Systematic thematic review of e-health research in the Gulf Cooperation Council (Arabian Gulf): Bahrain,Kuwait,Oman,Qatar,Saudi Arabia and United Arab Emirates
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online May, 2017
Systematic thematic review of e-health research in the Gulf Cooperation Council (Arabian Gulf): Bahrain,Kuwait,Oman,Qatar,Saudi Arabia and United Arab Emirates
The Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC or ‘Arabian Gulf’), comprising Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia and United Arab Emirates, is a political organization sharing a common history and culture. All GCC nations have made substantial investments in telecommunications and electronic health infrastructure since 2000.
Methods
We conducted a literature search in English and Arabic on peer-reviewed e-health research up to December 2014 originating in the GCC. The objective was to retrieve all research on e-health in the GCC and to categorize and analyse it qualitatively to reveal the current state of e-health research and development in the region. Inclusion criteria included peer-reviewed articles, books, book chapters, conference papers and graduate theses written on e-health in the GCC. Blogs, health websites and non-peer-reviewed literature were excluded.
Results
Three hundred and six articles were retrieved, categorized and analysed qualitatively to reveal the state of e-health research in the GCC. Both country-specific and GCC-wide major themes were identified using NVivo 10.0 qualitative software and summarized. The most common type of study was an overview (35.0%), with common study designs of case studies (26.8%) and descriptive articles (46.4%). Significant themes were: prospective national benefits from e-health, implementation and satisfaction with electronic health records, online technologies in medical education, innovative systems (case studies), and information security and personal health information.
Discussion
This is the first comprehensive analytical literature review of e-health in the GCC. Important research gaps were identified: few cost-benefit analyses, controlled interventional studies, or research targeting gender and religious issues were retrieved.
International Telecommunications Union (ITU). ICT facts and figures 2015, Percentage of individuals using the Internet; mobile-cellular subscriptions, www.itu.int/en/ITU-D/Statistics/Pages/stat/default.aspx (2015, accessed 30 November 2015).
2.
GottingF. Healing hands of Qatar, Doha: Doha Modern Printing Press, 2006, pp. 165–167.
WeberASVerjeeMRahmanZH. Typology and credibility of Internet health websites originating from Gulf Cooperation Council countries. East Mediterr Health J2015; 20: 804–811.
5.
SJR Journal and Country Rank: Saudi Arabia. Citable documents: Medicine 1996–2014, www.scimagojr.com/countryrank.php (2015, accessed 26 November 2015).
6.
SiddiqiSShennawyAMirzaZ. Assessing trade in health services in countries of the Eastern Mediterranean from a public health perspective. Int J Health Plann Manage2010; 25: 231–250.
7.
Qurban MH and Austria RD. eHealth strategies to manage cost, market potential, and business opportunities among four Middle East countries. In: Third eServices symposium: The future of eServices: The next step? (ed MA Abdellatif), Khobar, Saudi Arabia, 26–27 February 2008, pp.113–130. Hofuf: King Faisal University.
8.
Qurban MH and Austria RD. E-health readiness among four Middle East countries: Implications of SWOT analysis. Saudi Association for Health Informatics, www.sahi.org.sa (2008, accessed 20 November 2015).
9.
Al AlawiEAhmedAA. Screening for diabetic retinopathy: The first telemedicine approach in a primary care setting in Bahrain. Middle East Afr J Ophthalmol2012; 19: 295–298.
10.
AlyusufRHPrasadKAbdel SatirAM. Development and validation of a tool to evaluate the quality of medical education websites in pathology. J Pathol Inform2013; 4: 29–29.
11.
Al SalmanJMHaniSde Marcellis-WarinN. Effectiveness of an electronic hand hygiene monitoring system on healthcare workers’ compliance to guidelines. J Infect Public Health2015; 8: 117–126.
12.
LattimoreM Jr. A store-forward ophthalmic telemedicine case report from deployed U.S. army forces in Kuwait. Telemed J1999; 5: 309–313.
13.
FrancisaIMJunaidaTADajanibYF. Static image telepathology in routine surgical pathology diagnosis: A report on the first experience in the Arab world from Kuwait. Med Princ Pract1999; 8: 255–265.
14.
PattersonVSwinfenPSwinfenR. Supporting hospital doctors in the Middle East by email telemedicine: Something the industrialized world can do to help. J Med Internet Res2007; 9: e30–e30.
15.
McManusJSalinasJMortonM. Teleconsultation program for deployed soldiers and healthcare professionals in remote and austere environments. Prehosp Disaster Med2008; 23: 210–216, 217.
ConwayNTWotayanRAAlkuzamA. The Kuwait–Scotland eHealth innovation network (KSeHIN): A sustainable approach to quality improvement in healthcare. Qual Prim Care2014; 22: 43–51.
18.
WeberAS. Folk medicine in Oman. Int J Arts Sci2011; 4: 237–274.
19.
Al-FutaisiASaifAYAl-ZakwaniI. Clinical and epidemiological characteristics of pituitary tumours using a web-based pituitary tumour registry in Oman. Sultan Qaboos Univ Med J2007; 7: 25–30.
ICTQatar. Emerging ICT trends in Qatar, Doha, Qatar: The Ministry of Information and Communications Technology, 2014, pp. 6–6.
22.
Al-HajAAmerA. Secured telemedicine using region-based watermarking with tamper localization. J Digit Imaging2014; 27: 737–750.
23.
Mehmood WB, Hassan A, Touati F, et al. A fully functional secure ubiquitous healthcare monitoring system. In: ARC ’14. Qatar Foundation Annual Research Conference, Doha, Quatar, 18–19 November 2014. Doha: Quatar Foundation.
24.
Duke DL, Thorpe C, Mahmoud M, et al. Intelligent diabetes assistant: Using machine learning to help manage diabetes. In: Proceedings of international conference on computer systems and applications, 2008, AICCSA 2008. Piscataway, NJ, 31 March–4 April 2008, pp.913–914. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE.
25.
Alhazbi S, Alkhateeb M, Abdi A, et al. Mobile application for diabetes control in Qatar. In: Proceedings of the 8th international conference on computing technology and information management (ICCM), Seoul, South Korea, April 2012, vol. 2, pp.763–766. Seoul, South Korea: IEEE.
26.
Mansar SL and Kekre S. A Founding framework for addressing obesity in Qatar using mobile technologies. In: CENTERIS 2011, Part III, CCIS 221 (ed MM Cruz-Cunha, et al.), Vilamoura, Portugal, 2011, pp.402–412. NY: Springer.
27.
Weber AS and Musson DM. Educational considerations in the development of e-health systems in the Gulf Cooperation Council countries (GCC). In: Proceedings of the 8th IASTED international conference on web-based education, WBE 2010 (ed V Uskov), 2010, Sharm El-Sheikh, Egypt, pp.1–6. Sharm El-Sheikh: IASTED.
28.
AlkadiKRoudsariA. TeMaD system: Telecare for managing diabetes in Saudi Arabia. Stud Health Technol Inform2013; 183: 57–62.
29.
Al-HussainFA. Principles and practice of thrombolysis via telestroke. Neurosciences (Riyadh)2014; 19: 178–182.
30.
SwettHAHoladayLLeffellD. Telemedicine: Delivering medical expertise across the state and around the world. Conn Med1995; 59: 593–602.
31.
HousehMAlsughayarAAl-MutairiM. Empowering Saudi patients: How do Saudi health websites compare to international health websites?Stud Health Technol Inform2013; 183: 296–301.
32.
Al Huziah M, Al Kahtany R, Al Ammari R, et al. Assessment of online health information for Arabic sites. Geneva: Health on the Net Foundation; Riyadh: King Saud Bin Abdulaziz University for Health Science, 2009.
33.
King Abdullah bin Abdulaziz Arabic Health Encyclopedia (www.kaahe.org): A reliable source for health information in Arabic in the Internet. Saudi J Med Med Sci 2013; 1: 53–54.
34.
Bin-AbbasBJabbariMAl-FaresA. Effect of mobile phone short text messages on glycaemic control in children with type 1 diabetes. J Telemed Telecare2014; 20: 153–156.
35.
YoussefAAlharthiHAl KhaldiO. Effectiveness of text message reminders on nonattendance of outpatient clinic appointments in three different specialties: A randomized controlled trial in a Saudi hospital. J T U Med Sc2014; 9: 23–29.
36.
Alanzi TM, Istepanian RSH, Philip N, et al. A study on perception of managing diabetes mellitus through social networking in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. In: XIII Mediterranean conference on medical and biological engineering and computing 2013 (ed LM Roa Romero), 1907 IFMBE Proceedings 4. Seville, Spain: IFMBE.
37.
GoldbergMASharifHSRosenthalDI. Making global telemedicine practical and affordable: Demonstrations from the Middle East. AJR Am J Roentgenol1994; 163: 1495–1500.
38.
NormanJNBrebnerJABrebnerE. International telemedicine. J Telemed Telecare1997; 3: 111–114.
BrebnerEMBrebnerJANormanJN. A pilot study in medical education using interactive television. J Telemed Telecare1997; 3(Suppl. 1): 10–12.
41.
Lootah K, Amin S and Taawfik H. National health framework: The UAE vision. In: 4th e-health conference in the Middle East (ed S Aziz Anwar), Dubai, 30 January–2 February 2012, pp.134–141. Dubai, UAE: Hamdan Bin Mohammed e-University.
42.
PearlPLSableCEvansS. International telemedicine consultations for neurodevelopmental disabilities. Telemed J E Health2014; 20: 559–562.
43.
AbuKhousaEMohamedNAl-JaroodiJ. e-Health Cloud: Opportunities and challenges. Fut Internet2012; 4: 621–645.
44.
BenharrefASerhaniMA. Novel cloud and SOA-based framework for e-health monitoring using wireless biosensors. IEEE J Biomed Health Inform2014; 18: 46–55.
