As the search for human genetic variation has become a priority for biomedical science, debates have resurfaced about the use of race and ethnicity as scientific classifications. In this paper we consider the relationship between race, ethnicity and genetics, using insights from science and technology studies (STS) about processes of classification and standardization. We examine how leading biomedical science journals attempted to standardize the classifications of race and ethnicity, and analyse how a sample of UK genetic scientists used the concepts in their research. Our content analysis of 11 editorials and related guidelines reveals variations in the guidance on offer, and it appears that there has been a shift from defining the concepts to prescribing methodological processes for classification. In qualitative interviews with 17 scientists, the majority reported that they had adopted socio-political classification schemes from state bureaucracy (for example, the UK Census) for practical reasons, although some scientists used alternative classifications that they justified on apparently methodological grounds. The different responses evident in the editorials and interviews can be understood as reflecting the balance of flexibility and stability that motivate standardization processes. We argue that, although a genetic concept of race and ethnicity is unlikely to wholly supplant a socio-political one, the adoption of census classifications into biomedical research is an alignment of state bureaucracy and science that could have significant consequences.
Aspinall, Peter J. (2000) `The New 2001 Census Question Set on Cultural Characteristics: Is it Useful for the Monitoring of the Health Status of People from Ethnic Groups in Britain?' Ethnicity and Health5(1): 33-40.
2.
Bamshad, M., S. Wooding, B.A. Salisbury & J.C. Stephens (2004) `Deconstructing the Relationship between Genetics and Race', Nature Reviews Genetics5(8): 598-609.
3.
Bauman, Zygmunt (1993) Modernity and Ambivalence ( London: Polity Press).
4.
Bell, C.C. (1994) `Taking Issue', Hospital and Community Psychiatry45(1): 5.
5.
Bell, J. (1998) `The New Genetics in Clinical Practice', British Medical Journal316: 618-20.
6.
Bevan, D. (2004) `Genes, Race and Drugs', Clinical and Investigative Medicine27: 5-6.
7.
Bhopal, Raj (2004) `Glossary of Terms Relating to Race and Ethnicity: For Reflection and Debate', Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health58: 441-45.
8.
Bhopal, Raj, Judith Rankin & Trude Bennett (2000) `Editorial Role in Promoting Valid Use of Concepts and Terminology in Race and Ethnicity Research', Science Editor23(3): 75-80.
9.
Bowker, Geoffrey C. & Susan L. Star (1999) Sorting Things Out: Classification and its Consequences (London: MIT Press).
10.
Braun, Lindy (2002) `Race, Ethnicity, and Health: Can Genetics Explain Disparities?', Perspectives in Biology and Medicine45(2): 159-74.
11.
British Medical Journal (1996) `Style Matters: Ethnicity, Race, and Culture: Guidelines for Research, Audit, and Publication', Editorial, British Medical Journal312: 1094-95.
12.
Bulmer, Martin (1986) `Race and Ethnicity', in Robert G. Burgess (ed.), Key Variables in Social Investigation (London: Routledge): 54-57.
13.
Burchard, E.G., E. Ziv, N. Coyle, S.L. Gomez, H. Tang, A.J. Karter, et al. (2003) `The Importance of Race and Ethnic Background in Biomedical Research and Clinical Practice', New England Journal of Medicine348(12): 1170-75.
14.
Canadian Medical Association Journal (2000 ) `Scientific Reporting of Ethnicity, Age, Sex and Race', Editorial , Canadian Medical Association Journal162 (10): 1393.
15.
Cooper, Richard, Jay S. Kaufman & Ryk Ward (2004) `Race and Genomics', New England Journal of Medicine348(12): 1166-75.
16.
Davidoff, Frank (2000) `Letter', Science Editor23(6): 207.
17.
Department of Health/National Health Service Health and Social Care Information Centre/National Health Service Employers ( 2005) A Practical Guide to Ethnic Monitoring in the NHS and Social Care (London: Department of Health).
18.
Dubow, Saul (ed.) (2001) Science and Society in Southern Africa (Manchester: Manchester University Press).
19.
Durkheim, Emile & Marcel Mauss (1963) Primitive Classification (Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press).
20.
Duster, Troy (2005) `Race and Reification in Science', Science, 307 (18 February): 1050-51.
21.
Epstein, Steven (2004) `Bodily Differences and Collective Identities: The Politics of Gender and Race in Biomedical Research in the United States' , Body and Society10(2-3): 183-203.
22.
Foster, Morris W. & Richard R. Sharp (2002) `Race, Ethnicity, and Genomics: Social Classifications as Proxies of Biological Heterogeneity ', Genome Research12(6): 844-50.
23.
Foucault, Michel (1992) The Order of Things: An Archaeology of the Human Sciences (London andNew York: Routledge).
24.
Friedman, D.J., B.B. Cohen, A.R. Averbach & J.M. Norton (2000) `Race/Ethnicity and OMB Directive 15: Implications for State Public Health Practice', American Journal of Public Health90: 1714-19.
25.
Fuchs, Stephan (1992) The Professional Quest for Truth: A Social Theory of Science and Knowledge (Albany, NY: State University of New York Press).
26.
Fujimura, Joan (1996) Crafting Science: A Sociohistory of the Quest for the Genetics of Cancer (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press).
27.
Gibbons, Susan M. C., J. Kaye, A. Smart, C. Heeney & M. Parker (2007) `Governing Genetic Databases: Challenges Facing Research Regulation and Practice', Journal of Law and Society34(2): 163-89.
28.
Goodman, Alan H. (2000) `Why Genes Don't Count (for Racial Differences in Health)', American Journal of Public Health90(11): 1699-1702.
29.
Harris, Bernard & Ernst Waltraud (eds) (1999) Race, Science and Medicine 1700-1960 (New York: Routledge).
30.
Kahn, Jonathan (2006) `From Disparity to Difference: How Race-specific Medicines may Undermine Policies to Address Inequalities in Health Care', Southern California Interdisciplinary Law Journal15: 105-30.
31.
Kaplan, J.B. & Trude Bennett (2003) `Use of Race and Ethnicity in Biomedical Publication', Journal of the American Medical Association289(20): 2709-16.
32.
Keita S.O., Rick A. Kittles, Charmaine Royal, G.E. Bonney, P. Furbert-Harris, G.M. Dunstone & Charles Rotime (2004) `Conceptualising Human Variation ', Nature Genetics36(11): S17-S20.
33.
Kertzer, David I. & Dominique Arel (eds) (2002) Census and Identity: The Politics of Race, Ethnicity, and Language in National Censuses (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
34.
Khoury, Muin J., Wylie Burke & Elizabeth J. Thomson (eds) (2000) Genetics and Public Health in the 21st Century (Oxford: Oxford University Press ).
35.
Lie, John (2004) Modern Peoplehood (London: Harvard University Press).
Marks, Jonathan (1998) Human Biodiversity: Genes, Race and History (New York: Aldine de Gruyter).
38.
Mason, Jennifer (1996) Qualitative Researching (London : Sage Publications).
39.
McKenzie, Kwame & N.S. Crowcroft (1996) `Describing Race, Ethnicity, and Culture in Medical Research', British Medical Journal312 (7038):1054.
40.
Montagu, Ashley (1972) Statement on Race, third edition ( New York: Oxford University Press).
41.
Morris, J.M. (1988) `Images of Community in Scientific Texts: A Grid Group-Approach to the Analysis of Journal Editorials', Sociological Inquiry58(3): 240-60.
Office of Management and Budget (1997) Revisions to the Standards for the Classification of Federal Data on Race and Ethnicity (Washington, DC: Office of Management and Budget).
46.
Payne, Geoff & Malcolm Williams (2005) `Generalisation in Qualitative Research', Sociology39: 295-314.
47.
Rathore, Saif S. & Harlan M. Krumholz (2003) `Race, Ethnic Group, and Clinical Research', British Medical Journal327(7418): 763-64.
48.
Risch, Neil, Esteban Burchard, Elad Ziv & Hua Tang (2002) `Categorization of Humans in Biomedical Research: Genes, Race and Disease', Genome Biology3(7): 1-12.
49.
Ritchie, Jane, Jane Lewis & Gillian Elam (2003) `Designing and Selecting Samples', in Jane Ritchie & Jane Lewis (eds), Qualitative Research Practice: A Guide for Social Science Students and Researchers (London: Sage Publications).
50.
Rivara, Frederick & Laurence Finberg (2001) `Use of the Terms Race and Ethnicity', Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine , 155(2): 119.
51.
Root, Michael (2003) `The Use of Race in Medicine as a Proxy for Genetic Differences', Philosophy of Science70: 1173-83.
52.
Rose, Nikolas (2007) The Politics of Life Itself: Biomedicine, Power and Subjectivity in the Twenty-first Century (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press).
53.
Roth, Wolff-Michael (2005) `Making Classifications (at) Work: Ordering Practices in Science', Social Studies of Science35 (4): 581-621.
54.
Sankar, Pamela (2003) `MEDLINE Definitions of Race and Ethnicity and their Application to Genetic Research', Nature Genetics34(2): 119-20.
55.
Sankar, Pamela & Mildred K. Cho (2002) `Toward a New Vocabulary of Human Genetic Variation', Science298: 1337-38.
56.
Shim, Janet. K. (2005) `Constructing "Race" Across the Science-Lay Divide: Racial Formation in the Epidemiology and Experience of Cardiovascular Disease ', Social Studies of Science35(3): 405-36.
57.
Skinner, David (2006) `Racialised Futures: Biologism and the Changing Politics of Identity', Social Studies of Science36(3): 459-88.
58.
Spencer, L., J. Ritchie & W. O'Connor (2003) `Analysis: Practices, Principles and Processes ', in Jane Ritchie & Jane Lewis (eds), Qualitative Research Practice. A Guide for Social Science Students and Researcher (London : Sage Publications).
59.
Stepan, Nancy (1982) The Idea of Race in Science: Great Britain 1800-1960 (London: Macmillan Press).
60.
Stevens, J. (2003) `Racial Meanings and Scientific Methods: Changing Policies for NIHsponsored Publications Reporting Human Variation', Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law28: 1033-87.
61.
Taylor, Ame L., Susan Ziesche, Clyde Yancy, et al. (2004) `Combination of Isosorbide Dinitrate and Hydralazine in Blacks with Heart Failure', New England Journal of Medicine351: 2049-57.
62.
Tishkoff, S.A. & Kenneth K. Kidd (2004) `Implications of Biogeography of Human Populations for "Race" and Medicine', Nature Genetics36(11): S21-S27.
63.
Tutton, Richard & Oonagh Corrigan (eds) (2004) Genetic Databases: Socio-ethical Issues in the Collection and Use of DNA (London: Routledge).
64.
Waterton, Claire (2002) `Classifying Nature, Constructing Europe', Social Studies of Science27 (2): 177-204.
65.
Watson-Verran, Helen & David Turnbull (1995) `Science and Other Indigenous Knowledge Systems', in S. Jasanoff, G.E. Markle, J.C. Peterson & T. Pinch (eds), Handbook of Science and Technology Studies (London : Sage Publications): 115-39.
66.
Williams, H.C. (2002) `Have You Ever Seen an Asian/Pacific Islander? ', Archives of Dermatology138 (May): 673-74.
67.
Williams, Malcolm (2000) `Interpretivism and Generalisation', Sociology34: 209-24.
68.
Winkler, Margaret A. (2004) `Measuring Race and Ethnicity: Why and How?', Journal of the American Medical Association292(13): 1612-14.
