This paper is a tribute to an unsung accountant, economist and engineer, who had a
clear understanding of modern concepts in accounting and finance, such as discounted
cash flows, risk-adjusted discount rates and net present value (NPV), which are
usually considered to be twentieth century developments. He applied these in
practice from 1850 but, until now, he has not been publicly acknowledged as a
pioneer of modern financial planning. The paper also raises the question of why
these methods had to be reintroduced a century later.
Acquisition and Valuation of Land Committee on the Acquisition for Public
Purposes of Rights and Powers in connection with Mines and Minerals Cmd. 156, B.P.P.
(1919) Vol.xxix, pp.51-87.
2.
Arnold, A.J.
, (1997),
“‘Publishing your Private Affairs to the
World’: Corporate Financial Disclosures in the UK 1900-24”
, Accounting Business and Financial History, Vol.7,
No.2, pp.
143-173
.
3.
Arnold, A.J.
, (1995),
“Should Historians Trust Late Nineteenth-Century Company
Financial Statements?”
, Business History, Vol.38, No.2, pp.
40-54
.
4.
Baldwin, T.J.
, (1994),
“Management Aspiration and Audit Opinion: Fixed Asset Accounting
at the Staveley Coal and Iron Company”
, Accounting and Business Research,Vol.25,
No.97, pp.
3-12
.
5.
Baldwin, T.J.
and
Berry, R.H.
, (1999),
“The Measurement of Nineteenth Century Accounting Error: Cases
from the British Coal Industry 1864-1900”
, Accounting History, NS Vol.4, No.1, pp.
79-98
.
6.
Baldwin, T.J.
,
Berry, R.H.
and
Church, R.A.
, (1992),
“The Accounts of the Consett Iron Company 1964-1914”
, Accounting and Business Research,Vol.22,
No.86, pp.
99-109
.
7.
Boyns, T.
and
Edwards, J.R.
, (1995),
“Accounting and Decision-Making in the Mid-Victorian period: The
Case of the Consett Iron Company”
, Business History, Vol.37, No.3, pp.
28-51
.
8.
Boyns, T.
,
Edwards, J.R.
and
Emmanuel, C.
, (1999),
“A Longitudinal Study of the Determinant of Transfer Pricing Change”
, Management Accounting Research, Vol.10,
No.10, pp.
85-108
.
9.
Brackenbury, S.
,
McLean, T.
and
Oldroyd, D.
, (2001),
“The Emergence of Discounted Cash Flow Analysis in the Tyneside
Coal Industry c.1700-1830”
, British Accounting Review, Vol.33,
No.2, pp.
137-155
.
10.
Brealey, R.A.
and
Myers, S.C.
, (2000), Principles of Corporate Finance,
New York: Irwin McGraw-Hill
.
11.
Brief, R.P.
, (1993),
“Nineteenth Century Accounting Error”
,The Journal of Accounting Research,Spring (1965), reprinted in
The Continuing Debate Over Depreciation, Capital and Income, in Brief, R.P. (ed.),
New York and London: Garland Publishing Inc.
12.
Bryer, R.A.
, (1993),
“The Late Nineteenth Century Revolution in Financial Reporting:
Accounting for Investor or Managerial Capitalism?”
, Accounting, Organisations and Society,Vol.18,
No.7/8, pp.
649-690
.
13.
Bryer, R.A.
, (1998),
“The Laws of Accounting in Late Nineteenth Century Britain”
, Accounting History, NS Vol.3, No.1, pp.
55-94
.
14.
Christie, A.
and
Shaw, C.
, (1984), “DALE Sir David”,
Dictionary of Business Biography,in
Jeremy D.J.
(ed.),
London: Butterworths and London School of
Economics Business History Unit
.
15.
Church, R.A.
, (1986), The History of the British Coal Industry, Volume 3
1860-1913: Victorian Pre-eminence,
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
16.
Church, R.
,
Baldwin, T.
and
Berry, R.
, (1994),
“Accounting for Profitability at the Consett Iron Company Before
1914: Measurement, Sources and Uses”
, Economic History Review,Vol.XLVII,
No.4, pp.
703-724
.
17.
Cottrell, P.L.
, (1980), Industrial Finance 1830-1914: The Finance and
Organization of British Manufacturing Industry,
London: Methuen
.
18.
Edwards, J.R.
and
Boyns, T.
, (1994),
“Accounting Practice and Business Finance: Some Case Studies from
the Iron and Coal Industry 1865-1914”
, Journal of Business, Finance and
Accounting,Vol.21, No.8, pp.
1151-1178
.
19.
Edwards, J.R.
and
Warman, A.
, (1981),
“Discounted Cash Flow and Business Valuation in a Nineteenth
Century Merger: A Note”
, The Accounting Historians Journal, Vol.8,
No.2, pp.
37-50
.
20.
Fischer, D.H.
, (1996), The Great Wave,
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
21.
Fisher, I.
, (1906), The Nature of Capital and Income,reprinted
1965,
New York: Augustus M Kelley
.
22.
Fisher, I.
, (1930), The Theory of Interest, reprinted 1965,
New York: Augustus M Kelley
.
23.
Fleishman, R.K.
and
Parker, L.D.
, (1990),
“Managerial Accounting Early in the British Industrial
Revolution: The Carron Company, A Case Study”
, Accounting and Business Research, Vol. 20,
No.79, pp.
211-221
.
24.
Jones, S.
and
Aiken, M.
, (1994),
“The Significance of the Profit and Loss Account in
Nineteenth-Century Britain: A Reassessment”
, Abacus, Vol.30, No.2, pp.
196-229
.
25.
Lamb, M.A., (1997), “Tax Practice in the United Kingdom and the
Emergence of Interrelationships Between Accounting and the Taxation of Business
Profits” (unpublished Ph.D. thesis, Reading University).
26.
Linsley Stafford, M.
, (1984), “ARMSTRONG, William
George”, Dictionary of Business Biography,in
Jeremy, D.J.
(ed.),
London: Butterworths and London School of
Economics Business History Unit
.
27.
Marriner, S.
, (1980), “Company Financial Statements as Source
Material for Business Historians”, Business
History, Vol XXII, pp.203-235,
London: Frank Cass
.
28.
Matheson, E.
, (1893), The Depreciation of Factories, Mines and Industrial
Undertakings and their Valuation, reprinted (1976),
USA: Arno Press Inc.
29.
Miller, P.B.
and
Napier, C.J.
, (1993),
“Genealogies of Calculation”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society,Vol.18,
No.7/8, pp.
631-647
.
30.
Mitchell, B.R.
and
Deane, P.
, (1962), Abstract of British Historical Statistics,
Cambridge, Cambridge University Press
.
31.
Napier, C.J.
, (1990),
“Fixed Asset Accounting in the Shipping Industry: P&O 1840-1914”
, Accounting Business and Financial History,Vol.1,
No.1, pp.
23-50
.
32.
Nikitin, M., (1992), “La Naissance de la Comptabilité
Industrielle en France”, (unpublished Ph.D. thesis, Université
de Paris Dauphine).
NRO: Northumberland Record Office Armstrong 725 C54 1-4
, W.G.(sic) Armstrong's Reports, Valuations, Plans and
Correspondence Relating Mainly to Mining Enterprises in County Durham.
35.
Parker, R.H.
, (1968),
“Discounted Cash Flow in Historical Perspective”
, Journal of Accounting Research,Autumn, pp.
58-71
.
36.
Pitts, M.V.
, (1998),
“Did Dividends Dictate Depreciation in British Coal Companies 1864-1914?”
, Accounting History, NS Vol.3, No.2, pp.
37-67
.
37.
Pixley, F.W.
, (1881), Auditors, Their Duties and Responsibilities,
first edition,
London: Henry Good and Son
.
38.
Reid, J.M.
, (1986), Law and Accounting Pre-1889 British Legal
Cases,
New York and London: Garland Publishing Inc.
39.
Reports of the Royal Commission on the Coal Industry
(Sankey),(1919),
London: HMSO
.
40.
Ritchie, L.A.
, (1992), The Shipbuilding Industry: A Guide to Historical
Records,
Manchester: Manchester University Press
.
41.
Scorgie, M.E.
, (1996),
“Evolution of the Application of Present Value to Valuation of
Non-monetary Resources”
, Accounting and Business Research, Vol.26,
No.3, pp.
237-248
.
42.
Select Committee on Limited Liability Acts, B.P.P. (1867),
Vol.x,
London
.
43.
Taylor, A.J.
, (1980), “The Coal Industry”,
in
Church, R.
(ed.), Dynamics of Victorian Business: Problems and Perspectives to the
1870,
London: George Allen and Unwin
.
44.
Transactions of the Institution of Mining Engineers,
(1897-1898), Vol.XIV, pp.
171-173
, Newcastle upon Tyne.
45.
Wale, J.
, (1990),
“The Reliability of Reported Profits and Asset Values 1890-1914:
Case Studies from the British Coal Industry”
, Accounting and Business Research, Vol.20, pp.
253-267
.
46.
Wilson, Charles
, (1984), “BELL, Sir Isaac
Lowthian”, Dictionary of Business Biography,in
Jeremy D.J.
(ed.),
London: Butterworths and London School of
Economics Business History Unit
.
