This study collates existing evidence regarding weight loss among overweight but otherwise healthy adults who use commercial weight-loss programs. Systematic search of 3 databases identified 11 randomized controlled trials and 14 observational studies of commercial meal-replacement, calorie-counting, or pre-packaged meal programs which met inclusion criteria. In meta-analysis using intention-to-treat data, 57 percent of individuals who commenced a commercial weight program lost less than 5 percent of their initial body weight. One in two (49%) studies reported attrition ≥30 percent. A second meta-analysis found that 37 percent of program completers lost less than 5 percent of initial body weight. We conclude that commercial weight-loss programs frequently fail to produce modest but clinically meaningful weight loss with high rates of attrition suggesting that many consumers find dietary changes required by these programs unsustainable.
AhernALOlsonADAstonLMet al. (2011) Weight Watchers on prescription: An observational study of weight change among adults referred to Weight Watchers by the NHS. BMC Public Health11: 434.
2.
AremHIrwinM (2011) A review of web-based weight loss interventions in adults. Obesity Reviews12(5): e236–e243.
3.
BarteJCter BogtNCBogersRPet al. (2010) Maintenance of weight loss after lifestyle interventions for overweight and obesity, a systematic review. Obesity Reviews11(12): 899–906.
4.
BuchananKSheffieldJ (2017) Why do diets fail?: An exploration of dieters’ experiences using thematic analysis. Journal of Health Psychology22(7): 906–915.
5.
ByeCAveryALavinJ (2005) Tackling obesity in men—preliminary evaluation of men-only groups within a commercial slimming organization. Journal of Human Nutrition and Dietetics18(5): 391–394.
6.
CalderRKMussapAJ (2015) Factors influencing women’s choice of weight-loss diet. Journal of Health Psychology20(5): 612–624.
7.
ColemanCDKielJRMitolaAHet al. (2015) Effectiveness of a Medifast meal replacement program on weight, body composition and cardiometabolic risk factors in overweight and obese adults: A multicenter systematic retrospective chart review study. Nutrition Journal14: 77.
8.
CollinsCEMorganPJHutchessonMJet al. (2013) Efficacy of standard versus enhanced features in a Web-based commercial weight-loss program for obese adults, part 2: Randomized controlled trial. Journal of Medical Internet Research15(7): e140.
9.
DixonKJLShcherbaSKippingRR (2012) Weight loss from three commercial providers of NHS primary care slimming on referral in North Somerset: Service evaluation. Journal of Public Health34(4): 555–561.
10.
EzzatiMRiboliE (2013) Behavioral and dietary risk factors for noncommunicable diseases. New England Journal of Medicine369(10): 954–964.
11.
FinkelsteinEAKrugerE (2014) Meta- and cost-effectiveness analysis of commercial weight loss strategies. Obesity22(9): 1942–1951.
12.
FinleyCEBarlowCEGreenwayFLet al. (2007) Retention rates and weight loss in a commercial weight loss program. International Journal of Obesity31(2): 292–298.
13.
GoldBCBurkeSPintauroSet al. (2007) Weight loss on the web: A pilot study comparing a structured behavioral intervention to a commercial program. Obesity15(1): 155–164.
14.
GudzuneKADoshiRSMehtaAKet al. (2015) Efficacy of commercial weight-loss programs: An updated systematic review. Annals of Internal Medicine162(7): 501–512.
15.
GuptaSK (2011) Intention-to-treat concept: A review. Perspectives in Clinical Research2(3): 109–112.
16.
Hartmann-BoyceJJohnsDJJebbSAet al. (2014) Behavioural weight management programmes for adults assessed by trials conducted in everyday contexts: Systematic review and meta-analysis. Obesity Reviews15(11): 920–932.
17.
HemmingssonEJohanssonKErikssonJet al. (2012) Weight loss and dropout during a commercial weight-loss program including a very-low-calorie diet, a low-calorie diet, or restricted normal food: Observational cohort study. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition96(5): 953–961.
18.
HeshkaSAndersonJWAtkinsonRLet al. (2003) Weight loss with self-help compared with a structured commercial program: A randomized trial. Journal of the American Medical Association289(14): 1792–1798.
19.
HeymsfieldSBVan MierloCAJVan der KnaapHCMet al. (2003) Weight management using a meal replacement strategy: Meta and pooling analysis from six studies. International Journal of Obesity27(5): 537–549.
20.
HigginsJPTGreenS (2011) Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Inter-ventions Version 5.1.0 (updated March). Chichester, UK: The Cochrane Collaboration, John Wiley & Sons.
21.
HolzapfelCCresswellLAhernALet al. (2014) The challenge of a 2-year follow-up after intervention for weight loss in primary care. International Journal of Obesity38(6): 806–811.
22.
HutchessonMJCollinsCEMorganPJet al. (2013) An 8-week web-based weight loss challenge with celebrity endorsement and enhanced social support: Observational study. Journal of Medical Internet Research15(7): e129.
23.
JebbSAAhernALOlsonADet al. (2011) Primary care referral to a commercial provider for weight loss treatment versus standard care: A randomised controlled trial. Lancet378(9801): 1485–1492.
24.
JensenMDRyanDHApovianCMet al. (2014) 2013 AHA/ACC/TOS guideline for the management of overweight and obesity in adults: A report of the American College of Cardiology/American Heart Association Task Force on Practice Guidelines and The Obesity Society. Journal of the American College of Cardiology63(25 Pt B): 2985–3023.
25.
JohnstonBCKantersSBandayrelKet al. (2014) Comparison of weight loss among named diet programs in overweight and obese adults: A meta-analysis. Journal of the American Medical Association312(9): 923–933.
26.
JollyKLewisABeachJet al. (2011) Comparison of range of commercial or primary care led weight reduction programmes with minimal intervention control for weight loss in obesity: Lighten Up randomised controlled trial. British Medical Journal343: d6500.
27.
KrskaJLoveladyCConnollyDet al. (2010) Community pharmacy contribution to weight management: Identifying opportunities. Inter-national Journal of Pharmacy Practice18(1): 7–12.
28.
KushnerRFRyanDH (2014) Assessment and lifestyle management of patients with obesity: Clinical recommendations from systematic reviews. Journal of the American Medical Association312(9): 943–952.
29.
LaRoseJGLeaheyTMHillJOet al. (2013) Differences in motivations and weight loss behaviors in young adults and older adults in the National Weight Control Registry. Obesity21(3): 449–453.
30.
LavinJHAveryAWhiteheadSMet al. (2006) Feasibility and benefits of implementing a slimming on referral service in primary care using a commercial weight management partner. Public Health120(9): 872–881.
31.
LeskeSStrodlEHouXY (2012) A qualitative study of the determinants of dieting and non-dieting approaches in overweight/obese Australian adults. BMC Public Health12(1): 1086.
32.
LloydAKhanR (2011) Evaluation of healthy choices: A commercial weight loss programme commissioned by the NHS. Perspectives in Public Health131(4): 177–183.
33.
LoweMR (2015) Dieting: Proxy or cause of future weight gain?Obesity Reviews16(S1): 19–24.
34.
LuszczynskaASobczykAAbrahamC (2007) Planning to lose weight: Randomized controlled trial of an implementation intention prompt to enhance weight reduction among overweight and obese women. Health Psychology26(4): 507–512.
35.
MeffertCGerdesN (2010) Program adherence and effectiveness of a commercial nutrition program: The metabolic balance study. Journal of Nutrition and Metabolism2010: 197656.
36.
MellorDDWhithamCGoodwinSet al. (2014) Weight loss in a UK commercial all meal provision study: A randomised controlled trial. Journal of Human Nutrition and Dietetics27(4): 377–383.
37.
MillerBMBrennanL (2015) Measuring and reporting attrition from obesity treatment programs: A call to action!Obesity Research & Clinical Practice9(3): 187–202.
38.
MitchellNSEllisonMCHillJOet al. (2013) Evaluation of the effectiveness of making Weight Watchers available to Tennessee Medicaid (TennCare) recipients. Journal of General Internal Medicine28(1): 12–17.
39.
MoherDLiberatiATetzlaffJet al. (2009) Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. Annals of Internal Medicine151(4): 264–269.
40.
MoroshkoIBrennanLO’BrienP (2011) Predictors of dropout in weight loss interventions: A systematic review of the literature. Obesity Reviews12(11): 912–934.
41.
National Clinical Guideline Centre (2014) Obesity: Identification, Assessment and Management of Overweight and Obesity in Children, Young People and Adults: Partial Update of CG43. London: National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE).
42.
National Health and Medical Research Council (2013) Clinical Practice Guidelines for the Management of Overweight and Obesity in Adults, Adolescents and Children in Australia. Melbourne, VIC, Australia: National Health and Medical Research Council.
43.
National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) (2014) Weight Management: Lifestyle Services for Overweight or Obese Adults (PH53). London: National Institute for Health and Care Excellence.
44.
Neumark-SztainerDWallMStoryMet al. (2012) Dieting and unhealthy weight control behaviors during adolescence: Associations with 10-year changes in body mass index. Journal of Adolescent Health50(1): 80–86.
45.
NeveMMorganPJCollinsCE (2011) Weight change in a commercial web-based weight loss program and its association with website use: Cohort study. Journal of Medical Internet Research13(4): e83.
46.
NicklasJMHuskeyKWDavisRBet al. (2012) Successful weight loss among obese U.S. adults. American Journal of Preventive Medicine42(5): 481–485.
47.
O’BrienKMHutchessonMJJensenMet al. (2014) Participants in an online weight loss program can improve diet quality during weight loss: A randomized controlled trial. Nutrition Journal13: 82.
48.
O’NeilPMTheimKRBoekaAet al. (2012) Changes in weight control behaviors and hedonic hunger during a 12-week commercial weight loss program. Eating Behaviors13(4): 354–360.
49.
PintoAMFavaJLHoffmannDAet al. (2013) Combining behavioral weight loss treatment and a commercial program: A randomized clinical trial. Obesity21(4): 673–680.
50.
RockCLFlattSWSherwoodNEet al. (2010) Effect of a free prepared meal and incentivized weight loss program on weight loss and weight loss maintenance in obese and overweight women: A randomized controlled trial. Journal of the American Medical Association304(16): 1803–1810.
51.
SiahpushMTibbitsMShaikhRAet al. (2015) Dieting increases the likelihood of subsequent obesity and BMI gain: Results from a prospective study of an Australian national sample. International Journal of Behavioral Medicine22(5): 662–671.
52.
SoleymaniTDanielSGarveyW (2016) Weight maintenance: Challenges, tools and strategies for primary care physicians. Obesity Reviews17(1): 81–93.
53.
StubbsRJMorrisLPallisterCet al. (2015) Weight outcomes audit in 1.3 million adults during their first 3 months’ attendance in a commercial weight management programme. BMC Public Health15: 882.
54.
StubbsRJPallisterCWhybrowSet al. (2011) Weight outcomes audit for 34,271 adults referred to a primary care/commercial weight management partnership scheme. Obesity Facts4(2): 113–120.
55.
SumithranPProiettoJ (2013) The defence of body weight: A physiological basis for weight regain after weight loss. Clinical Science124(4): 231–241.
56.
SwinburnBSacksGVandevijvereSet al. (2013) INFORMAS (International Network for Food and Obesity/non-communicable Diseases Research, Monitoring and Action Support): Overview and key principles. Obesity Reviews14(S1): 1–12.
57.
TrubyHBaicSdeLooyAet al. (2006) Randomised controlled trial of four commercial weight loss programmes in the UK: Initial findings from the BBC “diet trials”. British Medical Journal332(7553): 1309–1314.
58.
TsaiAGWaddenTA (2005) Systematic review: An evaluation of major commercial weight loss programs in the United States. Annals of Internal Medicine142(1): 56–66.
59.
TsaiAGWaddenTA (2006) The evolution of very-low-calorie diets: An update and meta-analysis. Obesity14(8): 1283–1293.
60.
YumukVTsigosCFriedMet al. (2015) European guidelines for obesity management in adults. Obesity Facts8(6): 402–424.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
