This paper provides an empirical study of the between-individual and between-country differences in the popular legitimacy of European healthcare systems. In order to explain two dimensions of popular legitimacy (satisfaction and support for state responsibility), we assess the impact of self-interest motives (income and personal health), ideology (egalitarianism) and institutional arrangements (level of service provision, and private and government health expenditure). For this purpose, data from the European Social Survey Round 4 (ESS-4, 2008–2009) are analysed by means of multilevel models. Universal high support for state responsibility is found, while satisfaction varies considerably, with particularly low levels found in Eastern European and former Soviet Union countries. It appears that individuals are not guided by self-interest motives and ideology alone. In addition to these factors interacting, the results suggest that state-provided healthcare might be in everyone’s interest. Introducing a patient perspective could advance our understanding of healthcare legitimacy.
AlberJ. (1995) ‘A Framework for the Comparative Study of Social Services’, Journal of European Social Policy5(2): 131–49.
2.
AllinS.MasseriaC.SorensonC.PapanicolasI.MossaliosE. (2007) Measuring Inequalities in Access to Health Care: A Review of the Indices. Research Note for the DG ‘Employment, Social Affairs and Equal Opportunities’. Brussels: European Commission.
3.
ArdigoA. (1995) ‘Public Attitudes and Changes in Health Care Systems: A Confrontation and a Puzzle’, in BorreO.ScarboroughE. (eds) The Scope of Government. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
4.
ArhinfulD.K. (2003) The Solidarity of Self-interest. Social and Cultural Feasibility of Rural Health Insurance in Ghana. Leiden: African Studies Centre.
5.
BambraC. (2005) ‘Cash Versus Services: “Worlds of Welfare” and the Decommodification of Cash Benefits and Health Care Services’, Journal of Social Policy34(5): 195–213.
6.
BardageC.PluijmS.PedersenN.DeegD.JulhäM.NoaleM.BlumsteinT.OteroA. (2005) ‘Self-rated Health among Older Adults: A Cross-national Comparison’, European Journal of Aging2(2): 149–58.
7.
BeckerG. (1976) The Economic Approach to Human Behavior. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
8.
BlekesauneM.QuadagnoJ. (2003) ‘Public Attitudes toward Welfare State Policies’, European Sociological Review19(5): 415–27.
9.
BobakM.MarmotM. (1996) ‘East–West Mortality Divide and its Potential Explanations: Proposed Research Agenda’, British Medical Journal312 (7028): 421–5.
10.
BonoliG.PalierB. (1998) ‘Changing the Politics of Social Programmes: Innovative Change in British and French Welfare Reforms’, Journal of European Social Policy8(4): 317–30.
11.
BorisovaL.V. (2011) ‘Health Care Systems as Determinants of Health Outcomes in Transition Countries: Developing Classification’, Social Theory and Health9(4): 326–54.
12.
BrainerdE.CutlerD.M. (2005) ‘Autopsy on an Empire: Understanding Mortality in Russia and the Former Soviet Union’, Journal of Economic Perspectives19(1): 107–30.
13.
BurstromB.FredlundP. (2001) ‘Self Rated Health: Is it as Good a Predictor of Subsequent Mortality among Adults in Lower as well as in Higher Social Classes?’, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health55(11): 836–40.
14.
CampbellS.M.RolandM.O.BuetowS.A. (2000) ‘Defining Quality of Care’, Social Science and Medicine51(11): 1611–25.
15.
CarlsonP. (2004) ‘The European Health Divide: A Matter of Financial or Social Capital?’, Social Science and Medicine59(9): 1985–92.
16.
CohenG. (1996) ‘Age and Health Status in a Patient Satisfaction Survey’, Social Science and Medicine42(7): 1085–93.
17.
D’AnjouL.SteijnA.van AarsenD. (1995) Social Position, Ideology, and Distributive Justice’, Social Justice Research8(4): 351–84.
18.
DeSalvoK.B.BloserN.ReynoldsK.HeJ.MuntanerP. (2006) ‘Mortality Prediction with a Single General Self-rated Health Question’, Journal of General Internal Medicine21(3): 267–75.
19.
DownsA. (1957) An Economic Theory of Democracy. New York: Harper and Row.
20.
Esping-AndersonG. (1990) The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
21.
European Social Survey (2009) ESS-4 2009 Documentation Report: Edition 1.0. Bergen: European Social Survey Data Archive, Norwegian Social Science Data Services.
22.
FeldmanS.ZallerJ. (1992) ‘The Political Culture of Ambivalence: Ideological Responses to the Welfare State’, American Journal of Political Science36(1): 268–307.
GelissenJ. (2000) ‘Popular Support for Institutionalised Solidarity: A Comparison between European Welfare States’, International Journal of Social Welfare9(4): 285–300.
25.
GeversJ.GelissenJ.ArtsW.MuffelsR. (2000) ‘Public Health Care in the Balance: Exploring Popular Support for Health Care Systems in the European Union’, International Journal of Social Welfare9(4): 301–21.
26.
HagenaarsA.De VosK.ZaidiM.A. (1994) Poverty Statistics in the Late 1980s: Research Based on Micro-data. Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities.
27.
HallJ.A.DornanM.C. (1990) ‘Patient Sociodemographic Characteristics as Predictors of Satisfaction with Medical Care: A Meta-analysis’, Social Science and Medicine30(7): 811–18.
28.
HardinG. (1968) ‘The Tragedy of the Commons’, Science168: 1243–8.
JaegerM.M. (2006) ‘What Makes People Support Public Responsibility for Welfare Provision: Self-interest or Political Ideology?’, Acta Sociologica49(3): 321–38.
31.
JensenC. (2008) ‘Worlds of Welfare Services and Transfers’, Journal of European Social Policy18(2): 151–62.
32.
KangasO.E. (1997) ‘Self-interest and the Common Good: The Impact of Norms, Selfishness and Context in Social Policy Opinions’, Journal of Socio-Economics26(5): 475–94.
33.
KohlJ.WendtC. (2004) ‘Satisfaction with Health Care Systems: A Comparison of EU Countries’, in GlatzerW.BelowS.V.StoffregenM. (eds) Challenges for Quality of Life in the Contemporary World. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
34.
KohliM. (2005) ‘Generational Changes and Generational Equity’, in JohnsonM.L.BengstonV.L.ColemanP.G.KirkwoodT.B.L. (eds) The Cambridge Handbook of Age and Ageing (pp. 518–526). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
35.
KorpiW. (1980) ‘Social Policy and Distributional Conflict in the Capitalist Democracies: A Preliminary Comparative Framework’, West European Politics3(3): 296–316.
36.
LeeY.H.KasperJ.D. (1998) ‘Assessment of Medical Care by Elderly People: General Satisfaction and Physician Quality’, Health Services Research32(6): 741–58.
37.
LinosK.WestM. (2003) ‘Self-Interest, Social Beliefs, and Attitudes to Redistribution: Re-addressingthe Issue of Cross-National Variation’, European Sociological Review19: 393–409.
38.
MackenbachJ.P.StirbuI.RoskamA.J.SchaapM.M.MenvielleG.LeinsaluM.KunstA.E. (2008) ‘Socioeconomic Inequalities in Health in 22 European Countries’, New England Journal of Medicine358(23): 2468–81.
39.
MalatJ. (2001) ‘Social Distance and Patients’ Rating of Healthcare Providers’, Journal of Health and Social Behaviour42(4): 360–72.
40.
MarmorT.R.OkmaK.G.H.LathamS.R. (2010) ‘National Values, Institutions and Health Policies: What do they Imply for Medicare Reform?’, Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis12(1–2): 179–96.
41.
MarmotM.G.SmithG.D.StansfeldS.PatelC.NorthF.HeadJ.WhiteI.BrunnerE.FeeneyA. (1991) ‘Health Inequalities among British Civil Servants: The Whitehall II Study’, Lancet337(8754): 1387–93.
42.
MissinneS.BrackeP. (2012) ‘Depressive Symptoms among Immigrants and Ethnic Minorities: A Population Based Study in 23 European Countries’, Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology47(1): 97–109.
43.
MoranM. (2000) ‘Understanding the Welfare State: The Case of Health Care’, British Journal of Politics and International Relations2(2): 135–60.
44.
Moreno-SerraR.WagstaffA. (2009) System Wide Impact of Hospital Payment Reforms Evidence from Central and Eastern Europe and Central Asia. Washington DC: World Bank.
45.
MossialosE. (1997) ‘Citizens’ Views on Health Care Systems in the 15 Member States of the European Union’, Health Economics6(2): 109–16.
46.
MyersonR.B. (1991) Game Theory: Analysis of Conflict. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
47.
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (2006) OECD Health Data 2006. A Comparative Analysis of 30 Countries. Paris: OECD Publishing.
48.
PapadakisE.BeanC. (1993) ‘Popular Support for the Welfare State: A Comparison Between Institutional Regimes’, Journal of Public Policy13(3): 227–54.
49.
ReiblingN. (2010) ‘Healthcare Systems in Europe: Towards an Incorporation of Patient Access’, Journal of European Social Policy20(1): 5–18.
50.
RobertS.A.HouseJ.S. (2000). ‘Socioeconomic Inequalities in Health: An Enduring Sociological Problem’, in BirdC.E.ConradP.FremontA.M. (eds) Handbook of Medical Sociology (pp. 79–97). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
51.
RollerE. (1995) ‘The Welfare State: The Equality Dimension’, in BorreO.ScarboroughE. (eds) The Scope of Government. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
52.
RothsteinB. (2001) ‘The Universal Welfare State as a Social Dilemma’, Rationality and Society13: 213–33.
53.
SitziaJ.WoodN. (1997) ‘Patient Satisfaction: A Review of Issues and Concepts’, Social Science and Medicine45(12): 1829–43.
54.
SvallforsS. (1991) ‘The Politics of Welfare Policy in Sweden: Structural Determinants and Attitudinal Cleavages’, British Journal of Sociology42(4): 609–34.
55.
SvallforsS.KulinJ.SchnabelA. (2011) ‘Age, Class, and Attitudes toward Government Responsibilities’, in SvallforsS. (ed.) Contested Welfare States: Welfare Attitudes in Europe and Beyond. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
56.
Taylor-GoobyP. (1985) Public Opinion, Ideology and State Welfare. London: Routledge.
57.
Taylor-GoobyP. (1999) Markets and Motives: Trust and Egoism in Welfare Markets. Journal of Social Policy28(1): 97–114.
58.
ThompsonA.G.H.SunolR. (1995) ‘Expectations as Determinants of Patient Satisfaction: Concepts, Theory and Evidence’, International Journal for Quality in Health Care7(2): 127–41.
59.
ThomsonS.FoubisterT.MossialosE. (2010) ‘Can User Charges Make Health Care More Efficient?’, British Medical Journal341, c.3759.
60.
UNICEF (1997) Children at Risk in Central and Eastern Europe: Perils and Promises. Economies in Transition Studies: Regional Monitoring Report No. 4. Florence: UNICEF.
61.
van OorschotW. (1999) ‘The Legitimacy of Welfare: A Sociological Analysis of the Motives for Contributing to Welfare Schemes’, Work and Organization Research Centre (WORC) Paper 99.11.02. Tilburg: WORC/TISSER.
62.
van OorschotW.MeulemanB. (2012) ‘Does Popular Support for Welfare States Depend on their Outcomes?’, in SvallforsS. (ed.) Contested Welfare States: Welfare Attitudes in Europe and Beyond. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
63.
WagstaffA.Moreno-SerraR. (2009) ‘Europe and Central Asia’s Great Post-communist Social Health Insurance Experiment: Aggregate Impacts on Health Sector Outcomes’, Journal of Health Economics28(2): 322–40.
64.
WendtC. (2009) ‘Mapping European Healthcare Systems: A Comparative Analysis of Financing, Service Provision and Access to Health Care’, Journal of European Social Policy19(5): 432–45.
65.
WendtC.KohlJ. (2010) ‘Translating Monetary Inputs into Health Care Provision: A Comparative Analysis of the Impact of Different Modes of Public Policy’, Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis12(1–2): 11–31.
66.
WendtC.FrisinaL.RothgangH. (2009) ‘Healthcare System Types: A Conceptual Framework for Comparison’, Social Policy and Administration43(1): 70–90.
67.
WendtC.KohlJ.MischkeM.PfeiferM. (2010) ‘How Do Europeans Perceive Their Healthcare System? Patterns of Satisfaction and Preference for State Involvement in the Field of Healthcare’, European Sociological Review26(2): 177–92.
68.
WendtC.MischkeM.PfeiferM.ReiblingN. (2012) ‘Confidence in Receiving Medical Care When Seriously Ill: A Seven-Country Comparison of the Impact of Cost Barriers’, Health Expectations15(2): 212–24.
69.
WhiteheadM.DahlgrenG. (1991) What Can be Done About Inequalities in Health?Lancet338(8774): 1059–1063.
