Impact of the provision and timing of instructor-provided notes on university students’ learning

Abstract

Since the advent of PowerPoint and course delivery programs like Blackboard, more instructors in higher education are providing students with outlines of their lectures and expecting students to supplement these with their own notes. Although some have found that instructor-provided notes appear to enhance student learning, others suggest that students benefit from the act of taking detailed notes since it engages them in the learning process. While controlling for fidelity of lecture delivery, the present study examined the impact of three conditions on the posttest performance of 154 undergraduate and graduate students enrolled in an introductory special education course: (1) no instructor-provided notes were available, (2) instructor-provided notes were available immediately following lectures, and (3) instructor-provided notes were available before lectures. Analyses revealed that pretest scores were significantly correlated to posttest scores and that students who did not receive instructor-provided lecture notes received statistically significant lower posttest scores than students who received instructor-provided lecture notes before or after lectures. The implications for university instruction are discussed.

Keywords

instructor-provided lecture notes effective teaching higher education PowerPoint lecture notes university learning

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anderson TH and Armbruster BB ( 1991) The value of taking notes during lectures, in RF Flippo and DC Caverly (eds), Teaching Reading and Study Strategies at the College Level, pp. 166-94. Newark, DE: International Reading Association.

Austin JL , Lee M. and Carr JP ( 2004) The effects of guided notes on undergraduate recording of lecture content, Journal of Instructional Psychology 31(4): 314-20.

Barnett JE ( 2003) Do instructor-provided on-line notes facilitate student learning? Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Chicago, Illinois, April 21-25.

Brazeau G. ( 2006) Handouts in the classroom: Is note taking a lost skill? , American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education 70(2): 1-2.

Biddulph G. , Hess P. and Humes P. ( 2006) Help a child with learning challenges be successful in the general education classroom, Intervention in School and Clinic 41(5): 315-16.

Bonner JM and Holliday WG ( 2006) How college science students engage in note-taking strategies , Journal of Research in Science Teaching 43(8): 786-818.

Boyle JR ( 2007) The process of note taking: Implications for students with mild disabilities, The Clearing House 80(5): 227-230.

Castello M. and Monereo C. ( 2005) Students’ note-taking as a knowledge-construction tool, Educational Studies in Language and Literature 5: 265-85.

Cukras GG ( 2006) The investigation of study strategies that maximize learning for underprepared students, College Teaching 54(1): 194-7.

10.

DiVesta FJ and Gray GS ( 1972) Listening and note taking, Journal of Educational Psychology 63: 8-14.

11.

Einstein GO , Morris J. and Smith S. ( 1985) Note-taking, individual differences, and memory for lecture information, Journal of Educational Psychology 77(5): 522-32.

12.

Grabe M. ( 2005) Voluntary use of online lecture notes: Correlates of note use and note use as an alternative to class attendance, Computers and Education 44: 409-21.

13.

Grabe M. and Christopherson K. ( 2007) Optional student use of online lecture resources: Resource preferences, performance and lecture attendance, Journal of Computer Assisted Learning 24: 1-10.

14.

Hughes CA and Suritsky SK ( 1993) Notetaking skills and strategies for students with learning disabilities, Preventing School Failure 38(1): 7-12.

15.

Hughes CA and Suritsky SK ( 1994) Note-taking skills of university students with and without disabilities, Journal of Learning Disabilities 27(1): 20-4.

16.

James KE , Burke LA and Hutchins HA ( 2006) Powerful or pointless? Faculty versus student perceptions of PowerPoint use in business education, Business Communication Quarterly 69(4): 374-96.

17.

Katayama AD and Crooks SM ( 2003) Online notes: Differential effects of studying complete or partial graphically organized notes, Journal of Experimental Education 71(4): 293-312.

18.

Kiewra K. ( 1985) Providing the instructor’s notes: An effective addition to student note-taking, Educational Psychologist 20(1): 33-9.

19.

Kiewra K. ( 2002) How classroom teachers can help students learn and teach them how to learn, Theory into Practice 41(2): 71-80.

20.

Klahr D. and Wallace JG ( 1976) Cognitive Development: An Information Processing View . Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

21.

Kobayashi K. ( 2006) Combined effects of note-taking/reviewing on learning and the enhancement through interventions: A meta-analytic review, Educational Psychology 26(3): 459-477.

22.

Mercer CD and Mercer AR ( 2005) Teaching Students with Learning Problems, 7th edn. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson/Prentice Hall.

23.

Neef NA , McCord BE and Ferrerri SJ ( 2006) Effects of guided notes versus completed notes during lectures on college students’ quiz performance, Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis 39(1): 123-30.

24.

Stefanou C. , Hoffman L. and Vielee N. ( 2008) Note-taking in the college classroom as evidence of generative learning, Learning Environment Resources 11: 1-17.

25.

Suritsky SK and Hughes CA ( 1991) Benefits of notetaking: Implications for secondary and postsecondary students with learning disabilities, Learning Disability Quarterly 14(1): 7-18.

26.

Titsworth BS ( 2001) The effects of teacher immediacy, use of organizational lecture cues and students’ notetaking on cognitive learning, Communication Education 50(4): 283-97.

27.

Vandehey M. , Marsh CM and Diekhoff GM ( 2005) Providing students with instructors’ notes: Problems with reading, studying and attendance, Teaching of Psychology 32(1): 49-51.