Does an early childhood program have an influence on its participants that is
detectable 10 years later? The answer is yes. This research managed to
detect differences between children of Ethiopian origin who had immigrated to
Israel. It also managed to generalize and conceptualize these differences and
provide an explanation of them: The program began a process of individuation that
reinforced itself over the years. The research process succeeded in doing so through
the use of a combination of research logic (abduction) and a research method
(projective techniques); a combination especially effective where the researcher had
no advance hypotheses and no well-defined research variables.
Anteby, L.
(1995)
‘Print, magic and videotapes: New patterns of orality and
literacy among the Ethiopian Jews in Israel’
, in
H. G. Marcus
(ed.) New Trends in Ethiopian Studies: Proceedings of the Twelfth
International Conference of Ethiopian Studies. Lawrenceville,
NJ: The Red Sea Press.
2.
Anteby, L.
(1997)
‘Blood, identity and integration: Reflections on the Ethiopian
Jews in Israel’
, in
K. Fukui
,
E. Kurimoto
and
M. Shigeta
(eds) Ethiopia in Broader Perspective: Proceedings of the Thirteenth
International Conference of Ethiopian Studies, pp.
262-283
. Kyoto: Shokado Book Sellers.
3.
Ben-Porat, A.
(1993) The State and Capitalism in Israel.
Westport, CT: Greenwood Press
.
4.
Bodovski, D.
and
David, Y.
(1996) Ethiopian Jews’ Legacy.
Jerusalem: Bahalachin and Gutman Publishers
.
5.
Burks, A. W.
(1946)
‘Peirce’s theory of abduction’
. Philosophy of Science13:
301-306
.
6.
Chen, H. T.
and
Rossi, P. H.
(1992) ‘Introduction: Integrating theory into
evaluation practice’, in
H. Chen
and
P. H. Rossi
(eds) Using Theory to Improve Program and Policy Evaluation, pp.
1-11.
Westport, CT: Greenwood Press
.
7.
Cohen, R. N.
(2004) Introducing Tracer Studies: Guidelines for
Implementing Tracer Studies in Early Childhood Programmes.
The Hague. Bernard van Leer Foundation
.
8.
Copi, I. M.
(1961) Introduction to Logic.
London: Macmillan
.
9.
Copi, I. M.
and
Burgess-Jackson, K.
(1995) Informal Logic.
Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall
.
10.
Dushnik, L.
and
Sabar, N.
(2001) ‘The ethics of qualitative
research’, in
N. Sabar
(ed.) Genres and Traditions in Qualitative Research, pp.
343-368.
Lod, Israel: Dvir
.
11.
Eisenstadt, S. N.
(1966) Modernization.
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall
.
12.
Flum, Hanoch
(1998)
‘Embedded identity: The case of young high-achieving Ethiopian
Jewish immigrants in Israel’
. Journal of Youth Studies1(2):
143-161
.
13.
Fox, Richard
(1998) ‘Layered abduction and abductive
inference’,
Edinburg, TX: University of Texas, Computer Science
. Available at: http://www.cs.panam.edu/fox/RESEARCH/abd.html
(accessed November 2003).
14.
Garb, H. N.
(1998) Studying the Clinician: Judgment Research and
Psychological Assessment.
Washington, DC: American Psychological Association
.
15.
Gleser, L.
and
Stein, M. I.
, eds (1999) Evocative Images: The Thematic Apperception Test
and the Art of Projection.
Washington, DC: American Psychological Association
.
16.
Herman, M.
(1996)
‘Relating Bet Israel history in its Ethiopian context: Defining,
creating, constructing identity’
. Journal of the Anthropological Society of Oxford27(1):
47-59
.
17.
Katz, E.
and
Gurevitch, M.
(1976) The Secularization of Leisure: Culture and
Communication in Israel.
London: Faber and Faber
.
18.
Kumar, V.
,
Aaker, D. A.
and
Day, G. S.
(1999) Essentials of Marketing Research.
New York: John Wiley
.
19.
Lahad, Mully
(1997) Dramatherapy Theory and Practice.
London: Routledge
.
20.
Levin-Rozalis, M.
(2000a)
‘Social representations as emerging from social structure: The
case of the Ethiopian immigrants to Israel’
. Papers on Social Representations9:
1-22
.
21.
Levin-Rozalis, M.
(2000b)
‘Abduction, a logical criterion for program evaluation’
. Evaluation, the International Journal of Theory, Research and Practice6(4):
411-428
.
22.
Levin-Rozalis, M.
and
Shafran, N.
(2003) A Sense of Belonging: A Tracer Study of
Almaya’s Parents Cooperative Kindergarten. Early Childhood
Development: Practice and Reflection No. 19.
The Hague: Bernard van Leer Foundation
.
23.
Lillenfeld, O. S.
(1999)
‘Projective measures of personality and psychopathology: How well
do they work?’
. Skeptical Inquirer23(5):
32-39
.
24.
Lillenfeld, O. S.
,
Wood, M. J.
and
Garb, H.
(2000)
‘The scientific status of projective techniques’
. Psychological Science in the Public Interest1(2):
27-66
.
25.
Livingston, S.
(2003) Projective Techniques Uncover Real Consumer
Attitudes.
Windham, NH: Executive Solutions
. Available at: http://www.executivesolutions.com/art/1.shtml
(accessed November 2003).
26.
May, W. F.
(1980)
‘Doing ethics: The bearing of ethical theories on field work’
. Social Problems27(3):
358-370
.
27.
Peirce, C. S.
(1931-5) Collected Papers.
C. Hartshorne
and
P. Weiss
(eds).
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
28.
Peirce, C. S.
(1955) ‘Abduction and
induction’, in
Justus Buchler
(ed.) Philosophical Writing of Peirce, pp.
150-156.
New York: Dover Publications
.
29.
Rosen, H.
(1987) From Infancy to Adulthood in the Traditional Ethiopian
Society.
Jerusalem: Ministry of Absorption,
‘Hadasa’ - Women’s Association
.
30.
Schwandt, T. A.
(2001) Dictionary of Qualitative Inquiry.
New Delhi: SAGE
.
31.
Shank, G.
and
Cunningham, D. J.
(1996) ‘Six modes of Peircean
abduction’, Available at:
http://www.cs.indiana.edu/event/maics96/Proceedings/shank.html (accessed
November 2003).
32.
Turner, J. H.
(1986) The Structure of Sociological Theory.
Chicago, IL: The Dorsey Press
.
33.
Weil, S.
(1995a)
‘It is futile to trust in man: methodological difficulties in
studying non-mainstream populations with reference to Ethiopian Jews in Israel’
. Human Organization54(1):
1-9
.
34.
Weil, S.
(1995b)
‘Collective designations and collective identity among Ethiopian Jews’
. Israel Social Science Research10(2):
25-40
.
35.
Zikmund, W. G.
(1997) Exploring Marketing Research.
Orlando, FL: The Dryden Press
.
