This research studies the emergence of the concept of depreciation in Spain up to 1939, identifying the interplay between law and accounting. We focus our analysis on the hypotheses of both Watts and Zimmermann (1979) and of Napier and Noke (1992). Our intention is to fulfil this dual task of retrieval and reinterpretation of the origins of depreciation in Spain, in order to analyse the concerns over the importance of implementing depreciation policies and the role played by accounting thinkers and legal regulations in the adoption of Spanish accounting depreciation. We find no evidence for the market-for-excuses hypothesis and, in contrast to the conclusions of Watts and Zimmermann (1979), it seems that the change in accounting theory appeared before rather than after changes to the law. This interplay fits with Napier and Noke’s hypothesis of a multidirectional process in which each discipline affects and influences the other.
AlbiñanaC (1949) Tributación del beneficio de la empresa y de sus partícipes. Revista de Derecho Mercantil. Madrid. In: FernándezE (1991) La contabilidad y sus profesionales en la España de los siglos XIX y XX. Cuadernos de Estudios Empresariales (1): 61–70.
2.
AmatJCarmonaSRobertsH (1993) Context and change in management accounting systems: A Spanish case study. Management Accounting Research5(2): 107–122.
3.
ArchambaultJArchambaultM (2011) Earnings management among firms during the pre-sec era: A Benford’s Law analysis. Accounting Historians Journal38(2): 145–170.
4.
ArnoldA (1991) Secret reserves or special credits? A reappraisal of the reserve and provision accounting policies of the Royal Mail Packet Company, 1915–1927. Accounting and Business Research12(83): 203–214.
5.
ArnoldA (1998) U.K. accounting disclosure practices and information asymmetry during the first quarter of the twentieth century: The effects on book return and dividend cover. Journal of Business Finance and Accounting25(7/8): 775–794.
6.
ArnoldAJMcCartneyS (2000) The profitability of Britain’s early railways. Working papers of the Department of Accounting, Finance and Management. University of Essex.
7.
ArnoldAJMcCartneyS (2003) It may be earlier than you think: Evidence, myths and informed debate in Accounting History. Critical Perspectives on Accounting14(3): 227–253.
8.
ArnoldAJMcCartneyS (2008) The transition to financial capitalism and its implications for financial reporting: Evidence from the English canal companies. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal21 (8): 1185–1209.
9.
BaxterWTDavidsonS (1977) Studies in Accounting. London: Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales.
10.
BentabolMAGuzmánIMontoyaJLMoralesMJ (2011) La Amortización Contable en España durante el primer cuarto del siglo XX (1900–1925): El caso de la Compañía de los Caminos de Hierro del Norte de España. In: 10th International Congress of Spanish Association of Economic History (AEHE), Seville, Spain, 8–10September2011.
11.
BoynsT (1993) Cost accounting in the South Wales coal industry, 1870–1914. Accounting, Business & Financial History3(3): 327–352.
12.
BoynsTEdwardsJ (1995) Accounting systems and decision-making in the mid-Victorian period: The case of the Consett Iron Company. Business History37: 28–51.
13.
BoynsTEdwardsJ (1997) The construction of cost accounting systems in Britain to 1900: The case of the coal, iron and steel industries. Business History39: 1–29.
14.
BoynsTEdwardsJ (2007) The development of cost and management accounting in Britain. In: ChapmanCSHopwoodAGShieldsMD (eds) Handbook of Management Accounting Research II. Amsterdam: Elsevier, pp.969–1034.
15.
BriefR (1966) The origin and evolution of nineteenth-century asset accounting. Business History Review40(1): 1–23.
16.
BriefR (1976) The Late Nineteenth-century Debate over Depreciation, Capital and Income. New York: Arno Press.
17.
BryerRA (1991) Accounting for the “railway mania” of 1845: A great railway swindle?Accounting, Organizations and Society26(5/6): 439–486.
18.
BurlaudA. (1996) Depreciation: Concepts and Practices in France and the UK. European Accounting Review5(2): 299–316.
19.
CarlonSMorrisR (2003) The economic determinants of depreciation accounting in late nineteenth-century Britain. Accounting, Business & Financial History13(3): 275–303.
20.
CarnegieGDNapierCJ (1996) Critical and interpretive histories: Insights into accounting’s present and future through its past. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal9(3): 7–39.
21.
CarmonaS (2004) Accounting History Research and its Diffusion in an International Context”. Accounting History9 (3): 7–23
22.
CarmonaS (2007) The history of management accounting in France, Italy, Portugal and Spain. In: ChapmanCSHopwoodAGShieldsMD (eds) Handbook of Management Accounting Research II. Amsterdam: Elsevier, pp.905–923.
23.
CarmonaSMaciasM (2007) Institutional pressures, monopolistic conditions and the implementation of early cost management practices: The case of the Royal Tobacco Factory of Seville (1820–1887). Abacus37(2): 139–165.
24.
CarrascoDHernándezEMattessichR (2004) Accounting publications and research in Spain: First half of the 20th century. Review of Accounting and Finance3(2): 40–58.
25.
CarrascoDHernándezEMoralesMJSánchezD (2009) 20th century publications on cost accounting by Spanish authors previous to the Standardization Act (1900–1978). The Accounting Historians Journal36(2): 139–179.
DickseeLR (1903) Depreciation, Reserves, and Reserves Funds. London: Gee. (reprinted, New York: Arno Press1976).
34.
DonosoJAArqueroJL (2005) Inicios de las Enseñanzas Oficiales de Comercio en España. Creación de la Escuela de Comercio de Cádiz (1799–1804): Selección de los Primeros Profesores, Métodos de Enseñanza y Programas, con especial referencia a los de Contabilidad. Revista de Contabilidad8(15): 183–214.
35.
DonosoRBGinerBRuízA (2006) La Contabilidad de Costes a finales del S. XIX: El caso de la Empresa Española Trenor y CIA. (1838–1926). Revista Española de Historia de la Contabilidad4: 42–67.
36.
EdwardsJR (1986) Depreciation and fixed asset valuation in railway company accounts to 1911. Accounting and Business Research16(63): 251–263.
37.
EdwardsJR (1989) Industrial cost accounting developments in Britain to 1830: A review article. Accounting and Business Research19(76): 305–317.
38.
EdwardsJRNewellE (1991) The development of industrial cost and management accounting before 1850: A survey of the evidence. Business History33: 35–57.
39.
EdwardsJRWebbKM (1985) Use of table A by companies registering under the Companies Act 1862. Accounting and Business Research15 (59): 177-95.
40.
EdwardsJDSalmonsonRF (1961) Contributions of Four Accounting Pioneers: Kohler, Littleton, May and Paton. Michigan: MSU Business Studies.
41.
FernándezE (1991) La contabilidad y sus profesionales en la España de los siglos XIX y XX. Cuadernos de Estudios Empresariales1: 61–70.
42.
FernándezE (1992) La Contabilidad en España en el siglo XX. In: Gonzalo AnguloJA.La Contabilidad en España. Madrid: Instituto de Contabilidad y Auditoría de Cuentas.
43.
FiumeR (2007) Lorenzo de Minico’s thought in the development of accounting theory in Italy: An understated contribution. Accounting, Business & Financial History17(1): 33–52.
44.
FleischmanRKTysonTN (1993) Cost accounting during the industrial revolution: The present state of historical knowledge. Economic History Review46(3): 503–517.
45.
FleischmanRKTysonTN (2007) The history of management accounting in the US. In: ChapmanCSHopwoodAGShieldsMD (eds) Handbook of Management Accounting Research II. Amsterdam: Elsevier1071–1090.
46.
FrenchEA (1977) The evolution of the dividend law in England. In: BaxterWTDavidsonS, Studies in Accounting. London: Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales.
47.
GarcíaJL (1994) Apuntes para una historia crítica de las Escuelas de Comercio. Cuadernos de Estudios Empresariales4: 134–154.
48.
GarckeEFellsJM (1893) Factory Accounts: Their Principles and Practice. New York: McGraw-Hill.
49.
GoxensA (1984) La Contabilidad aquí, entre 1801 y 1950. In: Décimo aniversario del Plan General de Contabilidad. Madrid: Instituto de Planificación Contable, Ministerio de Economía y Hacienda.
50.
GrantELNortonPT (1949) Depreciation. New York: Ronald Press Company.
51.
GutiérrezFNúñezM (2000) Explaining change in Spain during the second half of the eighteenth century using institutional theory. In: Accounting and History, Madrid: AECA, pp.127–145.
52.
GutiérrezFLarrinagaCNúñezM (2005) Pre-industrial revolution evidence of cost and management accounting in Spain. The Accounting Historians Journal23(1): 111–148.
53.
HatfieldHR (1916) Modern Accounting. New York: D. Appleton and Company (reprinted, New York: Arno Press 1976).
54.
HatfieldHR (1927) Accounting: Its Principles and Problems. New York: D. Appleton and Company.
55.
HernándezE (1999) Literatura contable española 1522–1943. In: 10th Congreso de la Asociación Española de Contabilidad y Administración de Empresas (AECA). Zaragoza, Spain, 23–25September1999.
56.
KernB (2000) The role of depreciation and the investment tax credit in tax policy and their influence on financial reporting during the 20th century. Accounting Historians Journal27(2): 145–164.
57.
LabardinP (2013) Accounting valuation in nineteenth-century French bankruptcies. Accounting History18(3): 391–414.
58.
LeeGA (1975) The concept of profit in British accounting, 1760–1900. The Business History Review44(1): 6–36.
59.
LemarchandY (1993) The dark side of the result: Self-financing and accounting choices within nineteenth-century French industry. Accounting, Business & Financial History3(3): 303–325.
60.
LeporeA (2005) Sulle origini, sull’evoluzione e sullo statu dell’arte della storia della contabilitá in Spagna. Revista Española de Historia de la Contabilidad3: 33–71.
61.
LewisWA (1977) Depreciation and obsolescence as factors in costing in studies in accounting. In: BaxterWTDavidsonS, Studies in Accounting. London: Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales.
62.
LittletonAC (1933) Accounting Evolution to 1900. New York: American Institute Publishing (reprinted, New York: Russell & Russell, 1966).
63.
McCartneySArnoldAJ (2003) The railway mania of 1845–1847: Market irrationality or collusive swindle based on accounting distortions?Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal16(5): 8–52.
64.
MathesonE (1893) The Depreciation of Factories, Mines and Industrial Undertakings and their Valuation. In: EdwardsJR (1986) Depreciation and Fixed Asset Valuation in Railway Company Accounts to 1911. Accounting and Business Research16(63): 251–63.
65.
MattessichR (2003) Accounting research and researchers of the nineteenth century and the beginning of the twentieth century: An international survey of authors, ideas and publications. Accounting, Business & Financial History13(2): 125–170.
66.
MirantiPJ (1993) Measurement and organizational effectiveness: The ICC and accounting-based regulation, 1887–1940. Business and Economic History19: 183–192.
MontoyaJLGuzmanI (2012) Accounting regulation of Spanish rail in the first quarter of the twentieth century (1900–1925). De Computis. Spanish Journal of Accounting History17: 3–28.
69.
MoralesMJBentabolMABenitoH (2012) Depreciation in Spain 1898–1939: A case study at a flour-milling company. In: 8th International Research Seminar: “Critical Reflection on Research in Accounting History”. Seville, Spain, 6July2012.
70.
MorrisRD (1986) Lee vs Neuchatel Asphalte Co. (1889) and depreciation accounting: Two empirical studies. Accounting and Business Research17(65): 71–82.
71.
NapierC (1990) Fixed asset accounting in the shipping industry. P&O 180–1914. Accounting Business & Financial History1(1): 23–50.
72.
NapierCNokeC (1992) Accounting and the law: An historical overview of an uneasy relationship. In: BromwichMHopwoodA (eds) Accounting and the Law. Hertfordshire: Prentice Hall International UK Ltd.
73.
NikitinM (1990) Setting up an industrial accounting system at Saint Gobain (1820–1880). Accounting Historians Journal17(2): 73–93.
74.
NobesCWParkerRH (1979) The development of company financial reporting in Great Britain 1844–1977. In: LeeTAParkerRH (eds) The Evolution of Corporate Financial Reporting. Thomas Nelson & Sons, pp.197–207.
75.
ParkerRH (1990) Regulating British corporate financial reporting in the nineteenth century. Accounting, Business & Financial History1(1): 51–72.
76.
PassowR (1919) Die Erfolgsrechnung der deutschen Eisenbahnen in ihrer geschichtlichen Entwicklung (Buchdruckerei Joh.Heider).
77.
PatonWA (1920) Depreciation, apreciation and productive capacity. In: EdwardsJDSalmonsonRF (eds) Contributions of Four Accounting Pioneers: Kohler, Littleton, May and Paton. Michigan: MSU Business Studies.
78.
PittsMV (1998) Did dividends dictate depreciation in British coal companies 1864–1914?Accounting History3(2): 37–67.
79.
PittsMV (2001) In praise of the “other” William Armstrong: A nineteenth-century British engineer and early management consultant. Accounting History6(2): 37–67.
80.
PixleyFW (1922) The Accountants’ Dictionary. London: Waverley Book Co.
81.
PollinsH (1956) Aspects of railway accounting before 1868. In: LittletonACYameyBS (eds) Studies in the History of Accounting. London: Sweet and Maxwell Ltd., pp.332–355.
82.
RamaCM (1960) La crisis española del siglo XX. Mexico: Fondo de Cultura económica.
83.
RichardJ (2005) The concept of fair value in French and German accounting regulations from 1673 to 1914 and its consequences for the interpretation of the stages of development of capitalist accounting.Critical Perspectives on Accounting16: 387–399.
84.
RichardJ (2012) The victory of the Prussian railway “dynamic” accounting over the public finance and patrimonial accounting models (1838–1884): an early illustration of the appearance of the second stage of capitalist financial accounting and a testimony against the agency and the market for excuses theories. The Accounting Historians Journal39(1): 91–126.
85.
SanzE (1990) Normas fiscales versus normas contables. Partida Doble6: 4–16.
86.
SchefflerM (1879) “Über Bilanzen”. Vierteljahrschrift für Volkswirtschaft, Politik und Kulturgeschichte.
87.
VelascoC (1976) El siglo XX español: Notas históricas. Revista Información comercial Española514: 23–57.
88.
VlaemminckJ (1961) History and Doctrines of Accounting. Madrid: E.J.E.S.
89.
WattsRLZimmermannJL (1979) The demand for and supply of accounting theories: The market for excuses. The Accounting Review54: 273–305.
90.
WoodwardPD (1956) Depreciation – the development of an accounting concept. The Accounting Review31: 71–76.
91.
WrightFK (2006) Depreciation theory in the 1960s. Accounting History11(1): 85–95.
92.
YameyBS (1941) Aspects of the law relating to company dividends. Modern Law Review4(4) (revised and reprinted, 1979). In: YameyBS (ed) Essays in the History of Accounting. New York: Arno Press, pp.273–298.
