Did dividends dictate depreciation in British coal companies 1864

Abstract

This paper identifies the factors which determined the dividend and depreciation policy of early coal companies from surviving accounting records. It is found that, after the Companies Acts of 1844-1862, there was no change in dividend policy from that prevailing in partnerships: the distribution of a substantial steady percentage of the operating surplus. Most coal companies adopted this policy throughout the period 1860-1914. By 1885, a few companies had changed to paying a constant dividend, expressed as a fixed percentage of the paid-up share capital. Depreciation policies were much less consistent, particularly for companies in financial difficulty. Directors could choose whether to distribute trading surpluses as dividends, or retain them in the company as depreciation or revenue reserves, and the dividend payment was consistently given preference over any provision for depreciation. This may have led to a lack of cash for re-investment or even an erosion of the capital base of some companies. These results provide evidence on the faults and virtues of the Victorian entrepreneur in industrial capitalism.

Keywords

Dividend policy payout depreciation coal companies

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Baldwin, T. , Berry, R. and Church, R.A. , (1992), " The Accounts of the Consett Iron Company 1964-1914 ", Accounting and Business Research, Vol.22, No.86, pp. 99-109 .

Boyns, T. and Edwards, J.R. , (1995), " Accounting Systems and Decision-Making in the Mid-Victorian period; The Case of the Consett Iron Company ", Business History, Vol.37, No.3, pp. 28-51 .

Brief, R. , (1966), " The Origin and Evolution of Nineteenth-Century Asset Accounting ", The Business History Review, Vol.XL, No.1, pp. 1-23 , reprinted in The Continuing Debate over Depreciation, Capital and Income, 1993, New York and London: Garland Publishing Inc.

Bryer, R. , (1997), " The Mercantile Laws Commission of 1854 and the Political Economy of Limited Liability ", Economic History Review, Vol.50, No.1, pp. 36-54 .

Cottrell, P.L. , (1979), Industrial Finance 1830-1914: The Finance and Organisation of English Manufacturing Industry, London: Methuen .

Chandler, A. , (1976), "The Development of Modern Management Structure in the US and UK", in L. Hannah (ed.), Management Strategy and Business Development: An Historical and Comparative Study, London: Macmillan .

Church, R. , (1992), " The Family Firm in Industrial Capitalism: International Perspectives on Hypotheses and History ", Business History, Vol.35, No.4, pp. 17-43 .

Church, R. , Baldwin, T. and Berry, R. , (1994), " Accounting for Profitability at the Consett Iron Company before 1914: Measurement, Sources and Uses ", Economic History Review, Vol.XLVII, No.4, pp. 703-724 .

Edelstein, M. , (1971), "Rigidity and Bias in the British Capital Market 1870-1913" in D.N. McCloskey (ed.), Essays on a Mature Economy: Britain after 1840, London: Methuen .

10.

Edwards, J.R. , (1989), A History of Financial Accounting, London: Routledge .

11.

Edwards, J.R. , (1980), " British Capital Accounting Practices and Business Finance 1852-1919: An Exemplification ", Accounting and Business Research, Vol.10, Spring, pp. 241-258 .

12.

Edwards, J.R. , (1981), Company Legislation and Changing Patterns of Disclosure in British Company Accounts 1900-1940, London: ICAEW .

13.

Edwards, J.R. and Webb, K.M. , (1985), " Use of Table A by Companies Registering Under the Companies Act 1862 ", Accounting and Business Research, Vol.15, Summer, pp. 177-195 .

14.

Edwards, R.S. , (1939), " A Note on the Law Relating to Company Dividends", Economica, Vol.VI, May, pp. 170-190 .

15.

Fischer, D.H. , (1996), The Great Wave, Oxford: Oxford University Press .

16.

Florence, P. Sargant , (1961), Ownership, Control and Success of Large Companies: An Analysis of English Industrial Structure and Policy 1936-1951, London: Sweet and Maxwell .

17.

Jefferys, J.B., (1938), "Trends in Business Organisation in Great Britain since 1856 with special reference to the financial structure of companies, the mechanism of investment and the relations between shareholder and the company", London University: unpublished Ph.D. thesis.

18.

Jefferys, J.B. , (1946), " The Denomination and Character of Shares, 1855-1885 ", The Economic History Review, Vol.XVI, pp. 45-55 .

19.

Lee v Neuchatel Asphalte Co. (1899), 41 Ch.D.1.

20.

Lintner, J. , (1956), " Distribution of Incomes of Corporations among Dividends, Retained Earnings, and Taxes ", American Economic Review, Vol.XLVI, May, pp. 97-113 .

21.

Matheson, E. , (1893), The Depreciation of Factories, Mines and Industrial Undertakings and their Valuation, reprinted 1976, USA: Arno Press Inc .

22.

Ministry of Fuel and Power , Coal Mining. Report of the Technical Advisory Committee. March 14, 1945 (Charles C. Reid) Cmd 6610 IV, London: HMSO .

23.

Minutes of Evidence taken before the Company Law Amendment Committee (1944), London: HMSO.

24.

Morris, R.D. , (1986), " Lee v Neuchatel Asphalte Company (1889) and Depreciation Accounting: Two Empirical Studies ", Accounting and Business Research, Vol.17, Winter, pp. 71-81 .

25.

Payne, P.L. , (1984), "Family Business in Britain: An Historical and Analytic Survey" in Okochi, A. and Yasuoka, S. (eds.), Family Business in Eras of Industrial Growth, Tokyo .

26.

Reid, J. M. , (1986), Law and Accounting: Pre 1889 British Legal Cases, New York and London: Garland Publishing Inc .

27.

Reports of the Royal Commission on the Coal Industry (Sankey) (1919), London: HMSO .

28.

Shannon, H.A. , (1932), " The first 5000 Limited Companies and their Duration ", Economic History, Vol.1I, pp. 396-424 .

29.

Supple, B. , (1987), The History of the British Coal Industry, 4: The Political Economy of Decline, Oxford: Oxford University Press .

30.

Taylor, A.J. , (1980), "The Coal Industry" in Church, R. (ed.), Dynamics of Victorian Business: Problems and Perspectives to the 1870, London: George Allen and Unwin .

31.

Thomas, W.A. , (1973), The Provincial Stock Exchanges, London: Frank Cass .

32.

Watts, R.L. and Zimmerman, J.L. , (1979), " The Demand for and Supply of Accounting Theories: The Market for Excuses ", The Accounting Review, Vol. LIV, No.2, pp. 273-305 .

33.

Yamey, B.S. , (1941) " Aspects of the Law Relating to Company Dividends ", The Modem Law Review, Vol.4, April, pp. 273-298 .

34.

Yamey, B.S. , (1962), "The Case Law Relating to Company Dividends" in Baxter, W.T. and Davidson, S. (eds.), Studies in Accounting Theory, London: Sweet and Maxwell .

Did dividends dictate depreciation in British coal companies 1864 - 1914?

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References