How do newspapers frame female politicians, and does this framing change after a female politician's death during an election campaign? Benazir Bhutto, who served two terms as prime minister of Pakistan, was assassinated in 2007 by a terrorist group. South Asian newspapers framed her as corrupt, inefficient, and a threat to national security before her death; however, the elite press characterized her as a martyr and sage posthumously. Using qualitative content analysis, this study examines the editorial coverage of two newspapers (The Hindu and The Times of India) in India and two newspapers (The News and The Dawn) in Pakistan to examine how these elite newspapers framed Benazir Bhutto before and after her tragic death. We found that the framing of the slain leader changed from negative to positive after her assassination. The study concludes that her assassination influenced the media coverage and produced a eulogy effect that helped her party stay in power after her assassination.
AliS (2018) Political martyrs: sympathy vote and elections in South Asia. South Asian Politics9(2): 201–218.
2.
AltschullJH (1995) Agents of Power: The Media and Public Policy. New York: Prentice Hall.
3.
BabiakKSantSL (2020) All the news that’s fit to print? How the media frames professional athlete philanthropy. Journal of Sport Management1(aop): 1–14.
4.
BigioJVogelsteinR (2020) Women under attack: the backlash against female politicians. Foreign Affairs1: 131.
5.
BracicAIsrael-TrummelMShortleAF (2019) Is sexism for white people? Gender stereotypes, race, and the 2016 presidential election. Political Behavior41(2): 281–307.
6.
CohenBC (2015) The Press and Foreign Policy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
7.
CollierCNRaneyT (2018) Understanding sexism and sexual harassment in politics: a comparison of Westminster parliaments in Australia, the United Kingdom, and Canada. Social Politics: International Studies in Gender, State & Society25(3): 432–455.
GorenLJ(ed) (2009) You’ve Come a Long Way Baby: Women, Politics, and Popular Culture. Lexington: The University Press of Kentucky.
10.
FiskeAP (2019) Kama Muta: Discovering the Connecting Emotion. New York: Routledge.
11.
FoosFGilardiF (2020) Does exposure to gender role models increase women’s political ambition? A field experiment with politicians. Journal of Experimental Political Science7(3): 157–166.
12.
FukuyamaF (1998) Women and the evolution of world politics. Foreign Affairs77(5): 24–40.
13.
GauntlettD (2008) Media, Gender and Identity: An Introduction. New York: Psychology Press. and unmaking of the new left. Berkley, LA: University of California Press.
14.
GuzmanAL (2016) Evolution of news frames during the 2011 Egyptian revolution: critical discourse analysis of Fox News’s and CNN’s framing of protesters, Mubarak, and the Muslim Brotherhood. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly93(1): 80–98.
15.
HaJS (2017) Tailoring the Arab Spring to American values and interests: a framing analysis of US elite newspapers’ opinion pieces. International Communication Gazette79(3): 276–297.
16.
HaraldssonAWängnerudL (2019) The effect of media sexism on women’s political ambition: evidence from a worldwide study. Feminist Media Studies19(4): 525–541.
17.
HermanESChomskyN (2010) Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media. New York: Random House.
18.
HorwitzLSwyersH (2009) Why are all the presidents’ men? Televisual presidents and patriarchy. In: GorenLJ (ed) You’ve Come a Long Way Baby: Women, Politics and Popular Culture. Lexington: The University Press of Kentucky, pp.115–136.
19.
HsiehHFShannonSE (2005) Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qualitative Health Research15(9): 1277–1288.
20.
IyengarS (1991) Is Anyone Responsible: How Television Frames Political Issues?Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
21.
JaspersonAE (2006) Media as moderator of “the Sympathy Effect”: testing a model of the sympathy vote in political campaigns. Journal of Political Marketing5(1-2): 173–197.
22.
JenningsFJCokerCR (2020) ‘I just don’t think she has a presidential look:’ the influence of sexism on candidate image. Information, Communication & Society23(9): 1353–1367.
23.
KahnKF (1994) The distorted mirror: press coverage of women candidates for statewide office. The Journal of Politics56(1): 154–173.
24.
KnüpferCBEntmanRM (2018) Framing conflicts in digital and transnational media environments. Media, War & Conflict11(4): 476–488.
25.
MalikM (2007) Democracy and Liberal Politics in Pakistan. Islamabad: Institute of Policy Studies.
26.
ManneK (2020) Entitled: How male privilege hurts women. New York: Crown.
27.
McQuailDDeuzeM (2020) McQuail’s Media and Mass Communication Theory. London: Sage.
28.
NairK (2007, March 7) Talking politics in India. The Nation, p. 6.
29.
NitzMWestH (2004) Framing of newspaper news. In: MahwahSS (ed) The Environmental Communication Yearbook. New Jersey, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, pp.204–216.
30.
RaiP (2009, February) Bhutto’s political legacy. The Herald, 17–24. Available at: http://herald.dawn.com/.
31.
RobinsonPGoddardPParryK, et al. (2009) Testing models of media performance in wartime: uK TV news and the 2003 invasion of Iraq. Journal of Communication59(3): 534–563.
32.
SazaliHBasitL (2020) Meta analysis of women politician portrait in mass media frames. Journal Komunikasi: Malaysian Journal of Communication36(2): 320–334.
33.
SemetkoHAValkenburgPM (2000) Framing European politics: a content analysis of press and television news. Journal of Communication50(2): 93–109.
34.
SharifS (2018) The Slain Daughter: Framing Benazir Bhutto. New Delhi: Oriental Press.
35.
SmithMARackawayCAndersonK (2002) The eulogy effect: Candidate death and its effect on media coverage in a US Senate campaign. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Southwest Political Science Association Meeting, March 28–31, New Orleans.
36.
Van der PasDJAalderingL (2020) Gender differences in political media coverage: a meta-analysis. Journal of Communication70(1): 114–143.
37.
Van ZoonenL (2005) Entertaining the Citizen. Oxford: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
38.
WardO (2016) Seeing double: race, gender, and coverage of minority women's campaigns for the US house of representatives. Politics & Gender12(2): 317–343.
39.
WinfreyKLSchnoebelenJM (2019) Running as a woman (or man): a review of research on political communicators and gender stereotypes. Review of Communication Research7: 109–138.
40.
WolbrechtCCampbellDE (2007) Leading by example: female members of parliament as political role models. American Journal of Political Science51(4): 921–939.
41.
WolbrechtCCampbellDE (2017) Role models revisited: youth, novelty, and the impact of female candidates. Politics, Groups, and Identities5(3): 418–434.
42.
ZelizerBAllanS (2011) Journalism After 9/11. New York: Routledge.
