Protecting the community: How digital media promotes safer behavior during the Covid-19 pandemic in authoritarian communities—a case study of the ultra-Orthodox community in Israel
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online March, 2024
Protecting the community: How digital media promotes safer behavior during the Covid-19 pandemic in authoritarian communities—a case study of the ultra-Orthodox community in Israel
The Covid-19 pandemic has ushered in new behaviors and digital practices. This study explores how digital media has advanced safer behavior among ultra-Orthodox Israeli adults during the pandemic in authoritarian societies. We explored the level of adherence to government-issued health guidelines during the Covid-19 pandemic by conducting a public opinion survey among a representative sample of ultra-Orthodox Israeli adults (N = 500) during the second Covid-19 wave (Autumn 2020). The results show that digital media usage significantly contributes to higher levels of adherence to health guidelines. This offers new insight into the field of new media research, revealing the significant role of digital media in promoting safer behavior in times of emergency in authoritarian communities, possibly because it bypasses Internet censorship and disinformation. It also emphasizes the need for adapting risk communication to the media habits and cultural beliefs of different social groups, in turn contributing to well-being and life itself.
AvrahamEFirstA (2010) Can a regulator change representation of minority groups and fair reflection of cultural diversity in national media programs? Lessons from Israel. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media54(1): 136–148.
2.
Bar-levY (2007) Minority representations in public broadcasting. Unpublished MSc Thesis, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Be’er Sheva, Israel.
3.
Barzilai-NahonKBarzilaiG (2005) Cultured technology: the internet and religious fundamentalism. The Information Society21(1): 25–40.
4.
BlondheimMRosenbergH (2017) Media theology: new communication technologies as religious constructs, metaphors, and experiences. New Media & Society19(1): 43–51.
5.
CahanerLMalachG (2019) The Yearbook of Ultra-Orthodox Society in Israel 2019. Jerusalem, Israel: The Israel Democracy Institute.
6.
CahanerLMalachG (2020) The Yearbook of Ultra-Orthodox Society in Israel 2020. Jerusalem, Israel: The Israel Democracy Institute.
7.
CampbellHA (2011) Religion and the internet in the Israeli Orthodox context. Israel Affairs17(3): 364–383.
8.
CampbellHA (2017) Surveying theoretical approaches within digital religion studies. New Media & Society19(1): 15–24.
9.
CampbellHAGolanO (2011) Creating digital enclaves: negotiation of the internet among bounded religious communities. Media, Culture & Society33(5): 709–724.
10.
CohenY (2012) God, Jews and the Media: Religion and Israel’s Media. London: Routledge.
11.
CohenY (2017) The media challenge to Haredi rabbinic authority in Israel. ESSACHESS—Journal for Communication Studies10(2): 113–128.
12.
CohenY (2019) Israeli Haredi media and the “female factor”: the case of the Kol Barama radio station. Israel Affairs25(2): 366–382.
13.
CouldryN (2019) Capabilities for what? Developing Sen’s moral theory for communications research. Journal of Information Policy9: 43–55.
14.
DavidYBadenC (2020) Reframing community boundaries: The erosive power of new media spaces in authoritarian societies. Information, Communication and Society23(1): 110–127. DOI: 10.1080/1369118X.2018.1486869
15.
DavidYSommerladE (2021) Media and information in times of crisis: The case of the COVID-19 infodemic. In: AndrewsGJCrooksVAPearceJRMessinaJP (eds). COVID-19 and Similar Futures. Springer, Cham: Global Perspectives on Health Geography.
16.
DeutschN (2009) The forbidden fork, the cell phone holocaust, and other Haredi encounters with technology. Contemporary Jewry29(1): 3–19.
17.
DonohueGATichenorPJOlienCN (1995) A guard dog perspective on the role of media. Journal of Communication45(2): 115–132.
18.
Don-YehiyaE (2005) Orthodox Jewry in Israel and in North America. Israel Studies10(1): 157–187.
19.
DyerO (2020) COVID-19: Black people and other minorities are hardest hit in US. British Medical Journal369: m1483.
20.
FarkashT (2020) Densely and without medicine: “we are the largest laboratory in the world” testimonies from Bnei Brak. Ynet, 6April. Available at: https://www.ynet.co.il/articles/0,7340, L-5709456,00.html
21.
FirstAInbar-LankriH (2013) The Absent and the Present in Prime Time, Follow-Up. Jerusalem, Israel: The Second Authority for Television and Radio.
FriedmanM (1991) The Haredi Ultra-Orthodox Society: Sources Trends and Processes. Jerusalem, Israel: The Jerusalem Institute for Israel Studies.
24.
FriedmanS (2020) The Kosher Cellphone Market: From Black Hole to Balanced Regulation. Jerusalem, Israel: The Israel Democracy Institute.
25.
FriedmanSEven TzurG (2020) The High Holidays in the Shadow of Corona. Jerusalem, Israel: The Israel Democracy Institute.
26.
GarfinDRSilverRCHolmanEA (2020) The novel coronavirus (COVID-2019)outbreak: amplification of public health consequences by media exposure. Health Psychology39(5): 355–357.
27.
GarnhamN (1997) Amartya Sen’s “capabilities” approach to the evaluation of welfare: its application to communications. Javnost—The Public4(4): 25–34.
28.
GolanOMishol-ShauliN (2018) Fundamentalist web journalism: walking a fine line between religious ultra-Orthodoxy and the new media ethos. European Journal of Communication33(3): 304–320.
29.
HesmondhalghD (2017) Capitalism and the media: moral economy, well-being and capabilities. Media, Culture & Society39(2): 202–218.
JonesTW (2013) Religion, gender and sexuality in everyday life. Culture, Health & Sexuality15(10): 1253–1255.
38.
KenyonC (2020) Flattening-the-curve associated with reduced COVID-19 case fatality rates: an ecological analysis of 65 countries. Journal of Infection81(1): e98–e99.
39.
Keren-KratzM (2016) Westernization and Israelization within Israel’s extreme Orthodox Haredi society. Israel Studies Review31(2): 101–129.
40.
KordaHItaniZ (2013) Harnessing social media for health promotion and behavior change. Health Promotion Practice14(1): 15–23.
41.
LeonN (2015) An uneasy stability: the Haredi parties’ emergency campaign for the 2013 elections. Israel Affairs21(2): 230–244.
42.
LeshemEWilder-SmithA (2021) COVID-19 vaccine impact in Israel and a way out of the pandemic. The Lancet397: 1783–1785.
43.
Lev-OnALissitsaS (2018) Facilitating cross-cleavage communication online: findings from interviews with ultra-Orthodox, religious, and secular participants. The Communication Review21(3): 212–227.
MalchiAFriedmanSMalachG (2020) The mechanisms for reducing morbidity in the ultra-orthodox sector. The Israel Democracy Institute, Jerusalem, Israel, 18October. Available at: https://www.idi.org.il/articles/32681
46.
Neriya-Ben ShaharR (2017) Negotiating agency: Amish and ultra-Orthodox women’s responses to the Internet. New Media & Society19(1): 81–95.
47.
Neriya-Ben ShaharR (2020) “Mobile internet is worse than the internet; it can destroy our community”: old order Amish and Ultra-Orthodox Jewish women’s responses to cellphone and smartphone use. The Information Society36(1): 1–18.
48.
Neria-Ben ShaharRLev-OnA (2011) Gender, religion and new media: attitudes and behaviors related to the internet among Ultra-Orthodox women employed in computerized environments. International Journal of Communication5: 875–895.
49.
NimrodG (2021) Not good days for technophobes: older internet users during the COVID-19 pandemic. Educational Gerontology47: 160–171.
50.
NussbaumMC (2011) Creating Capabilities. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
51.
OlsonMKVosSCSuttonJ (2020) Threat and efficacy in television news: reporting on an emerging infectious disease. Western Journal of Communication84(5): 623–640.
RawlsJ (1971) A Theory of Justice. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
54.
RosenbergHRashiT (2015) Pashkevilim in campaigns against new media: what can pashkevilim accomplish that newspapers cannot? In:CampbellHA (ed.) Digital Judaism: Jewish Negotiations with Digital Media and Culture. New York; London: Routledge, pp. 169–190.
55.
RosenbergHBlondheimMKatzE (2019) It’s the text, stupid! Mobile phones, religious communities, and the silent threat of text messages. New Media & Society21(11–12): 2325–2346.
56.
RubinGJAmlotRPageL, et al. (2009) Public perceptions, anxiety, and behavior change in relation to the swine flu outbreak: cross sectional telephone survey. British Medical Journal339: b2651.
57.
SchejterATiroshN (2016) A Justice-Based Approach for New Media Policy: In the Paths of Righteousness. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
58.
SenA (2005) Human rights and capabilities. Journal of Human Development6(2): 151–166.
59.
SenA (2009) The Idea of Justice. New York: Penguin Books.
60.
ShomronB (2021a) The capability ‘to be secure’: Media coverage of African asylum seekers during Covid-19 in Israel. Journal of Refugee Studies. DOI: 10.1093/jrs/feaa131
61.
ShomronB (2021b) The utilization of Twitter by ultra-Orthodox journalists in protecting their community during the Covid-19 pandemic. Manuscript submitted for publication.
62.
ShomronB (in press) How the media promotes security and affects stigma: The cases of ultra-Orthodox “Haredi” Jews and Palestinian-Israelis during the Covid-19 pandemic. Western Journal of Communication.
63.
ShomronBSchejterA (2019) “He too will become a nation and he too will become great”: The information needs of the “Bnei Menashe” immigrant community in Israel as capability. International Communication Gazette82(4): 384–403. DOI: 10.1177/1748048518820459
64.
ShomronBSchejterA (2020) Diversity in broadcasting as an enabler of capabilities: The case of Palestinian-Israeli women on public and commercial radio and television. Feminist Media Studies. DOI: 10.1080/14680777.2020.1804978
65.
Shukrun-NagarP (2014) “About 1000 Haredim, members of Haeda Haharedit”: linguistic patterns and rhetorical functions of generalizations in the Israeli news. Israel Studies19(3): 154–186.
66.
SoroyaSHFarooqAMahmoodK, et al. (2021) From information seeking to information avoidance: understanding the health information behavior during a global health crisis. Information Processing & Management58(2): 102440.
67.
StadlerN (2012) A Well-Worn Tallis for a New Ceremony. Boston, MA: Academic Studies Press.
68.
TikochinskiS (2009) Musar Yeshivot from Lithuania to Israel: Slabodka Yeshiva, its emigration and establishment in mandate Palestine. PhD Thesis, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Jerusalem, Israel.
69.
Van Der LindenSDixonGClarkeC, et al. (2021) Inoculating against COVID-19 vaccine misinformation. The Lancet33: 100772.
70.
WassermanVGabelI (2019) Juggling resistance and compliance: the case of Israeli ultra-orthodox media. Culture and Organization25(3): 217–232.
71.
WebbTLJosephJYardleyL, et al. (2010) Using the internet to promote health behavior change: a systematic review and meta-analysis of the impact of theoretical basis, use of behavior change techniques, and mode of delivery on efficacy. Journal of Medical Internet Research12(1): e4.
