Academic undermatching—students enrolling in colleges that are less academically selective than those for which they qualify—is a barrier hindering college degree attainment. Given the many reasons students undermatch, this phenomenon is likely to continue; yet, we know little about the characteristics that may be related to degree attainment for this population of students. Utilizing the ELS: 2002 national dataset, we developed an operationalization of undermatch and then applied this operationalization to the BPS: 04/09 national dataset (N = 11,260). Using logistic regression methods, we identified institutional and student characteristics that are associated with degree attainment for undermatched students. Starting at a 4-year institution, completing at least precalculus, having at least one parent with a college education, being female, and being socially and academically integrated into the institution were positively associated with degree attainment. Our results emphasize the critical influence of nonacademic factors on degree attainment for undermatched students.
ACEAntonioA. L. (2004).
The influence of friendship groups on intellectual self-confidence and educational aspirations in college. The Journal of Higher Education,
75(4), 446–471.
4.
AstinA. (1984).
Student involvement: A developmental theory of higher education. Journal of College Student Personnel,
25(4), 297–308.
5.
AstinA. W. (1993). What matters in college? Four critical years revisited.
San Francisco, CA:
Jossey-Bass.
6.
AstinA. W.OsegueraL. (2012). Pre-college and institutional influences on degree attainment. In SeidmanA. (Ed.), College student retention (2nd ed., pp. 119–146).
New York, NY:
Rowman & Littlefield.
7.
Barron’s Educational Series. (2009). Barron’s profiles of American colleges of 2009.
Hauppauge, NY:
Barron’s Educational Series.
8.
BastedoM. M.FlasterA. (2014).
Conceptual and methodological problems in research on college undermatch. Educational Researcher,
43(2), 93–99.
9.
BastedoM. N.JaquetteO. (2011).
Running in place: Low-income students and the dynamics of higher education stratification. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis,
33(3), 318–339.
10.
BelascoA. S.TrivetteM. J. (2015a).
Aiming low: Estimating the scope and predictors of postsecondary undermatch. The Journal of Higher Education,
86(2), 233–263.
11.
BelascoA. S.TrivetteM. J. (2015b, November). An empirical analysis on the outcomes of postsecondary undermatch. Paper presented at the Annual Conference of the Association for the Study of Higher Education. Denver, CO.
12.
BergerJ. B. (2001–2002).
Understanding the organizational nature of student persistence: Empirically-based recommendations for practice. Journal of College Student Retention, Research, Theory, and Practice,
3(1), 3–21.
13.
BowenW. G.ChingosM. M.McPhersonM. S. (2009). Crossing the finish line: Completing college at America's public universities.
Princeton, NJ:
Princeton University Press.
14.
BraxtonJ. M.DoyleW. R.HartleyH. V.IIIHirschyA. S.JonesW. A.McLendonM. K. (2014). Rethinking college student retention.
San Francisco, CA:
Jossey-Bass.
15.
CabreraA. F.LaNasaS. M. (2000).
Understanding the college choice process. New Directions for Institutional Research,
107, 5–22.
16.
CejdaB. D. (1997).
An examination of transfer shock in academic disciplines. Community College Journal of Research and Practice,
21(3), 279–288.
17.
ChenR.St. JohnE. P. (2011).
State financial policies and college student persistence: A national study. Journal of Higher Education,
82(5), 629–660.
18.
ChenX.CarrollC. D. (2005). First-generation students in postsecondary education: A look at their college transcripts. Postsecondary education descriptive analysis report (NCES 2005-171), National Center for Education Statistics. Retrieved from https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED485756.pdf
19.
DannenbergM.VoightM. (2013). Doing away with debt: Using existing resources to ensure college affordability for low and middle-income families. Education Trust. Retrieved fromhttp://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED543214.pdf
20.
DesJardinsS. L.KimD.RzoncaC. S. (2002–2003).
A nested analysis of factors affecting bacherlor’s degree completion. Journal of College Student Research: Research, Theory, and Practice,
4(4), 407–435.
21.
DuckworthA. L.YeagerD. S. (2015).
Measurement matters: Assessing personal qualities other than cognitive ability for educational purposes. Educational Researcher,
44(4), 237–251. doi:10.3102/0013189X15584327.
22.
DyceC. M.AlboldC.LongD. (2013).
Moving from college aspiration to attainment: Learning from one college access program. The High School Journal,
96(2), 152–165.
23.
EaganK.StolzenbergE. B.BatesA. K.AragonM. C.Ramierz SuchardM.Rois-AguilarC. (2016). The American freshman: National norms fall 2015.
Los Angeles, CA:
Higher Education Research Institute.
24.
EhrenbergR.ZhangL.LevinJ. (2006).
Crafting a class: The trade-off between merit scholarships and enrolling lower-income students. The Review of Higher Education,
29(2), 195–211.
25.
EppleD.RomanoR.SiegH. (2006).
Admission, tuition, and financial aid policies in the market for higher education. Econometrica,
74(4), 885–928.
FosnachtK. (2014). Selectivity and the college experience: How undermatching shapes the college experience among high-achieving students. Paper presented at the American Educational Research Association, Philadelphia, PA.
28.
Gansemer-Topf, A.M., Downey, J., & Genschel, U. (2017). Definitions matter: Investigating and comparing different operationalizations of academic undermatching. Research and Practice in Assessment. 12, 28–40.
29.
Harper, S. R. (Ed.). (2008). Creating inclusive campus environments for cross-cultural learning and engagement. Washington, DC: NASPA.
30.
HatchD. K. (2012).
Unpacking the black box of student engagement: The need for programmatic investigation of higher impact practices. Community College Journal of Research and Practice,
36(11), 903–915.
31.
HeilS.ReiselL.AttewellP. (2014).
College selectivity and degree completion. American Educational Research Journal,
51(5), 913–935.
32.
HillmanN. W. (2012).
Tuition discounting for revenue management. Research in Higher Education,
53(3), 263–281.
33.
HosslerD.SchmittJ.VesperN. (2002). Going to college: How social, economic, and educational factors influence the decision students make.
Baltimore, MD:
Johns Hopkins.
34.
HowellJ. S.PenderM.KumarA. (2016). Academic match and fit. In KellyA. P.HowellJ. S.Sattin-BajajC. (Eds.), Matching students to opportunity: Expanding college choice, access, and quality (pp. 33–52).
Cambridge, MA:
Harvard Education Press.
35.
HoxbyC. M.AveryC. (2012). The missing “one-offs”: The hidden supply of high-achieving, low income students (Working paper No. w18586). National Bureau of Economic Research. Retrieved from http://www.nber.org/papers/w18586.pdf
36.
HurwitzM. (2012).
The impact of institutional grant aid on college choice. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis,
34(3), 344–363.
JohnsonD. R.SoldnerM.LeonardJ. B.AlvarezP.InkelasK. K.Rowan-KenyonH. T.LongerbeamS. D. (2007).
Examining sense of belonging among first-year undergraduates from different racial/ethnic groups. Journal of College Student Development,
48(5), 525–542.
KellyA. P.HowellJ. S.Sattin-BajajC. (2016). Introduction. In KellyA. P.HowellJ. S.Sattin-BajajC. (Eds.), Matching students to opportunity: Expanding college choice, access, and quality (pp. 1–14).
Cambridge, MA:
Harvard Education Press.
41.
KuhG. D.KinzieJ.SchuhJ. H.WhittE. J. (2011). Student success in college: Creating conditions that matter.
San Francisco, CA:
Jossey-Bass.
42.
LandryC. C. (2002–2003).
Retention of women and people of color: Unique challenges and institutional responses. Journal of College Student Retention: Research, Theory & Practice,
4(1), 1–14.
43.
LattucaL. R.KnightD.SeifertT. A.ReasonR. D.LiuQ. (2017).
Examining the impact of interdisciplinary programs on student learning. Innovative Higher Education,
42, 337–353. doi:10.1007/s10755-017-9393-z
44.
MattsonC. E. (2007).
Beyond admission: Understanding pre-college variables and the success of at-risk students. Journal of College Admission,
196, 8–13.
45.
MayhewM. J.RoceknbachA. N.BowmanN.SeifertT.WolniakG. (2016). How college affects students (
Vol.3).
San Francisco, CA:
Jossey-Bass.
46.
MertlerC. A.VanattaR. A. (2010). Advanced and multivariate statistical methods (4th ed.).
Glendale, CA:
Pyrczak.
47.
ParkE. (2014).
Low-income students' access to selective higher education (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Indiana University, Bloomington, IN.
48.
PascarellaE. T. (1985). College environmental influences on learning and cognitive development: A critical review and synthesis. In SmartJ. (Ed.), Higher education: Handbook of theory and research (
Vol.I).
New York, NY:
Agathon.
49.
PascarellaE. T.PiersonC. T.WolniakG. C.TerenziniP. T. (2004).
First-generation college students: Additional evidence on college experiences and outcomes. Journal of Higher Education,
75(3), 249–284.
50.
PascarellaE. T.TerenziniP. T. (2005). How college affects students (Vol. 2, K. A. Feldman, Ed.). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
51.
Paulsen, M. B., & St. John, E. P. (2002). Social class and college costs: Examining the financial nexus between college choice and persistence. The Journal of Higher Education, 73(2), 189–236.
52.
PernaL. W. (1998).
The contribution of financial aid to undergraduate persistence. Journal of Student Financial Aid,
28(3), 25–40.
53.
PernaL. W. (2010).
Toward a more complete understanding of the role of financial aid in promoting college enrollment: The importance of context. Higher Education: Handbook of Theory and Research,
25, 129–179.
54.
PernaL. W.TitusM. A. (2005).
The relationship between parental involvement as social capital and college enrollment: An examination of racial/ethnic group differences. Journal of Higher Education,
76(5), 485–518.
55.
PrósperoM.Vohra-GuptaS. (2007).
First generation college students: Motivation, integration, and academic achievement. Community College Journal of Research and Practice,
31(12), 963–975.
56.
QuayeS. J.HarperS. R. (2014). Student engagement in higher education: Theoretical perspectives and practical approaches for diverse populations.
New York, NY:
Routledge.
57.
RikoonS. H.LiebtagT.Olivera-AguilarM.SteinbergJ.RobbinsS. B. (2015).
Anticipating college enrollment: Adapting SuccessNavigator® for high school students. ETS Research Report Series,
2, 1–26. doi:10.1002/ets2.12084
RoderickM.CocaV.NagaokaJ. (2011).
Potholes on the road to college high school effects in shaping urban students’ participation in college application, four-year college enrollment, and college match. Sociology of Education,
84(3), 178–211.
60.
RodriguezA. (2013). Unpacking the black box: Estimating the high school-level effects of undermatching among under-represented students (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (Paper AAI3594848).
61.
RodriguezA. (2015).
Tradeoffs and limitations: Understanding the estimation of college undermatch. Research in Higher Education,
56(6), 566–594.
62.
RodriguezA.MartellC. (2016). Average students and college match. In KellyA. P.HowellJ. S.Sattin-BajajC. (Eds.), Matching students to opportunity: Expanding college choice, access, and quality (pp. 53–78).
Cambridge, MA:
Harvard Education Press.
63.
Rowan-KenyonH. T.Savitz-RomerM.OttM. W.SwanA. K.LiuP. P. (2017). Finding conceptual coherence: Trends and alignment in the scholarship on noncognitive xkills and their role in college success and career readiness. In PaulsenM. B. (Ed.), Higher education: Handbook of theory and research (pp. 141–179).
New York, NY:
Springer.
64.
SchuhJ. H.Gansemer-TopfA. M. (2010, December). The role of student affairs in student learning assessment (NILOA Occasional Paper No.7). Urbana, IL: University of Illinois and Indiana University.
65.
SedlacekW. E. (2004). Beyond the big test: Noncognitive assessment in higher education.
San Francisco, CA:
Jossey-Bass.
66.
SmithA. A. (2017, November 1). Free community college picks up steam. Inside Higher Education. Retrieved from www.insidehighered.com
67.
SmithJ. I.PenderM.HowellJ. (2013).
The full extent of academic undermatch. Economics of Education Review,
32, 247–261.
68.
SoriaK. M.StebletonM. J. (2012).
First-generation students' academic engagement and retention. Teaching in Higher Education,
17(6), 673–685.
69.
SunJ.HagedornL. S. (2016).
Homesickness at college: Its impact on academic performance and retention. Journal of College Student Development,
57(8), 943–957.
70.
TerenziniP. T.ReasonR. D. (2005, November). Parsing the first year of college: Rethinking the effects of college on students. Paper presented at the Annual Conference of the Association for the Study of Higher Education, Philadelphia, PA.
71.
TintoV. (1993). Leaving college: Rethinking the causes and cures of student attrition (2nd ed.).
Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press.
72.
TitusM. A. (2004).
Examining the influence of institutional context on persistence at four-year colleges and universities: A multilevel approach. Research in Higher Education,
45(7), 673–699.
73.
US Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics. (2002). Education longitudinal study of 2002 (ELS: 2002). (Data file). Restricted data license.
74.
US Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics. (2011). 2004/09 Beginning postsecondary longitudinal study (BPS: 04/09) (Data file). Restrected data license.
75.
WardL.DavenportZ.GardnerJ.SiegelM. (2012). First-generation college students understanding and improving the experience from recruitment to commencement.
San Francisco, CA:
Jossey-Bass.
