This paper revisits the case of Canaan – a massive informal settlement that emerged in the wake of the devastating 2010 earthquake in Haiti – in order to examine the often-forgotten aftermath of international aid programming in an urban, fragile-state context. Originally categorized as an (informal) internal displacement site, Canaan continued to expand in the years following the quake, reaching an estimated population of 300,000 by 2016. Using a qualitative case study of Canaan conducted nearly 15 years after its creation, the paper makes two interrelated arguments: first, that the ways in which the United Nations’ “durable solutions” framework is frequently understood and applied may be unrealistic and even deleterious for state–society relations in some fragile urban contexts. Second, even calls to shift (urban) internal displacement programming to a more development footing is far from a panacea if these interventions are not designed to be more politically nuanced, context-sensitive and modest about what can be achieved in such complex environments.
BatleyRMcLoughlinC (2010), “Engagement with non-state service providers in fragile states: reconciling state-building and service delivery”, Development Policy ReviewVol 28, pages 131–154.
2.
BennettCFoleyMPantulianoS (2016), “Time to let go: remaking humanitarian action for the modern era”, Overseas Development Institute, London.
3.
BlairR AWintersM S (2020), “Foreign aid and state-society relations: theory, evidence, and new directions for research”, Studies in Comparative International DevelopmentVol 55, No 2, pages 123–142.
4.
BoegeVBrownAClementsKNolanA (2008), “On hybrid political orders and emerging states: state formation in the context of ‘fragility’”, Berghof Research Centre for Constructive Conflict Management, Berlin.
5.
BohnetHCottierFHugS (2018), “Conflict-induced IDPs and the spread of conflict”, Journal of Conflict ResolutionVol 62, No 4, pages 691–716.
6.
BoothD (2012), “Development as a collective action problem: addressing the real challenges of African governance”, Overseas Development Institute, London.
7.
BrinkerhoffD (2014), “State fragility and failure as wicked problems: beyond naming and taming”, Third World QuarterlyVol 35, pages 333–344.
8.
CallC T (2011), “Beyond the ‘failed state’: toward conceptual alternatives”, European Journal of International RelationsVol 17, No 2, pages 303–326.
9.
CorbridgeS (editor) (2005), Seeing the State: Governance and Governmentality in India, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge; New York, 317 pages.
10.
CostalliSDi SalvatoreJRuggeriA (2023), “Do UN peace operations help forcibly displaced people?”, Journal of Peace Research, https://doi.org/10.1177/00223433231186448.
11.
CrispJMorrisTRefstieH (2012), “Displacement in urban areas: new challenges, new partnerships”, DisastersVol 36, No s1, pages S23–S42.
12.
de BoerJ (2015), “Resilience and the fragile city”, Stability: International Journal of Security and DevelopmentVol 4, No 1, 17.
DietrichSWintersM S (2021), “Foreign aid and quality of government”, in BågenholmABauhrMGrimesMRothsteinB (editors), The Oxford Handbook of the Quality of Government, Oxford University Press, Oxford, available at https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780198858218.013.22.
15.
EarleL (2023), “The urbanisation of displacement”, in JacobsenKMafidiN (editors), Handbook on Forced Migration, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, page 258.
ErtmanT (2005), “Building states – inherently a long-term process? An argument from comparative history”, States and Development: Historical Antecedents of Stagnation and Advance, Springer, Cham, pages 165–182.
Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime (2022), “Gangs of Haiti: expansion, power and an escalating crisis”, Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime, Geneva, available at https://globalinitiative.net/analysis/haiti-gangs-organized-crime/.
22.
GoodfellowT (2018), “Seeing political settlements through the city: a framework for comparative analysis of urban transformation”, Development and ChangeVol 49, No 1, pages 199–222.
23.
GrimmSLemay-HébertNNayO (2014), “‘Fragile states’: introducing a political concept”, Third World QuarterlyVol 35, No 2, pages 197–209.
24.
GripL (2017), “Coping with crises: forced displacement in fragile contexts”, SIPRI Yearbook 2017: Armaments, Disarmament and International Security, Stockholm.
25.
HaysomSel SarrajW (2013), “Sanctuary in the city? Reframing responses to protracted urban displacement”, HPG Policy Brief 52, London.
26.
HickeySSenKBukenyaB (editors) (2015), The Politics of Inclusive Development: Interrogating the Evidence, 1st edition, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 396 pages.
IFRC (2016), “World disasters report 2016 – resilience: saving lives today, investing for tomorrow”, International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies, available at https://www.ifrc.org/document/world-disasters-report-2016.
33.
International Monetary Fund (2010), “Haiti: 2010 Article IV consultation and request for a three-year arrangement under the extended credit facility: staff report, staff supplement; public information notice on the executive board discussion and statement by the executive director for Haiti”, IMF Country Report No. 10/263, Washington, DC, available at https://doi.org/10.5089/9781455206810.002
KälinW (2023), “Durable solutions in practice”, in KälinW (editor), Internal Displacement and the Law, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
38.
KaufmannDKraayA (2023), “Worldwide governance indicators, 2023 update”, available at www.govindicators.org.
39.
KelsallT (2012), “Neo-patrimonialism, rent-seeking and development: going with the grain?”, New Political EconomyVol 17, No 5, pages 677–682.
40.
KelsallTSchulzNFergusonW DvomMS HickeyHauLevyB (2022), Political Settlements and Development: Theory, Evidence, Implications, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
41.
KhanM H (2005), “Markets, states and democracy: patron–client networks and the case for democracy in developing countries”, DemocratizationVol 12, No 5, pages 704–724.
42.
KrasnerS DRisseT (2014), “External actors, state-building, and service provision in areas of limited statehood: introduction”, GovernanceVol 27, No 4, pages 545–567.
43.
LandauL B (2014), “Urban refugees and IDPs”, in Fiddian-QasmiyehELoescherGLongKSigonaN (editors), The Oxford Handbook of Refugee and Forced Migration Studies, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pages 139–150.
44.
LandauL B (2019), “Shunning solidarity: durable solutions in a fluid era”, in BradleyMMilnerJPeruniakB (editors), Refugees’ Roles in Resolving Displacement and Building Peace, Georgetown University Press, Washington, DC, pages 153–167.
45.
Lemay-HébertNMathieuX (2014), “The OECD’s discourse on fragile states: expertise and the normalisation of knowledge production”, Third World QuarterlyVol 35, No 2, pages 232–251.
LevyB (2014), Working with the Grain: Integrating Governance and Growth in Development Strategies, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
48.
LevyBWaltonM (2013), “Institutions, incentives and service provision: bringing politics back in”, SSRN Scholarly Paper, Rochester, NY, available at https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2386655.
49.
LottholzPLemay-HébertN (2016), “Re-reading Weber, re-conceptualizing state-building: from neo-Weberian to post-Weberian approaches to state, legitimacy and state-building”, Cambridge Review of International AffairsVol 29, No 4, pages 1467–1485.
50.
McLoughlinC (2018), “When the virtuous circle unravels: unfair service provision and state de-legitimation in divided societies”, Journal of Intervention and StatebuildingVol 12, No 4, pages 527–544.
51.
MillikenJKrauseK (2002), “State failure, state collapse, and state reconstruction: concepts, lessons and strategies”, Development and ChangeVol 33, No 5, pages 753–774.
52.
MitlinD (2022), “Understanding the politics of shelter in three African cities; the contribution of political settlements”, CitiesVol 128, 103797.
53.
MooreMUnsworthS (2010), “An upside down view of governance”, Institute of Development Studies, Brighton, 94 pages.
54.
MuggahR (2014), “Deconstructing the fragile city: exploring insecurity, violence and resilience”, Environment and UrbanizationVol 26, pages 345–358.
55.
MuggahR (2015), “A manifesto for the fragile city”, Journal of International AffairsVol 68, No 2, pages 19–36.
56.
MuggahR (2016), “Urban governance in fragile cities”, GSDRC Professional Development Reading Pack, University of Birmingham, Birmingham.
NayO (2013), “Fragile and failed states: critical perspectives on conceptual hybrids”, International Political Science ReviewVol 34, No 3, pages 326–341.
59.
NorthD CWallisJ JWeingastB R (2009), Violence and Social Orders: A Conceptual Framework for Interpreting Recorded Human History, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge; New York, 308 pages.
60.
O’DonnellGSchmitterP CWhiteheadL (2013), Transitions from Authoritarian Rule: Tentative Conclusions about Uncertain Democracies, Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore.
OrchardP (2010), “Protection of internally displaced persons: soft law as a norm-generating mechanism”, Review of International StudiesVol 36, No 2, pages 281–303.
RueschemeyerD (2005), “Building states – inherently a long-term process? An argument from theory”, in LangeMRueschemeyerD (editors), States and Development: Historical Antecedents of Stagnation and Advance, Palgrave Macmillan, New York, pages 143–164.
70.
SchmelzleCStollenwerkE (2018), “Virtuous or vicious circle? Governance effectiveness and legitimacy in areas of limited statehood”, Journal of Intervention and StatebuildingVol 12, No 4, pages 449–467.
71.
SchullerM (2016), Humanitarian Aftershocks in Haiti, Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, NJ, 312 pages.
72.
TendlerJFreedheimS (1994), “Trust in a rent-seeking world: health and government transformed in northeast Brazil”, World DevelopmentVol 22, No 12, pages 1771–1791.
73.
TillyC (1975), “Reflections on the history of European state-making”, The Formation of National States in Western EuropeVol 38, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, pages 3–83.
74.
UllrichL (2018), “Speak up via WhatsApp: understanding the life worlds of Syrian refugees and host communities in Lebanon”, UNDP Report Vol 29, 49 pages.
United Nations (1998), Guiding Principles on Internal Displacement, United Nations Commission on Human Rights, available at http://un-documents.net/gpid.htm.
United Nations (2021), “Shining a light on internal displacement: a vision for the future”, United Nations Secretary-General’s High-Level Panel on Internal Displacement, available at https://internaldisplacement-panel.org/index.html.
UnsworthS (2009), “What’s politics got to do with it? Why donors find it so hard to come to terms with politics, and why this matters”, Journal of International DevelopmentVol 21, No 6, pages 883–894.
84.
Van de WalleSScottZ (2011), “The political role of service delivery in state-building: exploring the relevance of European history for developing countries”, Development Policy ReviewVol 29, No 1, pages 5–21.
85.
WangS (2003), “The problem of state weakness”, Journal of DemocracyVol 14, pages 36–42.
86.
WardCJadotteL (2023), “Aid-induced informal settlement creation following disaster: the cautionary tale of Port-Au-Prince’s Canaan slum”, in JacobsenKMajidiN (editors), Handbook on Forced Migration, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, pages 277–283.
