In recent years, academic literature has stressed the declining importance of social class and religion as determinants of vote. In particular, many scholars have found that the working-class vote is no longer mostly addressed to socialist parties, whereas religious people still massively support confessional and conservative parties. This article explores the actual resilience of the two cleavages with particular attention to the relationship between religion and socialist parties. Our analysis, based on European Social Survey (ESS) data covering 13 West European countries in the period 2002–2014, proves that ‘a-religiosity’ – negative attitudes towards religion – has overcome social class as the determinant of a socialist vote, thanks to the emergence of a divisive ethical–moral agenda. This process is more visible in those countries where the Church and religious associations play an active role in the political arena and the ethical–moral issues have been politicized, as in Catholic and multi-faith countries.
AlbækEGreen-PedersenCLarsenLT (2012) Morality issues in Denmark: policies without politics In: EngeliIGreen-PedersenCLarsenLT (eds), Morality Politics in Western EuropeLondon: Palgrave Macmillan, pp 137–160.
2.
BaleT (2012) The Conservatives since 1945: The Drivers of Party ChangeOxford: Oxford University Press
3.
BartoliniS (2011) Cleavages: Social and Political In: BadieBBerg-SchlosserDMorlinoL (eds) International Encyclopedia of Political Science. Thousand Oacks: Sage Publications, pp 276–282
4.
BartoliniSMairP (1990) Identity Competition and Electoral Availability. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Beck-GernsheimEBeckU (2002) Institutionalized Individualism and its Social and Political ConsequencesLondon: Sage
7.
BellD (1973) The Coming of the Post-industrial Society. New York: Basic Books.
8.
BonafontLCRoquéAMP (2012) From Prohibition to Permissiveness: A Two-Wave Change on Morality Issues in Spain In: EngeliIGreen-PedersenCLarsenLT (eds) Morality Politics in Western Europe. London: Palgrave Macmillan, pp 62–87.
9.
BornschierS (2010) The new cultural divide and the two-dimensional political space in Western EuropeWest European Politics33(3): 419–444
10.
BroughtonDten NapelHM (eds), (2000) Religion and mass electoral behaviour in Europe. London: Routledge
11.
BrookeS (2011) Sexual Politics: Sexuality, Family Planning, and the British Left from the 1880s to the Present DayOxford: Oxford University Press
12.
CorderoG (2017) Three decades of religious vote in EuropeWorld Political Science13(1): 77–98
13.
DaltonRJWeldonS (2007) Partisanship and party system institutionalizationParty Politics13(2): 179–196
14.
DargentCMichelatG (2012) Le vote des catholiquesParis: SciencesPo
15.
DavieG (1994) Religion in Britain since 1945: Believing without Belonging. Oxford: Blackwell.
16.
DobbelaereK (1981) Secularization A Multi-Dimensional Concept. London: Sage.
17.
DobbelaereKPérez-AgoteA (eds), (2015). The Intimate Polity and the Catholic Church: Laws about Life, Death and the Family in so-called Catholic Countries. Leuven: Leuven University Press
18.
DobbelaereKVoyéL (2015) Euthanasia and the Belgian Catholic world. In: DobbelaereKPérez-AgoteA (eds). The intimate Polity and the Catholic Church – Laws about life, death and the family in so-called Catholic countries. Leuven: Leuven University Press, 13–54.
19.
DuncanF (2006) A decade of Christian democratic decline: the dilemmas of the CDU, ÖVP and CDA in the 1990sGovernment and Opposition41(4): 469–490
20.
DuncanF (2015) Preaching to the converted? Christian Democratic voting in six Western European countries. Party Politics21(4): 577–590.
21.
ElffM (2007) Social structure and electoral behavior in comparative perspective: The decline of social cleavages in Western Europe revisitedPerspectives on Politics5(2): 277–294
22.
EngeliIGreen-PedersenCLarsenLT (eds), (2012a) Morality Politics in Western Europe. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
23.
EngeliIGreen-PedersenCLarsenL T (2012b) Theoretical perspectives on morality issues In: Green-PedersenCLarsenL T (eds) Morality Politics in Western Europe. London: Palgrave Macmillan, pp 5–26.
24.
EngeliIVaroneF (2012) Morality politics in Switzerland: politicization through direct democracy In: EngeliIGreen-PedersenCLarsenLT (eds) Morality Politics in Western Europe. London: Palgrave Macmillan, pp 88–113.
25.
EngeliIGreen-PedersenCLarsenL T (2013) The puzzle of permissiveness: understanding policy processes concerning morality issuesJournal of European Public Policy20(3): 335–352
26.
EriksonRGoldthorpeJ HPortocareroL (1979) Intergenerational class mobility in three Western European societies: England, France and SwedenThe British Journal of Sociology30(4): 415–441
27.
EuchnerE M (2019) Morality Politics in a Secular AgeCham: Palgrave Macmillan
28.
EuchnerE-MPreidelC (2018) Dropping the curtain: the religious-secular party cleavage in German morality politics. Politics and Religion11: 221–248.
29.
EvansG (2000) The continued significance of class votingAnnual Review of Political Science3(1): 401–417
30.
EvansGDe GraafN D (eds), (2013) Political choice matters: explaining the strength of class and religious cleavages in cross-national perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
31.
EvansGNorthmore-BallK (2017) Class and religious cleavages In: FisherJFieldhouseEFranklinMN, et al (eds) The Routledge Handbook of Elections, Voting Behavior and Public Opinion. London: Routledge.
32.
FernándezS A (2012) Fighting against the moral agenda of Zapatero’s socialist government (2004-2011): the Spanish Catholic Church as a political contender. Politics and Religion5(3): 671–694.
33.
FinkS (2008) Politics as usual or bringing religion back in?Comparative Political Studies41(12): 1631–1656
34.
FranklinM N (2010) Cleavage research: a critical appraisalWest European Politics33(3): 648–658
35.
FranklinM NMackieTValenH (1992) Electoral Change: Responses to Evolving Social and Attitudinal Structures in Western CountriesCambridge: Cambridge University Press
36.
FreireABaumM A (2003) Referenda voting in Portugal, 1998: the effects of party sympathies, social structure and pressure groups. European Journal of Political Research42(1): 135–161.
37.
FreireASantana-PereiraJ (2012) Economic voting in Portugal, 2002-2009Electoral Studies31(3): 506–512
38.
FursethI (2018) Religious Complexity in the Public Sphere Comparing Nordic Countries. Cham: Springer.
39.
GiddensA (1994) Modernity and Self-Identity. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
40.
GoldbergAC (2014) The impact of religion on voting behaviour - a multilevel approach for SwitzerlandSwiss Political Science Review20(2): 305–329
41.
GouldAC (1999) Origins of Liberal Dominance: State, Church, and Party in Nineteenth-Century EuropeAnn Arbour: University of Michigan Press
42.
GuntherRMonteroJR (2009) The Politics of SpainCambridge: Cambridge University Press
43.
HalmanLVan IngenE (2015) Secularization and changing moral views: European trends in church attendance and views on homosexuality, divorce, abortion, and euthanasia. European Sociological Review31(5): 616–627.
44.
HoutmanD (2003) Class and Politics in Contemporary Social Science:" Marxism Lite" and its Blind Spot for CultureNew Brunswich: Transaction Publishers
45.
IannacconeLR (1992) Religious markets and the economics of religionSocial Compass39(1): 123–131
46.
InglehartR (1977) The Silent Revolution. Changing Values and Political Styles Among Western Publics. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
47.
InglehartRNorrisP (2004) Sacred and Secular: Religion and Politics Worldwide Cambridge Studies in Social Theory, Religion, and PoliticsCambridge: Cambridge University Press
48.
JansenGDe GraafNDNeedA (2012) Explaining the breakdown of the religion-vote relationship in The Netherlands, 1971-2006West European Politics35(4): 756–783
49.
JansenGEvansGde GraafND (2013) Class voting and left-right party positions: a comparative study of fifteen western democracies, 1960-2005. In: EvansGde GraafND (eds). Political choice matters: explaining the strength of class and religious cleavages in cross-national perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
50.
KalyvasS (1996) The Rise of Christian Democracy in EuropeIthaca and London: Cornell University Press
51.
KirchheimerO (1966) The transformation of the Western European party systems. In: LaPalombaraJWeinerM (eds). Political parties and political development. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 177–200.
52.
KnillCPreidelCNebelK (2014) Brake rather than barrier: The impact of the Catholic Church on morality policies in Western EuropeWest European Politics37(5): 845–866
53.
KnillCAdamCHurkaS (eds), On the road to permissiveness? Change and convergence of moral regulation in Europe (2015) (eds). Oxford: Oxford University Press
54.
KnutsenO (2004) Religious denomination and party choice in western Europe: a comparative longitudinal study from eight countries, 1970-97International Political Science Review25(1): 97–128
55.
KnutsenO (2017) Social Structure, Value Orientations and Party Choice in Western EuropeCham: Springer Nature
56.
KriesiHPGrandeEDolezalM, et al. (2012) Political Conflict in Western Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
57.
LarsenLTStudlarDTGreen-PedersenC (2012) Morality Politics in the United Kingdom: Trapped between Left and Right In: EngeliIGreen-PedersenCLarsenLT (eds), London: Palgrave Macmillan, pp 114–136
58.
LövheimMLindbergJBotvarPK, et al. (2018) Religion on the political agenda In: FursethI (ed), Religious Complexity in the Public Sphere Comparing Nordic CountriesCham: Springer, pp 137–191
59.
LindbergJ (2013) Religion in Nordic party platforms 1988-2008Nordic Journal of Religion and Society26(2): 121–139
60.
LinzJJ (1980) Religion and politics in Spain: from conflict to consensus above cleavageSocial Compass27(2–3): 255–277
61.
LipsetSMRokkanS (1967) Cleavage structures, party systems, and voter alignments: an introduction. In: LipsetSMRokkanS (eds). Party systems and voter alignments: Cross-national perspectives. New York, NY: Free Press, 1–64.
62.
MadeleyJ (2000) Reading the Runes In: BroughtonDten NapelHM (eds) Religion and Mass Electoral Behaviour. London: Routledge, pp 28–43
63.
MadeleyJ (2003) A framework for the comparative analysis of church-state relations in EuropeWest European Politics26(1): 23–50
64.
ManzaJWrightN (2003) Religion and political behavior. In: Handbook of the Sociology of Religion. Sage
65.
MairP (1992) Expalining the absence of class in IrelandProceedings of the British Academy79: 393–410
66.
MairPWeeksL (2005) The party system In: CoakleyJGallangherM (eds), Politics in the Republic of IrelandAbingdon: Routledge, pp 135–159
67.
MarksGAttewellDRovnyJHoogheL (2021) Cleavage Theory. In: RiddervoldMTrondalJNewsomeA (eds). The Palgrave Handbook of EU Crisis. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan, 173–193.
68.
MichelatGSimonM (1977) Classe, religion et comportement politique. Paris: Presses de Sciences Po.
69.
MinkenbergM (2002) Religion and public policyComparative Political Studies35(2): 221–247
70.
MinkenbergM (2003) The policy impact of church-state relations: family policy and abortion in Britain, France, and GermanyWest European Politics26(1): 195–217
71.
MinkenbergM (2010) Party politics, religion and elections in Western democraciesComparative European Politics8(4): 385–414
72.
MonizJB (2019) A culture of secularity? The phenomenon of non- religion in 21st century Portuguese society and politics. Journal for the Study of Religions and Ideologies18(53): 123–140.
73.
MonteroJRCalvoKMartínezÁ (2008) El voto religioso en España y PortugalRevista Internacional de Sociología66(51): 19–54
74.
NieuwbeertaP (1995) The Democratic Class Struggle in Twenty Countries 1945-1990Amsterdam: Thesis Publishers
75.
NorrisPInglehartR (2019) Cultural Backlash: Trump, Brexit, and Authoritarian Populism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
76.
OeschD (2006) Coming to grips with a changing class structureInternational Sociology21(2): 263–288
77.
OeschD (2013) Occupational Change in Europe: How Technology and Education Transform the Job StructureOxford: Oxford University Press
78.
OskarsonM (2005) Social Structure and Party Choice In: ThomassenJ (ed), Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp 84–105. The European Voter A Comparative Study of Modern
79.
PuirseilN (2009) Catholic Stakhanovites? Religion and the Irish Labour Party. In: DevineFLaneFPuirseilN (eds). Essays in Irish Labour History: A Festschrift for Elizabeth and John W. Boyle. Dublin: Irish Academic Press, 177–198.
80.
RennwaldL (2020) Social Democratic Parties and the Working Class: New Voting PatternsLondon: Palgrave McMillan
81.
ResendeMMHennigA (2015) Shunning direct intervention: explaining the exceptional behaviour of the Portuguese Church hierarchy in morality politicsNew Diversities17(1): 145–160
82.
ReyH (2004) La gauche et les classes populaires: histoire et actualité d’une mésententeParis: La Découverte
83.
RibberinkEAchterbergPHoutmanD (2015) Are all socialists anti-religious? anti-religiosity and the socialist left in 21 Western European Countries (1990-2008)Journal of Contemporary Religion30(3): 435–452
84.
RibberinkEAchterbergPHoutmanD (2018) Religious polarization: contesting religion in secularized Western European countriesJournal of Contemporary Religion33(2): 209–227
RoseRUrwinD (1969) Social cohesion, political parties and strains in regimesComparative Political Studies2(1): 7–67
87.
RoseR (1974) The Problem of Party GovernmentLondon: Macmillan
88.
StudlarDTBurnsGJ (2015) Toward the permissive society? Morality policy agendas and policy directions in Western democraciesPolicy Sciences48(3): 273–291
89.
TilleyJ (2015) 'We Don't Do God'? Religion and Party Choice in BritainThe British Journal of Psychiatry. Supplement45(4): 907–927
90.
TimmermansABreemanG. (2012) Morality issues in the Netherlands: coalition politics under pressure. In: EngeliIGreen-PedersenCLarsenLT (eds). Morality Politics in Western Europe. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 35–61.
91.
TouraineA (1969) La société post-industrielle. Paris: Denoël.
92.
Van der BrugWB HoboltSSde VreeseCH (2009) Religion and party choice in EuropeWest European Politics32(6): 1266–1283
93.
Van der EijkCFranklinM (2009) Elections and Voters. London: Macmillan International.
94.
Van HauteEPiletJBSandriG (2012) Still religious parties in Belgium? The decline of the denominational cleavage in the Belgian consociational democracy In: ForetFItçainaX (eds) Politics of Religion in Western Europe: Modernities in Conflict?London: Routledge, pp 144–169.
95.
Van KersbergenK (2008) The Christian democratic phoenix and modern unsecular politicsParty Politics14(3): 259–279
96.
ZiblattD (2017) Conservative Political Parties and the Birth of Modern Democracy in EuropeCambridge: Cambridge University Press
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
