The meta-theoretical resource of critical realism (CR) is deployed in order to examine transgender and healthcare. CR treads a middle way between positivism and postmodernism, within post-Popperian discussions of the philosophy of natural and social science. It focuses on the conditions of possibility for the emergence of a phenomenon under investigation. In this case, the focus is on the emergence of debates about transgenderism in healthcare. These have been technological (about the prospect of biomedical solutions to personal problems) and ideological, with the enlarged salience of identity politics and our currently unresolved “culture wars.” Identity politics have brought a focus on epistemological privilege or “lived experience” and on rights to healthcare being driven by consumer choice. The current contestation and its history are discussed in relation to our four planar social being (nature, relationality, socio-economic structures, and our particular personalities) and future scenarios are rehearsed.
AlfordRR (1975) Health Care Politics, Ideological and Interest Group Barriers to Reform. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.
2.
American Psychiatric Association (1980) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, 4th edn.Washington, DC: APA.
3.
AndersonP (1983) In the Tracks of Historical Materialism. London: Verso.
4.
AntakiC (ed.) (1981) The Psychology of Ordinary Explanations of Social Behaviour. London: Academic Press.
5.
Baron-CohenS (2003) The Essential Difference: The Truth About the Male and Female Brain. New York, NY: Basic Books.
6.
BemSL (1974) The measurement of psychological androgyny. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology42: 155–162.
7.
Benn MichaelsW (2006) The Trouble With Diversity: How We Learned to Love Identity and Ignore Inequality. New York, NY: Holt.
8.
BhaskarR (2008) A Realist Theory of Science. London: Verso.
9.
BhaskarRDanermarkBPriceL (2018) Interdisciplinarity and Wellbeing: A Critical Realist General Theory of Interdisciplinarity. London: Routledge.
10.
BiggsM (2018) The Open Society Foundations & the transgender movement. 4th Wave Now, 18May.
11.
BilekJ (2020a) Martine Rothblatt: A founding father of the transgender empire. Uncommon Ground, July.
12.
BilekJ (2020b) The billionaires behind the LGBT movement. Uncommon Ground, January.
13.
BlanchardR (2005) Early history of the concept of autogynephilia. Archives of Sexual Behavior34: 439–446.
14.
British Psychological Society (2019) Guidelines for Psychologists Working With Gender, Sexuality and Relationship Diversity. Leicester: British Psychological Society.
15.
BrizendineL (2006) The Female Brain. New York, NY: Morgan Road Books.
16.
Brunskell-EvansHMooreM (eds) (2018) Transgender Children and Young People: Born in Your Own Body. Newcastle: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
17.
BryantK (2006) Making gender identity disorder of childhood: Historical lessons for contemporary debates. Sexuality Research and Social Policy3: 23–39.
18.
ButlerCHutchinsonA (2020) Debate: The pressing need for research and services for gender desisters/detransitioners. Child and Adolescent Mental Health25: 45–47.
19.
ButlerJ (1999) Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity. New York, NY: Routledge.
20.
CabralM (2017) I am transgender and being myself is not a disorder. The Guardian, 24February.
21.
CohenDBarnesH (2019) Gender dysphoria in children: Puberty blockers study draws further criticism. BMJ366: l5647.
22.
CrenshawK (1991) Mapping the margins: Intersectionality, identity politics, and violence against women of color. Stanford Law Review43(6): 1241–1299.
23.
DahlenS (2020) De-sexing the medical record? An examination of sex versus gender identity in the general medical council’s trans healthcare ethical advice. The New Bioethics26: 38–52.
24.
DelimataN (2019) Articulating Intersex: A Crisis at the Intersection of Scientific Facts and Social Ideals. London: Springer Nature.
25.
DennyD (1997) Transgender: Some historical, cross-cultural, and modern-day models and methods of coping and treatment. In: BulloughBBulloughVAEliasJ (eds) Gender Blending. Amherst, NY: Prometheus Books, pp.33–47.
26.
de VriesALCohen-KettenisPT (2012) Clinical management of gender dysphoria in children and adolescents: The Dutch approach. Journal of Homosexuality59(3): 301–320.
27.
de VriesALCSteensmaTDDoreleijersTAH, et al. (2011) Puberty suppression in adolescents with gender identity disorder: A prospective follow-up study. Journal of Sexual Medicine8(8): 2276–2283.
28.
DhejneCLichtensteinPBomanM, et al. (2011) Long-term follow-up of transsexual persons undergoing sex reassignment surgery: Cohort study in Sweden. PLoS One6(2): e16885.
29.
DyAM (2020) Gender theory non-conforming: Critical realist feminism, trans politics, and affordance theory. In: van IngenMGrohmannSGunnarssonL (eds) Critical Realism, Feminism, and Gender: A Reader. London: Routledge.
30.
ElkinRKingD (2006) The Transgender Phenomenon. London: SAGE.
31.
FeinbergL (1999) Trans Liberation: Beyond Pink or Blue. Boston, MA: Beacon Press.
32.
FineC (2010) Delusions of Gender: How Our Minds, Society, and Neurosexism Create Difference. New York, NY: W. W. Norton.
33.
GheroviciP (2010) Please Select Your Gender: From the Invention of Hysteria to the Democratizing of Transgenderism. New York, NY: Routledge.
GreerG (1999) The Whole Woman. London: Transworld Publishers.
36.
GunnarssonL (2013) The naturalistic turn in feminist theory: A Marxist-realist contribution. Feminist Theory14: 3–19.
37.
HaigD (2004) The inexorable rise of gender and the decline of sex: Social change in academic titles, 1945-2001. Archives of Sexual Behavior33: 87–96.
38.
HarperN (2015) Eight members of Iran’s women’s soccer are transgender. QNews, 8October.
39.
HendersonB (2019) Beyond Binaries. Columbia, SC: Harrington Park Press.
40.
HengAHealCBanksJ, et al. (2018) Transgender peoples’ experiences and perspectives about general healthcare: A systematic review. International Journal of Transgenderism19: 359–378.
41.
HilárioAP (2019) (Re) making gender in the clinical context: A look at how ideologies shape the medical construction of gender dysphoria in Portugal. Social Theory & Health17: 463–480.
42.
HullC (2008) The Ontology of Sex: A Critical Inquiry Into the Construction and Reconstruction of Categories. London: Routledge.
43.
HuntS (2016) An Introduction to the Health of Two Spirit People Prince. George, BC: National Collaborating Centre for Aboriginal Health.
44.
IoannidisJPA (2018) Professional societies should abstain from authorship of guidelines and disease definition statements. Circulation Cardiovascular Quality and Outcomes11(10): e004889.
45.
JeffreysS (1997) Transgender activism: A lesbian feminist perspective. Journal of Lesbian Studies1: 55–74.
46.
Judiciary of England and Wales (2020) R (on the Application of) Quincy Bell and A v Tavistock and Portman NHS Trust and Others [2020] EWHC 3274 (Admin). London: Judiciary of England and Wales.
47.
Kaltiala-HeinoRSumiaMTyöläjärviM, et al. (2015) Two years of gender identity service for minors: Overrepresentation of natal girls with severe problems in adolescent development. Child and Adolescent Psychiatry and Mental Health9: 9.
48.
KochJMMcLachlanCVictorCJ, et al. (2020) The cost of being transgender: Where socio-economic status, global health care systems, and gender identity intersect. Psychology and Sexuality11: 103–119.
49.
LevAI (2006) Disordering gender identity: Gender identity disorder in the DSM-IV-TR. Journal of Psychology & Human Sexuality17(3–4): 35–69.
50.
LevineSB (2019) Informed consent for transgendered patients. Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy45(3): 218–229.
51.
LittmanL (2018) Parent reports of adolescents and young adults perceived to show signs of a rapid onset of gender dysphoria. PLoS One13(8): e0202330.
52.
MannSA (2018) Third wave feminism’s unhappy marriage of poststructuralism and intersectionality theory. Journal of Feminist Scholarship4: 54–73.
53.
MarchianoL (2017) Outbreak: On transgender teens and psychic epidemics. Psychological Perspectives60: 345–366.
Mauvais-JarvisFKleinSLLevinER (2020) Estradiol, progesterone, immunomodulation, and COVID-19 outcomes. Endocrinology161: bqaa127.
56.
MoalemS (2020) The Better Half: On the Genetic Superiority of Women. London: Penguin.
57.
MockJ (2014) Redefining Realness: My Path to Womanhood, Love and So Much More. New York, NY: Atria.
58.
MonroS (2005) Beyond male and female: Poststructuralism and the spectrum of gender. International Journal of Transgenderism8: 3–22.
59.
NewC (2005) Sex and gender: A critical realist approach. New Formations56: 54–70.
60.
OakleyA (1972) Sex, Gender and Society. Aldershot: Arena.
61.
OlsonKR (2016) Prepubescent transgender children: What we do and do not know. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry55: 155.e3–156.e3.
62.
PearceR (2018) Understanding Trans Health: Discourse, Power and Possibility. Bristol: Polity.
63.
PilgrimD (2018) Reclaiming reality and redefining realism: The challenging case of transgenderism. Journal of Critical Realism17: 308–324.
64.
PilgrimDEntwistleK (2020) GnRHa (‘Puberty Blockers’) and cross sex hormones for children and adolescents: Informed consent, personhood and freedom of expression. The New Bioethics26(3): 224–237.
65.
RaymondJG (1994) The Transsexual Empire: The Making of the She-Male. New York, NY: Teachers College Press.
66.
RubinG (2012) Deviations: A Gayle Rubin reader. Durham, CT: Duke University Press.
67.
SaadTCBlackshawBPRodgerD (2019) Hormone replacement therapy: Informed consent without assessment?Journal of Medical Ethics45: 824–825.
68.
SayerA (1999) Realism and Social Science. London: SAGE.
69.
ScamblerG (2001) Critical realism, sociology and health inequalities: Social class as a generative mechanism and its media of enactment. Alethia4: 35–42.
70.
SchummWRCrawfordDW (2020) Is research on transgender children what it seems? Comments on recent research on transgender children with high levels of parental support. The Linacre Quarterly87: 9–24.
71.
SeranoJ (2007) Whipping Girl: A Transsexual Woman on Sexism and the Scapegoating of Femininity. Berkeley, CA: Seal Press.
72.
SiguschV (1998) The neosexual revolution. Archives of Sexual Behavior27: 331–359.
73.
SmithESJungerJDerntlB, et al. (2015) The transsexual brain – a review of findings on the neural basis of transsexualism. Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews59: 251–266.
74.
SontagS (1966) Against Interpretation and Other Essays. London: Penguin.
75.
StaggSDVincentJ (2019) Autistic traits in individuals self-defining as transgender or non-binary. European Psychiatry61: 17–22.
76.
SteensmaTDWensing-KrugerAKlinkDT (2017) How should physicians help gender-transitioning adolescents consider potential iatrogenic harms of hormone therapy?AMA Journal of Ethics19: 762–770.
77.
SummersellJ (2018) Trans women are real women: A critical realist intersectional response to pilgrim. Journal of Critical Realism17: 329–336.
WatkinsS (2018) Which feminisms?New Left Review109(2): 5–76.
80.
WilliamsSJMartinPGabeJ (2011) The pharmaceuticalisation of society? A framework for analysis. Sociology of Health & Illness33(5): 710–725.
81.
ZuckerKJWoodHSinghD, et al. (2012) A developmental, biopsychosocial model for the treatment of children with gender identity disorder. Journal of Homosexuality59(3): 369–397.
