This article revisits the relationship between urban form and excess commuting by analyzing 206 metropolitan statistical areas in the United States. Using the most recent Census Transportation Planning Products, we revalidated the importance of using multidimensional indices when examining excess commuting across metropolitan areas. We found that higher levels of polycentricity aggravate cross-commuting, while higher central city dominance improves excess commuting. In addition, our results indicate the significant impact of sprawl or jobs–housing dispersal on excess commuting. These findings shed light on the multidimensional relationship between urban form and excess commuting.
BertaudAlain. 2002. “Note on Transportation and Urban Spatial Structure.” In Annual Bank Conferences on Development Economics, edited by PleskovicBorisSternNicholas Herbert. Washington, DC: World Bank.
2.
BrotchieJohn F.1984. “Technological Change and Urban Form.” Environment and Planning A16 (5): 583–96.
3.
BrotchieJohn F.AndersonM.GippsP. G.McNamaraC. 1996. “Urban Productivity and Sustainability—Impacts of Technological Change.” In Transport, Land-use and the Environment, edited by HayashiYoshitsuguRoyJohn, 81–99. Boston, MA: Springer.
4.
BuliungRonald N.KanaroglouPavlos S. 2002. “Commute Minimization in the Greater Toronto Area: Applying a Modified Excess Commute.” Journal of Transport Geography10 (3): 177–86.
5.
CerveroRobertKockelmanKara. 1997. “Travel Demand and the 3Ds: Density, Diversity, and Design.” Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment2 (3): 199–219.
6.
CharronM.2007. “From Excess Commuting to Commuting Possibilities: More Extension to the Concept of Excess Commuting.” Environment and Planning A39 (5): 1238–54.
7.
ChowdhuryTufayel A.ScottDarren M.KanaroglouPavlos S. 2013. “Urban Form and Commuting Efficiency: A Comparative Analysis across Time and Space.” Urban Studies50 (1): 191–207.
8.
CraneRandall. 2000. “The Influence of Urban Form on Travel: An Interpretive Review.” Journal of Planning Literature15 (1): 3–23.
9.
CropperMaureen L.GordonPatrice L. 1991. “Wasteful Commuting: A Re-examination.” Journal of Urban Economics29 (1): 2–13.
10.
EwingReidCerveroRobert. 2010. “Travel and the Built Environment: A Meta-Analysis.” Journal of the American Planning Association76 (3): 265–94.
11.
FrostM. E.SpenceN. A. 1995. “The Rediscovery of Accessibility and Economic Potential: The Critical Issue of Self-potential.” Environment and Planning A27 (11): 1833–48.
12.
GainzaXabierLivertFelipe. 2013. “Urban Form and the Environmental Impact of Commuting in a Segregated City, Santiago de Chile.” Environment and Planning B40 (3): 507–22.
13.
García-PalomaresJuan Carlos. 2010. “Urban Sprawl and Travel to Work: The Case of the Metropolitan Area of Madrid.” Journal of Transport Geography18 (2): 197–213.
14.
GreenNick. 2007. “Functional Polycentricity: A Formal Definition in Terms of Social Network Analysis.” Urban Studies44 (11): 2077–2103.
15.
HamidiShimaEwingReidPreussIlanaDoddsAlex. 2015. “Measuring Sprawl and Its Impacts: An Update.” Journal of Planning Education and Research35 (1): 35–50.
16.
HamiltonBruce W.1982. “Wasteful Commuting.” Journal of Political Economy90:1035–53.
17.
HamiltonBruce W. 1989. “Wasteful Commuting Again.” Journal of Political Economy97 (6): 1497–504.
18.
HornerMark W.2002. “Extensions to the Concept of Excess Commuting.” Environment and Planning A34 (3): 543–66.
19.
HornerMark W.2007. “A Multi-scale Analysis of Urban Form and Commuting Change in a Small Metropolitan Area (1990–2000).” Annals of Regional Science41 (2): 315–32.
20.
HornerMark W.2010. “How Does Ignoring Worker Class Affect Measuring the Jobs-Housing Balance? Exploratory Spatial Data Analysis.” Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board (2163): 57–64.
21.
HornerMark W.SchleithDaniel. 2012. “Analyzing Temporal Changes in Land-Use–Transportation Relationships: A LEHD-Based Approach.” Applied Geography35 (1): 491–98.
22.
HornerMark W.SchleithDaniel K.WidenerMichael J. 2015. “An Analysis of the Commuting and Jobs-Housing Patterns of Older Adult Workers.” Professional Geographer67 (4): 575–85.
23.
HuYujieWangFahui. 2015. “Decomposing Excess Commuting: A Monte Carlo Simulation Approach.” Journal of Transport Geography44:43–52.
24.
JunMyung-JinChoiSimonWenFrankKwonKi-Hyun. 2016. “Effects of Urban Spatial Structure on Level of Excess Commutes: A Comparison between Seoul and Los Angeles.” Urban Studies55 (1): 195–221.
25.
KanaroglouPavlos S.HigginsChristopher D.ChowdhuryTufayel A. 2015. “Excess Commuting: A Critical Review and Comparative Analysis of Concepts, Indices, and Policy Implications.” Journal of Transport Geography44:13–23.
26.
KotavaaraOssiAntikainenHarriRusanenJarmo. 2011. “Population Change and Accessibility by Road and Rail Networks: GIS and Statistical Approach to Finland 1970–2007.” Journal of Transport Geography19 (4): 926–35.
27.
LaymanCharlesHornerMark W. 2010. “Comparing Methods for Measuring Excess Commuting and Jobs-Housing Balance: Empirical Analysis of Land Use Changes.” Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board2174:110–17.
28.
LinDongAllanAndrewCuiJianqiang. 2015. “The Impact of Polycentric Urban Development on Commuting Behavior in Urban China: Evidence from Four Sub-centers of Beijing.” Habitat International50:195–205.
29.
LopezRussel. 2014. “Urban Sprawl in the United States: 1970-2010.” Cities and the Environment7 (1): Article 7.
30.
LopezRusselHynesH. Patricia. 2003. “Sprawl in the 1990s Measurement, Distribution, and Trends.” Urban Affairs Review38 (3): 325–55.
31.
MaKang-RaeBanisterDavid. 2006. “Extended Excess Commuting: A Measure of the Jobs-Housing Imbalance in Seoul.” Urban Studies43 (11): 2099–113.
32.
MaKang-RaeBanisterDavid. 2007. “Urban Spatial Change and Excess Commuting.” Environment and Planning A39 (3): 630–46.
33.
MurphyEndaKillenJames E. 2011. “Commuting Economy: An Alternative Approach for Assessing Regional Commuting Efficiency.” Urban Studies48 (6): 1255–72.
34.
NiedzielskiMichael A.HornerMark W.XiaoNingchuan. 2013. “Analyzing Scale Independence in Jobs-Housing and Commute Efficiency Metrics.” Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice58:129–43.
35.
O’KellyMorton E.LeeWook. 2005. “Disaggregate Journey-to-Work Data: Implications for Excess Commuting and Jobs-Housing Balance.” Environment and Planning A37 (12): 2233–52.
36.
O’KellyMorton E.MikelbankBrian A. 2002. “Social Change and Transportation in US Edge Cities.” In Social Change and Sustainable Transport, edited by BlackW.NijkampP. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
37.
SchwanenTimDielemanFrans M.DijstMartin. 2004. “The Impact of Metropolitan Structure on Commute Behavior in the Netherlands: A Multilevel Approach.” Growth and Change35 (3): 304–33.
38.
SmallKenneth A.SongShunfeng. 1992. “‘Wasteful’ Commuting: A Resolution.” Journal of Political Economy100 (4): 888–98.
39.
SultanaSelimaWeberJoe. 2007. “Journey-to-Work Patterns in the Age of Sprawl: Evidence from Two Midsize Southern Metropolitan Areas.” Professional Geographer59 (2): 193–208.
40.
VandersmissenMarie-HélèneVilleneuvePaulThériaultMarius. 2003. “Analyzing Changes in Urban Form and Commuting Time.” Professional Geographer55 (4): 446–63.
41.
WachsMartinTaylorBrian D.LevineNedOngPaul. 1993. “The Changing Commute: A Case-Study of the Jobs-Housing Relationship over Time.” Urban Studies30 (10): 1711–29.
42.
WhiteMichelle J.1988. “Urban Commuting Journeys Are Not ‘Wasteful.’” Journal of Political Economy96 (5): 1097–110.
43.
YangJiawen. 2005. “Commuting Impacts of Spatial Decentralization: A Comparison of Atlanta and Boston.” Journal of Regional Analysis and Policy35 (1): 69–78.
44.
YangJiawen. 2008. “Policy Implications of Excess Commuting: Examining the Impacts of Changes in US Metropolitan Spatial Structure.” Urban Studies45 (2): 391–405.
45.
YangJiawenFerreiraJosephJr.2008. “Choices versus Choice Sets: A Commuting Spectrum Method for Representing Job-Housing Possibilities.” Environment and Planning B35 (2): 364–78.
46.
ZhaoPengjunLüBinde RooGert. 2010. “Urban Expansion and Transportation: The Impact of Urban Form on Commuting Patterns on the City Fringe of Beijing.” Environment and Planning A42 (10): 2467–86.
