Shiao, Bode, Beyer, and Selvig argue that the theory of race as a social construct should be revisited in light of recent genetic research, which they interpret as demonstrating that human biological variation is patterned in “clinal classes” that are homologous to races. In this reply, I examine both their claims and the genetics literature they cite, concluding that not only does constructivist theory already accommodate the contemporary study of human biology, but few geneticists portray their work as bearing on race. Equally important, methods for statistically identifying DNA-based clusters within the human species are shaped by several design features that offer opportunities for the incorporation of cultural assumptions about difference. As a result, Shiao et al.’s theoretical distinction between social race and biological “clinal class” is empirically jeopardized by the fact that even our best attempts at objectively recording “natural” human groupings are socially conditioned.
AbendGabriel. 2006. “Styles of Sociological Thought: Sociologies, Epistemologies, and the Mexican and U.S. Quests for Truth.”Sociological Theory24(1):1-41.
2.
American Anthropological Association. 1998. “Statement on ‘Race.’”American Anthropologist. Retrieved August 19, 2014 (http://www.aaanet.org/stmts/racepp.htm).
3.
American Sociological Association. 2003. The Importance of Collecting Data and Doing Social Scientific Research on Race. Washington, DC: American Sociological Association.
4.
BaerRoberta D.ArteagaErikaDyerKarenEdenAimeeGrossRosalynHelmyHannahKarnyskiMargaretPapadopoulosAiriaReeserDoug. 2013. “Concepts of Race and Ethnicity among Health Researchers: Patterns and Implications.”Ethnicity and Health18(2):211-25.
5.
BlissCatherine. 2012. Race Decoded: The Genomic Fight for Social Justice. Redwood City, CA: Stanford University Press.
6.
BloorDavid. 1991. Knowledge and Social Imagery. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
7.
BolnickDeborah A.FullwileyDuanaDusterTroyCooperRichard S.FujimuraJoan H.KahnJonathanKaufmanJayMarksJonathanMorningAnnNelsonAlondraOssorioPilarReardonJennyReverbySusan M.TallBearKimberly. 2007. “The Science and Business of Genetic Ancestry.”Science318(5849):399-400.
8.
BurchardEsteban GonzalezZivEladCoyleNatashaGomezScarlett LinTangHuaKarterAndrew J.MountainJoanna L.Perez-StableEliseo J.SheppardDeanRischNeil. 2003. “The Importance of Race and Ethnic Background in Biomedical Research and Clinical Practice.”New England Journal of Medicine348(12):1170-75.
9.
CalhounCraigLightDonaldKellerSuzanne. 2001. Understanding Sociology. New York: Glencoe McGraw-Hill.
10.
ComptonElizabethBentleyMichaelEnnisSharonRastogiSonya. 2012. “2010 Census Race and Hispanic Origin Alternative Questionnaire Experiment,” edited by 2010 Census Program for Evaluations and Experiments. Washington, DC: U.S. Census Bureau.
11.
DannaKaren. 2011. “The Organization of Everyday Identity (and What It Reveals about the Organization of Culture).”Paper presented at American Sociological Association, August 20, Las Vegas, NV.
12.
DubowSaul. 1995. Scientific Racism in Modern South Africa. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
13.
DusterTroy. 2006. “American Sociological Association 2005 Presidential Address: Comparative Perspectives and Competing Explanations. Taking on the Newly Configured Reductionist Challenge to Sociology.”American Sociological Review71(1):1-15.
14.
FleckLudwik.[1935] 1979. Genesis and Development of a Scientific Fact. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
15.
FujimuraJoan H.RajagopalanRamya. 2011. “Different Differences: The Use of ‘Genetic Ancestry’ versus Race in Biomedical Human Genetic Research.”Social Studies of Science41(1):5-30.
16.
FullwileyDuana. 2007. “Race and Genetics: Attempts to Define the Relationship.”Biosocieties2(2):221-37.
17.
GouldStephen Jay. 1996. The Mismeasure of Man. New York: Norton.
18.
GrahamHugh Davis. 2002. “The Origins of Official Minority Designation.” Pp. 288-99 in The New Race Question: How the Census Counts Multiracial Individuals, edited by PerlmannJ.WatersM. C.New York: Russell Sage Foundation and the Levy Economics Institute of Bard College.
19.
HackingIan. 1992. “The Self-vindication of the Laboratory Sciences.” Pp. 29-64 in Science as Practice and Culture, edited by PickeringA.Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
20.
Haney LópezIan F.1996. White by Law: The Legal Construction of Race. New York: New York University Press.
21.
HardingSandra. 1986. The Science Question in Feminism. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
22.
HarrisMarvin. 1964. Patterns of Race in the Americas. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.
23.
HellenthalGarrettBusbyGeorge B. J.BandGavinWilsonJames F.CapelliCristianFalushDanielMyersSimon. 2014. “A Genetic Atlas of Human Admixture History.”Science343:747-51.
24.
HelwegArthurHelwegUsha. 1990. An Immigrant Success Story: East Indians in America. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
25.
HeyerEvelyneBalaresquePatriciaJoblingMark A.Quintana-MurciLluisChaixRaphaelleSegurelLaureAldashevAlmazHegayTanya. 2009. “Genetic Diversity and the Emergence of Ethnic Groups in Central Asia.”BioMed Central Genetics10(1):49.
26.
HumesKaren R.JonesNicholas A.RamirezRoberto R.2011. Overview of Race and Hispanic Origin: 2010. Washington, DC: U.S. Census Bureau.
27.
JacobsonMatthew Frye. 1998. Whiteness of a Different Color: European Immigrants and the Alchemy of Race. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
28.
KayyaliRanda. 2013. “US Census Classifications and Arab Americans: Contestations and Definitions of Identity Markers.”Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies39(8):1299-1318.
29.
KevlesDaniel J.1985. In the Name of Eugenics: Genetics and the Uses of Human Heredity. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
30.
KriegerNancy. 2005. “Stormy Weather: Race, Gene Expression, and the Science of Health Disparities.”American Journal of Public Health95(12):2155-60.
31.
LeeCatherine. 2009. “‘Race’ and ‘Ethnicity’ in Biomedical Research: How Do Scientists Construct and Explain Differences in Health?”Social Science & Medicine68:1183-90.
32.
LeroiArmand Marie. 2005. “A Family Tree in Every Gene.”The New York Times, March14, p. A21.
33.
MarksJonathan. 1995. Human Biodiversity: Genes, Race, and History. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
34.
MartinEmily. 2001. The Woman in the Body: A Cultural Analysis of Reproduction. Boston: Beacon Press.
35.
MartinPaulAshcroftRichardEllisonGeorge T. H.SmartAndrewTuttonRichard. 2007. Reviving “Racial Medicine”? The Use of Race/Ethnicity in Genetics and Biomedical Research, and the Implications for Science and Healthcare. London: Faculty of Health and Social Care Sciences at St. George’s, University of London.
MorningAnn. 2001. “The Racial Self-identification of South Asians in the United States.”Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies27(1):61-79.
38.
MorningAnn. 2008. “Ethnic Classification in Global Perspective: A Cross-national Survey of the 2000 Census Round.”Population Research and Policy Review27(2):239-72.
39.
MorningAnn. 2011. The Nature of Race: How Scientists Think and Teach about Human Difference. Berkeley: University of California Press.
40.
NelkinDorothyLindeeM. Susan. 1995. The DNA Mystique: The Gene as Cultural Icon. New York: Freeman.
41.
NelsonAlondra. 2008. “Bio Science: Genetic Genealogy Testing and the Pursuit of African Ancestry.”Social Studies of Science38(5):759-83.
42.
NoblesMelissa. 2000. Shades of Citizenship: Race and the Census in Modern Politics. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
43.
ObasogieOsagie K.2014. Blinded by Sight: Seeing Race through the Eyes of the Blind. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
44.
OmiMichaelWinantHoward. 1986. Racial Formation in the United States. New York: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
45.
OmiMichaelWinantHoward. 1994. Racial Formation in the United States: From the 1960s to the 1990s. New York: Routledge.
46.
OssorioPilarDusterTroy. 2005. “Race and Genetics: Controversies in Biomedical, Behavioral, and Forensic Sciences.”American Psychologist60(1):115-28.
47.
PaschouPeristeraZivEladBurchardEsteban G.ChoudhryShwetaRodriguez-CintronWilliamMahoneyMichael W.DrineasPetros. 2007. “PCA-correlated SNPs for Structure Identification in Worldwide Human Populations.”PLoS Genetics3(9):1672-86.
48.
PritchardJonathan K.StephensMatthewDonnellyPeter. 2000. “Inference of Population Structure Using Multilocus Genotype Data.”Genetics155(2):945-59.
49.
RischNeilBurchardEstebanZivEladTangHua. 2002. “Categorization of Humans in Biomedical Research: Genes, Race and Disease.”Genome Biology3(7):1-12.
50.
RobertsDorothy. 2011. Fatal Invention: How Science, Politics, and Big Business Re-create Race in the Twenty-first Century. New York: New Press.
51.
RosenbergNoah A.MahajanSaurabhRamachandranSohiniZhaoChengfengPritchardJonathan K.FeldmanMarcus W.2005. “Clines, Clusters, and the Effect of Study Design on the Inference of Human Population Structure.”PLoS Genetics1(6):660-71.
52.
RosenbergNoah A.PritchardJonathan K.WeberJames L.CannHoward M.KiddKenneth K.ZhivotovskyLev A.FeldmanMarcus W.2002. “Genetic Structure of Human Populations.”Science298:2381-85.
53.
RubinGayle. 1975. “The Traffic in Women: Notes on the ‘Political Economy’ of Sex.” Pp. 157-210 in Toward an Anthropology of Women, edited by ReiterR.New York: Monthly Review Press.
54.
SamhanHelen Hatab. 1999. “Not Quite White: Race Classification and the Arab-American Experience.” Pp. 209-26 in Arabs in America: Building a New Future, edited by SuleimanM. W.Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
55.
SandersEdith R.1969. “The Hamitic Hypothesis: Its Origins and Functions in Time Perspective.”Journal of African History10(4):521-32.
56.
SarichVincentMieleFrank. 2004. Race: The Reality of Human Differences. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
57.
SatelSally. 2002. “I Am a Racially Profiling Doctor.”The New York Times Magazine, May5, pp. 56-58.
58.
SchiebingerLonda. 1993. Nature’s Body: Gender in the Making of Modern Science. Boston, MA: Beacon Press.
59.
SerreDavidPääboSvante. 2004. “Evidence for Gradients of Human Genetic Diversity within and Among Continents.”Genome Research14:1679-85.
60.
ShahAnish M.TamangRakeshMoorjaniPriyaRaniDeepa SelviGovindarajPeriyasamyKulkarniGururajBhattacharyaTanmoyMustakMohammed S.BhaskarL.V.K.S.ReddyAlla G.GadhviDharmendraGaiPramod B.ChaubeyGyaneshwerPattersonNickReichDavidTyler-SmithChrisSinghLaljiThangarajKumarasamy. 2011. “Indian Siddis: African Descendants with Indian Admixture.”American Journal of Human Genetics89(1):154-61.
61.
ShapinSteven. 1995. “Here and Everywhere: Sociology of Scientific Knowledge.”Annual Review of Sociology21:289-321.
62.
ShiaoJiannbin LeeBodeThomasBeyerAmberSelvigDaniel. 2012. “The Genomic Challenge to the Social Construction of Race.”Sociological Theory30 (2):67-88.
63.
SmedleyAudreySmedleyBrian. 2012. Race in North America: Origin and Evolution of a Worldview. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
64.
StepanNancy. 1982. The Idea of Race in Science: Great Britain 1800-1960. London: Archon Books.
65.
TempletonAlan R.1999. “Human Races: A Genetic and Evolutionary Perspective.”American Anthropologist100(3):632-50.
66.
U.S. Office of Management and Budget. 1997. Revisions to the Standards for the Classification of Federal Data on Race and Ethnicity. Washington, DC: Author.
67.
WailooKeith. 2001. Dying in the City of the Blues: Sickle Cell Anemia and the Politics of Race and Health. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
68.
WailooKeithPembertonStephen. 2006. The Troubled Dream of Genetic Medicine: Ethnicity and Innovation in Tay-Sachs, Cystic Fibrosis, and Sickle Cell Disease. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
69.
WeberMax.[1956] 1978. Economy and Society: An Outline of Interpretive Sociology. Berkeley: University of California Press.
70.
WilsonJames F.WealeMichael E.SmithAlice C.GratrixFionaFletcherBenjaminThomasMark G.BradmanNeilGoldsteinDavid B.2001. “Population Genetic Structure of Variable Drug Response.”Nature Genetics29(3):265-69.
71.
WinantHoward. 2001. The World Is a Ghetto: Race and Democracy Since World War II. New York: Basic Books.
