The Varying Impacts of Merit-Aid Policy Design on Enrollment,Retention,and Graduation at Public Four-Year Colleges and Universities

Abstract

This study examines whether and which aspects of statewide merit-aid policies influence students’ enrollment, retention, and completion outcomes at public four-year institutions, before exploring the influence of discontinuing merit aid on student outcomes. Using a novel dataset capturing details of merit-based aid policies for public four-year institutions over nearly two decades, we find suggestive evidence that merit-aid adoption is related to postsecondary enrollment, retention, and completion outcomes, with considerable variation among student populations and certain policy designs. Exploratory analyses pertaining to the influence of discontinuing statewide merit aid reveal a null influence on postsecondary enrollment, retention, and graduation outcomes.

Keywords

financial aid college access retention completion state policies educational equity event study

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Astin

A. W.

Oseguera

(2004). The declining “equity” of American higher education. The Review of Higher Education, 27(3), 321–341. https://doi.org/10.1353/rhe.2004.0001

Bastedo

M. N.

Jaquette

(2011). Running in place: Low-income students and the dynamics of higher education stratification. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 33(3), 318–339. https://doi.org/10.3102/0162373711406718

Belasco

Rosinger

Hearn

(2015). The test-optional movement at America’s selective liberal arts colleges: A boon for equity or something else? Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 37(2), 206–223. https://doi.org/10.3102/0162373714537350

Bennett

C. T.

(2022). Untested admissions: Examining changes in application behaviors and student demographics under test-optional policies. American Educational Research Journal, 59(1), 180–216. https://doi.org/10.3102/00028312211003526

Berg

G. A.

(2016). Low-income students and the perpetuation of inequality: Higher education in America. Routledge.

Berkner

Berker

Rooney

Peter

(2002). Student financing of undergraduate education: 1999–2000 (NCES 2002–167). U.S. Department of Education, NCES.

Bettinger

(2015). Need-based aid and college persistence: The effects of the Ohio College Opportunity Grant. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 37(1S), 102–119. https://doi.org/10.3102/0162373715576072

Bettinger

Gurantz

Kawano

Sacerdote

Stevens

(2019). The long-run impacts of financial aid: Evidence from California’s Cal Grant. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 11(1), 64–94. https://doi.org/10.1257/pol.20170466

Biswas

Dasgupta

(2023). Is merit-aid for all? The effects of aid-eligibility changes on college access in the United States. Studies in Higher Education, 49(11), 1984–1997. https://doi.org/10.1080/03075079.2023.2285857

10.

Brown

(2007). Merit aid: The practice of giving money to those who do not need it. New Directions for Student Services, 2007(118), 39–47.

11.

Buchmann

Condron

D. J.

Roscigno

V. J.

(2010). Shadow education, American style: Test preparation, the SAT and college enrollment. Social Forces, 89(2), 435–461. https://doi.org/10.1353/sof.2010.0105

12.

Callaway

Sant’Anna

P. H.

(2020). Difference-in-differences with multiple time periods. Journal of Econometrics, 225(2), 200–230. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jeconom.2020.12.001

13.

Carruthers

C. K.

Özek

(2016). Losing HOPE: Financial aid and the line between college and work. Economics of Education Review, 53, 1–15. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econedurev.2016.03.014

14.

Castleman

B. L.

Long

B. T.

(2016). Looking beyond enrollment: The causal effect of need-based grants on college access, persistence, and graduation. Journal of Labor Economics, 34(4), 1023–1073. https://doi.org/10.1086/686643

15.

Chetty

Friedman

J. N.

Saez

Turner

Yagan

(2020). Income segregation and intergenerational mobility across colleges in the United States. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 135(3), 1567–1633. https://doi.org/10.1093/qje/qjaa005

16.

Cohen-Vogel

Ingle

W. K.

Levine

A. A.

Spence

(2008). The “spread” of merit-based college aid: Politics, policy consortia, and interstate competition. Educational Policy, 22(3), 339–362. https://doi.org/10.1177/0895904807307059

17.

Cohodes

S. R.

Goodman

J. S.

(2014). Merit aid, college quality, and college completion: Massachusetts’ Adams scholarship as an in-kind subsidy. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 6(4), 251–285. https://doi.org/10.1257/app.6.4.251

18.

College Board. (2023). SAT suite of assessments annual report. College Board. https://reports.collegeboard.org/media/pdf/2023-total-group-sat-suite-of-assessments-annual-report%20ADA.pdf

19.

Cornwell

Mustard

Sridhar

(2006). The enrollment effects of merit-based financial aid: Evidence from Georgia’s HOPE Scholarship. Journal of Labor Economics, 24(4), 761–786. https://doi.org/10.1086/506485

20.

Cummings

Laderman

Lee

Tandberg

Weeden

(2021). Investigating the impacts of state higher education appropriations and financial aid. State Higher Education Executive Officers Association. https://sheeo.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/SHEEO_ImpactAppropationsFinancialAid.pdf

21.

Custer

B. D.

Akaeze

H. O.

(2021). A typology of state financial aid grant programs using latent class analysis. Research in Higher Education, 62(2), 175–205. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11162-019-09585-5

22.

de Chaisemartin

D’Haultfoeuille

(2020). Two-way fixed effects estimators with heterogeneous treatment effects. American Economic Review, 110(9), 2964–2996. https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.20181169

23.

de Chaisemartin

D’Haultfœuille

(2023). Two-way fixed effects and differences-in-differences with heterogeneous treatment effects: A survey. Econometrics Journal, 26, C1–C30. https://doi.org/10.1093/ectj/utac017

24.

de Chaisemartin

D’Haultfœuille

Malézieux

Sow

(2023). Comparing the did_multiplegt and did_multiplegt_dyn Stata commands. Routledge.

25.

Domina

(2014). Does merit aid program design matter? A cross-cohort analysis. Research in Higher Education, 55(1), 1–26.

26.

Doyle

W. R.

(2010). Does merit-based aid “crowd out” need-based aid? Research in Higher Education, 51, 397–415. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11162-010-9166-3

27.

Dynarski

(2000). Hope for whom? Financial aid for the middle class and its impact on college attendance. National Tax Journal, 53, 629–661.

28.

Dynarski

(2004). The new merit aid. In Hoxby

C. M.

(Ed.), College choices: The economics of where to go, when to go, and how to pay for it (pp. 63–100). University of Chicago Press.

29.

Engle

Tinto

(2008). Moving beyond access: College success for low-income, first-generation students. Pell Institute for the Study of Opportunity in Higher Education.

30.

Erwin

Binder

(2020). Does broad-based merit aid improve college completion? Evidence from New Mexico’s lottery scholarship. Education Finance and Policy, 15(1), 164–190. https://doi.org/10.1162/edfp_a_00270

31.

Everett

Rosinger

Baker

D. J.

Kim

H. J.

Kelchen

Ortagus

J. C.

(2024). Tennessee’s burden: How students apply for state financial aid within one southern state. Research in Higher Education, 65(8), 1826–1852. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11162-024-09793-8

32.

FairTest. (n.d.). What is test-optional? National Center for Fair and Open Testing. https://fairtest.org/test-optional/

33.

Farrell

P. L.

Kienzl

G. S.

(2009). Are state non-need, merit-based scholarship programs impacting college enrollment? Education Finance and Policy, 4(2), 150–174. https://doi.org/10.1162/edfp.2009.4.2.150

34.

Fitzpatrick

M. D.

Jones

(2016). Post-baccalaureate migration and merit-based scholarships. Economics of Education Review, 54, 155–172.

35.

Ford

K. S.

Rosinger

K. O.

Zhu

(2021). Consolidation of class advantages in the wake of the Great Recession: University enrollments, educational opportunity and stratification. Research in Higher Education, 62, 915–941. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11162-021-09624-0

36.

Goldrick-Rab

Harris

D. N.

Trostel

P. A.

(2009). Why financial aid matters (or does not) for college success: Toward a new interdisciplinary perspective. In Smart

J. C.

(Ed.), Higher education: Handbook of theory and research (Vol. 24, pp. 1–45). Springer.

37.

Goldrick-Rab

Kelchen

Harris

D. N.

Benson

(2016). Reducing income inequality in educational attainment: Experimental evidence on the impact of financial aid on college completion. American Journal of Sociology, 121(6), 1762–1817. https://doi.org/10.1086/685442

38.

González Canché

M. S.

(2023). Becoming HOPEless in the 2-year sector. Educational Policy, 37(7), 2051–2115. https://doi.org/10.1177/08959048221120276

39.

Groen

J. A.

(2011). Do merit-aid programs help states build skilled workforces? Change, 43(6): 33–37.

40.

Gurantz

Odle

T. K.

(2022). The impact of merit aid on college choice and degree attainment: Reexamining Florida’s Bright Futures Program. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 44(1), 79–104. https://doi.org/10.3102/01623737211030489

41.

Guinier

(2016). The tyranny of the meritocracy: Democratizing higher education in America. Beacon Press.

42.

Hadavand

(2018). Educational aid policy and inequality: The case for merit-and need-based aid. Review of Social Economy, 76(4), 535–562.

43.

Harrington

Muñoz

Curs

Ehlert

(2016). Examining the impact of a highly targeted state administered merit aid program on brain drain: Evidence from a regression discontinuity analysis of Missouri’s Bright Flight Program. Research in Higher Education, 57(4), 423–447.

44.

Hegland

T. A.

(2023). Wooldid: Estimation of difference-in-differences treatment effects with staggered treatment onset using heterogeneity-robust two-way fixed effects regressions. Routledge.

45.

Heller

D. E.

(2006). Merit aid and college access. Wisconsin Center for the Advancement of Postsecondary Education.

46.

Heller

D. E.

Marin

(2002). Who should we help? The negative social consequences of merit scholarships. The Civil Rights Project at Harvard University.

47.

Heller

D. E.

Rasmussen

(2001). Merit scholarships and college access: Evidence from two states. State merit aid programs: College access and equity. The Civil Rights Project at Harvard University.

48.

Henry

G. T.

Rubenstein

Bugler

D. T.

(2004). Is HOPE enough? Impacts of receiving and losing merit-based financial aid. Educational Policy, 18(5), 686–709.

49.

Horn

Peter

(2003). What colleges contribute: Institutional aid to full-time undergraduates attending 4-year colleges and universities (NCES 2003–157). U.S. Department of Education, NCES. U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, DC.

50.

Fernandez

Qiu

Capaldi

. (2024). The good, the bad, and the balanced: A typology of state merit-aid programs for community college students. Community College Review, 52(3), 289–314. https://doi.org/10.1177/00915521241238753

51.

Jez

S. J.

(2014). The differential impact of wealth versus income in the college-going process. Research in Higher Education, 55(7), 710–734. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11162-014-9332-0

52.

Jia

(2019). Heterogeneous effects of merit scholarships: Do program features matter? Applied Economics, 51(27), 2963–2979. https://doi.org/10.1080/00036846.2018.1564017

53.

Jones

T. R.

Kreisman

Rubenstein

Searcy

Bhatt

(2022). The effects of financial aid loss on persistence and graduation: A multi-dimensional regression discontinuity approach. Education Finance and Policy, 17(2), 206–231. https://doi.org/10.1162/edfp_a_00337

54.

Kash

J. P.

Lasley

(2011). The role of utilization and retention on the distribution of merit aid. Virginia Social Science Journal, 46, 39–56.

55.

LaSota

R. R.

Polanin

J. R.

Perna

L. W.

Austin

M. J.

Steingut

R. R.

Rodgers

M. A.

(2022). The effects of losing postsecondary student grant aid: Results from a systematic review. Educational Researcher, 51(2), 160–168. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X211056868

56.

LaSota

R. R.

Polanin

J. R.

Perna

L. W.

Rodgers

M. A.

Austin

M. J.

(2024). Does aid matter? A systematic review and meta-analysis of the effects of grant aid on college student outcomes. Review of Educational Research, 95(3), 464–504. https://doi.org/10.3102/00346543241239955

57.

Lee

(2018). Does merit-based aid promote degree attainment? KEDI Journal of Educational Policy, 15(1), 99–118.

58.

Leeds

DesJardins

(2015). The effect of merit aid on enrollment: A regression discontinuity analysis of Iowa’s National Scholars Award. Research in Higher Education, 56(5), 471–495.

59.

Liu

(2011). Unraveling the myth of meritocracy within the context of US higher education. Higher Education, 62(4), 383–397. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-010-9394-7

60.

Long

M. C.

Bateman

N. A.

(2020). Long-run changes in underrepresentation after affirmative action bans in public universities. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 42(2), 188–207. https://doi.org/10.3102/0162373720904433

61.

Lowry

R. C.

(2019). The effects of state higher education policies and institutions on access by economically disadvantaged students. Research in Higher Education, 60(1), 44–63.

62.

Manic

Ptukhina

(2022). The impact of state-funded merit aid on the retention of college graduates. The Review of Regional Studies, 52, 210–248.

63.

Miller

D. L.

(2023). An introductory guide to event study models. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 37(2), 203–230. https://doi.org/10.1257/jep.37.2.203

64.

Ness

E. C.

Mistretta

M. A.

(2010). Merit aid in North Carolina: A case study of a “nonevent.” Educational Policy, 24(5), 703–734. https://doi.org/10.1177/0895904809339165

65.

Ness

E. C.

Tucker

(2008). Eligibility effects on college access: Under-represented student perceptions of Tennessee’s Merit Aid Program. Research in Higher Education, 49(7), 569–588.

66.

Nguyen

T. D.

Kramer

J. W.

Evans

B. J.

(2019). The effects of grant aid on student persistence and degree attainment: A systematic review and meta-analysis of the causal evidence. Review of Educational Research, 89(6), 831–874. https://doi.org/10.3102/0034654319877156

67.

Perna

L. W.

Leigh

E. W.

(2018). Understanding the promise: A typology of state and local college promise programs. Educational Researcher, 47(3), 155–180. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X17742653

68.

Rosinger

(2020). Toppling testing? COVID-19, test-optional college admissions, and implications for equity. Third Way.

69.

Roth

(2022). Pretest with caution: Event-study estimates after testing for parallel trends. American Economic Review: Insights, 4(3), 305–322. https://doi.org/10.1257/aeri.20210236

70.

Schneider

Ingram

(1993). Social construction of target populations: Implications for politics and policy. American Political Science Review, 87(2), 334–347.

71.

Scott-Clayton

(2011). On money and motivation a quasi-experimental analysis of financial incentives for college achievement. Journal of Human Resources, 46(3), 614–646. https://doi.org/10.3368/jhr.46.3.614

72.

Singell

Stater

(2006). Going, going, gone: The effects of aid policies on graduation at three large public institutions. Policy Sciences, 39(4), 379–403.

73.

Sjoquist

D. L.

Winters

J. V.

(2014). Merit aid and post-college retention in the state. Journal of Urban Economics, 80, 39–50. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jue.2013.10.003

74.

Sjoquist

D. L.

Winters

J. V.

(2015). State merit-based financial aid programs and college attainment. Journal of Regional Science, 55(3), 364–390.

75.

Sjoquist

D. L.

Winters

J. V.

(2016). The effects of state merit aid programs on attendance at elite colleges. Southern Economic Journal, 83(2), 527–549.

76.

Song

Rubenstein

(2024). How does reducing merit-aid generosity and certainty affect college choices? Evidence from Georgia’s HOPE Scholarship. Research in Higher Education, 65, 1–41. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11162-023-09747-6

77.

Stevens

M. L.

(2009). Creating a class: College admissions and the education of elites. Harvard University Press.

78.

Sun

Abraham

(2021). Estimating dynamic treatment effects in event studies with heterogeneous treatment effects. Journal of Econometrics, 225(2), 175–199. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jeconom.2020.09.006

79.

The Higher Education Student Assistance Authority (HESAA). (2011). 2011 annual report. https://www.hesaa.org/Documents/Financial/AnnualReports/AnnualReport2011Final.pdf

80.

The Higher Education Student Assistance Authority (HESAA). (2025). Grants and scholarships. https://www.hesaa.org/Pages/NJGrantsHome.aspx

81.

The National Association of State Student Grant and Aid Programs (NASSGAP). (2023). 54th Annual survey reports on state-sponsored student financial aid, 2022–2023 academic year. https://www.nassgapsurvey.com/survey_reports/2022-2023-54th.pdf

82.

Toutkoushian

R. K.

Hillman

N. W.

(2012). The impact of state appropriations and grants on access to higher education and outmigration. The Review of Higher Education, 36(1), 51–90.

83.

Welch

J. G.

(2014). HOPE for community college students: The impact of merit aid on persistence, graduation, and earnings. Economics of Education Review, 43, 1–20.

84.

Whatley

(2019). Study abroad participation: An unintended consequence of state merit-aid programs? Research in Higher Education, 60(7), 905–930. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11162-018-09540-w

85.

Winston

G. C.

(1999). Subsidies, hierarchy and peers: The awkward economics of higher education. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 13(1), 13–36. https://doi.org/10.1257/jep.13.1.13

86.

Zhang

Sensenig

(2013). The effect of Florida’s Bright Futures Program on college enrollment and degree production: An aggregated-level analysis. Research in Higher Education, 54(7), 746–764. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11162-013-9293-8

87.

Zhang

Sun

(2016). The effect of Florida’s Bright Futures Program on college choice: A regression discontinuity approach. The Journal of Higher Education, 87(1), 115–146. https://doi.org/10.1080/00221546.2016.11777396

88.

Zhang

Ness

E. C.

(2010). Does state merit-based aid STEM brain drain? Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 32(2), 143–165. https://doi.org/10.3102/0162373709359683