Newborn Male Circumcision with Parental Consent,as Stated in the AAP Circumcision Policy Statement,Is Both Legal and Ethical

Abstract

Newborn male circumcision is a minor surgical procedure that has generated significant controversy. Accumulating evidence supports significant health benefits, most notably reductions in urinary tract infections, acquisition of HIV and a number of other sexually transmitted infections, penile cancer, phimosis, paraphimosis, balanitis and lichen sclerosis. While circumcision, like any surgical procedure, has risks for complications, they occur in less than 1 in 500 infants circumcised and most are minor and require minimal intervention. The CDC and the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) believe that health benefits of circumcision outweigh the risks. For this reason, the AAP believes that parents should be allowed to make the decision concerning circumcision of their male infants after receiving non-biased information on health risks and health benefits.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Benatar and

Benatar , “Between Prophylaxis and Child Abuse: The Ethics of Neonatal Male Circumcision,” American Journal of Bioethics 32, no. 2 (2003): 35-48.

J. S.

Svoboda

, “Circumcision of Male Infants as a Human Rights Violation,” Journal of Medical Ethics 39, no. 7 (2013): 469-474.

B. J.

Morris

, “Why Circumcision is a Biomedical Imperative for the 21(st) Century,” Bioessays 29, no. 11 (2007): 1147-1158.

S. L.

Sansom

et al. , “Cost-Effectiveness of Newborn Circumcision in Reducing Lifetime HIV Risk among U.S. Males,” Public Library of Science One 5, no. 1 (2010): e8723.

H. C.

Thompson

et al.

“Report of the Ad Hoc Task Force on Circumcision,”

Pediatrics 56, no. 4 (1975): 610-611.

American Academy of Pediatrics, “Report of the Task Force on Circumcision,” Pediatrics 84, no. 2 (1989): 388-391.

Task Force on Circumcision, American Academy of Pediatrics, “Circumcision Policy Statement,” Pediatrics 103 no. 3 (1999): 686-693.

“Male Circumcision,”

Pediatrics 130, no. 3 (2012): e756-785.

Committee on Bioethics, American Academy of Pediatrics, “Informed Consent, Parental Permission, and Assent in Pediatric Practice,” Pediatrics 95 no. 2 (1995): 314-317.

10.

“Male Circumcision,”

supra note 8.

11.

Id.

12.

D. K.

Smith , et al., “Male Circumcision in the United States for the Prevention of HIV Infection and Other Adverse Health Outcomes: Report from a CDC Consultation,” Public Health Report 125 Supplement 1 (2010): 72-82.

13.

N. N.

Shaikh

et al. , “Prevalence of Urinary Tract Infection in Childhood: A Meta-Analysis,” Pediatric Infectious Disease Journal 27 no. 4 (2008): 302-308; D. J. Singh-Grewal et al., “Circumcision for the Prevention of Urinary Tract Infection in Boys: A Systematic Review of Randomized Trials and Observational Studies,” Archives of Diseases in Childhood 90 no. 8 (2005): 853-858; T. To, et al., “Cohort Study on Circumcision of Newborn Boys and Subsequent Risk of Urinary-Tract Infection,” The Lancet 352, no. 9143 (1998): 1813-1816.

14.

B. D.

Auvert

et al. , “Randomized, Controlled Intervention Trial of Male Circumcision for Reduction of HIV Infection Risk: The ANRS 1265 Trial,” Public Library of Science Medicine 2, no. 11 (2005): e298; R. H. Gray et al., “Male Circumcision for HIV Prevention in Men in Rakai, Uganda: A Randomised Trial,” The Lancet 369, no. 9562 (2007): 657-666; R. C. Bailey et al., “Male Circumcision for HIV Prevention in Young Men in Kisumu, Kenya: A Randomised Controlled Trial,” The Lancet 369, no. 9562 (2007): 643-656.

15.

A. R.

Giuliano

et al. , “Circumcision and Sexual Behavior: Factors Independently Associated with Human Papillomavirus Detection Among Men in the HIM Study,” International Journal of Cancer 124, no. 6 (2009): 1251-1257;

Nielson

et al. , “Associations between Male Anogenital Human Papillomavirus Infection and Circumcision by Anatomic Site Sampled and Lifetime Number of Female Sex Partners,” Journal of Infectious Diseases 199, no. 1 (2009): 7-13;

B. Y.

Hernandez

et al. , “Circumcision and Human Papillomavirus Infection in Men: A Site-Specific Comparison,” Journal of Infectious Diseases 197 no. 6 (2008): 787-794;

S. B.

Baldwin

et al. , “Condom Use and Other Factors Affecting Penile Human Papillomavirus Detection in Men Attending A Sexually Transmitted Disease Clinic,” Sexually Transmitted Diseases 31, no. 10 (2004): 601-607;

Castellsague

et al. , “Male Circumcision, Penile Human Papillomavirus Infection, and Cervical Cancer in Female Partners,” New England Journal of Medicine 346, no. 15 (2002): 1105-1112;

E. I.

Svare

et al. , “Risk Factors for Genital HPV DNA in Men Resemble those Found in Women: A Study of Male Attendees at a Danish STD Clinic,” Sexually Transmitted Infections 78, no. 3 (2002): 215-218;

B. J.

Auvert

et al. , “Effect of Male Circumcision on the Prevalence of High-Risk Human Papillomavirus in Young Men: Results of a Randomized Controlled Trial Conducted in Orange Farm, South Africa,” Journal of Infectious Diseases 199, no. 1 (2009): 14-19;

A. A.

Tobian

et al. , “Male Circumcision for the Prevention of HSV-2 and HPV Infections and Syphilis,” New England Journal of Medicine 360, no. 13 (2009): 1298-1309;

H. A.

Weiss

et al. , “Male Circumcision and Risk of Syphilis, Chancroid, and Genital Herpes: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis,” Sexually Transmitted Infections 82, no. 2 (2006): 101-109; discussion 110;

Sobngwi-Tambekou

et al. , “Male Circumcision and Neisseria Gonorrhoeae, Chlamydia Trachomatis and Trichomonas Vaginalis: Observations After a Randomised Controlled Trial for HIV Prevention,” Sexually Transmitted Infections 85, no. 2 (2009): 116-120;

T. L.

Cherpes

et al. , “Risk Factors for Infection with Herpes Simplex Virus Yype 2: Role of Smoking, Douching, Uncircumcised Males, and Vaginal Flora,” Sexually Transmitted Diseases 30 no. 5 (2003): 405-410;

Todd

et al. , “Risk Factors for Active Syphilis and TPHA Seroconversion in a Rural African Population,” Sexually Transmitted Infections 77, no. 1 (2001): 37-45;

S. G.

Mahiane

et al. , “Transmission Probabilities of HIV and Herpes Simplex Virus Type 2, Effect of Male Circumcision and Interaction: A Longitudinal Study in a Township of South Africa,” AIDS 23, no. 3 (2009): 377-383.

16.

J. R.

Daling

et al. , “Penile Cancer: Importance of Circumcision, Human Papillomavirus and Smoking in In Situ and Invasive Disease,” International Journal of Cancer 116, no. 4 (2005): 606-616;

H. F.

Tsen

et al. , “Risk Factors for Penile Cancer: Results of a Population-Based Case-Control Study in Los Angeles County (United States),” Cancer Causes and Control 12 no. 3 (2001): 267-277.

17.

D. M.

Fergusson

et al. , “Neonatal Circumcision and Penile Problems: An 8-Year Longitudinal Study,” Pediatrics 81, no. 4 (1988): 537-541;

S. B.

Verma and

Wollina , “Looking Through the Cracks of Diabetic Candidal Balanoposthitis!” International Journal of General Medicine 4 (2011): 511-513;

Vunda

et al. , “Videos in Clinical Medicine: Reduction of Paraphimosis in Boys,” New England Journal of Medicine 368, no. 13 (2013): e16.

18.

F. M.

Kohn

et al. , “Penile Skin Diseases,” Andrologia 31, Supplement 1 (1999): 3-11.

19.

See

Castellsague

et al. , supra note 115;

A. A.

Tobian and

R. H.

Gray , “Male Foreskin and Oncogenic Human Papillomavirus Infection in Men and their Female Partners,” Future Microbiology 6, no. 7 (2011): 739-745.

20.

“Sexually Transmitted Diseases: Bacterial Vaginosis,” (2010), available at <www.cdc.gov/std/bv/STDFact-Bacterial-Vaginosis.htm> (last visited October 14, 2013);

R. H.

Gray

et al. , “The Effects of Male Circumcision on Female Partners' Genital Tract Symptoms and Vaginal Infections in a Randomized Trial in Rakai, Uganda,” American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 200 no. 1 (2009): 42 e41-47.

21.

B. J.

Morris and

T. E.

Wiswell , “Circumcision and Lifetime Risk of Urinary Tract Infection: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis,” Journal of Urology 189, no. 6 (2013): 2118-2124.

22.

Ib.

23.

Gucuk

et al. , “Do Antibiotic Prophylaxis and/or Circumcision Change Periurethral Uropathogen Colonization and Urinary Tract Infection Rates in Boys with VUR?” Journal of Pediatric Urology 9, no. 12 (2013):1131-1136.

24.

See

Auvert

et al. , Gray et al., Bailey et al., supra note 14.

25.

See Smith, et al., supra note 12;

Kassler and

Aral , “Beyond Risk Groups: Behavioral Correlates of HIV Seroconversion in Sexually Transmitted Disease Clinic Patients,” XI Meeting of the International Society for STD Research, Abstract #017;

Moses

et al. , “Male Circumcision: Assessment of Health Benefits and Risks,” Sexually Transmitted Infections 74, no. 5 (1998): 368-373;

D. K.

Smith

et al. , “Male Circumcision in the United States for the Prevention of HIV Infection and Other Adverse Health Outcomes: Report from a CDC Consultation,” Public Health Reports 125, Supplement 1 (2010): 72-82;

P. S.

Sullivan

et al. , “Male Circumcision for Prevention of HIV Transmission: What the New Data Mean for HIV Prevention in the United States,” Public Library of Science Medicine 4, no. 7 (2007): e223;

E. E.

Telzak

et al.

“HIV-1 Seroconversion in Patients With and Without Genital Ulcer Disease: A Prospective Study,”

Annals of Internal Medicine 119, no. 12 (1993): 1181-1186;

A. A.

Tobian

et al. , “Male Circumcision for the Prevention of Acquisition and Transmission of Sexually Transmitted Infections: The Case for Neonatal Circumcision,” Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine 164, no. 1 (2010): 78-84;

Warner

et al. , “Male Circumcision and Risk of HIV Infection Among Heterosexual African American Men attending Baltimore Sexually Transmitted Disease Clinics,” Journal of Infectious Diseases 199, no. 1 (2009): 59-65.

26.

Sansom, supra note 4.

27.

Id.

28.

Id.

29.

Id.

30.

Id.

31.

Kacker

et al. , “Costs and Effectiveness of Neonatal Male Circumcision,” Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine 166 no. 10 (2012): 910-918.

32.

A. L.

Andrews

et al. , “The Cost of Medicaid Savings: The Potential Detrimental Public Health Impact of Neonatal Circumcision Defunding,” Infectious Diseases in Obstetrics and Gynecology (2012): Article ID 540295.

33.

Cathcart

et al. , “Trends in Pediatric Circumcision and Its Complications in England between 1997 and 2003,” British Journal of Surgery 93, no. 7 (2006): 885-890;

D. M.

Fergusson

et al. , “Neonatal Circumcision and Penile Problems: An 8-year Longitudinal Study,” Pediatrics 81, no. 4 (1988): 537-541;

W. F.

Gee and

J. S.

Ansell , “Neonatal Circumcision: A Ten-Year Overview: With Comparison of the Gomco Clamp and the Plastibell Device,” Pediatrics 58, no. 6 (1976): 824-827.

34.

See

Cathcart

et al. , Fergusson et al., and Gee and Ansell, supra note 28.

35.

See

Cathcart

et al. , Fergusson et al., and Gee and Ansell, supra note 28;

D. A.

Christakis

et al. , “A Trade-Off Analysis of Routine Newborn Circumcision,” Pediatrics 105, no. 1 (2000): 246-249.

36.

See

Cathcart

et al. , Fergusson et al., and Gee and Ansell, supra note 28;

J. N.

Krieger

et al. , “Adult Male Circumcision: Effects on Sexual Function and Sexual Satisfaction in Kisumu, Kenya,” Journal of Sexual Medicine 5, no. 11 (2008): 2610-2622.

37.

J. A.

Ferris

et al. , “Circumcision in Australia: Further Evidence on its Effects on Sexual Health and Wellbeing,” Australia and New Zealand Journal of Public Health 34, no. 2 (2010): 160-164;

Senkul

et al. , “Circumcision in Adults: Effect on Sexual Function,” Urology 63, no. 1 (2004): 155-158;

Richters

et al. , “Circumcision in Australia: Prevalence and Effects on Sexual Health,” International Journal of STD & AIDS 17, no. 8 (2006): 547-554;

E. O.

Laumann

et al. , “Circumcision in the United States: Prevalence, Prophylactic Effects, and Sexual Practice,” JAMA 277, no. 13 (1997): 1052-1057;

K. L.

Payne

et al. , “Sensation and Sexual Arousal in Circumcised and Uncircumcised Men,” Journal of Sexual Medicine 4, no. 3 (2007): 667-674; Committee on Fetus and Newborn, Committee on Drugs, Section on Anesthesiology, Section on Surgery, American Academy of Pediatrics, Fetus and Newborn Committee, Canadian Paediatric Society, “Prevention and Management of Pain and Stress in the Neonate,” Pediatrics 105, no. 2 (2000): 454-461;

C. B.

Bleustein

et al. , “Effect of Neonatal Circumcision on Penile Neurologic Sensation,” Urology 65, no. 4 (2005): 773-777;

B. J.

Morris and

J. N.

Krieger , “Does Male Circumcision Affect Sexual Function, Sensitivity, or Satisfaction? A Systematic Review,” Journal of Sexual Medicine 10, no. 11 (2013): 2644-2657;

Tian

et al. , “Effects of Circumcision on Male Sexual Functions: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis,” Asian Journal of Andrology 15, no. 5 (2013): 662-666.

38.

See Morris and Krieger, Tian et al., supra note 32.

39.

“Trends in HIV-Related Risk Behaviors Among High School Students — United States, 1991-2011,”

The Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 61, no. 29 (2012): 556-560.

40.

H. A.

Weiss

et al. , “Complications of Circumcision in Male Neonates, Infants and Children: A Systematic Review,” BMC Urology 10 (2010): 2;

A. A.

Tobian and

R. H.

Gray , “The Medical Benefits of Male Circumcision,” JAMA 30, no. 13 (2011): 1479-1480.