Holding Therapy and Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy Are Not Supported and Acceptable Social Work Interventions: A Systematic Research Synthesis Revisited
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online July, 2007
Holding Therapy and Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy Are Not Supported and Acceptable Social Work Interventions: A Systematic Research Synthesis Revisited
This article re-examines material discussed in a recent systematic research synthesis by Craven and Lee. The authors find that two of the interventions for foster children discussed by Craven and Lee were erroneously classified as supported by evidence of efficacy, and one, holding therapy, is shown to be potentially physically harmful to children. Detailed evidence is offered to show that holding therapy and dyadic developmental psychotherapy are not appropriately categorized as supported and acceptable interventions.
Becker-Weidman, A.
(2006a). Dyadic developmental psychotherapy: A multi-year follow-up. In S
. M. Sturt
(Ed.), New developments in child abuse research (pp. 43-60).
New York: Nova Science
.
2.
Becker-Weidman, A.
(2006b).
Treatment for children with trauma-attachment disorders: Dyadic developmental psychotherapy
. Child and Adolescent Social Work Journal, 23,
147-171
.
3.
Becker-Weidman, A.
, &
Shell, D.
(Eds.). (2005). Creating capacity for attachment.
Oklahoma City, OK: Wood `N' Barnes
.
4.
Bettelheim, B.
(1950). Love is not enough.
Glencoe, IL: Free Press
.
5.
Bowlby, J.
(1982). Attachment.
New York: Basic
.
6.
Cappelletty, G.G.
,
Brown, M.M.
, &
Shumate, S.E.
(2005).
Correlates of the Randolph Attachment Disorder Questionnaire (RADQ) in a sample of children in foster placement
. Child and Adolescent Social Work Journal, 22,
71-84
.
7.
Chaffin, M.
,
Hanson, R.
,
Saunders, B.E.
,
Nichols, T.
,
Barnett, D.
,
Zeanah, C.
, et al. (2006).
Report of the APSAC Task Force on attachment therapy, reactive attachment disorder, and attachment problems
. Child Maltreatment, 11,
76-89
.
8.
Clark, C.
(2005). Dyadic developmental psychotherapy in long-term foster care. In
A. Becker-Weidman
&
D. Shell
(Eds.), Creating capacity for attachment (pp. 163-181).
Oklahoma City, OK: Wood `N' Barnes
.
9.
Cline, F.W.
(1992). Hope for high risk and rage filled children.
Evergreen, CO: EC
.
10.
Craven, P.A.
, &
Lee, R.E.
(2006).
Therapeutic interventions for foster children: A systematic research synthesis
. Research on Social Work Practice , 16,
287-304
.
11.
Emerson, W.
(2002).
The vulnerable pre-nate. Pre- and PerinatalPsychology Journal, 10,
125-142
.
12.
Gambrill, E.
(2006).
Evidence-based practice and policy: Choices ahead
. Research on Social Work Practice, 16,
338-357
.
13.
Grof, S.
(1980). Beyond death: The gates of consciousness.
London: Thames & Hudson
.
14.
Hughes, D.
(1997). Facilitating developmental attachment.
Northvale, NJ: Jason Aronson
.
15.
Hughes, D.
(2005). The development of dyadic developmental psychotherapy . In
A. Becker-Weidman
&
D. Shell
(Eds.), Creating capacity for attachment (pp. vii-xvi).
Oklahoma City, OK: Wood `N' Barnes
.
16.
Janov, A.
(1970). The primal scream.
New York : Dell
.
17.
Katz, T.J.
(2006).
Propagation of errors in review articles (letter)
. Science, 313,
1236
.
18.
Lindquist, E.F.
(1956). Design and analysis of experiments in psychology and education.
Boston: Houghton Mifflin
.
19.
Littrell, J.
(1998).
Is the reexperience of painful emotion therapeutic
? Clinical Psychology Review, 18,
71-102
.
20.
Mercer, J.
(2002).
Attachment therapy: A treatment without empirical support. Scientific Review ofMental Health Practice, 1(2),
9-16
.
21.
Mercer, J.
(2003).
Violent therapies: The rationale behind a potentially harmful child psychotherapy and its acceptance by parents. Scientific Review ofMental Health Practice, 2(1),
27-37
.
22.
Mercer, J.
,
Misbach, A.
,
Pennington, R.
, &
Rosa, L.
(2006). Letter. Child Maltreatment, 11(4),
378
.
23.
Mercer, J.
,
Sarner, L.
, &
Rosa, L.
(2003). Attachment therapy on trial.
Westport, CT: Praeger
.
24.
Myeroff, R.L.
(1997). Comparative effectiveness of attachment therapy with the special needs adoptive population. Unpublished doctoral dissertation,
The Union Institute, Cincinnati, OH
.
25.
Myeroff, R.L.
,
Mertlich, G.
, &
Gross, G.
(1999).
Comparative effectiveness of holding therapy with aggressive children
. Child Psychiatry and Human Development , 29,
303-313
.
26.
National Association of Social Workers.
(2005 , August 7). NASW anti-restraint resolution. Retrieved September 10, 2006, from http://www.childrenintherapy.org/library/documents/nasw.html
27.
National Crime Victims Research and Treatment Center.
(2001). Guidelines for the psychosocial treatment of intrafamilial physical and sexual abuse Retrieved August 30, 2002, from http://www.musc.edu/cvc/OVCGuidelinesFinalDraft7-30-01
28.
Randolph, E.
(2000). Manual for the Randolph Attachment Disorder Questionnaire .
Evergreen, CO: The Attachment Center Press
.
29.
Rutter, M.
(2002).
Nature, nurture, and development: From evangelism through science toward policy and practice
. Child Development , 73,
1-21
.
30.
Saunders, B.
,
Berliner, L.
, &
Hanson, R.
(2004). Child physical and sexual abuse: Guidelines for treatments. Retrieved September 15, 2006, from http://www.musc.edu/cvc.guidel.htm
31.
Sharma, A.
,
McGue, M.
, &
Benson, P.
(1998).
The psychological adjustment of United States adoptive adolescents and their non-adopted siblings
. Child Development, 69,
791-802
.
32.
Thomas, N.L.
(2000). Parenting children with attachment disorders. In
T. M. Levy
(Ed.), Handbook of attachment interventions (pp. 67-109).
San Diego, CA: Academic Press
.
33.
Zaslow, R.
, &
Menta, M.
(1975). The psychology of the z-process: Attachment and activity.
San Jose, CA: San Jose State University Press
.
