Post-stroke spasticity (PSS) is a common complication that affects recovery and quality of life. Traditional rehabilitation approaches may benefit from complementary therapies.
Objective
This study aims to evaluate the efficacy of Tuina massage combined with conventional treatment for PSS through a meta-analysis, providing a scientific basis for clinical decision-making and future research directions.
Method
A literature search was conducted across both English-language (PubMed, Embase, Cochrane, Web of Science) and Chinese-language (CNKI, Wanfang, VIP) databases. Inclusion criteria were limited to randomized controlled trials. Data analysis was performed using Cochrane Collaboration's Review Manager 5.3 and Stata 12.0 software, with detailed inclusion and exclusion criteria and quality assessment using the Jadad scoring system.
Results
Eighteen studies met the inclusion criteria, involving 1937 patients treated with various Tuina techniques alone or in combination with other therapies. Results indicated that Tuina significantly improved symptoms and quality of life, with the Tuina treatment group outperforming the control group in the Modified Ashworth Scale (MAS), Modified Barthel Index (MBI), and Fugl–Meyer Assessment (FMA).
Conclusion
This meta-analysis demonstrates that Tuina massage combined with conventional treatment significantly reduces PSS severity and enhances functional abilities and quality of life, highlighting its potential integration into rehabilitation programs for comprehensive PSS management.
GBD 2019 Stroke Collaborators. Global, regional, and national burden of stroke and its risk factors, 1990–2019: a systematic analysis for the global burden of disease study 2019. Lancet Neurol2021; 20: 795–820.
2.
RohmahIKR. The effectiveness massage therapy on motoric Status among non-hemorrhagic stroke patients. International Journal of Nursing and Health Services (IJNHS)2021; 4: 575–583.
3.
SariNKarimDElitaV. The Effectiveness Of Swedish Massage With Lavender Oil To Improve Muscle Strength Of Post-Stroke Patients. Riau International Nursing Conference2015.
4.
LiFChenJTuM,et al.Effect of needle-warming moxibustion combined with rehabilitation training in the treatment of post-stroke spastic hemiplegia. Journal of Acupuncture and Tuina Science2019; 35: 14–17.
5.
AbramovichSGDrobyshevVAPyatovaAE, et al.Comprehensive use of dynamic electrical neurostimulation and Botulinum toxin therapy in patients with post-stroke spasticity. J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis2020; 29: 105189.
6.
van der RietPMaguireJDedkhardS,et al.Are traditional Thai therapies better than conventional treatment for stroke rehabilitation? A quasi-experimental study. European Journal of Integrative Medicine2015; 7: 16–22.
7.
KoogYHJinSSYoonK,et al.Interventions for hemiplegic shoulder pain: systematic review of randomised controlled trials. Disabil Rehabil2010; 32: 282–291.
8.
SmithM. Management of hemiplegic shoulder pain following stroke. Nurs Stand2012; 26: 35–44.
9.
ZhangQSJiGCCaoF, et al.Tuina for spasticity of poststroke: protocol of a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ Open2020; 10: e038705.
10.
Cabanas-ValdésRCalvo-SanzJSerra-LlobetP, et al.The effectiveness of massage therapy for improving sequelae in post-stroke survivors. A systematic review and meta-analysis. Int J Environ Res Public Health2021; 18: 4424.
11.
LiZAlexanderSA. Current evidence in the management of poststroke hemiplegic shoulder pain: a review. J Neurosci Nurs2015; 47: 10–19.
12.
SuiMJiangNYanL, et al.Effect of electroacupuncture on shoulder subluxation in poststroke patients with hemiplegic shoulder pain: a sham-controlled study using multidimensional musculoskeletal ultrasound assessment. Pain Res Manag2021; 2021: 5329881.
13.
GladstoneDJDanellsCJBlackSE. The fugl-meyer assessment of motor recovery after stroke: a critical review of its measurement properties. Neurorehabil Neural Repair2002; 16: 232–240.
14.
ChenY. Acupoint massage combined with muscle tapping for the rehabilitation of post-stroke spastic hemiplegia: a clinical observation. Modern Distance Education of Chinese Medicine of China2020; 18: 3.
15.
DiHHanSDuX, et al.Applying tuina to exterior-interiorly connected meridians for post-stroke upper limb spasticity. Journal of Acupuncture and Tuina Science2017; 15: 27–30.
16.
HanSMaZZhangN, et al.Tuina along the meridians combined with Chinese medicine for motor functions and activities of daily living in patients with post-stroke upper limb spasticity. Journal of Acupuncture and Tuina Science2015; 13: 295–299. doi:10.1007/s11726-015-0870-6.
17.
LingH. Observations on the efficacy of Gua Sha combined with acupoint massage in the intervention of post-stroke spastic paralysis. Clinical Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine2014; 26: 1154–1156.
18.
KangS. The rehabilitation treatment effect of rehabilitation massage therapy on patients with stroke-induced hemiplegic spasm. World Latest Medicine Information2016; 16: 231–232.
19.
LiuXLinJTianL, et al.Observation on the rehabilitation effect of massage combined with Bobath technique on limb rehabilitation during the spastic stage of stroke. Zhejiang Journal of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine2012; 22: 706–707.
20.
WangLGeRWenQ, et al.Observations on the efficacy of pressing acupoints along the Hand Yangming Meridian in relieving spastic elbow flexion in hemiplegic upper limbs. Journal of Sino-Japanese Friendship Hospital2015; 29: 277–280.
21.
JiaoyuW. “Songjing” rehabilitation massage therapy is lacking in treatment Clinical efficacy evaluation of increased tension state. zhejiang chinese medical university.2022.02. doi:10.27465/d.cnki.gzzyc.2022.000321.
22.
WenQWangLGuoH, et al.Clinical study on reducing upper limb flexor spasm in post-stroke hemiplegic patients by pressing the elbow acupoint combined with Maitland elbow joint mobilization. Hebei Traditional Chinese Medicine2016; 38: 4.
23.
XieCLvY. Clinical observation of tuina plus rehabilitation therapy for lower limb extensor spasticity in recovery stage of stroke. Journal of Acupuncture and Tuina Science2019; 17: 44–48.
24.
YangYJZhangJHouY, et al.Effectiveness and safety of Chinese massage therapy (Tui Na) on post-stroke spasticity: a prospective multicenter randomized controlled trial. Clin Rehabil2017; 31: 904–912.
25.
YangDShenP. Observation and nursing of the efficacy of arm Taiyin meridian massage in treating post-stroke upper limb spasm. Journal of Nurses Training2009: 379–383.
26.
ZhanLWuXLiaoY. Observation on the efficacy of acupoint massage combined with antispasmodic technique in inhibiting upper limb muscle spasm in stroke patients. Journal of Xinxiang Medical University2012; 29: 201–203.
27.
ZhangQ. Analysis of the effect of massage and acupoint therapy combined with rehabilitation treatment on post-cerebral infarction upper limb spastic hemiplegia. Massage and Rehabilitation Medicine2021; 12: 1–3.
28.
ZhouBZhengHWangY, et al.Treatment of post-stroke upper limb flexion spasm in 35 cases by antagonistic muscle massage combined with rehabilitation training. Zhejiang Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine2015; 50: 741–742.
29.
ZhuCQiuLSunW, et al.Effect of TCM rehabilitation program on activities of daily living in patients with post-stroke limb spasticity: an observational study. Medicine (Baltimore)2023; 102: e36079.
30.
LuoZ. Clinical analysis of Xingnao Kaiqiao acupuncture method combined with comprehensive rehabilitation of hand and foot three-yin meridian massage in the treatment of spastic paralysis after stroke. Reflexology and Rehabilitation Medicine2023; 4: 23–25, 36.
31.
GaoS. Effect analysis of rehabilitation training on stroke recovery patients based on acupuncture combined with Tuina. Rehabilitation2024; 2: 4–6, 42.
32.
WhatleyJPerkinsJSamuelC. Reflexology: exploring the mechanism of action. Complement Ther Clin Pract2022; 48: 101606.
33.
PosadzkiPErnstE. The safety of massage therapy: an update of a systematic review. Focus on Alternative and Complementary Therapies2013; 18: 27–32.
34.
QinSXiaoYChiZ, et al.Effectiveness and safety of massage in the treatment of anxiety and depression in patients with cancer: a protocol for systematic review and meta-analysis. Medicine (Baltimore)2020; 99: e22262.
35.
LiS. Spasticity, motor recovery, and neural plasticity after stroke. Front Neurol2017; 8: 20.
36.
HongyeHBingqianWShuijinC, et al.Chinese Tuina remodels the synaptic structure in neuropathic pain rats by downregulating the expression of N-methyl D-aspartate receptor subtype 2B and postsynaptic density protein-95 in the spinal cord dorsal horn. J Tradit Chin Med2023; 43: 715–724.
37.
StevensonVLMarsdenJF. What is spasticity. Spasticity management: a practical multidisciplinary guide. London, UK: Informa Healthcare, 2006, pp.3–14.
38.
SeimCChenBHanC, et al.Relief of post-stroke spasticity with acute vibrotactile stimulation: controlled crossover study of muscle and skin stimulus methods. Front Hum Neurosci2023; 17: 1206027.
39.
TrompettoCMarinelliLMoriL, et al.Pathophysiology of spasticity: implications for neurorehabilitation. Biomed Res Int2014; 2014: 354906.
40.
LiSFranciscoGE. New insights into the pathophysiology of post-stroke spasticity. Front Hum Neurosci2015; 9: 92.
41.
VieiraTMLemosTOliveiraLAS, et al.Postural muscle unit plasticity in stroke survivors: altered distribution of Gastrocnemius’ action potentials. Front Neurol2019; 10: 86.
42.
LiuYChenYTZhangC, et al.Motor unit distribution and recruitment in spastic and non-spastic bilateral biceps brachii muscles of chronic stroke survivors. J Neural Eng2022; 19.
43.
BavikatteGSubramanianGAshfordS, et al.Early Identification, Intervention and Management of Post-stroke Spasticity: Expert Consensus Recommendations. 2021; 13:11795735211036576. doi:10.1177/11795735211036576.
44.
JiYWangYLouH, et al.Tuina combined with physical therapy for spasticity of poststroke: a protocol for systematic review and meta-analysis. Medicine (Baltimore)2022; 101: e28780.
