A new form of union organizing in Japan? Community unions and the case of the McDonald’s ‘McUnion’

Abstract

The article examines how and why a new independent trade union was established in McDonald’s Japan in 2006. We discuss these developments both within the McDonald’s ‘system’ and the broader context of the growth of community unions in the Japanese employment system. The findings suggest that the ‘McUnion’ could be seen as a new form of trade union organizing in Japan; unlike an enterprise union it is independent of the employer and recruits ‘non-regular’ workers, yet unlike most community unions is established in one large employer, on a national rather than regional basis, has largely retained its membership and was established and operates with the direct involvement of the main Japanese Trade Union Confederation, Rengo.

Keywords

community unions Japanese employment relations McDonald’s multinational companies

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Asahi Shimbun (2009) Sick Society Must Mend Ways or Face Disaster. 21 May. Available (consulted 10 June 2009) at: http://www.asahi.com/english/Herald-asahi/TKY200905220068.html

Blundell

(2000) McJob, McCheque, McWonderful. Economic Affairs 20(1): 44–6.

Cranford

Das Gupta

Ladd

Vosko

(2006) Thinking through community unionism. In: Vosko

(ed.) Precarious Employment: Understanding Labour Market Insecurity in Canada. Toronto: McGill-Queens University Press, 353–77.

Dantes

(2010) Baltimore McDonald’s Fined for Violating Child Labour Laws. 14 July. Available (consulted 13 January 2011) at: www.walletpop.com/2010/07/14/baltimore-mcdonalds-fined

Deakin

Whittaker

(2009) On a different path? The managerial reshaping of Japanese corporate governance. In: Whittaker

Deakin

(eds) Corporate Governance and Managerial Reform in Japan. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1–27.

Endo

(2009) Big achievement of Hibiya Tent Village for the jobless [Meiji Daigaku Keieigaku Kenkyusho]. Keiei Ronshu 56(3/4): 97–109.

Fine

(2005) Community unions and the revival of the American labor movement. Politics and Society 33(1): 153–99.

Frege

Heery

Turner

(2004) The new solidarity? Trade union coalition-building in five countries. In: Frege

Kelly

(eds) Varieties of Unionism: Strategies for Union Revitalisation in a Globalizing Economy. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 137–58.

Fukui

(2002) Komyuniti yunion ga kobetsu funso kaiketsu ni hatasu yakuwari ni tsuite [The Role of Community Unions in Resolutions of Individual Labour Disputes]. Kyosei Shakaigaku 2: 29–45.

10.

Gordon

(1998) The Wages of Affluence: Labour and Management in Post-War Japan. Cambridge, MA and London: Harvard University Press.

11.

Gould

(2010) Working at McDonald’s: some redeeming features. Work, Employment and Society 24(4): 780–802.

12.

Halpin

Forst

Zautke

(2008) Conditions causing burn injuries in foodservice workers. Journal of Foodservice 19(3): 189–93.

13.

Hazama

(1997) The History of Labour Management in Japan. Translated by Sako

Sako

. London: Macmillan.

14.

Igarashi

(2008) Rodo sai-kisei: hanten no kozu o yomitoku [Labour re-regulation: interpreting the composition of the reverse course]. Tokyo: Chikumashinsho.

15.

Jacoby

(2005) The Embedded Corporation and Employment Relations in Japan and the United States. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

16.

Japan Times (2006) McDonald’s Gets Labor Union. 30 May. Available (consulted 11 December 2010) at: http://search.jpantimes.co.jp

17.

Japan Times (2008) McDonald’s to Pay Managers Overtime. Wednesday, 21 May. Available (consulted 3 October 2008) at: www.searchjapantimes.co.jp/cgi-bin

18.

Joeng

Aguilera

(2008) The evolution of enterprise unionism in Japan: a socio-political perspective. British Journal of Industrial Relations 46(1): 98–132.

19.

Leidner

(2002) Fast-food work in the United States. In: Royle

Towers

(eds) Labour Relations in the Global Fast-Food Industry. London and New York, NY: Routledge, 8–29.

20.

Lewis

(2009) Japan’s Army of Hostesses Break Shackles of Exploitation by Forming a Union. The Times 29 December. Available (consulted 25 May 2010) at: www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/asia/article6969903.ece

21.

Lichtenstein

(2009) The Retail Revolution: How Wal-Mart Created a Brand New World of Business. New York, NY: Henry Holt.

22.

Lindsay

McQuaid

(2004) Avoiding the McJobs: unemployed job seekers and attitudes to service work. Work, Employment and Society 18(2): 297–339.

23.

Love

(1995) McDonald’s Behind the Arches. New York, NY: Bantam.

24.

McCheat (2010) McCheat and Co / McFusk & Amp. [Swedish TV documentary] Available (consulted 20 June 2010) at: http://svt.se/2.123489/1.1996078/mcfusk_och_co, see also http://frianyheter.wordpress.com/2010/05/13/svt-dokumentar-mcfusk-co

25.

Mainichi Shinbum Online (2010) Tokyo Court Recognizes Death from Karoshi. 18 January. Available (consulted 20 May 2010) at: http://mainichi.jp/select/jiken/news/20100119k0000m040073000c.html

26.

MHLW (Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare) (2009) Heisei 21 Nen Rodo Kumiai Kiso Chosa Kekka no Gaikyo. 10 December, Available (consulted 21 May 2010) at: http://www.mhlw.go.jp/toukei/itiran/roudou/roushi/kiso/09/index.html

27.

Milkman

(2006) LA Story: Immigrant Workers and the Future of the US Labor Movement. New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.

28.

Mouer

Kawanishi

(2005) A Sociology of Work and Employment in Japan. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

29.

Nakamura

(2008) McDonald’s told to pay overtime to manager. Japan Times, 29 January, p. 3.

30.

Nakamura

(2007) Aragau wakamono: hiseiki koyo/wakamono no rodo kumiai no kuto [Fighting youth: the bitter struggle of labour unions for non-regular and young workers]. Gendai riron 11(Spring): 34–41.

31.

Nihon Keizai Shinbum (2009a) Tencho Nado 2000 nin ni Zangyo dai [Overtime pay for 2000 employees, including managers]. 9 October, p. 19.

32.

Nihon Keizai Shinbum (2009b) [McDonald’s agreement with former managers, dispute raised by ‘name only managers’] 27 October, p. 42.

33.

Osterman

(2006) Community organizing and employee representation. British Journal of Industrial Relations 44(4): 629–49.

34.

Ouchi

(2008) Nabakari Kanrishoku, Mondai no Toikakeru Mono. Business Labor Trend August: 18–21. Japan Institute for Labor Policy and Training. Available (consulted 10 June 2009) at: www.jil.go.jp/kokunai/blt/bn/2008-08/018-021.pdf

35.

Reiter

(2002) Fast-food in Canada, working conditions, labour law and unionization. In: Royle

Towers

(eds) Labour Relations in the Global Fast-Food Industry. London and New York, NY: Routledge, 30–47.

36.

Royle

(1998) Avoidance strategies and the German system of co-determination. International Journal of Human Resource Management 9(6): 1026–47.

37.

Royle

(1999a) The reluctant bargainers? McDonald’s, unions and pay determination in Germany and the UK. Industrial Relations Journal 30(2): 135–50.

38.

Royle

(1999b) Recruiting the acquiescent workforce: a comparative analysis of McDonald’s in Germany and the UK. Employee Relations 21(6): 540–55.

39.

Royle

(2000) Working for McDonald’s in Europe: The Unequal Struggle? London: Routledge.

40.

Royle

(2004) Employment practices of multinationals in the Spanish and German quick food service sectors: low road convergence? European Journal of Industrial Relations 10(1): 51–71.

41.

Royle

(2005) The union-recognition dispute at McDonald’s Moscow food-processing factory. Industrial Relations Journal 36(4): 318–32.

42.

Royle

(2006) The dominance effect? Multinational corporations in the Italian quick food service sector. British Journal of Industrial Relations 44(4): 757–59.

43.

Royle

(2010) McDonald’s and the global ‘McJob’: a longitudinal study of work, pay and unionization in the international fast-food industry. Labor History 51(2): 249–69.

44.

Sato

(2008) Long working hours and death from overwork. Kanagawa Shinbum, 6 September, p. 21.

45.

Sanchanta

(2005) McDonald’s faces $18m bill. Financial Times Wednesday 3 August, p. 17.

46.

Schlosser

(2002) Fast Food Nation. London: Penguin.

47.

schneiderwallace.com (2008) Class Action Alleges Widespread Violations of Labor Standards by McDonald’s Nationwide. 17 November. Available (consulted 13 January 2011) at: http://www.schneiderwallace.com/news_detail.php?id=13

48.

Shinoda

(2008) The return of Japanese labour? The mainstreaming of the labour question in Japanese politics. Labor History 49(2): 145–59.

49.

Shinoda

(2009) Which Side Are You on? Haken Mura and the Working Poor as a Tipping Point in Japanese Labor Politics. Asia-Pacific Journal 14(3). Available (consulted 25 May 2010) at: www.japanfocus.org/articles/print_article/3113

50.

Shipper

(2006) Foreigners and civil society in Japan. Pacific Affairs 79(2): 269–89.

51.

Stewart

Urano

(2009) Beyond organized labour in Japan: the case study of the Japan Community Union Federation. In: McBride

Greenwood

(eds) Community Unionism: A Comparative Analysis. London: Palgrave, 121–38.

52.

Suzuki

(2008) Community unions in Japan: similarities and differences of region-based labour movements between Japan and other industrialized countries. Economic and Industrial Democracy 29(4): 492–520.

53.

Takano

(2009) Makudonarudo Saiban [McDonald’s judicial trial]. Columns and Messages. Rengo’s Centre for Non-Regular Workers HP. Available (consulted 10 June 2009) at: http://www.jtuc-rengo.or.jp/roudou/koyou/hiseikiroudou/column/20090417.html

54.

Tannock

(2001) Youth at Work: The Unorganized Fast-Food and Grocery Workplace. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.

55.

Tattersall

(2005) There is power in coalition: a framework for assessing how and when union-community coalitions are effective and enhance union power. Labour and Industry 16(2): 97–112.

56.

Turner

(2006) Globalization and the logic of participation: unions and the politics of coalition building. Journal of Industrial Relations 48(1): 83–97.

57.

unite.org.nz (2009) Collective Agreement Settled after 50 Strikes. Monday 26 January. Available (consulted 12 April 2012) at: http://www.unite.org.nz/node/562

58.

Urano

Stewart

(2007) Including the excluded workers? The challenges of Japan’s Kanagawa City Union. Working USA: The Journal of Labour and Society 10: 103–23.

59.

waiterpay.com (2010) Assistant Manager Trainees at McDonald’s Restaurants Get $2.4m Settlement of FLSA Overtime Lawsuit. 12 November. Available (consulted 13 January 2011) at: http://waiterpay.com/assistant-manager-trainess-at-mcdonsld%E2%80%99s

60.

Weathers

(2010) The rising voice of Japan’s community unions. In: Vinken

. (eds) Civic Engagement in Contemporary Japan: Established and Emerging Repertoires. London: Springer, 67–83.

61.

Weathers

North

(2009) Overtime activists take on the titans: Toyota, McDonald’s and Japan’s work hour controversy. Pacific Affairs 82(4): 615–36.

62.

Wills

(2004) Organising the low paid: East London’s living wage campaign as a vehicle for change. In: Healy

. (eds) The Future of Worker Representation. London: Palgrave, 264–82.

63.

Yahoo Japan (2010) McDonald’s Shop at Yokohama, Karoshi Problem: McUnion Makes the First Agreement with the Company Concerning a Reduction in Overtime. 6 January. Available (consulted 25 May 2010) at: http://headlines.yahoo.co.jp/hl?a=20100106-00000004-kana-l14