Tuning the discipline of history in the United States: Harmony (and dissonance) in teaching and learning

Abstract

Tuning's progress in the discipline of history in the United States since 2009 illustrates the project's continuing capacity to develop “educational structures and programmes on the basis of diversity and autonomy”, maintaining the initiative's original European Union commitment in a markedly different academic environment across the Atlantic. Struggling initially against a backdrop of confusion, hesitancy, and resistance among US faculty, Tuning has been adopted by a steadily expanding number of educators in individual institutions, state systems, and the history discipline's premier professional society. Though operating, at times, in an uneven, imprecise, or pro forma manner, Tuning in the US manages to address several important goals: bringing a more coherent frame of reference to scattered conversations about higher education; framing a more meaningful discussion about the knowledge, skills, and non-monetized “value” developed through higher education; focusing on the central role of faculty discipline experts in the work of assessment, accreditation, and accountability; and engaging professional scholarly societies on questions of teaching and learning.

Keywords

Arts humanities Tuning learning outcomes historians assessment discipline core competencies proficiencies American Historical Association US higher education

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adelman

(2008a, April) The Bologna Club: What U.S. Higher Education Can Learn from a Decade of European Reconstruction, Washington, DC: Institute for Higher Education PolicyAvailable at: www.ihep.org/Research/GlobalPerformance.cfm (accessed 24 October 2015).

Adelman

(2008b, July) Learning Accountability from Bologna: A Higher Education Policy Primer, Washington, DC: Institute for Higher Education PolicyAvailable at: http://www.ihep.org/sites/default/files/uploads/docs/pubs/learning_accountability_from_bologna.pdf (accessed 24 October 2015).

Adelman

(2008c) Accountability “light”: Our version is going the way of the dollar vs. the euro. Liberal Education 94(4): 6–13.

Adelman

(2009, April) The Bologna Process for U.S. Eyes: Re-learning Higher Education in the Age of Convergence, Washington, DC: Institute for Higher Education PolicyAvailable at: http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED504904.pdf (accessed 24 October 2015).

Adelman

Ewell

Gaston

et al. (2014) The Degree Qualifications Profile 2.0: Defining U.S. Degrees through Demonstration and Documentation of College Learning, Indianapolis, IN: Lumina Foundation.

AHA Tuning Project (2012) History discipline core: A statement from the AHA's tuning project. Perspectives on History 50(7): 42–43. Available at: https://www.historians.org/publications-and-directories/perspectives-on-history/search-past-issues (accessed 1 May 2016).

Andrews

Burke

(2007) What does it mean to think historically?. Perspectives on History 45(1): 32–35.

Belanger

(2016) Using US tuning to effect: The American historical association's tuning project and the first year research paper. Arts and Humanities in Higher Education. Epub ahead of print 15 February 2016. DOI: 10.1177/1474022216628379. Available at: http://ahh.sagepub.com.dist.lib.usu.edu/content/early/2016/02/15/1474022216628379.full.pdf+html (accessed 27 February 2016).

Brint

Proctor

Murphy

et al. (2009) General education models: Continuity and change in the U.S. undergraduate curriculum, 1975–2000. The Journal of Higher Education 80(6): 605–642.

10.

Brookins J (2012, February) History faculty begin nationwide Tuning project. In: AHA Today, a blog of the American Historical Association. Available at: http://blog.historians.org/2012/02/history-faculty-begin-nationwide-tuning-project/ (accessed 14 January 2016).

11.

Brookins

(2015) AHA tuning project holds events around the country. Perspectives on History 53(9): 42–43.

12.

Carey

Haviland

Platt

et al. (2014) Teaching undergraduates: A conversation in Brooklyn. Perspectives on History 52(6): 9–10. .

13.

CLIOHWORLD (2011) Creating a New Historical Perspective: EU and the Wider World: CLIOHWORLD – Guide II: Guidelines and Reference Points for the Design and Delivery of Degree Programmes in History, Pisa: DedaloAvailable at: http://www.unideusto.org/tuningeu/images/stories/Summary_of_outcomes_TN/Guidelines_and_References_Points_for_Design_and_Delivery_of_Degree_Programmes_in_History_-_Cliohworld_Guide_II.pdf (accessed 20 January 2016).

14.

Crooks

(1979) History's role in general education. The Journal of General Education 31(2): 109–121.

15.

Department of the Treasury (2012) The economics of higher education: A report prepared by the Department of the Treasury with the Department of Education. Report, Washington, DC, December. Available at: https://www.treasury.gov/connect/blog/Documents/20121212_Economics%20of%20Higher%20Ed_vFINAL.pdf (accessed 18 November 2015).

16.

Dewald

(2012) On the tuning project. Perspectives on History 50(8): 50.

17.

Dorn S (2012) The American historical association tuning project. In: ShermanDorn.com, 2 April. Available at: http://shermandorn.com/wordpress/?p=4612 (accessed 2 January 2016).

18.

Doyle

(2012) On historians, tuning, and markets. Perspectives on History 50(6): 49–50.

19.

European Commission (2012) Co-operation in higher education between the United States of America and the European Union to produce a robust methodology to evaluate the application of the Tuning approach. Final report. Available at: http://tuningacademy.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/Tuning-EU_US-Study_Final-Report.pdf (accessed 1 December 2015).

20.

Glover H and Sauer K (2010) Tuning USA final report: The 2009 Indiana Pilot, revised June 2010. In: Document Archive, Degree Qualifications Profile, National Institute for Learning Outcomes Assessment. Available at: http://degreeprofile.org/press_four/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/IN-Updated_Final_report_for_June_submission1.pdf (accessed 5 January 2016).

21.

Greenfield B (2012) Questioning the “tuning” project. In: Public History Commons, 14 March. Available at: http://publichistorycommons.org/questioning-the-tuning-project/ (accessed 2 January 2016).

22.

Grossman

(2012a) Tuning in to the history major. Perspectives on History 50(4): 7–8.

23.

Grossman

(2012b) Response to C Doyle. Perspectives on History 50(6): 50–51.

24.

Grossman

Brookins

(2016) Assessment is what we make it. Journal of American History 102(4): 1132–1137.

25.

Hutchings

(2011) What New Faculty Need to Know About Assessment, Champaign, IL: National Institute for Learning Outcomes Assessment, Assessment Briefs: FacultyApril. Available at: http://www.learningoutcomesassessment.org/documents/ABfaculty.pdf (accessed 5 January 2016).

26.

Hutchings Jankowski

Ewell

(2014) Catalyzing Assignment Design Activity on Your Campus: Lessons from NILOA's Assignment Library Initiative, Champaign, IL: National Institute for Learning Outcomes AssessmentAvailable at: http://www.learningoutcomesassessment.org/documents/Assignment_report_Nov.pdf (accessed 20 December 2015).

27.

Hyde

(2013a) Advising mom and dad: History majors and family worries. Perspectives on History 51(4): 29–30.

28.

Hyde A (2013b) AHA History Tuning Project: History Discipline Core. American Historical Association (September). Available at: https://www.historians.org/teaching-and-learning/tuning/history-discipline-core (accessed 15 January 2016).

29.

Hyde

(2015) Confessions from the field: Building assessments with the history discipline core. Perspectives on History 53(1): 19.

30.

Institute for Evidence-Based Change (IEBC) (2012a) Tuning activities to date. Tuning Newsletter 1(1): 1–2. Available at: http://www.iebcnow.org/IEBCPublicFiles/iebc.public/df/df67c362-122e-44d7-b5f2-1d814cc3e5b9.pdf (accessed 23 January 2016).

31.

Institute for Evidence-Based Change (IEBC) (2012b) Tuning American Higher Education. Available at: http://degreeprofile.org/press_four/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/Tuning-Higher-Education-The-Process.pdf (accessed 30 November 2015).

32.

Jaschik S (2012) “Tuning” history. Inside Higher Ed, 13 February.

33.

Jones

(2012) “Tuning” the disciplines. Liberal Education 98(4): 52–59.

34.

Jones

(2015) The continuous death and resurrection of the liberal arts. Liberal Education 101/102(4/1): 44–51.

35.

Katz

(2005) Retrieving the Master's Degree from the Dustbin of History, Washington, DC: The American Historical AssociationAvailable at: http://historians.org/about-aha-and-membership/aha-history-and-archives/archives/retrieving-the-masters-degree-from-the-dustbin-of-history (accessed 20 December 2015).

36.

Katz S and Grossman J (2008) The history major and undergraduate liberal education: Report of the national history center working group to the Teagle foundation. Report, Teagle Foundation. Available at: https://www.princeton.edu/~snkatz/papers/NHCTeageReportFinal_9-29-08.pdf (accessed 26 December 2015).

37.

Keeling

(2013) On “history for non-majors.”. Perspectives on History 51(6): 64.

38.

Kelly M (2015) History out of tune. In: Edwired, 15 February. Available at: http://edwired.org/2015/02/15/history-out-of-tune/ (accessed 2 January 2016).

39.

Kennedy

Frankel

(2006) Report presented on internationalizing student learning outcomes in history. Perspectives on History 44(3): 9.

40.

Kramer M (2012) De-tuning the AHA's tuning project. In: Michael J Kramer, 18 October. Available at: http://www.michaeljkramer.net/cr/de-tuning-the-ahas-tuning-project/ (accessed 2 January 2016).

41.

Kuh

Hutchings

(2015) Assessment and initiative fatigue: Keeping the focus on learning. In: Kuh

et al. (eds) Using Evidence of Student Learning to Improve Higher Education, San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass, pp. 183–200.

42.

Kuh

Ikenberry

Jankowski

et al. (2015) Beyond compliance: Making assessment matter. Change: The Magazine of Higher Learning 47(5): 8–17.

43.

Labi A (2009) Europe's higher-education restructuring holds lessons for U.S., report says. Chronicle of Higher Education, 8 April.

44.

Lumina Foundation (2009) FAQs on bologna and tuning. Lumina Foundation: Helping People Achieve Their Potential, Indianapolis, IN: Lumina Foundation for Educationrevised 5 June 2010. Available at: https://shelbycearley.files.wordpress.com/2010/06/faqs-on-bologna-and-tuning.pdf (accessed 16 December 2015).

45.

Maki

(2010) Assessing for Learning: Building a Sustainable Commitment Across the Institution, 2nd ed. Sterling, VA: Stylus Publishing, pp. 217–225.

46.

Marty

Gosselin

Palmer

et al. (1990) Liberal Learning and the History Major: A Report by the American Historical Association Task Force in the Association of American College's Project on Liberal Learning, Study in Depth, and the Arts and Sciences Majors, Washington, DC: American Historical AssociationAvailable at: http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED387418.pdf (accessed 4 November 2015).

47.

McInerney

(2010) Rubrics for history courses: Lessons from one campus. Perspectives on History 48(7): 31–33.

48.

McInerney D (2013) Tuning: An example of the impact. In: PowerPoint, Montana tuning conference, Helena, Montana, 5 September. Available at: https://mus.edu/2yr/TuningInitiative/MontanaTuningImpactPresentation-McInerney.pdf (accessed 10 November 2015).

49.

McInerney

(2014) Tuning history in Utah: winning friends and influencing policy makers. Perspectives on History 52(4): 14–15.

50.

McKiernan

Birtwistle

(2010) Making the implicit explicit: demonstrating the value added of higher education by a qualifications framework. Journal of College and University Law 36(2): 511–564.

51.

National Center for Education Statistics (2013a) Digest of Education Statistics: 2013 Table 303.25, total fall enrollment in degree-granting post-secondary institutions, by control and level of institution: 1970 through 2012. Available at: https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d13/tables/dt13_303.25.asp (accessed 24 October 2015).

52.

National Center for Education Statistics (2013b) Digest of Education Statistics: 2013 Table 317.40: number of degree-granting post-secondary institutions and enrollment in these institutions, by enrollment size, control, and level of institution: Fall 2012. Available at: https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d13/tables/dt13_317.40.asp?referrer=report (accessed 24 October 2015).

53.

National Center for Education Statistics (2015) Undergraduate enrollment (May). Available at: http://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator_cha.asp (accessed 24 October 2015).

54.

National Communication Association (2016) Learning outcomes in communication. Available at: https://www.natcom.org/LOC/ (accessed 12 January 2016).

55.

Neem

(2013) Does history matter? A cautionary tale for the tuning project. Perspectives on History 51(4): 36–37.

56.

Nováky

(2015) The same history for all? Tuning history. In: Ludvigsson

Booth

(eds) Enriching history teaching and learning: Challenges, possibilities, practice: Proceedings of the Linköping conference on history teaching and learning in higher education, May 2014, Linköping: ISAK, Linköpings Universitet, pp. 101–119. .

57.

Quality Assurance Agency For Higher Education, UK (QAA) (2007) Subject benchmarks statements: history. Available at: http://www.qaa.ac.uk/en/Publications/Documents/Subject-benchmark-statement-History.pdf (accessed 14 December 2015).

58.

Redden E (2008) On accountability, consider Bologna. Inside Higher Ed 28 July.

59.

Safman P, Evenson W and Jones N (2009) Tuning USA interim report, Utah. In: Utah Tuning: Defining Learning Outcomes for Post-Secondary Degrees, 18 November. Available at: utahtuning.weebly.com/uploads/1/4/6/9/14699846/interim_report_nov2009.pdf (accessed 19 December 2015).

60.

Safman P, Evenson W and Jones N (2011) Tuning USA final report, Utah. In: Utah Tuning: Defining Learning Outcomes for Post-Secondary Degrees, 28 February. Available at: http://utahtuning.weeblycom/uploads/1/4/6/9/14699846/final_tuning_usa_report_feb2011.pdf (accessed 10 January 2016).

61.

Safman P, Evenson W and Jones N (2014) Lumina foundation grantee final narrative report. In: Utah Tuning: Defining Learning Outcomes for Post-Secondary Degrees, 15 July. Available at: http://utahtuning.weebly.com/uploads/1/4/6/9/14699846/report.7.15.14.pdf (accessed 6 January 2016).

62.

Salt Lake Community College (2016) SLCC eportfolio student resource site. Available at: http://eportresource.weebly.com/ (accessed 6 February 2016).

63.

Seale Y (2016) American historical association annual meeting, 2016. In: Yvonne Seale. Available at: http://yvonneseale.org/blog/conferences-lectures/american-historical-association-annual-meeting-2016/ (accessed 31 January 2016).

64.

Shurts S (2013) Reflections on the February 2013 Tuning workshop. In: AHA Today, A Blog of the American Historical Association (5 March). Available at: http://blog.historians.org/2013/03/reflections-on-the-february-2013-tuning-workshop/ (accessed 14 January 2016).

65.

Townsend

(2012) Underpaid and underappreciated: A portrait of part-time faculty. Perspectives on History 50(6): 11–13.

66.

Utah Tuning (2010a) History learning outcomes. In: Utah Tuning: Defining Learning Outcomes for Post-Secondary Degrees. Available at: http://utahtuning.weebly.com/uploads/1/4/6/9/14699846/learning_outcomes_usu_history_undergraduate_major.pdf (accessed 3 January 2016).

67.

Utah Tuning (2010b) Rubrics for history courses. In: Utah Tuning: Defining Learning Outcomes for Post-Secondary Degrees. Available at: http://utahtuning.weebly.com/history.html (accessed 3 January 2016).

68.

Utah Tuning (2010c) History pre-major. In: Utah Tuning: Defining Learning Outcomes for Post-Secondary Degrees. Available at: http://utahtuning.weebly.com/uploads/1/4/6/9/14699846/pre-major.jpg (accessed 3 January 2016).

69.

Whisnant A (2012) Regarding the AHA's “tuning” project. In: Whisnant Projects, 22 February. Available at: http://annewhisnant.web.unc.edu/2012/02/22/regarding-the-ahas-tuning-project/#comments (accessed 2 January 2016).

70.

Wokeck

(2010) Articulating learning outcomes in history: Lessons learned in Indiana. Perspectives on History 48(7): 34–35.

71.

Yopp J and Marshall D (2014) Tuning USA: Meeting the Challenges of US Higher Education. PowerPoint, Institute for Evidence-Based Change, 24 April. Available at: http://www.iebcnow.org/NewsAndPublications/Videos/TX-Completes-Dashboard-Tools-Review-Webinar-%281%29.aspx (accessed 24 October 2015).