The use of anthropometric and clinical parameters for early identification and categorisation of nutritional risk in pre-school children in Benin City,Nigeria

Abstract

This study was conducted in Benin City, Nigeria between June and August 1996 to assess nutritional status and health risks of three to five-year-old children, with the view to suggesting practical approaches to their early detection and intervention.

A total of 165 children comprising 90 males and 75 females was studied. Mid-upper arm circumference (MUAC), weight-for-age (WFA), weight-for-height (WFH) and height-for-age (HFA) z-scores were determined and used to calculate percentage preva lence of malnutrition. Clinical features of macro- and micro-nutrient deficiency were used to develop a clinical scoring system which was subsequently matched with anthro pometric z-scores. The results showed that MUAC z-scores (-1.91 SD±0.74) gave the highest percentage prevalence of malnutrition of 45.2% in this population, followed by the WFA (-1.22 SD±1.07) and HFA (-0.84 SD±1.42) z-scores with a percentage preva lence of 23.3% and 20.6% respectively. The WFH z-score (-0.89 SD±1.06) was the least sensitive in detecting malnutrition (14.7% prevalence). The percentage prevalence calculated from MUAC z-scores matched FAO figures (43%) for the sub-Saharan African region in 1996. MUAC z-scores also correlated more closely with the clinical features of malnutrition (R² = 0.7087). Progressively worsening clinical features were also seen with decreasing z-scores for all variables. Even though moderate differences in clinical and anthropometric variables were detected between the sexes with females fairing better than male subjects, these differences were not statistically significant. Comparisons between anthropometric variables showed only weak correlation, except for WFA vs. HFA z-scores (R² = 0.5233) and WFH vs. WFA z-scores (R² = 0.4559) which showed moderately positive correlation.

We conclude that whereas MUAC z-scores were most sensitive in detecting the extent of malnutrition in this population, merely using anthropometric variables alone may lead to significant under-reporting of the prevalence of malnutrition in a commu nity. A combination of various anthropometric z-scores with clinical features will how ever help in the early identification and categorisation of subjects in terms of degree of nutritional risk. The training of field health and nutrition workers should therefore emphasise the routine use and combination of anthropometric and clinical variables in the determination of prevalence of malnutrition and in the formulation of intervention strategies for nutrition rehabilitation.

Keywords

Anthropometry nutritional risk clinical scores pre-school children

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anderson M.A. , Gopaldas T. , Abbi R. and Gujral S. (1990). Agreement between arm circumference, weight for age and weight for height measures of malnutrition in children. Indian J Pediatr, 27(3), 247-254

Bishop C.W. and Patchey S.J. (1987). Estimation of the mid-upper arm circumference measurement error J Am Diet Assoc; 87(4), 469-473

Carter E.P. (1987). Comparison of weight:height ratio and arm circumference in assessment of acute malnutrition. Arch Dis Child; 62(8), 833-835

Daniel W.W. (1999). Biostatistics: A foundation for analysis in the health sciences. 7th Edition. pp. 150-203

De Onis M. , Montero C. , Akre J. and Clugston G. (1993). The world-wide magnitude of protein-energy malnutrition: an overview from the WHO global data base on child growth. Bull World Health Organ; 71 (6), 703-712

Dibley M.J. , Staehling N. , Nieburg P. and Trowbridge F.L. (1987). Interpretation of z-score anthropometric indicators derived from the international growth reference. Am J clin Nutr; 46, 749-762

Dixon R.A. (1995). Under fives nutritional status in rural communities in western Nigeria. Use of age-standardised weight and mid-upper arm circumference . West Afr J Med; 14(4), 210-216

Fao (1990). Conducting small scale nutrition surveys - A field manual. Rome: FAO

Fao (1996). Food, Agriculture and Food Security: Developments since the world food conference and prospects. World Food Summit. Technical background documents . Volume 1. Rome: FAO FAO (1997). Agriculture, Food and Nutrition for Africa - A resource book for teachers of agriculture. Rome: FAO

10.

Garrow J and James W P T (Editors) (1993). Human Nutrition and Dietetics . 9th Edition. Churchill Livingstone

11.

Gayle H.D. , Binkin N.J. , Staehling N.W. and Trowbridge F.L. (1988). Arm circumference v weight-for-height in nutritional assessment: Are the findings comparable? J Trop Pediatr; 34, 213-217

12.

Gernaat H B P E , Dechering W. Im H J C and Voorhoeve Henk W.A. (1996). Absolute values or z-scores of mid-upper arm circumference to identify wasting? Evaluation in a community as well as a clinical sample of under fives from Nchelenge, Zambia. J Trop Pediatr; 42(2), 27-33

13.

Gorstein J. , Sullivan K. , Yip R. , Oni de M. , Trowbridge F. , Fajans P. and Clogston G. (1994). Issues in the assessment of nutritional status using anthropometry. Bull World Health Organ; 72(2), 273-283

14.

Hamill P V V , Drizd T.A. , Johnson C.L. , Reed R.B. , Roche A.F. and Moore W.M. (1979). Physical growth: National centre for health statistics percentiles. Am J Clin Nutr; 32, 607-629

15.

Latham M.C. (1997). Human nutrition in the developing world. Rome: FAO

16.

Macfarlane S.B. (1995). Errors in calculating weight-for-height. Disasters; 9(1), 37-49

17.

Mayatepek E. , Becker K. , Gana L. , Hollman G.H. and Leichsenring M. (1993). Leukotrienes in the pathophysiology of kwashiorkor . Lancet; 342, 958-960

18.

Ramnath T. and Mathur M.L. (1996). An approach to evaluate a possible bias in Indian well-to-do standard weight values and its implications for interpretations of survey results. J Trop Pediatr; 423(6), 376-378

19.

Shrestha R.M. , Tyson S. and Selenje L. , (1990). Association between weight for age and mid-upper arm circumference measurement: findings from Malawi. J Trop Pediatr ; 36(4),192-195

20.

Trowbridge F.L. and Staehling N. (1980). Sensitivity and specificity of arm circumference indicators in identifying malnourished children. Am J Clin Nutr; 33(3), 687-696

21.

Unicef (1995). The State of the World's Children. Oxford: Oxford University Press

22.

Unicef (1998). The State of the World's Children. Oxford: Oxford University Press

23.

Van Den Broeck J. , Eeckels R. and Vuylsteke J. (1993). Influence of nutritional status on child mortality in rural Zaire. Lancet; 341, 1491-1495

24.

Who (1995). Expert Committee Report. Physical status: The use and interpretation of anthropometry. Series 854