The paper argues a case for the economic determinism of human resource management
practice. The arguments put aside human agency and suggest that human resource
management practice can best be understood through the influence of industrial
and labour economics. The question has been asked in the HRM literature as to
whether economic determinism has led to the collapse of the HRM metaphor. This
paper suggests that the hospitality and tourism industry is a case of where
economic determinism has prevented modern HRM paradigms from starting up. The
friction between concerns for modern management practice and unchanging economic
imperatives forms the basis of the paper. The conditions that might produce
change are discussed.
AlpertW.J.
(1986) ‘The Minimum Wage in the Restaurant
Industry’, Praeger,
New York.
2.
ArrowsmithJ.McGoldrickA.
(1996) ‘HRM service practices:
Flexibility, quality and employee strategy’,
International Journal of Service Industry Management,
7, 3,
46–62.
3.
BeasleyM.
A. (1995)
‘Establishing and maintaining a cross-training
program’, Food Management,
30, 11, 44.
4.
BurackH.
E.BurackM. D.MillerD. M.MorganK.
(1994) ‘New paradigm approaches in
strategic human resource management’, Group
and Organization Management, 19, 2,
141–159.
5.
BurchillB.ElliiotJ.RuberyJ.WilkinsonF.
(1994) ‘Management and employee
perceptions of skill’, in PennR.RoseM.RuberyJ.
(eds) ‘Skill and Occupational Change’,
Oxford University Press,
Oxford,
159–188.
6.
ButtlerR.
(1995) ‘Time in organisations; its
experience, explanations and effects’,
Organizational Studies, 16,
6, 925–950.
7.
DarrahC.
(1994) ‘Skill requirements at work:
Rhetoric versus reality’, Work and
Occupations, 21, 1,
4–84.
8.
DoeringerP.
B.PioreM.
(1971) ‘Internal Labor Markets and Manpower
Analysis’, Heath Lexington,
New York.
9.
DouglasM.
(1987) ‘How Institutions Think’,
Routledge and Kegan Paul,
London.
10.
EdwardsR.
(1993) ‘Rights at Work’,
Twentieth Century Fund, Brookings
Institute, Washington,
DC.
11.
EvansD.
S.LeightonL.
S. (1989)
‘Why do smaller firms pay
less?’, Journal of Human
Resources, 24, 2,
299–318.
12.
GallieD.WhiteM.ChengY.TomlinsonM.
(1998) ‘Restructuring the Employment
Relationship’, Oxford University
Press, Oxford.
13.
GowlerD.LeggeK.
(1970) ‘The wage payment
system’, in RobinsonD.
(ed.) ‘Local Labour Markets and Wage Structures’,
Gower Press,
London.
14.
GreveH.
R. (1994)
‘Industry diversity effects on job
mobility’, Acta Sociologica,
37,
119–139.
15.
HageJ.
(1989) ‘The sociology of traditional
economic problems; product and labor markets’,
Work and Occupations, 16,
4, 416–445.
16.
JohnsonK.
(1981) ‘Towards an understanding of
labour turnover’, Service Industries
Review, 1, 1,
4–17.
17.
KelliherC.
(1989) ‘Flexibility in employment;
developments in the hospitality industry’,
International Journal of Hospitality Management,
8, 2,
57–166.
18.
KelliherC.JohnsonK.
(1997) ‘Personnel management in hotels
— An update; a move to human resource
management?’. Progress in Tourism and
Hospitality Research, 4, 4,
321–332.
19.
KleijwegA.ThurikR.
(1988) ‘Determinants of aggregate
employment; an example of the food retail and hotel and catering
sectors’, Service Industries
Journal, 8, 1,
91–100.
20.
KnightI.
B. (1971)
‘Patterns of Labour Mobility in the Hotel and Catering
Industry’, Hotel and Catering Industry
Training Board,
London.
21.
KrakoverS.
(1998) ‘Employment adjustment trends in
tourism hotels in Israel’, Tourism Recreation
Research, 23,
23–32.
22.
LashleyC.WatsonS.
(1999) ‘Researching human resource
management in the hospitality industry: The need for a new
agenda?’, International Journal of
Tourism and Hospitality Research, 1,
1, 19–40.
23.
LeichtK.
T. (1998)
‘Work (if you can get it) and occupations (if there
are any)? What social scientists can learn from predictions of the
end of work and radical workplace change’,
Work and Occupations, 25,
1, 36–48.
24.
PriceE.
(1994) ‘Poor personnel practice in the
hotel and catering industry: Does it matter?’,
Human Resouce Management Journal, 4,
4, 44–62.
25.
RileyM.
(1991) ‘An analysis of hotel labour
markets’, in CooperC.
(ed.) ‘Progress in Tourism, Recreation and Hospitality
Management’, Belhaven
Press, London,
232–246.
26.
RileyM.
(1996) ‘Human Resource Management in the
Hospitality and Tourism Industry’, 2nd
edn, Butterworth Heinemann,
Oxford.
27.
RileyM.LockwoodA.
(1997) ‘Strategies and measurement for
workforce flexibility; an application of functional flexibility in a service
setting’, International Journal of Operations
and Productivity Management, 17, 4,
413–419.
28.
RileyM.LockwoodA.Powell-PerryJ.BakerM.
(1998) ‘Job satisfaction, organisation
commitment and occupational culture: A case from the UK pub
industry’, Progress in Tourism and
Hospitality Research, 4,
1–10.
29.
SchulerR.
S. (1989)
‘Strategic human resource management and industrial
relations’, Human Relations,
42, 2,
157–184.
30.
ShamirB.
(1980) ‘Between service and servility,
role conflict in subordinate service roles’,
Human Relations33, 10,
741–756.
31.
SimmsJ.HalesC.RileyM.
(1988) ‘An examination of the concept of
internal labour markets in UK hotels’,
Tourism Management, 9, 1,
3–12.
32.
SparrowP.
R.MarchingtonM.
(1998) ‘Human Resouce Management. The New
Agenda’, Pitman-Financial
Times, London.
33.
StoreyJ.
(1995) ‘New Perspectives on Human Resource
Management’, Routledge,
London.
34.
TimperleyS.SissonsK.
(1994) ‘From manpower planning to human
resource planning?’, in SissonsK.
(ed.) ‘Personnel Management in Britain’,
Blackwell,
Oxford.
35.
TrussC.GrattonL.Hope-HaileyV.McGovernP.StilesP.
(1997) ‘Soft and hard models of human
resouces management: A reappraisal’, Journal
of Management Studies, 34, 1,
53–73.
36.
WalshD.
F. (1998)
‘Structure/agency’, in
JenksC.
(ed.) ‘Core Sociological Dichotomies’,
Sage,
London.
37.
WrightP.
M.SnellS.
A. (1998)
‘Toward a unifying framework for exploring fit and
flexibility in strategic human resource management’,
Academy of Management Review, 23,
4, 756–772.
38.
YoungM.
V.KaufmanB.
E. (1997)
‘Interfirm wage differentials in a local labor market:
The case of the fast-food industry’, Journal
of Labor Research, 28, 3,
463–480.
