The opinion-writing process is a vital yet understudied aspect of judicial decision making on state supreme courts. We argue that this process is influenced by the political context and particularly by institutional rules that serve to reactivate and reinforce divisions among justices, leading to less cooperation on the court. We test our theory with original data comprising all education cases decided from 1995 to 2005 in all 50 states and find evidence to support our theory. Specifically, we find that elections lead to fewer unanimous decisions and more separate written opinions, indicating that judicial elections may have a more pervasive effect on the daily work of these courts than previously thought.
BairdVanessa A.2001. “Building Institutional Legitimacy: The Role of Procedural Justice.” Political Research Quarterly54(2): 333–54.
2.
BaumLawrence. 2006. Judges and Their Audiences: A Perspective on Judicial Behavior. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
3.
BeneshSara C.2006. “Understanding Public Confidence in American Courts.” The Journal of Politics68(3): 697–707.
4.
BeneshSara C.MartinekWendy L.2002. “State Supreme Court Decision Making in Confession Cases.” Justice System Journal23(1): 109–33.
5.
BerryWilliam D.RingquistEvan J.FordingRichard C.HansonRussell L.1998. “Measuring Citizen and Government Ideology in the American States.” American Journal of Political Science42(1): 327–48.
6.
BonneauChris W.2005. “What Price Justice(s)? Understanding Campaign Spending in State Supreme Court Elections.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly5(2): 107–25.
7.
BonneauChris W.2007. “The Effects of Campaign Spending in State Supreme Court Elections.” Political Research Quarterly60(3): 489–99.
8.
BonneauChris W.HallMelinda Gann. 2009. In Defense of Judicial Elections. 1st ed. New York: Routledge.
9.
BracePaulBoyeaBrent D.2008. “State Public Opinion, the Death Penalty, and the Practice of Electing Judges.” American Journal of Political Science52(2): 360–72.
10.
BracePaulHallMelinda Gann. 1990. “Neo-institutionalism and Dissent in State Supreme Courts.” The Journal of Politics52(1): 54–70.
11.
BracePaulHallMelinda Gann. 1993. “Integrated Models of Judicial Dissent.” The Journal of Politics55(4): 914–35.
12.
BracePaulLangerLauraHallMelinda Gann. 2000. “Measuring the Preferences of State Supreme Court Judges.” The Journal of Politics62(2): 387–413.
13.
CaldaroneRichard P.Canes-WroneBrandiceClarkTom S.2009. “Partisan Labels and Democratic Accountability: An Analysis of State Supreme Court Abortion Decisions.” The Journal of Politics71(2): 560–73.
14.
CaldeiraGregory A.GibsonJames L.1992. “The Etiology of Public Support for the Supreme Court.” American Journal of Political Science36(3): 635–64.
15.
CaldeiraGregory A.WrightJohn R.1988. “Organized Interests and Agenda Setting in the U.S. Supreme Court.” The American Political Science Review82(4): 1109–27.
16.
CaldeiraGregory A.ZornChristopher J. W.1998. “Of Time and Consensual Norms in the Supreme Court.” American Journal of Political Science42(3): 874–902.
17.
Canes-WroneBrandiceClarkTom S.ParkJee-Kwang. 2012. “Judicial Independence and Retention Elections.” Journal of Law, Economics, & Organization28(2): 211–34.
18.
CannDamon M.WilhelmTeena. 2011. “Case Visibility and the Electoral Connection in State Supreme Courts.” American Politics Research39(3): 557–81.
19.
CanonBradley C.JarosDean. 1970. “External Variables, Institutional Structure & Dissent on State Supreme Courts.” Polity3(2): 175–200.
20.
ChristensenRobert K.SzmerJohnStritchJustin M.2012. “Race and Gender Bias in Three Administrative Contexts: Impact on Work Assignments in State Supreme Courts.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory22(4): 625–48.
21.
CorleyPamela C.2011. Concurring Opinion Writing on the U.S. Supreme Court. Albany: State University of New York Press.
22.
CrossFrank B.TillerEmerson H.1998. “Judicial Partisanship and Obedience to Legal Doctrine: Whistleblowing on the Federal Courts of Appeals.” The Yale Law Journal107(7): 2155–76.
23.
EpsteinLeeSegalJeffrey A.2000. “Measuring Issue Salience.” American Journal of Political Science44(1): 66–83.
24.
EpsteinLeeSegalJeffrey A.SpaethHarold J.2001. “The Norm of Consensus on the U.S. Supreme Court.” American Journal of Political Science45(2): 362–77.
25.
FlangoCarol R.RottmanDavid B.1998. Appellate Court Procedures. Williamsburg, VA: National Center for State Courts.
26.
FrederickBrianStrebMatthew J.2008. “Paying the Price for a Seat on the Bench: Campaign Spending in Contested State Intermediate Appellate Court Elections.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly8(4): 410–29.
27.
GibsonJames L.2009. “‘New-Style’ Judicial Campaigns and the Legitimacy of State High Courts.” The Journal of Politics71(4): 1285–304.
28.
GibsonJames L.CaldeiraGregory A.2009. Citizens, Courts, and Confirmations: Positivity Theory and the Judgments of the American People. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
29.
GibsonJames L.GottfriedJeffrey A.Delli CarpiniMichael X.JamiesonKathleen Hall. 2011. “The Effects of Judicial Campaign Activity on the Legitimacy of Courts.” Political Research Quarterly64(3): 545–58.
30.
GlickHenry R.EmmertCraig F.1986. “Selection Systems and Judicial Characteristics: The Recruitment State Supreme Court Judges.” Judicature70:228–35.
31.
GlickHenry R.VinesKenneth N.1973. State Court Systems. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall.
32.
GordonSanford C.HuberGregory A.2007. “The Effect of Electoral Competitiveness on Incumbent Behavior.” Quarterly Journal of Political Science2(2): 107–38.
33.
HaireSusan B.LindquistStefanie A.SongerDonald R.2003. “Appellate Court Supervision in the Federal Judiciary: A Hierarchical Perspective.” Law & Society Review37(1): 143–68.
34.
HallMelinda Gann. 1987. “Constituent Influence in State Supreme Courts: Conceptual Notes and a Case Study.” The Journal of Politics49:1117–24.
35.
HallMelinda Gann. 1990. “Opinion Assignment Procedures and Conference Practices in State Supreme Courts.” Judicature73:209–14.
36.
HallMelinda Gann. 1992. “Electoral Politics and Strategic Voting in State Supreme Courts.” The Journal of Politics54(2): 427–46.
37.
HallMelinda Gann. 2007. “Voting in State Supreme Court Elections: Competition and Context As Democratic Incentives.” The Journal of Politics69(4): 1147–59.
38.
HallMelinda GannBonneauChris W.2006. “Does Quality Matter? Challengers in State Supreme Court Elections.” American Journal of Political Science50(1): 20–33.
39.
HallMelinda GannBracePaul. 1989. “Order in the Courts: A Neo-institutional Approach to Judicial Consensus.” The Western Political Quarterly42(3): 391–407.
40.
HallMelinda GannBracePaul. 1992. “Toward an Integrated Model of Judicial Voting Behavior.” American Politics Research20(2): 147–68.
41.
HardenJeffrey J.2011. “A Bootstrap Method for Conducting Statistical Inference with Clustered Data.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly11(2): 223–46.
42.
HaynieStacia L.1992. “Leadership and Consensus on the U.S. Supreme Court.” The Journal of Politics54(4): 1158–69.
43.
HettingerVirginia A.LindquistStefanie A.MartinekWendy L.2004. “Comparing Attitudinal and Strategic Accounts of Dissenting Behavior on the U.S. Courts of Appeals.” American Journal of Political Science48(1): 123–37.
44.
HettingerVirginia A.LindquistStefanie A.MartinekWendy L.2006. Judging on a Collegial Court: Influences on Federal Appellate Decision Making. Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press.
45.
HibbingJohn R.Theiss-MorseElizabeth. 2002. Stealth Democracy: Americans’ Beliefs about How Government Should Work. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
46.
HuberGregory A.GordonSanford C.2004. “Accountability and Coercion: Is Justice Blind When It Runs for Office?” American Journal of Political Science48(2): 247–63.
47.
JarosDeanCanonBradley C.1971. “Dissent on State Supreme Courts: The Differential Significance of Characteristics of Judges.” Midwest Journal of Political Science15(2): 322–46.
48.
KastellecJonathan P.2007. “Panel Composition and Judicial Compliance on the US Courts of Appeals.” Journal of Law, Economics, & Organization23(2): 421–41.
49.
KastellecJonathan P.2011. “Hierarchical and Collegial Politics on the U.S. Courts of Appeals.” The Journal of Politics73(2): 345–61.
50.
KleinDavid E.2002. Making Law in the United States Courts of Appeals. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
51.
LangerLaura. 2002. Judicial Review in State Supreme Courts: A Comparative Study. Albany: State University of New York Press.
52.
LangerLaura. 2003. “Strategic Considerations and Judicial Review: The Case of Workers’ Compensation Laws in the American States.” Public Choice116(1): 55–78.
53.
LaxJeffrey R.CameronCharles M.2007. “Bargaining and Opinion Assignment on the US Supreme Court.” Journal of Law, Economics, & Organization23(2): 276–302.
54.
MaltzmanForrestSpriggsJames F.WahlbeckPaul J.2000. Crafting Law on the Supreme Court: The Collegial Game. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
55.
MaltzmanForrestWahlbeckPaul J.1996. “Inside the U.S. Supreme Court: The Reliability of the Justices’ Conference Records.” The Journal of Politics58(2): 528–39.
56.
RohdeDavid W.1972. “Policy Goals, Strategic Choice, and Majority Opinion Assignments in the U.S. Supreme Court.” Midwest Journal of Political Science16(4): 652–82.
57.
SampleJamesSkaggsAdamBlitzerJonathanCaseyLinda. 2010. The New Politics of Judicial Elections, 2000–2009: Decade of Change. Washington, DC: Justice at Stake Campaign.
58.
SegalJeffrey A.SpaethHarold J.2002. The Supreme Court and the Attitudinal Model Revisited. New York: Cambridge University Press.
59.
SheldonCharles H.MauleLinda S.1997. Choosing Justice: The Recruitment of State and Federal Judges. Pullman: Washington State University Press.
60.
SickelsRobert J.1965. “The Illusion of Judicial Consensus: Zoning Decisions in the Maryland Court of Appeals.” The American Political Science Review59(1): 100–104.
61.
SkaggsAdamMaria da SilvaHallCharles. 2011. The New Politics of Judicial Elections: 2009–10. Washington, DC: Justice at Stake Campaign.
62.
SlotnickElliot E.1977. “Who Speaks for the Court—The View from the States.” Emory Law Journal26:107.
63.
SongerDonald R.SegalJeffrey A.CameronCharles M.1994. “The Hierarchy of Justice: Testing a Principal-Agent Model of Supreme Court-Circuit Court Interactions.” American Journal of Political Science38(3): 673–96.
64.
SpriggsJames F.1997. “Explaining Federal Bureaucratic Compliance with Supreme Court Opinions.” Political Research Quarterly50(3): 567–93.
65.
SquirePeverill. 2008. “Measuring the Professionalization of U.S. State Courts of Last Resort.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly8(3): 223–38.
66.
StrebMatthew J.FrederickBrianLaFranceCasey. 2009. “Voter Rolloff in a Low-Information Context: Evidence from Intermediate Appellate Court Elections.” American Politics Research37(4): 644–69.
67.
ViningRichard L.WilhelmTeena. 2011. “Measuring Case Salience in State Courts of Last Resort.” Political Research Quarterly64(3): 559–72.
68.
ViningRichard L.WilhelmTeenaHiersSara E.MarcinPhil. 2010. “Patterns of Newspaper Reporting on State Supreme Courts.” Justice System Journal31:273–89.
69.
WilhelmTeena. 2007. “The Policymaking Role of State Supreme Courts in Education Policy.” Legislative Studies Quarterly32(2): 309–33.
