447 (2001).
29.
SimmonsR. M.Ablative Techniques in the Treatment of Benign and Malignant Breast Disease. J. Am. Coll. Surg.197, 334–338 (2003).
30.
Hall-CraggsM. A.VaidyaJ. S.Minimally Invasive Therapy for the Treatment of Breast Tumours. Eur. J. Radiol.42, 52–57 (2002).
31.
IzzoF.ThomasR.DelrioP.RinaldoM.ValloneP.DeChiaraA.BottiG.D'AiutoG.CortinoP.CurleyS. A.Radiofrequency Ablation in Patients with Primary Breast Carcinoma: A Pilot Study in 26 Patients. Cancer92, 2036–2044 (2001).
32.
BohmT.HilgerI.MullerW.ReichenbachJ. R.FleckM.KaiserW. A.Saline-enhanced Radiofrequency Ablation of Breast Tissue: An In Vitro Feasibility Study. Invest. Radiol.35, 149–157 (2000).
33.
BurakW. E.JrAgneseD. M.PovoskiS. P.YanssensT. L.BloomK. J.WakelyP. E.SpigosD. G.Radiofrequency Ablation of Invasive Breast Carcinoma Followed by Delayed Surgical Excision. Cancer98, 1369–1376 (2003).
34.
HayashiA. H.SilverS. F.van der WesthuizenN. G.DonaldJ. C.ParkerC.FraserS.RossA. C.OlivotoI. A.Treatment of Invasive Breast Carcinoma with Ultrasound-guided Radiofrequency Ablation. Am. J. Surg.185, 429–435 (2003).
35.
SingletaryS. E.Feasibility of Radiofrequency Ablation for Primary Breast Cancer. Breast Cancer10, 4–9 (2003).
36.
BoehmT.MalichA.ReichenbachJ. R.FleckM.KaiserW. A.Percutaneous Radiofrequency (RF). Thermal Ablation of Rabbit Tumors Embedded in Fat: A Model for RF Ablation of Breast Tumors. Invest. Radiol. v, 480–486 (2001).
37.
NoguchiM.Minimally Invasive Surgery for Small Breast Cancer. J. Surg. Oncol.84, 94–101 (2003).
38.
DowlatshahiK.FrancescattiD. S.BloomK. J.Laser Therapy for Small Breast Cancers. Am. J. Surg.184, 359–363 (2002).
39.
KaufmanC. S.BachmanB.JacobsonL.KaufmanL. B.Cryoablation of Benign and Malignant Breast Tumors: Lessons Learned and Future Implications. Ann. Surg. Onc. 10 Supp, S56–S57 (2003).
40.
KaufmanC. S.Mammographic Appearance of Fibroadenoma Disappears After Cryoablation. Presented at RSNA 2002, Annual Meeting of the Radiologic Society of North America, Chicago, Illinois, December 4, 2002.
41.
TafraL.SmithS. J.WoodwardJ. E.FernandezK. L.SawyerK. T.GrenkoR. T.Pilot Trial of Cryoprobe-assisted Breast-conserving Surgery for Small Ultrasound-visible Cancers. Ann. Surg. Oncol.10, 1018–1024 (2003).
42.
ViciniF. A.KestinL.ChenP.BenitezP.GoldsteinN. S.MartinezA.Limited-field Radiation Therapy in the Management of Early-stage Breast Cancer. J. Nat. Ca. Inst.95, 1205–1211 (2003).
43.
KeischM.ViciniF.KuskeR. R.HebertM.WhiteJ.QuietC.ArthurD.ScrogginsT.StreeterO.Initial Clinical Experience with the Mammosite Breast Brachytherapy Applicator in Women with Early-stage Breast Cancer Treated with Breast-conserving Therapy. In. J. Rad. Onc.55, 289–293 (2003).
