Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

Notwithstanding the trend toward increased citizen participation in planning, many city governments, even those led by avowedly progressive regimes, are ambivalent about popular empowerment in practice. This case study of waterfront planning in Philadelphia explores how a progressive administration responded to earlier initiatives to expand participatory planning by scaling back outreach efforts, co-opting citizen advocacy, and managing public forums in ways that dampened critical reflection and deliberation. The article documents the limitations of relying on the good intentions of progressive administrations and the need for firm rules and mandates for citizen participation through the duration of a planning process.

Keywords

citizen participation governance land use politics society

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

A Civic Vision for the Central Delaware. 2007. Prepared by Penn Praxis, Wallace Roberts & Todd, and William Penn Foundation. Philadelphia, November.

Abbott

Howe

Adler

1994. Planning the Oregon Way: A Twenty-Year Evaluation. Corvallis: Oregon State University Press.

Abernathy

2011. Personal interview. Director of Policy and Communications, Councilmember Frank DiCicco, 2004-2010. June 7.

AICP (American Institute of Certified Planners). 2005. Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct. http://www.planning.org/ethics/ethicscode.htm (accessed September 20, 2012).

Arnstein

1969. “A Ladder of Citizen Participation.” Journal of the American Institute of Planners 35 (July): 216–24.

Barber

B. R.

1984. Strong Democracy: Participatory Politics for a New Age. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Beaudry

2010. Personal interview. Activist, Neighbors Allied for the Best Riverfront. December 8.

Berry

J. M.

Portney

K. E.

Thompson

1993. The Rebirth of Urban Democracy. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.

Bond

Thompson-Fawcett

2007. “Public Participation and the New Urbanism: A Conflicting Agenda?” Planning Theory and Practice 8 (4): 449–72.

10.

Boni

2010. Personal interview. Society Hill Civic Association, November 29.

11.

Brody

Godschalk

Burby

2003. “Mandating Citizen Participation in Plan Making: Six Strategic Planning Choices.” Journal of the American Planning Association 69 (3): 245–64.

12.

Burby

R. J.

2003. “Making Plans That Matter: Citizen Involvement and Government Action.” Journal of the American Planning Association 69 (1): 33–49.

13.

Central Delaware Advocacy Group letter. 2011. To DRWC. August 24.

14.

Central Delaware Advocacy Group meeting. 2011a. Philadelphia, September 8.

15.

Central Delaware Advocacy Group meeting. 2011b. Philadelphia, January 13.

16.

Central Delaware Advocacy Group meeting. 2010. Philadelphia, November 11.

17.

Clavel

2010. Activists in City Hall: The Progressive Response to the Reagan Era in Boston and Chicago. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

18.

Clavel

1986. The Progressive City: Planning and Participation. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.

19.

Crosby

Kelly

J. M.

Schaefer

1986. “Citizens Panels: A New Approach to Citizen Participation.” Public Administration Review, 46: 170–78.

20.

Cuthill

2004. “Community Visioning: Facilitating Informed Citizen Participation in Local Area Planning on the Gold Coast.” Urban Policy and Research 22 (4): 427–45.

21.

Davidoff

1965. “Advocacy and Pluralism in Planning.” Journal of the American Institute of Planners 31: 331–38.

22.

Day

1997. “Citizen Participation in the Planning Process: An Essentially Contested Concept?” Journal of Planning Literature 11: 421–34.

23.

DeLeon

R. E.

2003. “San Francisco: The Politics of Race, Land Use, and Ideology.” In Racial Politics in American Cities, 3rd ed., edited by Browning

R. P.

Marshall

D. R.

Tabb

D. H.

, 167–98. New York: Longman.

24.

DRWC meeting. 2010. Fishtown neighborhood, Philadelphia. November 17.

25.

Eichel

2007. “Street’s Foe Now Set to Succeed Him.” Philadelphia Inquirer, May 16.

26.

Executive Order. 2006. “Signed by Mayor John Street.” Philadelphia, October 5.

27.

Fernandez

2002. “Penn’s Landing Deal Declared Dead.” Philadelphia Inquirer, August 14.

28.

Flander

1997. “City Rolls the Dice on Waterfront Again.” Philadelphia Inquirer, November 10.

29.

Florida

2002. The Rise of the Creative Class: And How It’s Transforming Work, Leisure, Community, and Everyday Life. New York: Basic Books.

30.

Forester

1989. Planning in the Face of Power. Berkeley: University of California Press.

31.

Gates

K. P.

2009. “CDAG Holds Report Card on Waterfront Progress.” www.planphilly.com/articles/author/kellie-patrick-gates?page29 (accessed May 19, 2010).

32.

Gates

K. P.

2010a. “Size of Riverfront Setback Could Shrink Considerably.” www.planphilly.com/articles/author/kellie-patrick-gates?page23 (accessed October 18, 2010).

33.

Gates

K. P.

2010b. “CDAG Issues Waterfront Progress Report.” www.planphilly.com/articles/author/kellie-patrick-gates?page24 (accessed November 10, 2010).

34.

Gelbart

2009. “Nutter to Welcome Public Input on Budget.” Philadelphia Inquirer, January 16.

35.

Gelbart

2006. “Street’s ‘If at First’ River Plan.” Philadelphia Inquirer, October 13.

36.

Gerber

E. R.

Phillips

J. H.

2004. “Direct Democracy and Land Use Policy: Exchanging Public Goods for Development Rights.” Urban Studies 41 (2): 463–79.

37.

Goodwin

2010. Personal interview. Representative (Pennsport Civic Association), Central Delaware Advocacy Group, December 13.

38.

Greenle

. Personal interview. Penn Praxis, December 22.

39.

Gorenstein

1997. “$130 Million in Family Entertainment Planned for Penn’s Landing Open Space.” Philadelphia Inquirer, May 16.

40.

Hanson

Wolman

Connolly

Pearson

McManmon

2010. “Corporate Citizenship and Urban Problem Solving: The Changing Civic Role of Business Leaders in American Cities.” Journal of Urban Affairs 32 (1): 1–23.

41.

Healey

2008. “Civic Engagement, Spatial Planning and Democracy as a Way of Life.” Planning Theory and Practice 9 (3): 379–414.

42.

Heiko

2010. Personal interview. Activist, Casino-Free Philadelphia, December 13.

43.

Helling

1998. “Collaborative Visioning: Proceed with Caution! Results from Evaluating Atlanta’s Vision 2020 Project.” Journal of the American Planning Association 64 (3): 335–49.

44.

Holcomb

2003. “Five Waterfront Condo Towers Planned.” Philadelphia Inquirer, October 10.

45.

Hunt

2010. Personal interview. Activist, Neighbors Allied for the Best Riverfront, November 29.

46.

Inglehart

1990. Culture Shift in Advanced Industrial Society. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

47.

Innes

J. E.

1998. “Information in Communicative Planning.” Journal of the American Planning Association 64 (1): 52–63.

48.

Irvin

R. A.

Stansbury

2004. “Citizen Participation in Decision Making: Is It Worth the Effort?” Public Administration Review 64 (1): 55–65.

49.

Jaffe

2007. “Green Infrastructure’s Expense.” http://planphilly.com/node/2176 (accessed May 26, 2010).

50.

Johnston

1993. “A Shifting Tide along the River.” Philadelphia Inquirer, March 14.

51.

Julian

D. A.

Reischl

T.M.

Cerrick

R. V.

Katrenich

1997. “Citizen Participation—Lessons from a United Way Planning Process.” Journal of the American Planning Association 63 (3): 345–55.

52.

Kerkstra

2007. “City Planning a Top Priority.” Philadelphia Inquirer, September 19.

53.

King

C. S.

Stivers

1998. Government Is Us: Public Administration in an Anti-government Era. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

54.

Lin

2007. “Plan for River’s Edge Is Greeted.” Philadelphia Inquirer, November 15.

55.

Lin

2010. “Pa. Revokes Foxwoods’ Casino License.” Philadelphia Inquirer, December 17.

56.

Lowndes

Pritchett

Stoker

2001. “Trends in Public Participation: Part I—Local Government Perspectives.” Public Administration, 79 (1): 205–22.

57.

Master Plan for Philadelphia’s Waterfront. 1963. Prepared by Geddes, Brecher, Qualls & Cunningham. Department of Commerce. Philadelphia.

58.

Matza

2009. “Designer Picked to Create Waterfront Master Plan.” Philadelphia Inquirer, November 24.

59.

Mayer

2010. Personal interview. Representative (Neighbors Allied for the Best Riverfront), Central Delaware Advocacy Group, November 29.

60.

McCaney

2011. Personal interview. Program officer, William Penn Foundation, February 17.

61.

McGovern

S. J.

1998. The Politics of Downtown Development: Dynamic Political Cultures in San Francisco and Washington, D.C. Lexington: University Press of Kentucky.

62.

McGovern

S. J.

2008. “Evolving Visions of Waterfront Development in Postindustrial Philadelphia: The Formative Role of Elite Ideologies.” Journal of Planning History 7 (4): 295–326.

63.

McGovern

S. J.

2009. “Mobilization on the Waterfront: The Ideological Roots of Potential Regime Change in Philadelphia.” Urban Affairs Review 44 (5): 663–94.

64.

Micale

2011. Personal interview. Project manager, Wallace, Roberts & Todd, January 25.

65.

Miller

1987. Democracy Is in the Streets: From Port Huron to the Siege of Chicago. New York: Simon & Schuster.

66.

NABR survey. 2011. Survey conducted by Neighbors Allied for the Best Riverfront and presented at CDAG meetings, January 13 and February 3.

67.

Nicholas

1996. “Rendell Renews Effort to Get Riverboat Gambling Here.” Philadelphia Inquirer, March 3.

68.

The New Laboratories of Democracy. 2009. National Civic Review 98 (Summer): 9–14.

69.

Page

2011. Personal interview. Interface Studio, March 31.

70.

Parmley

2005. “Gaming in Pennsylvania.” Philadelphia Inquirer, December 29.

71.

Pateman

1970. Participation and Democratic Theory. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

72.

Plein

L. C.

Green

K. E.

Williams

D. G.

1998. “Organic Planning: A New Approach to Public Participation in Local Governance.” Social Science Journal 35 (4): 509–23.

73.

Punter

2003. The Vancouver Achievement. Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press.

74.

Putnam

1995. “Bowling Alone: America’s Declining Social Capital.” Journal of Democracy 6 (1): 65–78.

75.

Rairigh

2010. Personal interview. Activist, Neighbors Allied for the Best Riverfront, December 8.

76.

Rohe

W. M.

2009. “From Local to Global: One Hundred Years of Neighborhood Planning.” Journal of the American Planning Association 75 (2): 209–30.

77.

Ruben

2011. Personal interview. Vice-Chair, Central Delaware Advocacy Group, May 12.

78.

Russell

1999. “Goodnite: Party’s Over, We Reveled for Years Waiting for Developers.” Philadelphia Daily News, September 7.

79.

Saffron

2003. Personal interview. Architecture critic, Philadelphia Inquirer, April 22.

80.

Saffron

2006. “Welcome Step.” Philadelphia Inquirer, October 6.

81.

Saffron

2008. “Nutter Endorses PennPraxis Waterfront Plan.” Philadelphia Inquirer, June 27.

82.

Saffron

Gelbart

2008. “Call to Reform Penn’s Landing Corp.” Philadelphia Inquirer, June 26.

83.

Satullo

2008. “Citizens’ Voices Finding an Ear.” Philadelphia Inquirer, February 26.

84.

Schaefer

M. A.

2009. “15 Named to Philadelphia Waterfront Agency.” Philadelphia Inquirer, January 31.

85.

Schelter

2011. Personal interview. Director, The Development Workshop, June 9.

86.

Schiavo

2010. Personal interview. Representative (Old City Civic Association), Central Delaware Advocacy Group, November 17.

87.

Scorsone

2010. Personal interview. Representative (River’s Edge Civic Association), Centeral Delaware Advocacy Group, December 16.

88.

Shiffman

Gelbart

2005. “Street Ally Pleads Guilty to Corruption Charge.” Philadelphia Inquirer, December 14.

89.

Shipley

Utz

2012. “Making It Count: A Review of the Value and Techniques for Public Consultation. Journal of Planning Literature 27 (1): 22–42.

90.

Silverman

R. M.

2005. “Caught in the Middle: Community Development Corporations (CDCs) and the Conflict between Grassroots and Instrumental Forms of Citizen Participation.” Community Development, 36 (2): 35–51.

91.

Silverman

R. M.

2003. “Citizens’ District Councils in Detroit: The Promise and Limits of Using Planning Advisory Boards to Promote Citizen Participation. National Civic Review 92 (4): 3–13.

92.

Simonsen

Robbins

M. D.

2000. Citizen Participation in Resource Allocation. Boulder, CO: Westview.

93.

Sirianni

2007. “Neighborhood Planning as Collaborative Democratic Design: The Case of Seattle.” Journal of the American Planning Association 73 (4): 373–87.

94.

Smith

P. D.

McDonough

M. H.

2001. “Beyond Public Participation: Fairness in Natural Resource Decision Making.” Society and Natural Resources 14: 239–49.

95.

Sokoloff

2010. Personal interview. Director, Penn Project on Civic Engagement, Graduate School of Education, University of Pennsylvania, December 15.

96.

Sokoloff

Steinberg

Pyser

S. N.

2005. “Deliberative City Planning on the Philadelphia Waterfront.” In The Deliberative Democracy Handbook: Strategies for Effective Citizen Engagement in the Twenty-First Century, edited by Gastil

Levine

, 185–96. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

97.

Steinberg

2011. Personal interview. Director, Penn Praxis, University of Pennsylvania, April 26.

98.

Steinberg

2012. “We’ve Come a Long Way, Philly.” Philadelphia Inquirer, May 8.

99.

Street

2011. Personal interview, Mayor, City of Philadelphia, 2000-2008, May 31, 2011.

100.

Strom

2008. “Rethinking the Politics of Downtown Development.” Journal of Urban Affairs 30 (1): 37–61.

101.

Stumpf

2010. Personal interview. Representative (Neighbors Allied for the Best Riverfront), Central Delaware Advocacy Group, November 29.

102.

Thompson

J. P.

2006. Double Trouble: Black Mayors, Black Communities, and the Call for a Deep Democracy. New York: Oxford University Press.

103.

Urek

2011. Personal interview. Director of Strategic Planning and Policy, Philadelphia City Planning Commission, June 1.

104.

Walters

Aydelotte

Miller

2000. “Putting More Public in Policy Analysis.” Public Administration Review 60: 349–59.

105.

Williamson

Fung

2004. “Public Deliberation: Where We Are and Where Can We Go?” National Civic Review 93 (4): 3–15.

106.

Wilson

2011. Personal interview. Member, Board of Directors, Delaware River Waterfront Corporation, June 6.

107.

Yang

2005. “Public Administrators’ Trust in Citizens: A Missing Link in Citizen Involvement Efforts.” Public Administration Review 65: 273–85.

Ambivalence over Participatory Planning within a Progressive Regime

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References