Big Data and the Illusion of Choice: Comparing the Evolution of India’s Aadhaar and China’s Social Credit System as Technosocial Discourses

Abstract

India and China have launched enormous projects aimed at collecting vital personal information regarding their billion-plus populations and building the world’s biggest data sets in the process. However, both Aadhaar in India and the Social Credit System in China are controversial and raise a plethora of political and ethical concerns. The governments claim that participation in these projects is voluntary, even as they link vital services to citizens registering with these projects. In this study, we analyze how the news media in India and China—crucial data intermediaries that shape public perceptions on data and technological practices—framed these projects since their inception. Topic modeling suggests news coverage in both nations disregards the public interest and focuses largely on how businesses can benefit from them. The media, institutionally and ideologically linked with governments and corporations, show little concern with violations of privacy and mass surveillance that these projects could lead to. We argue that this renders citizens structurally incapable of making a meaningful “choice” about whether or not to participate in such projects. Implications for various stakeholders are discussed.

Keywords

Aadhaar Social Credit System media privacy surveillance data

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Acquisti

Gross

Stutzman

(2011, August 4). Faces of Facebook: Privacy in the age of augmented reality. Paper presented at BlackHat Conference, Las Vegas, NV.

Andrejevic

Gates

(2014). Big data surveillance: Introduction. Surveillance & Society, 12, 185–196.

Angwin

Larson

Mattu

Kirchner

(2016). Machine bias. ProPublica. Retrieved from https://www.propublica.org/article/machine-bias-risk-assessments-in-criminal-sentencing

Baruh

Popescu

(2017). Big data analytics and the limits of privacy self-management. New Media & Society, 19, 579–596.

Bloomberg. (2017). India ID program wins World Bank praise despite “big brother” fears. Retrieved from https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-03-15/india-id-program-wins-world-bank-praise-amid-big-brother-fears

boyd

Crawford

(2012). Critical questions for big data. Information, Communication & Society, 15, 662–679.

Brewer

P. R.

Gross

(2010). Studying the effects of issue framing on public opinion about policy issues: Does what we see depend on how we look. In D’Angelo

Kuypers

(Eds.), Doing news framing analysis: Empirical and theoretical perspectives (pp. 159–186). New York, NY: Routledge.

Central People’s Government (2000). The Central Committee of the Communist Party of China Recommendations for the Tenth Five-Year Plan for Social Development. Retrieved from http://www.gov.cn/gongbao/content/2000/content_60538.html

Chadha

M. S.

Broor

Gunasekaran

Potdar

V. A.

Krishnan

Chawla-Sarkar

,… Klimov

(2012). Multisite virological influenza surveillance in India: 2004–2008. Influenza and Other Respiratory Viruses, 6, 196–203.

10.

Chakravartty

Roy

(2013). Media pluralism redux: Towards new frameworks of comparative media studies “beyond the west.” Political Communication, 30, 349–370.

11.

Chandrasekhar

(2015). A shaky Aadhaar. The Indian Express. Retrieved from http://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/a-shaky-aadhaar/

12.

Chen

Reese

S. D.

(2015). Introduction: A new agenda: Digital media and civic engagement in networked China. In Chen

Reese

S. D.

(Eds.), Networked China: Global Dynamics of Digital Media and Civic Engagement (pp. 21–36). New York, NY: Routledge.

13.

China Copyright and Media. (2014). Planning outline for the construction of a social credit system (2014-2020). Retrieved from https://chinacopyrightandmedia.wordpress.com/2014/06/14/planning-outline-for-the-construction-of-a-social-credit-system-2014-2020/

14.

Crawford

(2016). Artificial intelligence’s white guy problem. New York Times. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/26/opinion/sunday/artificial-intelligences-white-guy-problem.html

15.

Dai

Zhu

Liang

Wang

Y. P.

Wang

Mao

(2011). Birth defects surveillance in China. World Journal of Pediatrics, 7, 302–310.

16.

De Vreese

C. H.

(2010). Framing the economy: Effects of journalistic news frames. In D’Angelo

Kuypers

(Eds.), Doing news framing analysis: Empirical and theoretical perspectives (pp. 187–214). New York, NY: Routledge.

17.

DiMaggio

Nag

Blei

(2013). Exploiting affinities between topic modeling and the sociological perspective on culture: Application to newspaper coverage of U.S. Government arts funding. Poetics, 41, 570–606.

18.

Dixon

(2017). A failure to do no harm—India’s Aadhaar biometric ID program and its inability to protect privacy in relation to measures in Europe and the U.S. Health Technology, 7, 539–567.

19.

Durham

F. S.

(1998). News frames as social narratives: TWA flight 800. Journal of Communication, 48, 100–117.

20.

Elueze

Quan-Haase

(2018). Privacy attitudes and concerns in the digital lives of older adults: Westin’s privacy attitude typology revisited. American Behavioral Scientist, 62, 1372–1391.

21.

Entman

R. M.

(1993). Framing: Toward clarification of a fractured paradigm. Journal of Communication, 43, 51–58.

22.

Fung

A. Y.

(2007). Political economy of Hong Kong media: Producing a hegemonic voice. Asian Journal of Communication, 17, 159–171.

23.

Gamson

W. A.

Modigliani

(1989). Media discourse and public opinion on nuclear power: A constructionist approach. American Journal of Sociology, 95, 1–37.

24.

Garson

(1988). The electronic sweatshop: How computers are transforming the office of the future into the factory of the past. New York, NY: Simon & Schuster.

25.

Gellman

Poitras

(2013, June 6). US, British intelligence mining data from nine US internet companies in broad secret program. The Washington Post. Retrieved from http://www.washingtonpost.com/investigations/usintelligence-mining-data-from-nine-us-internet-companies-in-broad-secret-program/2013/06/06/3a0c0da8-cebf-11e2-8845-d970ccb04497_story.html

26.

Guo

Vargo

C. J.

Pan

Ding

Ishwar

(2016). Big social data analytics in journalism and mass communication: Comparing dictionary-based text analysis and unsupervised topic modeling. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly, 93, 332–359.

27.

Hawkins

(2017). Chinese citizens want the government to rank them. Foreign Policy. Retrieved from http://foreignpolicy.com/2017/05/24/chinese-citizens-want-the-government-to-rank-them/

28.

Herman

E. S.

Chomsky

(1988). Manufacturing consent: The political economy of the mass media. New York, NY: Pantheon Books.

29.

Hindustan Times . (2017). Jharkhand’s Aadhaar breach: India needs a strong data protection law. Retrieved from http://www.hindustantimes.com/editorials/jharkhand-s-aadhaar-breach-india-needs-a-strong-data-protection-law/story-5of3gapEnnMWiy7c7vJ4YN.html

30.

Hoofnagle

Urban

(2014). Alan Westin’s privacy homo economicus. Wake Forest Law Review, 49, 261–309.

31.

India Today . (2012, October 19). Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh will launch Aadhaar enabled service delivery on October 20 in Dudu, Rajasthan marking the 2nd anniversary of Aadhaar.

32.

Indian Express . (2013, November 27). 11 states get SC notice on PIL against Aadhaar validity.

33.

Indian Express . (2014). Don’t exclude those without Aadhaar, share data: SC. Retrieved from http://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-others/supreme-court-bars-sharing-of-uidai-info-denial-of-benefits-to-those-without-aadhaar/

34.

Jacobi

Atteveldt

Welbers

(2016). Quantitative analysis of large amounts of journalistic texts using topic modelling. Digital Journalism, 4, 89–106.

35.

Kumaraguru

Cranor

L. F.

(2005). Privacy indexes: A survey of Westin’s studies. Institute for Software Research International, Carnegie Mellon University. Retrieved from http://repository.cmu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1857&context=isr

36.

Lee

C-C.

(2003). Chinese media, global contexts. London, England: Routledge.

37.

Liang

X. F.

Liu

D. W.

K. L.

W. D.

Zhu

B. P.

,… Yin

D. P.

(2011). Safety of influenza A (H1N1) vaccine in postmarketing surveillance in China. New England Journal of Medicine, 364, 638–647.

38.

Lukes

(1974). Power: A radical view. London, England: Macmillan.

39.

Mail Today . (2011, August 12). Post offices involved in Aadhaar.

40.

McIntyre

Michael

Albrecht

(2015). RFID: Helpful new technology or threat to privacy and civil liberties? IEEE Potentials, 34, 13–18.

41.

Mneney

Van Belle

J. P.

(2016, January). Big data capabilities and readiness of South African retail organisations. In Cloud System and Big Data Engineering (Confluence), 2016 6th International Conference (pp. 279–286). Noida: IEEE.

42.

Nilekani

(2015). Why Supreme Court judgment on Aadhaar calls for an appeal. The Indian Express. Retrieved from http://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/why-supreme-court-judgment-on-aadhaar-calls-for-an-appeal/

43.

Pan

(2000). Spatial configuration in institutional change: A case of China’s journalism reforms. Journalism, 1, 253–281.

44.

Pentland

A. S.

(2014). Social physics: How good ideas spread—The lessons from a new science. New York, NY: Penguin Books.

45.

People’s Daily (2011). On the Significance of the Formation of the Socialist Judicial System with Chinese Characteristics. Retrieved from http://theory.people.com.cn/GB/13815782.html

46.

Philo

(2014). The Glasgow media group reader, vol. II: Industry, economy, war and politics. London, England: Routledge.

47.

Quail

Larabie

(2010). Net neutrality: Media discourses and public perception. Global Media Journal, 3, 31–50.

48.

Reese

S. D.

(2001). Prologue—Framing public life. In Reese

S. D.

Gandy

O. H.

Jr Grant

A. E.

(Eds.), Framing public life: Perspectives on media and our understanding of the social world (pp. 7–31). New York, NY: Routledge.

49.

Roy

Kalra

(2011, August 12). The information technology rules, 2011, PRS Legislative Research, Center for Policy Research. Retrieved from http://www.prsindia.org/uploads/media/IT%20Rules/IT%20Rules%20and%20Regulations%20Brief%202011.pdf

50.

Safire

(2002, November 14). You are a suspect. The New York Times. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2002/11/14/opinion/you-are-a-suspect.html

51.

Sawicki

D. S.

Craig

W. J.

(1996). The democratization of data: Bridging the gap for community groups. Journal of the American Planning Association, 62, 512–523.

52.

Schrock

Shaffer

(2017). Data ideologies of an interested public: A study of grassroots open government data intermediaries. Big Data & Society, 4, 1–10.

53.

Sen

(2016). Digital politics and culture in contemporary India: The making of an info-nation. London, England: Routledge.

54.

Shah

Mathur

(2010). Surveillance of cardiovascular disease risk factors in India: The need & scope. The Indian Journal of Medical Research, 132, 634.

55.

Shahin

(2016a). Right to be forgotten: How national identity, political orientation, and capitalist ideology structured a trans-Atlantic debate on information access and control. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly, 93, 360–382.

56.

Shahin

(2016b). When scale meets depth: Integrating natural language processing and textual analysis for studying digital corpora. Communication Methods and Measures, 10, 28–50.

57.

Shahin

(2017). Facing up to Facebook: How digital activism, independent regulation, and mass media foiled a neoliberal threat to net neutrality. Information, Communication & Society. doi:10.1080/1369118X.2017.1340494

58.

Shahin

Zheng

Sturm

H. A.

Fadnis

(2016). Protesting the paradigm: A comparative study of news coverage of protests in Brazil, China, and India. The International Journal of Press/Politics, 21, 143–164.

59.

Srinivasan

Bailur

Schoemaker

Seshagiri

(2018). Privacy at the margins| The poverty of privacy: Understanding privacy trade-offs from identity infrastructure users in India. International Journal of Communication, 12, 1228–1247.

60.

Stanaland

A. J.

Lwin

M. O.

(2013). Online privacy practices: Advances in China. Journal of International Business Research, 12, 33.

61.

Stoycheff

(2016). Under surveillance: Examining Facebook’s spiral of silence effects in the wake of NSA internet monitoring. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly, 93, 296–311.

62.

Sun

Wang

Zheng

Wang

,… Wang

(2007). The development of HIV/AIDS surveillance in China. Aids, 21, S33–S38.

63.

Telegraph . (2015, August 6). Aadhaar privacy test.

64.

Tehelka . (2009). Falling between the bar codes. Retrieved from http://www.tehelka.com/2009/08/falling-between-the-barcodes/?singlepage=1

65.

Thussu

D. K.

(2007). The Murdochization of news? The case of star TV in India. Media, Culture & Society, 29, 593–611.

66.

Times of India . (2009). Fingerprinting or iris scan during 2011 census for UID scheme. Retrieved from https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Fingerprinting-or-iris-scan-during-2011-census-for-UID-scheme-Nandan-Nilekani/articleshow/5130518.cms

67.

Unique Identification Authority of India. (n.d.). About Aadhaar. Retrieved from https://uidai.gov.in/your-aadhaar/about-aadhaar.html

68.

Ward

J. S.

Barker

(2013). Undefined by data: A survey of big data definitions. Retrieved from https://arxiv.org/abs/1309.5821

69.

White House. (2012). Consumer data privacy in a networked world: A framework for protecting privacy and promoting innovation in the global digital economy. Retrieved from http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/privacy-final.pdf

70.

Wired . (2005). Why the world is flat. Retrieved from https://www.wired.com/2005/05/friedman-2/

71.

Wired . (2017). Big data meets big brother as China moves to rate its citizens. Retrieved from http://www.wired.co.uk/article/chinese-government-social-credit-score-privacy-invasion

72.

Xinhua.net. (June 22, 2014). How much is trust. Retrieved from http://finance.ifeng.com/a/20140622/12585704_0.shtml

73.

(2017). Networking China: The digital transformation of the Chinese economy. Champaign: University of Illinois Press.

74.

Zhou

(2009, May 7). The urgency of building up financial credit system from: A lesson from US financial crisis. Retrieved form http://finance.people.com.cn/GB/67543/9260040.html