In the DC Comics Universe, Harley Quinn and the Joker have been an iconic and problematic canonical couple, represented as everything from enviable “mad” lovers to abusive relationship cautionary tale. The couple made cinematic headlines in 2016 with the release of Suicide Squad. In this case study of the “mad love” canon/fanon ship (as embodied in recent works of fanfiction, shipper manifestos posted and shared through social media, and Tumblr discourse), I examine the progressive rhetoric and feminist elevation of Harley Quinn as a shield for the underlying toxicity of the Joker. Fandom’s discourse of “problematic faves” is important as it provides space for fans to love a text even while admitting its representational problems; however, in the case of Harley and the Joker, this discourse risks becoming an excuse for not subverting the toxic tropes of the idolized, abusive, yet still lovable, villain and his obsessive fangirl following.
Anonymous. 2016. “I Want a Relationship Just Like the Joker and Harley Quinn Neane Who Id Bend Over Wards No Hat I Want as to Them Wh I Mis Ir E Harboring Feeling for Ressed Up in Bat Pajamas Can’t You Just FEEL the Love?” ME.ME, August25. https://me.me/i/i-want-a-relationship-just-like-the-joker-and-harley-1806723.
BoothPaul. 2011. “Saw Fandom and the Transgression of Fan Excess.” In Transgression 2.0: Media, Culture, and the Politics of a Digital Age, edited by GournelosTedGunkelDavid J. 69–83. London: A&C Black.
DiniPaulTimmBruce. 2015. Batman Adventures: Mad Love Deluxe Edition. Burbank, CA: DC Comics.
12.
FerredayDebra. 2015. “Game of Thrones, Rape Culture and Feminist Fandom.” Australian Feminist Studies30 (83): 21–36.
13.
FieslerCaseyMorrisonShannonBruckmanAmy S.2016. “An archive of their own: a case study of feminist HCI and values in design.” Proceedings of the 2016 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (pp. 2574–2585). ACM.
GoldnerVirginiaPennPeggySheinbergMarciaWalkerGillian. 1990. “Love and Violence: Gender Paradoxes in Volatile Attachments.” Family Process29 (4): 343–64. doi:10.1111/j.1545-5300.1990.00343.x.
16.
GoodmanLesley. 2015. “Disappointing Fans: Fandom, Fictional Theory, and the Death of the Author.” The Journal of Popular Culture48 (4): 662–76. doi:10.1111/jpcu.12223.
TankelJonathan DavidMurphyKeith. 1998. “Collecting Comic Books: A Study of the Fan and Curatorial Consumption.” In Theorizing Fandom: Fans, Subculture and Identity, edited by AlexanderAlisonHarrisCheryl, 55–69. Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press.
WarnerKristen J.2018. “JunexNick: The Quietest Ship in the Handmaid Fandom.” Communication, Culture and Critique11 (1): 198–200. doi:10.1093/ccc/tcx015.
